[Basic Mafia] Fiddleton - Game Over

[Tiinker]

UNVOTE

 

Just incase..

[Tiinker]

Nobody cast the hammer. Actually, somebody should just unvote in case a mafia swoops in for the easy kill.

 

If GMaster is lying, let the true Finder come forth. If no one does, I propose we lynch Talya. Since we can't afford to lynch another Townie, it's a moot point about keeping the Finder secret. With the Healer still in play, it wouldn't be too great a risk anyway, and not only that, but we'd also have a clear confirmed scum, which is just as get as GMaster's Finding of Talya.

 

Problem is, they only need this lynch and a NK to win the game.

[Tiinker]

People who have been on but haven't claimed Finder (implies they aren't or they would be severely disagreeing) since GM's claim:

 

Tiinker

Locke

Talya

Meesh

Phelix

Tina

Deadly

 

 

Seems its up to Mav. Note though that he too could be mafia and claim finder so we lynch the wrong person.. But for the sake of it, i'd rather believe he's not.

[Niniel]

Nobody cast the hammer. Actually, somebody should just unvote in case a mafia swoops in for the easy kill.

 

If GMaster is lying, let the true Finder come forth. If no one does, I propose we lynch Talya. Since we can't afford to lynch another Townie, it's a moot point about keeping the Finder secret. With the Healer still in play, it wouldn't be too great a risk anyway, and not only that, but we'd also have a clear confirmed scum, which is just as get as GMaster's Finding of Talya.

 

 

Actually I have been more and more convinced during the day that GMaster is scum. He act very strang in my opinion. He changed hes reson for lynching Mynd not just ones but twise and now that it is pointed out he agrees that he made those resons up as he went along. I have a really hard time trusting GMaster. That said I think Lockes move here were very wise. Since we have the doc alive it isn´t that risky to come forward with a cop claim. That would in fact be helpfull to the town. I say it again that GMaster looks very scum. But I also have to admit that I (like some of you) have lynched two townies already so my scumdar isn´t working very well.

 

 

 

People who have been on but haven't claimed Finder (implies they aren't or they would be severely disagreeing) since GM's claim:

 

Tiinker

Locke

Talya

Meesh

Phelix

Tina

Deadly

 

 

Seems its up to Mav. Note though that he too could be mafia and claim finder so we lynch the wrong person.. But for the sake of it, i'd rather believe he's not.

 

You´re confusing this with the Mistborn maffia game. Mmeesh is not in this one.

[Niniel]

So for now unvote GMaster

[Tiinker]

Nobody cast the hammer. Actually, somebody should just unvote in case a mafia swoops in for the easy kill.

 

If GMaster is lying, let the true Finder come forth. If no one does, I propose we lynch Talya. Since we can't afford to lynch another Townie, it's a moot point about keeping the Finder secret. With the Healer still in play, it wouldn't be too great a risk anyway, and not only that, but we'd also have a clear confirmed scum, which is just as get as GMaster's Finding of Talya.

 

 

Actually I have been more and more convinced during the day that GMaster is scum. He act very strang in my opinion. He changed hes reson for lynching Mynd not just ones but twise and now that it is pointed out he agrees that he made those resons up as he went along. I have a really hard time trusting GMaster. That said I think Lockes move here were very wise. Since we have the doc alive it isn´t that risky to come forward with a cop claim. That would in fact be helpfull to the town. I say it again that GMaster looks very scum. But I also have to admit that I (like some of you) have lynched two townies already so my scumdar isn´t working very well.

 

 

 

People who have been on but haven't claimed Finder (implies they aren't or they would be severely disagreeing) since GM's claim:

 

Tiinker

Locke

Talya

Meesh

Phelix

Tina

Deadly

 

 

Seems its up to Mav. Note though that he too could be mafia and claim finder so we lynch the wrong person.. But for the sake of it, i'd rather believe he's not.

 

You´re confusing this with the Mistborn maffia game. Mmeesh is not in this one.

 

Oops. I took those names from the first page. Mm must've been thinking about her yesterday..

[Tiinker]

Her posts.. >_>

[Niniel]

lol

[Locke]

I also suggest that more than two people post....

 

It is imperative that the Finder, if he/she is not GMaster, reveals.

[danneric]

Sorry haven't been able to post today because im haveing a B-day party for a friend (shes turning 50) so its a big day now lets see.

 

i agree we cant be too rash and just vote someone who is doing scummy acts And who chooses the finder roll (hence the reason i didn't even vote.) so far i have no good grasps on what is going on we went from voting GM to not voteing (which again i agree with) so does anyone have any suspicians what so ever?

 

I still have mine from earlier in the game and im going to keep it until im very sure.

[Niniel]

Deadly, do you propose that we should lynch someone else? Not Talya? Not GMaster?

 

Mav, what are your thoughts?

[Leelou]

VOTE COUNT

 

Talya (2) - GMaster, Locke

GMaster (2) - Talya, Phelix

 

Not voting: Mav, TinaHel, Tiinker, Deadly

 

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. Deadline in 25 hours.

[Niniel]

VOTE COUNT

 

Talya (2) - GMaster, Locke

GMaster (2) - Talya, Phelix

 

Not voting: Mav, TinaHel, Deadly

 

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. Deadline in 25 hours.

 

Dear Mod. I think you have forgot Tiinker.

 

 

What have been very fun with this game is that lot of people have been very active. But that suddenly stoped? I know that it is weekend and some can´t post during weekends. But maybe some players are getting scared now that we are in this important situation and are afraid of revealing to much? Well, just a thought.

 

I can´t shrug it off that I find GMaster suspicious but since noone else has claimed finder I have to believe him for now. So, until anyone comes forward with a better thought I vote Talya.

 

Deadly - I think you make some strange posts. Don´t come with any own thoughts just saying that you will wait. Ok, I will wait too - for you to come up with something more useful.

[Leelou]

VOTE COUNT

 

Talya (3) - GMaster, Locke, Tina

GMaster (2) - Talya, Phelix

 

Not voting: Mav, Tiinker, Deadly

 

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. Deadline in 25 hours.

 

I *cough* don't know what you are talking about Tina...*whistles innocently* see everyone is there.

[Niniel]

Off course. I probably need new glasses. Lol

[Mav]

Well, I can't say that I'm the finder. But about trusting GM to be the finder... does there even have to be a finder?

[Tiinker]

Mm I guess it's possible. But it's Basic Mafia so usually there would be one.

 

Unvote, Vote Talya

 

Better be right this time >_>

[Leelou]

VOTE COUNT

 

Talya (4) - GMaster, Locke, Tina, Tiinker

GMaster (2) - Talya, Phelix

 

Not voting: Mav, Deadly

 

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. Deadline in 20 hours.

[Niniel]

Mav - I understand that you don´t believe in GM. I have a hard time to do it myself. But do we have any options when noone else claims finder?

 

(First post tells us this game has town, cop, doc and maffia.)

[danneric]

ummm so we have twenty hours for the deadline. ok for one i think that what mynd was saying about talya coaching GM on what to say fits. i think this because after he said it all then Locke, GM, Tinker and Talya vote against him those were the first votes against him. don't you think its strange that the people mynd was changing his votes on were these peop0le then he revealed that talyas play style was off and before that lockes "scummiest post int the game came up? so im thinking that the mafia are one of those people. because a town wouldn't have jumped on the wounded cat straight away they would be trying to reread all of his posts and then see if the persons accusations on the person being voted is good or not. (at least thats what i do)

 

ps is that still fluff? i really don't like quoting but maybe i should start.

[GMaster479]

Again. No Coach. I made my own mistakes. Deadly just put down the hammer please so i can prove i am right :)

[Leelou]

VOTE COUNT

 

Talya (4) - GMaster, Locke, Tina, Tiinker

GMaster (2) - Talya, Phelix

 

Not voting: Mav, Deadly

 

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

 

 

Deadline in 3 hours.

[Niniel]

ummm so we have twenty hours for the deadline. ok for one i think that what mynd was saying about talya coaching GM on what to say fits. i think this because after he said it all then Locke, GM, Tinker and Talya vote against him those were the first votes against him. don't you think its strange that the people mynd was changing his votes on were these peop0le then he revealed that talyas play style was off and before that lockes "scummiest post int the game came up? so im thinking that the mafia are one of those people. because a town wouldn't have jumped on the wounded cat straight away they would be trying to reread all of his posts and then see if the persons accusations on the person being voted is good or not. (at least thats what i do)

 

ps is that still fluff? i really don't like quoting but maybe i should start.

 

 

Well, this time no fluff!

 

Are you saying that GMaster and Talya are scum? Do I understand you correct? Why would he/scum team sacrifie one of their own? Lets look at the options. Maybe I have forgot something so just fill in where I did.

 

 

1. GMaster and Talya are scum. Scumteam sacrifies Talya cos it would give us proof that GMaster is the true cop. If Talya lynch goes through then we have 5 town and 2 maffia. If maffia have a succesfull nk we have 4 town and 2 maffia. We now have "proof" that GMaster is cop, he points someone out and we lynch that person. If GMaster is maffia that person is town. Then we are down to 3 town and 2 scum. If maffia has a successfull nk we have 2 town and 2 maffia. Maffia wins.

 

2. GMaster is scum and Talya town. If we lynch Talya there will be 4 town and 3 maffia. If maffia has a succesfull nk we have 3 town and 3 maffia. Maffia wins.

 

3. GMaster is cop and Talya is scum. If we lynch Talya we have 5 town and 2 scum. If maffia have a successfull nk we have 4 town and 2 scum.

 

All these scenarios changes if doc succesfully protect a town.

 

If I have understod you right Deadly you think option 1 is correct. Both are scum. What do I know - it could be true and then we wont be certain that GMaster is cop even if Talya is lynched. But I think three things speaks against it.

1. If GMaster is scum it would be easier and get faster to lynch a town.

2. You base your theory on Mynds claim and I think he just made it up to provoke Talya.

3. Noone else have claimed cop.

 

If someone else have claimed cop I would consider your idea (cos I still think GMaster makes scummy posts) but now...

 

Right now it looks like we wont have a lynch at all. If we don´t have one we just have to hope that a random lynch benefits the town.

[Mav]

Vote Talya

 

Well, lets be the hammer then.

[Mav]

Vote Talya

 

Well, lets be the hammer then.

 

 

Vote Talya

 

I stand corrected.