Pirates of Fiddland - GAME OVER - Page 32

[Talya]

The only doubt I have about Vemy being evil, is that we haven't had a finder counter claim (except Barm who was evil). Now if their is a real finder out there I would have hoped they would have viewed Vemy night one or at least night two, and he would have come out saying that Vemy was evil. We have had no such thing. Because of that my only conclusion is that Vemy is the finder.

 

If you don't believe that Vemy is the finder then treat it like we haven't had a finder claim and go with who you believe may be guilty, however I don't think lynching Vemy at this stage would be useful to anyone, see above for my reason on giving him the benefit of the doubt.

 

It doesn't mean I believe Vemy 100% but it's the only thing we have.

 

So Nephi I have to disagree with Vemy being the next to go, if his the finder he offers a little more hope than not having one.

 

I'll stick with my vote.

[Guest nephitess]

humm, true. I'll have to think a bit more before i vote.

 

*looks at everyone suspect*

[Toy and Minion]

Vote Count:

 

YellowSister (1): Talya

 

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch.

[Vemynal]

@ bcx: You shouldn’t ever speculate on who the healer or finder is if no one has come forward, it just makes you look more suspicious and if your right then it exposes someone valuable on our side to danger

 

@ dark: <3 ya dark, and hope you last longer in Ilgross’ game. Tis true they tend to go for the valuable players first.

 

<3 ya nephy & talya XD

 

But Talya’s only half hit the nail on the head; theoretically if barm and Iwere both evil and made claims then the finder would lay low till today right? So if we don’t have a finder claim today then I can be believed as the finder :P

 

This isn’t gonna be a long review quoting instances and stuff cuz I have an essay to write but-

yellow=unknown, purple=healer, blue=finder, red=evil, green=good.

Alive:

Talya- Talya had some weird logic in the beginning that still has me kinda suspicious of her. She’s also valuable so I’d like to keep her around until we have more conclusive evidence.

 

Gryphan- New girl, quiet, I don’t trust quiet but she’s new so all is forgiven. I don’t bite hard XD, just a nibble here or there^^. You can post more, cuz we <3 you^^. But while I'd love to see her post more I'm also highly suspicious of her, see below.

 

nephitess- /cheers! She may think I’m evil but you’re playing the game. I r happy bunny^^. Basically nephi your off my list kinda, or at least lower. I doubt *ANY* evil would have the pure ballz the call me evil atm, that just went a long way in my book. + looking back on the votes, your vote and bcx’s vote have always been a consistency on me. Day1 and day2. Especially I’d rather think at least 1 evil is among those who voted barm and the other on barm or not voting.

YellowSister- Quiet, but active with her posts. Hax does that and isn’t evil always.

 

ilgross- the fake healer claim was weird and you’ve been quiet till just recently. But the fact that loreina and dark both have voted you and both died makes me think you’re less likely to be evil and it’s more of a set up. I could swing either way here.

Tigara- Quiet. Voted me day 1 and took his vote off me soon as I claimed. Normally this would be completely normal, but no one else did so it stands out =/. Day 2 he voted ilgross to avoid voting for me or barm. Even talya who mentioned the concept didn’t actually do it. Has me a little suspicious.

bcxanth- same as nephi about the voting thing.

 

Vemynal- I r Finder, hear me roar! /meow

 

Dead:

Kryos - Lynched Day 1- this was a loss, one of my few good plans pans out and then he dies. How the game works but is still sad. We can assume at the time there was at least 1 evil on the kryos vote. Possibly 2.

 

Loreina - Killed Night 1- Night killed and honest to god I don’t know why! Was it to throw us off? Not give us information? Trying to discredit me since I thought she was suspicious? Out of the lot not give us information imo is the more likely.

 

Barmacral - Lynched Day 2- told ya so :P. so who did barm openly support day 1? Cuz I doubt we will find evils in that group. Rather I think the ones he avoided addressing all together would be the evil ones. *maybe* the people who voted him in the beginning but took their votes off later.

 

Dark Justice - Killed Night 2- Sad to see him go, he had great instincts. And I’m going to take what he said to simply mean he has great instincts. The fact that we do know dark is innocent and went for ilgross is in my book a nice +1 to ilgross’ suspiciousness.

 

Comparing vote counts:

Page 5:

Vemynal (3): Tigara, Loreina, bcxanth

Kryos (2): Barmacral, nephy

Loreina(1): Vemynal

Barm(1): Ilgross

non-voters: Talya, Gryphan, YSH, Kryos, Dark

 

Page7:

Vemynal (3): Tigara, bcxanth, Gryphan,

Kryos (3): barm, nephitess, vemynal

Barmacral (2) ilgross, Talya

Ilgross(1): dark

not voting: Loreina, YSH and Kryos

 

Page11:

Kryos(4): Barmacral, nephitess, YSH, Tigara

Vemynal(3): bcxanth, Gryphan, Talya

Nephitess(2): Vemynal, Kryos

Barmacral(1) ilgross

Ilgross(1): Dark Justice

not voting: Loreina

 

Page15:

Kryos(5): Barmacral, nephitess, YSH, Tigara, bcxanth

Nephitess(5): Vemynal, Kryos, Dark, Lorei, Gryphan

Barmacral(1): ilgross,

not voted: Talya

(I’m including Gryphan’s vote for informational purposes, though it’s likely it didn’t factor in the day 1 lynch)

 

Day 2-

Page22:

Barmacral (5): Vemynal, Dark Justice, Gryphan Crymsonstarr, Talya, Ilgross

Vemynal (3): Barmacral, nephitess, bcxanth

ilgross (1): Tigara

nonvoters: Yellowsister

 

So two things. I think that at least 1 evil was on kryos, 1 evil was on me, and 1 evil was on nephy day 1. I also expect there was at least 1 evil on barm yesterday. Maybe 2 but I'd like not to stretch that just yet.

 

If we look at the kryos vote all the way through day 1 we know the evil was barm. Which supports the idea for me that likely nephy and bcx are innocent and YSH and tig arn't looking that evil to me. of the nephy vote there is me, the finder, 3 confirmed innocents by death and gryphan. + gryphan jumped from me to nephy, so while its believable I just convinced her its also possible she was the evil on me and became the evil on nephy. So for me that means gryphan just shot *WAY* up on my evil-meter its not confirmed still. Its also been done to vote a fellow evil on day 1 to disconnect yourself from them later on like what ilgross did to barm, making him seem a whole lot eviler. *BOTH* of them were on the barm vote on day 2.

 

Then there is the whole healer thing about ilgross and what he tried to pull last night. I'm slightly leaning towards gryphan since i think its more likely for an evil to have jumped on the barm vote earlier then ilgross did. but again I'm not sure. For now I'll vote [glow=red,2,300]Gryphan[/glow], but if the Ilgross vote goes up again this time, I'll change my vote. Can we get Gryphan's reason for voting barm? I forget if she posted one or not.

 

I also gave a lot of raw information above, sift through it and tell me what you guys think and who you think is suspicious. and someone slap me for writing so much :P

[Guest nephitess]

First *smootches Vemy* thank you for your words. I guess i'm finding it very weird that the Evils have not taken you out yet...who did you veiw last night? i'd like to see some stats there. everyday i'd like to know who you veiwed so we can get finding the evils. so your voting Gryph..ok...here is my idea...the person you vote for should be the person you veiw. then if they come up evil great, the next day we will lynch. if they are innocent...we know your evil.

 

does that make sense? what do you say to that idea?

[Vemynal]

actually i didn't understand at all sorry  :(

 

but I viewed dark last night since he was always agreeing with me and in every game has always argued with me, + he was one of the more inactive people =/.

 

while I don't understand what your trying to get at I do understand you want to tell me who to view. Bad idea.

 

If its posted in this thread (and it has to be posted in this thread) then the evils know who to kill. And if it becomes a democratic process (i.e. voting) who I should view then the evils have a direct influence on it.

 

Just wait it out nephy, today is the last day the evils can claim finder from what I said above. If they make a claim today then you know 1 of the 2 remaining evil players so even if I get lynched then things are vastly advantageous to us innocents.

[ilgross]

[glow=red,2,300]Vote: nephitess[/glow]

 

for voting with Barm. Every time.

[Toy and Minion]

Vote Count:

 

YellowSister (1): Talya

Gryphan (1): Vemynal

nephitess (1): ilgross

 

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch.

[Talya]

I know what you are trying to say Nephi, the trouble with that is, is if Vemy keeps viewing innocents, which can happen, all we would be doing is reducing our numbers down and not touching the evils...so it would be very good for them.

 

As for revealling, by all means reveal an alignment of who the finder viewed, but not the name, as the evils will just pick them off, and we would lose our base of innocents albeit the finder would be the only one that knew.

 

You have a good point in Gryphan, Vemy, but I will still stick with my vote. And I disagree she has been very quite and only comes in to vote...so you can't be quite and active!!!

[bcxanth]

Ok, now that I have power again and am not using my fiance's laptop in a hotel room, I shall take the time to pass on my latest thoughts.  Why didn't I post when I used her computer?  Well, if you saw the number of keys her keyboard was missing, you'd understand. ;)

 

As for my current thoughts, I'm torn.  From what has been said on this thread before, there should be two evil left. I have my ideas on who they are, as at this point there are only two people on my radar. However there are are apparently only two evils left, yet I have three people on my radar. So I'm unsure.

 

Ilgross is still on my radar, despite my having been wrong on one of my details in my previous post.  Now I'd been thinking along the same lines as Vemy in that one of the people that voted against Barm is likely evil. Ilgross vote for Barm came in very late, almost as if it was a last ditch effort to throw some suspicion off themself. Then he comes in with a vote for Nephie with a reasoning that doesn't make sense to me. Considering the back and forth between Nephie and Vemy in the first two days, I don't think her votes had anything to do with Barm and everything to do with her feelings about Vemy at the time.

 

I'm also a little suspicious of Yellow Sister and Gryphan because of how quiet they are.  They remind me of the show Big Brother (the US version) Where it seems like the people who are elast trustworthy seem to skate by for a time under everyone's radar by being quiet and keeping to themselves.

 

However, as I type this out I feel that my reasoning for those last two are still too shaky to base a vote on yet. I need more info I think.

 

So for now, I vote [glow=red,2,300]ilgross[/glow]

[Gryphan_Crymsonstarr]

I know I seem suspicious because i am quiet. I am new at this and I am still trying to figure it all out. There is no way I can convince you I am not a ninja, but I am not. And I have not decided you I am voting for.

[Vemynal]

hmm, I'm gonna keep my vote on gryphan for a bit longer

 

And Gryphan, its not that your quiet that really getting at me, rather like i said in my comments about the voting records it just fits with you a bit more :P

 

 

YellowSister (1): Talya

Gryphan (1): Vemynal

nephitess (1): ilgross

ilgross(1): bcxanth

 

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch.

[Tigara]

Hmm, I have no real suspicions on my own ATM. Too much info. For now I will vote for someone already voted for.

 

Yellow Sister, can't. I can't do that to someone who wants to be in my Ajah!

 

Ilgross, I'm starting to think he is innocent. Maybe the ninjas are setting him up? Myabe he is the Healer? Maybe not...

 

Comes to nephi and Gryph. Well, nephi is a British Columbian, so I vote [glow=red,2,300]Gryph[/glow]

[Vemynal]

Wait...so are you voting nephy because she's Canadian or Gryph because she is?

[ilgross]

Well I know I am inncocent. But I think the important thing is to not kill/reveal the healer...

[Tigara]

I voted Gryph because Nephy is Canadian. I had written my post in the quick reply box and forgot that I need my vote to glow, so I copied and pasted into the posting screen and must have hit submit without adding my vote. I edited it now.

[Vemynal]

Gryphan (2): Vemynal, Tigara

 

YellowSister (1): Talya

nephitess (1): ilgross

ilgross(1): bcxanth

 

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch.

 

And guys, editing bad in this game^^, double post to your hearts content though!^^

 

/runs away from Alys wielding a butchers knife

 

Alys edits devilishly. I would never chase anyone with a butcher's knife! Maybe a frying pan though. :P

[YellowSisterHanacho]

I know I seem suspicious because of the activity I have in the game, but know that this is due to the fact I have little to no time on the web.

 

I know my words alone will not convince you of my innocence, Talya, but I am an innocent. I would look the the players who are around more often than I. But that is just me.

 

I have to agree with some of the things that have been said in accordance with the others who are being voted for and I think that perhaps Ilgross could be the guilty one but I am not sure yet. I do not believe that it is Vemy as I did once before. I am not really sure what to think right now and so I will reserve my vote until I have a little more time to think things over.

[Toy and Minion]

*****24 HOUR NOTICE*****

 

Gryphan (2): Vemynal, Tigara

 

YellowSister (1): Talya

nephitess (1): ilgross

ilgross(1): bcxanth

 

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch.

[Gryphan_Crymsonstarr]

I don't know who throw under the bus. I am suspicious of you all including Dsage. I may have to do a little random violence. I will choose tomorrow

[bcxanth]

You know, the very fact that she's suspicious of the cap'n means she's ok in my book. ;)

[Toy and Minion]

I see.  Suspicious of me cause I'm doing all the lynches, eh?  Well, I wouldn't have to if you could get the max votes on someone by the deadline ;)

[Guest nephitess]

ok...so because i'm going against my feelings  :-\ ...I'll cooperate with the most votes. I'll vote [glow=red,2,300]Gryph[/glow] i truly hope she is a ninja. *sighs*

[ilgross]

[glow=red,2,300]Vote Gryph[/glow]

 

I hope he is not a doc.

[Toy and Minion]

Vote Count:

 

Gryphan (4): Vemynal, Tigara, nephitess, ilgross

 

YellowSister (1): Talya

ilgross(1): bcxanth

 

Not Voting: Gryphan, YellowSister

 

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch.