Game Over - Insane Mafia Game. Page 94

[Ishamael-Mafia]

 

Bah. This game is giving me a headache.

 

I'm the assassin. I killed Osan'gar, got blocked on Messy, killed Rahvin, and killed Halima.

 

I announced that I had a plan when we went to night. It was to reveal who I killed at 4:59, just before Barm posted at 5. I knew I could do this because I was going to wait to send in my action just before that. The night ended early because I got blocked by Aran'gar. [glow=yellow,2,300]She and Moggy both clearly state that they suspected me to be the assassin, knowing that if I was the assassin, I had already killed two evils. Only evils would try to block an assassin who kills evils! [/glow]

 

Mori, please unvote me. Moggy will wait until one more person falls into her trap and then seal the deal! I'm happy to answer questions. I want the innocents to win. Hell, I'm the only one who has killed any evils!

[Balthamel-Mafia]

Are you saying Aran'gar and Moggy are both evil?

[Ishamael-Mafia]

They do seem to be working together, a feat that requires communication outside of the thread.

 

Aran'gar openly admits to blocking me because she thought I was the assassin. But I have killed evils, so why would she block an assassin that kills evils?

 

Moggy says she suspects I'm the assassin, but still might consider lynching me because I only hit one evil? This does not even make sense, and as the assassin I have killed two evils. Why would an innocnet want to lynch an assassin who has killed two evils?

 

That's my logic. I think that they are the last two mafia. Aran'gar first, Moggy second.

 

Mori had also commented on previous "plays" and notorious players. We are dealing with one of the originals, so that is exactly what I would expect from them.

 

[Guest Moghedien-Mafia]

Together, they determine that they have prevented me from killing someone last night.

 

What? I claimed nothing of the kind. I speculated on Aran'gar's knee jerk reaction. I have been thinking you were not only a one nighter for a while.

 

Why would Moggy want to lynch an assassin who has killed an evil, and thus is innocent?

 

 

Umm, because you could be something other than what you say you are? Good reason? Even if you are only the assassin, you might be worth trying merely because as assassin, you really have done more harm than good. How many innocents did you kill? That's what I said. And I said I was tempted. But I want to know what the others believe about your alignment before I do anything else. That's also what I said.

 

Why does Moggy try to make two dead evils appear as only one? (Rahvin and Halima were night kills, and

I doubt that the evils did this for us.)

 

Because it's been such a long game that I forgot that Rahvin existed. I am having issues with extended family and going to school all together too early every morning. My brain is fried and it's the third week in. *sigh*

 

Why does Moggy insist on claiming that Halima did something when the mod has told us that this is

not the case? Bad Meta-Moggy

 

I asked and recieved no response about whether you thought Halima was used as a surrogate for the evil actions. It could be so, but as a mod, it is not something I would do. The story is supposed to compliment the action, not confuse it. This bit of story has only confused the action, and it bothers me.

 

I don't like taking mod's advice about ignoring stuff because there was once a mod who didn't want to see a player lynched on something that seemed stupid, but it was really a player mistake that showed an evil. None of the other players lynched that evil and that evil won. And I knew that player was evil. And only one other player listened.

 

How about this for an alternative explanation: Moggy lied and pulled another all-night-action-block.

 

Wish I could claim that, but I can't. I make it a point not to lie so as to not get confused in the lies. There are enough real mistakes caused by forgetfulness to not add on.

 

She and Moggy both clearly state that they suspected me to be the assassin, knowing that if I was the assassin, I had already killed two evils. Only evils would try to block an assassin who kills evils

 

If I remember correctly, Aran'gar actually said she thought you were evil and that was that. I am the one who said I thought you might still be an active assassin, though you could be evil. It is for that reason she voted and I did not.

 

Posting then going to read Ishy's post.

[Arangar-Mafia]

Can you please show me where I "clearly stated" that I thought you were the assassin?  I said you told us that you were a one night Vig whose ONE SHOT was the second night.The night Moggy said she blocked all.  Now, you are claiming to be assassin for ALL nights. Claiming something else when I gave you proof I am a roleblocker is called Lying.

 

If you were this "assassin" and I blocked you then who blocked the evil team from getting someone?  I think Moggy would have already discredited me had she another all blocker.  

[Guest Moghedien-Mafia]

Mori had also commented on previous "plays" and notorious players. We are dealing with one of the originals, so that is exactly what I would expect from them.

 

I have told you before, I don't know why you think I am that good. I get it wrong far more often than I get it right. I just see the logic flaws.

[Balthamel-Mafia]

[glow=red,2,300]Ishy[/glow]

 

I wish I could use my cop ability...

[DPR]

 

Go back and look guys. There is a reason I have not been voted against much. I play it straight and my logic holds water. I have to post as me because I'm having ISP issues, and this is the last chance I'll get to be online for a while.

 

After you kill me, look at the people who voted against me. They'll be the evil ones, standing in the winner's circle.....good luck.

[Ishamael-Mafia]

 

I'm back in disguise now. Thanks for waiting. I'll have a few answers to questions in a moment...

[Ishamael-Mafia]

I'm asking everybody to look at this the same way you would a healer or a finder reveal. You don't want to lose me as a resource and I can prove that I'm telling the truth with tonight's kill.  But I need those votes off of me before an evil comes along and finishes me off!

 

A few things about me:

 

I'm an assassin who has killed two evils, one innocent, and was blocked from killing another innocent (who looked guilty enough to get lynched). So, I look at my record as a good one!

 

I set up my role to be revealed when necessary with the I KILLED MESAANA code because I figured at some point it would come down to this.

 

I have supported Moridin as an innocent eveer since I saw Barm's post before it was edited.

 

Multiple players have remarked on my alibi's and it's because they make sense!  More to come.....

[Ishamael-Mafia]

 

A few things about Aran'gar and Moggy:

 

Aran'gar has been hitting radars for days now, and for multiple reasons. Here's another: Her latest post in retort to my reveal asks where she "clearly stated" that she thought I was the assassin.

 

In the post where you admitted to blocking me last night.

 

Why would you block me unless you suspected me. And I find it coincidental that you and Moggy both jump right out with that suspicion, even though it has not been discussed on the thread before. It makes me think it was discussed somehwere....You then claim that you gave me proof as a roleblocker. I never even sent in a kill last night because i was trying to time it for a last minute reveal. Your block reveal proves nothing. 

 

What did you not discuss in your retort? You did not mention how it was that you felt so comfortable posting right after Barm on a night when no kills where made. the last time that happened, two innocent people died, but just jump right in, and surprise! Nothing happens.

 

You also don't respond to my comment that you and Moggy seem to be working a plan together. Your immediate jump on my lynch, and then the back and forth with Mog comes across as the first "working together" plan I've noticed in this game. But it's not all about you....

 

Moggy. What can I say? The voice of reason and of wisdom. It's interesting that you have not had a solid opinion on anyone or anything since the Cyndane bandwagon, so as not to attract any unwanted attention? Your retort takes on the same casual tone, but you don't address either of the points that Aran'gar seemed to leave out as well. Another communication and plan in effect? Seems unlikely that niether of you would answer those questions....

 

Instead, you go on to try an turn my two evil kills into "doing more harm than good". How does that work, exactly? The game would be over right now if I had not killed them.

 

The we get into the whole "my brain is fried" thing. But it's not too fried to work up a case against the only assassin that the innocnets have, is it?

 

Then you deny the ability to use your role on more than one night. Given that everyone else can, why can't you?

 

You can phrase things however you like, but the bottom line is you suspected I was the assassin and you still posted in a way that made me look bad. You certainly did not defend me, or say "Hey, wait a minute! Aran'gar has been shifty the whole game, but the assassin is killing evils. Let's hold off on that lynch for a minute and think about this." 

 

I'll wager the only reason that fourth vote has not been cast yet is becasue there is no defense against my innocent reveal and an win is not a lock yet.

 

Alright, that's it for now. I'll be on for a little while if anyone has anything they want me to answer to.

[Guest Moghedien-Mafia]

The we get into the whole "my brain is fried" thing. But it's not too fried to work up a case against the only assassin that the innocnets have, is it?

 

i didn't work up a case. I stated what I thought. Nothing to back it up was posted. Just my thoughts.

 

Your retort takes on the same casual tone, but you don't address either of the points that Aran'gar seemed to leave out as well.

 

Working together? We didn't even have the same opinion. We had quite the opposite. Please, stop being so aggressive and open your eyes. She never said she thought you the assassin. I did. I did. I did. Not her.

 

What did you not discuss in your retort? You did not mention how it was that you felt so comfortable posting right after Barm on a night when no kills where made.

 

I didn't think about that since I saw a flaw in the logic and, owing to my nature, had to point it out. If you know me from else where *cough*D&D*cough* then you know that's my nature. I am a voice of reason that sometimes gets swayed by the heat of the moment.

 

Any other questions I saw, I answered this morning. Did you even read that response?

 

Instead, you go on to try an turn my two evil kills into "doing more harm than good". How does that work, exactly? The game would be over right now if I had not killed them.

 

Based on the assumption that you were the only assassin, you would have killed more innocents than guilty. I already said I had forgotten to count Rahvin. I had also forgotten that Be'lal might have been a bomb. Likely Amathea was an assassin too. The assassins over all have done pretty bad by us. We really don't know right now, it's all a guess. You claim assassin just like I thought you were. I wasn't wrong even if I didn't discuss it. BTW, tell me how not discussing it in the thread is a bad thing? Would you have rathered I made you a target earlier?

 

Then you deny the ability to use your role on more than one night. Given that everyone else can, why can't you?

 

Because some of you are lying for protection. You did. Others are too.

 

That's all my role was good for. Think about it like this. You can kill the number of persons that we have nights. I had the potential to stop 18 actions all at once. In a way, that's more powerful than your role. Why would I need to keep using it? How much power do you give one single person? At what point would the ability to keep using it would it become counter productive?

[Guest Moghedien-Mafia]

I am tired of defending something you misread from another player. We are running out of time. The final vote for [glow=red,2,300]Ishy[/glow] is here.

[Guest Sammael-Mafia]

[glow=red,2,300]Ishamael[/glow] today you really are coming off very strong and accusing people of being guilty for supposedly conspiring to voting against you and speculate that you have been the full fledged assassin.  We have no proof that Aran'gar or Moghedien have spoken and this does make you look guilty by trying to throw the blame elsewhere.

[Guest Moghedien-Mafia]

This is why I vote for you. Where did she say the things you accuse her of? I see no edit marks.

 

http://forums.dragonmount.com/index.php/topic,19873.msg550882.html#msg550882

[Ishamael-Mafia]

Moridin is going to have to disown himself now. I did my best innocents. Rest In Pieces.

 

 

[Guest Moridin-Mafia]

Wouldn't be the first time.

 

So. Who will join me as we dance our merry way to the end of our temporary universe? Assuming this is the last lynch of the game, would Mog care to post her list of names so we can compare her accuracy to the real list? I don't doubt she's got me right. Actually because of the no night kill last night we'll have another one tommorrow provided we haven't screwed up today. Oh what a bother. I was hoping to go fishing ...

[Aginor-Mafia]

:-\

Really not feeling the whole Ishy evil thing.

 

[Barmacral]

Aran’gar rests peacefully, sipping a drink beside a pool when suddenly she is rousted to her feet by Moghedien and dragged by her hair to the main square, where Ishamael lays bleeding to death, surrounded by the largest collection of weapons you have ever seen one person keep. Balthamel is marched in from the opposite side of the square by Sammael, while Aginor goes picking through Ishy’s collection. Moridin is nowhere to be seen. Aginor looks at Sammael, and shakes his head.

“Moridin got away eh? Too bad.”

Forced to their knee’s Balthamel and Aran’gar take a look at each other, the madness finally clearing from their eyes… just long enough to clue in that they are going to die.

 

Several hours later, with no trace of any of the dead remaining, Sammael, Moghedien and Aginor leave Far Madding. None looked back.

Which was too bad really, for if they had looked back, they would have seen the great mod in the sky decend to the mortal plane to survey his handywork, and if they had looked back they would have seen Graendal’s corpse reform itself, and if they had looked back they would have seen Graendal’s skeleton put a bone knife through the mod’s heart, and if they had looked back they would have seen the surprised look on the mod’s face as he died.

But they didn’t look back. Instead, right after they got over the bridge they decided to play King of the Hill on top of one of the Rancor Pits.

 

Winners: Evil Team and Moridin.

Losers: Everyone Else.

[Vemynal]

you guys have *no* idea how much fun I had watching this all play out^^

 

and btw, moggy wasn't always evil so don't beat your heads over it to hard^^

 

and yes damn it! I *was* a healer!!!

 

XD

 

great game talya, cloud, twitchy, leelou and alys. you all did very well^^

[Barmacral]

Mesaana – You are a roleblocker. However, you can only block a role on odd nights (night 1, night 3, etc…)

 

Moghedien – You are the one stop role block. Once per game you may block all roles for a single night.

 

Balthamel – You are the cop. You investigate one person per night, and get to find out their alignment and role.

 

Asmodean – You are the lynch stopper. Once per game you may stop a lynch of your choice. This role must be used during the day phase, and must be used before the lynch takes place. (I check my PM’s before I check the thread)

 

Semirhage – You are the doctor (yes, cruel, but lets face it, you are the best of the best… or were before the bore was opened).

 

Graendal – You are the cultist. Each night you select a player. When the player targets you with their role, they become a slave and lose all of their abilities. You will not know if or when they have targeted you with their role. You are also immune being night-killed.

At any time you may choose to trade this ability to form a new mafia with anyone whom has become your slave.

You alone know that every player has a role. You may not reveal or even hint at this information.

 

Cyndane – You are a Vigilante, each night you may kill a person of your choice. However, if you chose not to kill anyone that night, you will become immune to all night actions for that night.

 

Moridin – You are the winning man. You get 1 point for being on a lynch, and 2 for being the hammer (first or last vote that counts). You are immune to night actions. You win when you attain a certain number of points (to be revealed at game completion)

 

Demandred – You are the bad cop. And by bad I mean you suck. Seriously, when you investigate somebody, they will know that they have been investigated the previous night.

 

Ishamael – You are the super-human. You are immune to night-kills and you may kill one person per night. You win so long as you survive the game.

 

Lanfear – You are out for vengeance. For that reason, when you die the person who A) night killed you or B) was the last vote on the lynch will die as well.

 

Aran’gar – You are a roleblocker. You may choose one person per night to block the role of. Your block will not always work due to circumstances that will be revealed upon death or game completion (whichever comes first)

 

Osan’gar – You are the vote buyer. You can buy 1 vote per game. The following day your vote will count for 2 and somebody else’s vote will count for 0.

 

Be’lal – You are the daytime vigilante. Twice during the game you may choose to have somebody killed during the day phase. Your PM must be sent to me during the day phase.

 

Aginor – You are mafia. You can recruit 1 person per game.

 

Sammael – You are Mafia. You cannot be night-killed.

 

Rahvin – You are mafia. You will turn up innocent when investigated.

 

Halima – You are mafia. You may block one role per night.

 

Players:

 

Demandred: Soybomb, FDM

Aran’gar: Naeann

Osan’gar: FDM

Be’lal: Kivam

Lanfear: Amethea

Ishamael: Wes

Balthamel: Ilgross

Moggy: Alys

Asmodean: Loki, FDM

Rahvin: Talya

Sammael: Leelou

Aginor: Twitchy

Halima: CloudCrono

Graendal: Danya

Cyndane: Toy

Moridin: Goodgrief

Semirhage: Vemynal

Mesaana: Thorum

 

Evils: Aginor, Rahvin, Sammael, Halima, Moggy (recruited)

 

FDM replaced soybomb after Osan’gar died, and replaced loki after Demandred died.

 

[Vemynal]

barm, your not gonna give them a night by night explaination of what happened?

[Toy and Minion]

I was cyndane and you guys pissed me off!  I thought we had an extra day and went off all happy at my brilliant plan, then I come back and boom!  dead.  Thanks!

 

Naw.  It's okay.  I was the stupid one!  *head + desk*

 

Great game! :D

[Barmacral]

Right, sorry, forgot:

 

First: Aran'gars handicap was that she could not block female alts. The idea was that she could only use her feminane wyles on the males.

 

Night Actions:

 

Night 1:

Graendal: Asmodean

Semirhage: Himself

Mesaana: Be’lal

Cyndane: Immunity

Demandred: Semirhage

Aran’gar: Balthamel

Balthamel: Be’lal

 

Evil Team:

Halima: Semirhage

Evil: Semirhage

 

Night 2:

Balthamel: Mesaana

Ishamael: Mesaana

Cyndane: Immunity

Moggy: Block

Aran’gar: Asmodean

Demandred: Mesaana

 

Evils: Mesaana

Halima: Balthamel

 

Day 3:

Be’lal: Lanfear

 

Night 3:

Cyndane: Immunity

Balthamel: Moridin

Ishamael: Rahvin

Aran’gar: Cyndane

Demandred: Balthamel

 

Evils: Demandred

Aginor: Moggy

Halima: Demandred

 

 

Night 4:

Balthamel: Sammy

Ishamael: Halima

Aran’gar: Halima

 

Evils: Moridin

Halima: Balthamel

 

Night 5:

Aran’gar: Ishamael

Ishamael: Unknown

Balthamel: Aran’gar

 

Evils: Ishamael

[Naeann]

Gah!!!  I'm sorry Ishy/Wes. :(  Great game everyone!