The Founding of Quahog (Peter's Progress) Mafia - Game Over

[Clovdyx]

The former has left me thinking you feel good but I don't know what you're fully capable of and BFG doesn't trust you and if you trust BFG I'm not sure to make of that and

 

BFG isn't playing as I expect her to but I need to set that aside sooner or later and look at the broad scope of it before passing judgement and

 

I want more from Tiink because I feel good about him on a level that I think he can fool me at and

 

Verbal hasn't been around for a while and is fading from my memory and

 

Ben is probably just a misguided villager but his lack of broader focus still bugs me on some level

 

This is.

[Shad_]

lol

[Shad_]

It's like I'm [insert Zander/Cass personality letters] or something

[Shad_]

Frankly the back and forth between you and BFG is what's really making my head spin in this game.

[Shad_]

2/3 of my top D1 towns are confirmed town so I guess I had something going?

[Gentled Ben]

The former has left me thinking you feel good but I don't know what you're fully capable of and BFG doesn't trust you and if you trust BFG I'm not sure to make of that and

 

BFG isn't playing as I expect her to but I need to set that aside sooner or later and look at the broad scope of it before passing judgement and

 

I want more from Tiink because I feel good about him on a level that I think he can fool me at and

 

Verbal hasn't been around for a while and is fading from my memory and

 

Ben is probably just a misguided villager but his lack of broader focus still bugs me on some level

So after all those read-relevant responses you just claimed to have succeeded in generating, and after a ton of additional content from me, this is your read? “Probably a villager?”

[Gentled Ben]

I have to work now. I’ll check back in later tonight’.

[Clovdyx]

I don't know that I DO trust her as much as I don't want to lynch her.  Like I said, I had some really premature concerns and knew that there might be factors which made it null.  After reviewing a lot of her content that I wasn't able to really pay much attention to while I was at work yesterday, I was feeling a little better.  

 

Her posts to/about me from last page or whatever kind of pingponged me back down a bit.  If she didn't see my earlier posts, they're absolutely null.  If she did see them, I don't know what to make of her.  Her explanation of how I'm apparently reading her doesn't fit with anything I feel I've said in the past day, and that's honestly really frustrating but I don't know if she's deliberately misrepping me, somehow misinterpreting me, or just not fully caught up.

[Clovdyx]

Did you think I said anything that suggested I was scumreading her (recently)?

[Shad_]

It seemed to me like when  you were talking to Tiink you had it in your head that she was town

[Shad_]

That was why I brought up me making ~ the same argument

[Clovdyx]

It seemed to me like when  you were talking to Tiink you had it in your head that she was town

 

That made it seem like I was scumreading her?

[Shad_]

Because I got the impression in the moment a page ago that it was something you felt was a strong positive for her but I didn't recall you challenging me on calling her wolfy for it?

[Shad_]

But I could be missing context stuffs

[Shad_]

 

It seemed to me like when  you were talking to Tiink you had it in your head that she was town

 

That made it seem like I was scumreading her?

 

 

I posted that simultaneously with your question, but no?  What made you ask?

[Shad_]

So after all those read-relevant responses you just claimed to have succeeded in generating, and after a ton of additional content from me, this is your read? “Probably a villager?”

Scum's probably already won this game lol

[Shad_]

What do you want Ben?

 

like

 

You're either a villager hopelessly locked into tunnel vision or a wolf taking the easy street of just pushing one target relentlessly for the entire game in the face of all reason and it's probably the former because I think you're more cautious than that as scum + I've seen you do it as a villager + you aren't overplaying anything tonally a la your push on Tiink last game or the entirety of your second stint in Tennis mafia

[Clovdyx]

Her read on me is based around me scumreading her.

 

I'm pretty sure I covered at least some of that last night

I don't believe his reaction to eod1

I don't believe that he'd have me as anything as null from the first half of day 1 yet he's 'withholding a read' which implies something (contrast with his null read on Cory in the bt game for low participation, or how he treats his scum reads in that game)

Chris understands my mafia game better than anyone else playing this game. There are now things in thread that fundamentally conflict with my approach to playing as mafia that he's apparently ignoring in favour of a relatively shallow 'low impact' read

 

I'm asking because I want somebody else's opinion.  I feel my posts from last night made it abundantly clear I was trying to give her some space before taking a hard stance one way or another - again, both because of IRL stuff and because I wasn't caught up.  I had some time to look over her posts from yesterday and gave some general impressions based around what Sooh and Ben (?) were talking about.  I don't see how her takeaway from those is "Chris is currently scumreading me for being low impact."

 

At the same time, I realize other people aren't going to view my posts the way I do.  I know what my reads are.  I know what the reasons behind them are.  Of course my posts are going to make sense to me - I'm the one writing them.  That doesn't mean it's the same for the rest of the game.

[Clovdyx]

Anybody can weigh in on that lol

[Shad_]

I honestly can't answer that without a proper ISO of both of you.

 

My impression was that you started out pretty suspicious of her and it transitioned to conflicted and then to a town lean with some reservations, and by the talk with Tiink I felt like you were fairly sure she was town

 

I'm not sure if BFG is actually claiming you're scum reading her there or just calling your progression unnatural? But the fact that her exact stance isn't clear to me is weird to me?

[Shad_]

I mean maybe this really is just epic distancing and we're all f---ed but suffice to say you two have my head in a knot

[Clovdyx]

Because I got the impression in the moment a page ago that it was something you felt was a strong positive for her but I didn't recall you challenging me on calling her wolfy for it?

 

I think it's something that isn't remotely damning, and I wanted to see where his head at.  Even removing the fact it was her involved, it's nothing I would think is significantly more likely to come from mafia than town, and it was a rare chance for me to actually interact with Tink.

[Shad_]

Fair enough

[Shad_]

There are now things in thread that fundamentally conflict with my approach to playing as mafia

Do you agree with this statement?

[Clovdyx]

I honestly can't answer that without a proper ISO of both of you.

 

My impression was that you started out pretty suspicious of her and it transitioned to conflicted and then to a town lean with some reservations, and by the talk with Tiink I felt like you were fairly sure she was town

 

I'm not sure if BFG is actually claiming you're scum reading her there or just calling your progression unnatural? But the fact that her exact stance isn't clear to me is weird to me?

 

Basically?  I've never been as confident on her as I have been on you, Sooh, or Turin after his claim, but close enough.