[Basic] Peg + Cat Mafia -- TOWN WIN

[Eldrick4221]

I'm definitely not in any rush to vote. I was sure about all 3 of those lynches.

 

If you guys have any questions for me, go for it.

[Tigraine]

Eldrick, how do you put people on ignore?

[Eldrick4221]

It's under your profile preferences.

[Eldrick4221]

Manage Ignore press.

 

You type their name in the box at the bottom.. then you can choose what you want to ignore. Posts. Sig. Etc

[Eldrick4221]

Prefs*

[Eldrick4221]

I'll be up for another couple hours. Gonna go try and figure this out.

 

@Tress you accused me of gauging if tigs would vote you. If she's town, I would want her to do that. If you're town, you'd want me to vote her. So I don't see the problem.

[Eldrick4221]

And you didn't address why you weren't involved with yesterday's lynch. You have said something along the lines of both being motivated to play, ever since around when Darthe got lynched. Do you not see how that could look like being bummed about being the last scum?

[Eldrick4221]

If you're town, I need you to explain how your lack of involvement in the past few days is towny.

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

Darthe- Null read, hasn't posted content other than to specify a quote or two either Wolfy or townie.

Tress- null read, only game content was to say she agreed with Ed that Adella is town and to say she likes the work Shanti has put in

Spade- never played with before (it just sounds wrong! I know I'm 31 and a mother of three but my mind goes bad places) but she seems to be legitimately trying to game solve. She's asking about votes and questioning things in a positive manner.

LZM- hasn't checked in

Eddie- hasnt said much which is game related. Common for him during day 1 but Eddie is one that I ALWAYS find scummy. It's how he got me last game. I try to give him the benefit of the doubt and it colors my game play with him. So I always keep an eye on him but other than remarking about Alex and spades back and forth, he hasn't said anything.

I'm going ahead and posting this because believe it or not it has taken me hours to type this out. Like I said, I am on mobile and it's a true process. Not to mention my one year old dive/princess/demon/drama queen/ beauty I am dealing with...kid likes to eat and poop and push buttons on my phone :(

I'm starting to work on the rest but know that it will prob be a while before I can get my thoughts on everyone else to you guys. ISOing on mobile and trying to type it all on my notepad to copy and paste to you guys is tedious.

 

 

QFR in case she flips scum. Good chance one of her teammates would be in this partial list.

Requoting because Darthe is one of the 5 people tigs mentioned.

 

Tigs, why did you choose these people to give reads on?

[Eldrick4221]

I've talked myself into either

 

tigs is town

or

tigs is scum and Redd and Tress are both town.

Well at least this read was right

[Eldrick4221]

Time to remember why I thought that.

[Eldrick4221]

Tigs joke voted Tress because of the stalking thing and lefr it there.

 

That's why I cleared you two as being teaates.

 

Redd agreed with me that tigs' lack of solve looked bad, and went after her with me. That's why Redd and Tigs made sense to not be teammates.

 

How did I get to tress or Redd was scum if tigs was town? It's times like these I wish I take notes.

[Songstress]

I'll be up for another couple hours. Gonna go try and figure this out.

 

@Tress you accused me of gauging if tigs would vote you. If she's town, I would want her to do that. If you're town, you'd want me to vote her. So I don't see the problem.

 

What it looks like is suggesting things to see if she'll jump at them and vote me.

 

That may or may not be what you're doing, but it's up to me to figure it out.

[Eldrick4221]

Reason for suspecting Redd was his not sticking with his scum read on Tigs.

 

Sorry for the thinking out loud.

[Eldrick4221]

 

I'll be up for another couple hours. Gonna go try and figure this out.

@Tress you accused me of gauging if tigs would vote you. If she's town, I would want her to do that. If you're town, you'd want me to vote her. So I don't see the problem.

 

 

What it looks like is suggesting things to see if she'll jump at them and vote me.

 

That may or may not be what you're doing, but it's up to me to figure it out.

Well I am doing it partly to get you guys to input on what I say. Not necessarily to vote.

 

Is there anything I'm saying that you'd like to dispute?

[Eldrick4221]

If I make it to lylo and you still haven't figured me out, let it be a problem then.

Since you have trouble with me at the beginning, don't focus on me.

>.>

[Songstress]

And you didn't address why you weren't involved with yesterday's lynch. You have said something along the lines of both being motivated to play, ever since around when Darthe got lynched. Do you not see how that could look like being bummed about being the last scum?

 

Look, Eld.

 

I've made it VERY clear that I don't trust my reads this game because LOLME listing Alex as town and Darthe as my n1 peek, plus misreading Dice, and oh yeah, then there was Ed, and Adella....  I had Shanti as town all game, then suddenly D5 y'all are kicking her around as an option.

 

I was at work during that portion of the day where the majority of the discussion happened and trying to make sense of what to think about it.  After she blew up, I wanted to give her a chance to come back in when she was calmer.  We had almost a full day to vote and I thought I had time to contribute more, but Spades decided to hammer.  After the hammer there was nothing left to say but to hope it was right because this right here?  THIS IS MY NIGHTMARE SCENARIO.   In the best of times when I'm having a confident game I hate being at F3 because I'm always wrong.   This game is 20 times worse because I've been more wrong about everyone and everything and my confidence in being able to make a good decision is shot.

 

If you think this has a remote shot of being my scum game, you have not been paying attention.

[Songstress]

 

If I make it to lylo and you still haven't figured me out, let it be a problem then.

Since you have trouble with me at the beginning, don't focus on me.

>.>

 

 

*headdesk*

[Tigraine]

@eld- I actually addressed that more than once already I believe. Each time I gave reads, I either started at the top or the bottom of the OP list of players.

[Eldrick4221]

Ok. I remember what I was thinking then. I had reason to clear both of you (Tress and redd) if tigs flipped scum, but you could both independently be scum is she was town.

 

Ergo remembering what I was thinking there didn't help :/

[Eldrick4221]

 

And you didn't address why you weren't involved with yesterday's lynch. You have said something along the lines of both being motivated to play, ever since around when Darthe got lynched. Do you not see how that could look like being bummed about being the last scum?

 

 

Look, Eld.

 

I've made it VERY clear that I don't trust my reads this game because LOLME listing Alex as town and Darthe as my n1 peek, plus misreading Dice, and oh yeah, then there was Ed, and Adella....  I had Shanti as town all game, then suddenly D5 y'all are kicking her around as an option.

 

I was at work during that portion of the day where the majority of the discussion happened and trying to make sense of what to think about it.  After she blew up, I wanted to give her a chance to come back in when she was calmer.  We had almost a full day to vote and I thought I had time to contribute more, but Spades decided to hammer.  After the hammer there was nothing left to say but to hope it was right because this right here?  THIS IS MY NIGHTMARE SCENARIO.   In the best of times when I'm having a confident game I hate being at F3 because I'm always wrong.   This game is 20 times worse because I've been more wrong about everyone and everything and my confidence in being able to make a good decision is shot.

 

If you think this has a remote shot of being my scum game, you have not been paying attention.

Thank you for this response. I completely agree with the nightmare scenario part. I didn't want to be here either.

 

Your reasoning for not being involved makes sense. So does your explanation for your response.

 

To be fair, I don't know your scum game. I haven't played with you much.

[Songstress]

You might take into account the opinions of those who do.

[Eldrick4221]

@eld- I actually addressed that more than once already I believe. Each time I gave reads, I either started at the top or the bottom of the OP list of players.

I missed you saying it was an every time thing. I remember your bottom to top d2 explanation.

[Eldrick4221]

You might take into account the opinions of those who do.

I prefer to learn from personal experience. If you are town, this will hopefully be memorable in the future.

[Eldrick4221]

Tress, how well do you know Tigs?