[Advanced] Fight Club Mafia! - Game Thread!

Darthe · March 25, 2017

The comment I was referring to was regarding DPR.

I haven't read this entire game, like I said, but what little I've seen reminds me of the last two games I saw him as scum.

Very combative and lightly trolling but not so heavy that anyone wants him dead over it.

He is willing to engage in fights over minutia to keep his "opponent" and the rest of the town engaged on nothing instead of scum hunting.

IMO that's what he's doing right now.

[v]DPR[/v]

Also let's throw Darthe in there for now.

IMO it'll be a win win situation.

[v]Darthe[/v]

My train is a joke

Songstress · March 25, 2017

so FTR are you ccing darthe?

Oh heck no.

I don't believe there is a coroner role in the game, fwiw. From what I know about game balance, it makes no sense from a setup perspective.

Darthe made a convenient claim to get out of a lynch, and hasn't bothered to come back and answer legitimate questions. And as a claimed power role, he lived through the night, which kinda adds to my not believing him.

I mean, do you honestly believe him?

Coroner makes perfect sense in a game with a janitor. It's keeping powers in check so that mafia cant run amok if they do happen to kill a cop or whatnot.

Especially makes sense with any sort of rolestop, etc.

Psssh. Keep going. I'm having fun, are you?

Darthe · March 25, 2017

I figure it's a win win with regards to his claim.

It's typical of him to claim a PR to get out of being lynched.

Given that he's MIA with a result it looks like he might be on his scum meta as well.

Either he's lynched and it's resolved one way or another or DPR is lynched.

I'm ok with either outcome.

This is actually not a bad answer

Darthe · March 25, 2017

Other than Dice, who I'm pretty sure is town, I literally don't care who fights Darthe today. I am never voting to lynch anyone other than Darthe, and I'm not comfortable pulling anyone else out of the POE right now.

Not enough content to judge alignment:

9. Crusher - positive note is DPR's meta comment that he tends to be more active and involved as scum

12. Hallia - ??? where has she been?

Nullish but with some concerns:

8. Nolder (Wildfire Sedai) - WiFi's super defensive reaction to DPR's vote during RVS, plus her lack of involvement... Giving Nolder a chance to provide salient content but if he doesn't want to catch up on the earlier part of the game, I'm unsure if this is going to help.

4. Ironeyes - Early focus on Cuth for his attempt to start a train on Darthe, on the bright side he did move Darthe down to the bottom of his list D2. Has been a bit fence-sitty. Will be more concerned about him if DPR is town.

I have gone back and forth on all 3 of these at various points - they all show good engagement in the thread and appear to be attempting to solve, but there are things that concern me about all of them. I think it's most likely only one of them is mafia but I really couldn't tell you which one right now. Could be two with some distancing, but I would be surprised if there wasn't an inactive or one of my nulls on the team with Darthe and one of these three.

6. Seph

10. DreadPirateRoberts

13, Ed2funy

Tough to see a world where you arent fake claiming cop from my PoE, so yeah im calling it.

Simple logic, I can see my role PM which says town coroner, I see you didnt vote me last night, I see youre 100% on me out of nowhere today.

Darthe · March 25, 2017

Nice of you to show up and not answer DPR's questions about the mechanics of your role.

Its coroner, how hard is the role to understand??

Songstress · March 25, 2017

Other than Dice, who I'm pretty sure is town, I literally don't care who fights Darthe today. I am never voting to lynch anyone other than Darthe, and I'm not comfortable pulling anyone else out of the POE right now.

Not enough content to judge alignment:

9. Crusher - positive note is DPR's meta comment that he tends to be more active and involved as scum

12. Hallia - ??? where has she been?

Nullish but with some concerns:

8. Nolder (Wildfire Sedai) - WiFi's super defensive reaction to DPR's vote during RVS, plus her lack of involvement... Giving Nolder a chance to provide salient content but if he doesn't want to catch up on the earlier part of the game, I'm unsure if this is going to help.

4. Ironeyes - Early focus on Cuth for his attempt to start a train on Darthe, on the bright side he did move Darthe down to the bottom of his list D2. Has been a bit fence-sitty. Will be more concerned about him if DPR is town.

I have gone back and forth on all 3 of these at various points - they all show good engagement in the thread and appear to be attempting to solve, but there are things that concern me about all of them. I think it's most likely only one of them is mafia but I really couldn't tell you which one right now. Could be two with some distancing, but I would be surprised if there wasn't an inactive or one of my nulls on the team with Darthe and one of these three.

6. Seph

10. DreadPirateRoberts

13, Ed2funy

Tough to see a world where you arent fake claiming cop from my PoE, so yeah im calling it.

Simple logic, I can see my role PM which says town coroner, I see you didnt vote me last night, I see youre 100% on me out of nowhere today.

Gee, because I wasn't sure whether to believe you during the D2 fight phase, I can't decide I don't believe you D3 without it being a mafia fake claiming cop?

REALLY?

Songstress · March 25, 2017

Nice of you to show up and not answer DPR's questions about the mechanics of your role.

Its coroner, how hard is the role to understand??

HUMOR HIM.

Darthe · March 25, 2017

For the news youve all been waiting for, I was informed specifically that my action last night revealed nothing.

ROFL. Good job.

??? You really are a wolf arent you?

Songstress · March 25, 2017

For the news youve all been waiting for, I was informed specifically that my action last night revealed nothing.

ROFL. Good job.

??? You really are a wolf arent you?

I'm really not.

But you're really fun to fight.

HEY, GUYS. PUT ME IN, I VOLUNTEER TO BOX DARTHE.

Darthe · March 25, 2017

so FTR are you ccing darthe?
Oh heck no.

I don't believe there is a coroner role in the game, fwiw. From what I know about game balance, it makes no sense from a setup perspective.

Darthe made a convenient claim to get out of a lynch, and hasn't bothered to come back and answer legitimate questions. And as a claimed power role, he lived through the night, which kinda adds to my not believing him.

I mean, do you honestly believe him?

Coroner makes perfect sense in a game with a janitor. It's keeping powers in check so that mafia cant run amok if they do happen to kill a cop or whatnot.

Especially makes sense with any sort of rolestop, etc.

Psssh. Keep going. I'm having fun, are you?

Not really, no. Im here because its not fair not to be, but im busy irl and ive been sussed all game, for god only knows what reasons.

Darthe · March 25, 2017

Other than Dice, who I'm pretty sure is town, I literally don't care who fights Darthe today. I am never voting to lynch anyone other than Darthe, and I'm not comfortable pulling anyone else out of the POE right now.

Not enough content to judge alignment:

9. Crusher - positive note is DPR's meta comment that he tends to be more active and involved as scum

12. Hallia - ??? where has she been?

Nullish but with some concerns:

8. Nolder (Wildfire Sedai) - WiFi's super defensive reaction to DPR's vote during RVS, plus her lack of involvement... Giving Nolder a chance to provide salient content but if he doesn't want to catch up on the earlier part of the game, I'm unsure if this is going to help.

4. Ironeyes - Early focus on Cuth for his attempt to start a train on Darthe, on the bright side he did move Darthe down to the bottom of his list D2. Has been a bit fence-sitty. Will be more concerned about him if DPR is town.

I have gone back and forth on all 3 of these at various points - they all show good engagement in the thread and appear to be attempting to solve, but there are things that concern me about all of them. I think it's most likely only one of them is mafia but I really couldn't tell you which one right now. Could be two with some distancing, but I would be surprised if there wasn't an inactive or one of my nulls on the team with Darthe and one of these three.

6. Seph

10. DreadPirateRoberts

13, Ed2funy

Tough to see a world where you arent fake claiming cop from my PoE, so yeah im calling it.

Simple logic, I can see my role PM which says town coroner, I see you didnt vote me last night, I see youre 100% on me out of nowhere today.

Gee, because I wasn't sure whether to believe you during the D2 fight phase, I can't decide I don't believe you D3 without it being a mafia fake claiming cop?

REALLY?

Decide, sure. Resolute, unyielding push for "just cause", no. You're playing it like a claim, and didnt say you werent, so thats what it is. Youve hinted at it and are using that assumption planted on thread to back your word more strongly.

Im calling your crap crap.

Songstress · March 25, 2017

so FTR are you ccing darthe?
Oh heck no.

I don't believe there is a coroner role in the game, fwiw. From what I know about game balance, it makes no sense from a setup perspective.

Darthe made a convenient claim to get out of a lynch, and hasn't bothered to come back and answer legitimate questions. And as a claimed power role, he lived through the night, which kinda adds to my not believing him.

I mean, do you honestly believe him?

Coroner makes perfect sense in a game with a janitor. It's keeping powers in check so that mafia cant run amok if they do happen to kill a cop or whatnot.

Especially makes sense with any sort of rolestop, etc.

Psssh. Keep going. I'm having fun, are you?

Not really, no. Im here because its not fair not to be, but im busy irl and ive been sussed all game, for god only knows what reasons.

OK, so... you contend that you really are town coroner, and you refuse to go into detail about how your role works... and you got no result from targeting Sooh N2 because... roleblocked by mafia?

So tell me, are you the janitor or the roleblocker?

Songstress · March 25, 2017

Decide, sure. Resolute, unyielding push for "just cause", no. You're playing it like a claim, and didnt say you werent, so thats what it is. Youve hinted at it and are using that assumption planted on thread to back your word more strongly.

Im calling your crap crap.

You're so cute.

You're really not having fun?

I am disappointed.

Darthe · March 25, 2017

Nice of you to show up and not answer DPR's questions about the mechanics of your role.
Its coroner, how hard is the role to understand??

HUMOR HIM.

HUMOR YOUR BIGGEST WOLF READ, THE MOST FAMOUS MOD ON SITE, ABOUT THE MECHANICS OF A COMMON ROLE.

really?

Darthe · March 25, 2017

For the news youve all been waiting for, I was informed specifically that my action last night revealed nothing.
ROFL. Good job.
??? You really are a wolf arent you?

I'm really not.

But you're really fun to fight.

HEY, GUYS. PUT ME IN, I VOLUNTEER TO BOX DARTHE.

Thats a bold way to commit suicide

Songstress · March 25, 2017

Nice of you to show up and not answer DPR's questions about the mechanics of your role.
Its coroner, how hard is the role to understand??

HUMOR HIM.

HUMOR YOUR BIGGEST WOLF READ, THE MOST FAMOUS MOD ON SITE, ABOUT THE MECHANICS OF A COMMON ROLE.

really?

There are other people in this game who don't understand mechanics as well as DPR and I do.

And you stubbornly just won't give the info to benefit them because... we should just trust the guy who claimed coroner to save his own skin and then has no info to give at all?

Darthe · March 25, 2017

so FTR are you ccing darthe?
Oh heck no.

I don't believe there is a coroner role in the game, fwiw. From what I know about game balance, it makes no sense from a setup perspective.

Darthe made a convenient claim to get out of a lynch, and hasn't bothered to come back and answer legitimate questions. And as a claimed power role, he lived through the night, which kinda adds to my not believing him.

I mean, do you honestly believe him?

Coroner makes perfect sense in a game with a janitor. It's keeping powers in check so that mafia cant run amok if they do happen to kill a cop or whatnot.

Especially makes sense with any sort of rolestop, etc.

Psssh. Keep going. I'm having fun, are you?
Not really, no. Im here because its not fair not to be, but im busy irl and ive been sussed all game, for god only knows what reasons.

OK, so... you contend that you really are town coroner, and you refuse to go into detail about how your role works... and you got no result from targeting Sooh N2 because... roleblocked by mafia?

So tell me, are you the janitor or the roleblocker?

I dont refuse, I refuse for him. And you. Because im that guy. And its something y'all could google.

Songstress · March 25, 2017

For the news youve all been waiting for, I was informed specifically that my action last night revealed nothing.
ROFL. Good job.
??? You really are a wolf arent you?

I'm really not.

But you're really fun to fight.

HEY, GUYS. PUT ME IN, I VOLUNTEER TO BOX DARTHE.

Thats a bold way to commit suicide

Call me Katniss. :wink:

Songstress · March 25, 2017

I dont refuse, I refuse for him. And you. Because im that guy. And its something y'all could google.

You're that guy. :biggrin:

It's so fun to play with you.

Songstress · March 25, 2017

You know what disappoints me most?

It's the weekend, and so few people are actually around to watch this.

Darthe · March 25, 2017

Nice of you to show up and not answer DPR's questions about the mechanics of your role.
Its coroner, how hard is the role to understand??
HUMOR HIM.
HUMOR YOUR BIGGEST WOLF READ, THE MOST FAMOUS MOD ON SITE, ABOUT THE MECHANICS OF A COMMON ROLE.

really?

There are other people in this game who don't understand mechanics as well as DPR and I do.

And you stubbornly just won't give the info to benefit them because... we should just trust the guy who claimed coroner to save his own skin and then has no info to give at all?

Save my skin? I PUT MYSELF THERE. I VOTED ME. I talked about no lynching cuth after he and I talked a but at night. I claimed a role that needs results to work, ME, THE MOST FAMOUS FAKE CLAIMER ON SITE WHO KNOWS BASICALLY EVERY ROLE.

HOW DO YOU EXPLAIN ME RATIONALLY PLAYING THIS AS A WOLF? Darthe forgot foresight for the first time youve ever seen? He didnt plan his claim? He panicked?

I claimed a role that puts more pressure on me because it's true, simple as that. Were I an actual wolf I couldve claimed mason last night or vigilante, or jailkeeper, or tracker, or a half dozen other roles that off the top of my head would actually be helping me today instead of hurting me.

Darthe · March 25, 2017

You know what disappoints me most?

It's the weekend, and so few people are actually around to watch this.

Itll be worth a chuckle post game, tbf.

Songstress · March 25, 2017

Nice of you to show up and not answer DPR's questions about the mechanics of your role.
Its coroner, how hard is the role to understand??
HUMOR HIM.
HUMOR YOUR BIGGEST WOLF READ, THE MOST FAMOUS MOD ON SITE, ABOUT THE MECHANICS OF A COMMON ROLE.

really?

There are other people in this game who don't understand mechanics as well as DPR and I do.

And you stubbornly just won't give the info to benefit them because... we should just trust the guy who claimed coroner to save his own skin and then has no info to give at all?

Save my skin? I PUT MYSELF THERE. I VOTED ME. I talked about no lynching cuth after he and I talked a but at night. I claimed a role that needs results to work, ME, THE MOST FAMOUS FAKE CLAIMER ON SITE WHO KNOWS BASICALLY EVERY ROLE.

HOW DO YOU EXPLAIN ME RATIONALLY PLAYING THIS AS A WOLF? Darthe forgot foresight for the first time youve ever seen? He didnt plan his claim? He panicked?

I claimed a role that puts more pressure on me because it's true, simple as that. Were I an actual wolf I couldve claimed mason last night or vigilante, or jailkeeper, or tracker, or a half dozen other roles that off the top of my head would actually be helping me today instead of hurting me.

Hubris. It's always a fatal flaw. :wub:

Songstress · March 25, 2017

You know what disappoints me most?

It's the weekend, and so few people are actually around to watch this.

Itll be worth a chuckle post game, tbf.

I really need to play more often. *nod*

Darthe · March 25, 2017

Nice of you to show up and not answer DPR's questions about the mechanics of your role.
Its coroner, how hard is the role to understand??
HUMOR HIM.
HUMOR YOUR BIGGEST WOLF READ, THE MOST FAMOUS MOD ON SITE, ABOUT THE MECHANICS OF A COMMON ROLE.

really?

There are other people in this game who don't understand mechanics as well as DPR and I do.

And you stubbornly just won't give the info to benefit them because... we should just trust the guy who claimed coroner to save his own skin and then has no info to give at all?

Save my skin? I PUT MYSELF THERE. I VOTED ME. I talked about no lynching cuth after he and I talked a but at night. I claimed a role that needs results to work, ME, THE MOST FAMOUS FAKE CLAIMER ON SITE WHO KNOWS BASICALLY EVERY ROLE.

HOW DO YOU EXPLAIN ME RATIONALLY PLAYING THIS AS A WOLF? Darthe forgot foresight for the first time youve ever seen? He didnt plan his claim? He panicked?

I claimed a role that puts more pressure on me because it's true, simple as that. Were I an actual wolf I couldve claimed mason last night or vigilante, or jailkeeper, or tracker, or a half dozen other roles that off the top of my head would actually be helping me today instead of hurting me.

Hubris. It's always a fatal flaw.

No denying that one, but it goes both ways this round.

[Advanced] Fight Club Mafia! - Game Thread!

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook