[Advanced] Old West Mischief Mafia - Town Wins!

[seph]

So cass you actually think a town roleblocker would lie about roleblocking the town doctor just to get the doctor lynched?

[Darthe]

I don't think you're stupid, but you've currently got a stupid and incredibly improbable belief held up by a series of wild assumptions.

 

So its gonna be a challenge to not talk down to you.

[Cuth]

however the rest of this game pans out i'm going to look back on this and laugh

[Cuth]

So cass you actually think a town roleblocker would lie about roleblocking the town doctor just to get the doctor lynched?

but maybe he's not the roleblocker?

 

...

[MrsClov]

I don't think you're stupid, but you've currently got a stupid and incredibly improbable belief held up by a series of wild assumptions.

 

So its gonna be a challenge to not talk down to you.

 

Then expect me to do the same to you. 

[Darthe]

 

 

 

 

 

This is pretty locked up rn. What's the argument clov? I'm giving *myself* up for no reason to kill a doc who's been absent?

technically you're being pushed

 

but yes your play makes a ton more sense given the claim than hers

if darthe is telling the truth we netter a scum

If cass is telling the truth we netted a scum and lose 2 confirmed town. her and the nightkill kronos most likely.

 

Cuth from your prospective is it best for the doc to come forward and claim if cass is lying? or do we risk it.

if we risk it with darthe there is so much ++ if he is telling the truth, but also there is alot of negative when wrong.

 

or we can play it a bit safer ask the doc to claim. if no claim we lynch darthe. if a claim we lynch cass and the doc protects themselves or kronos.

OR YOU CAN JUST BELIEVE THAT I'M THE DOC

 

And there's an error with your bold - Just because I'm Town doesn't mean that Darthe is scum. More likely, yes, but not guaranteed - what advantage does scum have claiming here with one vote on them in Darthe's position?

What?? You are now proposing that im NOT a wolf?

I'm saying you could be either.

 

I had you wolfy but I'm not gonna pretend that I'm caught up enough to understand the tinier details of the game.

 

Go on and tell me how this is a bad thing.

Well... For starters it's bad because why would town me do that to town you??

[Cuth]

No no. Cuth, im a known busser so I decided I wanted to yolo 1 v 12-13 this game for the lolz.

this is also quite towny

 

this is a thing town says

[Darthe]

 

I don't think you're stupid, but you've currently got a stupid and incredibly improbable belief held up by a series of wild assumptions.

 

So its gonna be a challenge to not talk down to you.

Then expect me to do the same to you.

Somehow I think I'll live.

[seph]

 

So cass you actually think a town roleblocker would lie about roleblocking the town doctor just to get the doctor lynched?

but maybe he's not the roleblocker?

 

...

 

then i guess that makes him scum doesn't it =p

somehow, someway he could be town though... bastard mods <3

[Darthe]

 

So cass you actually think a town roleblocker would lie about roleblocking the town doctor just to get the doctor lynched?

but maybe he's not the roleblocker?

 

...

Im also a fake claimer ldo, get with the meta

[Cuth]

psa: cass HAS to claim doc 

 

darthe does not HAVE to claim RB, though it wouldn't be a bad idea

 

but if it's just him he always loses anyway

[seph]

in b4 cass is cum and darthe is scum and they concocted this plan so darth could actually 1vs 12 this game 

[seph]

CASS IS SCUM... almost worth the modkill to edit that....

[Darthe]

Dont forget if its not just me then im leaving my teammate alone in a game with like ten townies alive.

[Cuth]

 

 

So cass you actually think a town roleblocker would lie about roleblocking the town doctor just to get the doctor lynched?

but maybe he's not the roleblocker?

 

...

 

then i guess that makes him scum doesn't it =p

somehow, someway he could be town though... bastard mods <3

 

i mean technically he wouldn't know she's town

 

but given he has not shown an overwhelming factual conviction of her guilt

 

he's probably not assuming she's scum if he doesn't have a result that disagrees

[Darthe]

in b4 cass is cum and darthe is scum and they concocted this plan so darth could actually 1vs 12 this game

I would definitely scum if that actually worked.

[Cass]

So cass you actually think a town roleblocker would lie about roleblocking the town doctor just to get the doctor lynched?

 

I'm not saying he's Town lying. 

 

I'm saying I see possibility where he's Town.

 

I know two things:

 

- I protected Kronos

- Nobody died

 

My initial take on that was that I saved Kronos from a kill. He makes sense as the target to me, so that fits.

 

Next step

 

- My protect was successful

- My protect was blocked but didn't matter

 

I think it's highly unlikely that the Scum didn't submit a kill there, but it doesn't mean it's impossible

[Cuth]

in b4 cass is scum and darthe is scum and they concocted this plan so darth could actually 1vs 12 this game 

lol

[Cuth]

inb4 they're both town and there's another doc that actually protected kronos

[Darthe]

 

So cass you actually think a town roleblocker would lie about roleblocking the town doctor just to get the doctor lynched?

I'm not saying he's Town lying.

 

I'm saying I see possibility where he's Town.

 

I know two things:

 

- I protected Kronos

- Nobody died

 

My initial take on that was that I saved Kronos from a kill. He makes sense as the target to me, so that fits.

 

Next step

 

- My protect was successful

- My protect was blocked but didn't matter

 

I think it's highly unlikely that the Scum didn't submit a kill there, but it doesn't mean it's impossible

 

Post game we should chat about how it's not a good idea to fake claim when you're not present on thread. This is really half baked, and I raised you to be better.

[seph]

 

So cass you actually think a town roleblocker would lie about roleblocking the town doctor just to get the doctor lynched?

 

I'm not saying he's Town lying. 

 

I'm saying I see possibility where he's Town.

 

I know two things:

 

- I protected Kronos

- Nobody died

 

My initial take on that was that I saved Kronos from a kill. He makes sense as the target to me, so that fits.

 

Next step

 

- My protect was successful

- My protect was blocked but didn't matter

 

I think it's highly unlikely that the Scum didn't submit a kill there, but it doesn't mean it's impossible

 

true. but its pretty -ev to not submit a nk when your down 2 mafias. one more day you have to try and outlast everyone.

[Darthe]

inb4 they're both town and there's another doc that actually protected kronos

Liars gon lie yo

[Cass]

 

 

So cass you actually think a town roleblocker would lie about roleblocking the town doctor just to get the doctor lynched?

I'm not saying he's Town lying.

 

I'm saying I see possibility where he's Town.

 

I know two things:

 

- I protected Kronos

- Nobody died

 

My initial take on that was that I saved Kronos from a kill. He makes sense as the target to me, so that fits.

 

Next step

 

- My protect was successful

- My protect was blocked but didn't matter

 

I think it's highly unlikely that the Scum didn't submit a kill there, but it doesn't mean it's impossible

 

Post game we should chat about how it's not a good idea to fake claim when you're not present on thread. This is really half baked, and I raised you to be better.

 

 

You raised me to be good Scum, come talk to me when you wanna mentor me about being Town with limited time.

[seph]

just gana say the pr's have been pretty damn incredible if this holds up. They were actually pretty incredible b4 this. dare I say LEGENDARY

[seph]

cass I need you to do everything in your power and tell me why your the doctor.

n1 why protect dice who was pushing lzclov when the train we switched to was mafia. Wouldn't someone on that train be better? did you really think dice was a good n1 kill candidate if so why?