I went for Peace for the reasons I had been sussing him for. GK and Peace were both basically using the same argument, just on different people. Gk was who I was going to vote until he claimed. But the thing is, I couldn't have lynched Peace all by myself so obviously there was something that pinged others too. I sussed Darthe's "I am town" because it was his first post. He actually said something like "it's nice to be town again" and it just struck me as odd...which I explained at that time. It wasn't the words necessarily, it was the timing and deliverance. I would have gone with SD...was that the mafia's plan? Thanks for enlightening us....again, as I explained because he was on my radar and Darthe wasn't. What? Why are you trying to act like GK didn't get Nk'ed? He was either shot by Ed or shot by scum. But you gave a very plausible play then try to pretend it didn't happen... I'm going to need someone to explain how freeing up the doc, which you didn't know if there was one, would be more beneficial than the surprisingly surviving an attempt by scum to kill you? No joke, I seriously don't see it. And I didn't say anything about your D3 claim. It really didn't matter at that point because you had given away the advantage of knowing you couldn't have NAs used against you. Again, I applaud your play, cause it saw you through... And the same goes for Heavy that went for Peace....I couldn't have lynched either by myself. What argument would you have presented to save Heavy? I'm genuinely curious. Because Heavy dug himself into that mess

Omg I hate DM on mobile

I did try to hammer Peace and I did hammer Heavy, it sucks. Sucks even more that I wasn’t here to vote either Darthe or SD (i would've voted SD because I had sussed him from pretty early, other than announcing he was town right out of the gate and 1 more thing, Darthe managed not to ping me.) I had had Heavy as town all game until his claim came out and it just seemed he couldn't get his ducks in a row. You've legit been throwing shade my way ever since I sussed Darthe for his "I'm town" but I addressed that multiple times yet you acted like you'd never seen it, even repeating the sus. Speaking of which, you haven't answered why you'd give away a town advantage by advising the doc to not protect you (unless i missed it) and I've asked multiple times. It makes sense if you look at it as a wolf trying to coax the vigilante to not target you for a kill or a read and also explains your presence throughout the game because you claim to be a commuter and therefore not targetable by any NA, it's the only thing that makes sense because it didn't benefit town in any way I can see. It's actually pretty genius. Ed can kill me and they can deal with you tomorrow or maybe you're telling the truth, doesn't really explain why you told the doc not to protect you and doesn't explain why you repeatedly refuse to answer my question. But if thats the case then you and whatever town are left can figure out who the last wolf is. I'd like to be here to see this through but I win with town regardless of when I get killed.

I did try to hammer Peace and I did hammer Heavy, it sucks. Sucks even more that I wasn’t here to vote either Darthe or SD (i would've voted SD because I had sussed him from pretty early, other than announcing he was town right out of the gate and 1 more thing, Darthe managed not to ping me.) I had had Heavy as town all game until his claim came out and it just seemed he couldn't get his ducks in a row. You've legit been throwing shade my way ever since I sussed Darthe for his "I'm town" but I addressed that multiple times yet you acted like you'd never seen it, even repeating the sus. Speaking of which, you haven't answered why you'd give away a town advantage by advising the doc to not protect you (unless i missed it) and I've asked multiple times. It makes sense if you look at it as a wolf trying to coax the vigilante to not target you for a kill or a read and also explains your presence throughout the game because you claim to be a commuter and therefore not targetable by any NA, it's the only thing that makes sense because it didn't benefit town in any way I can see. It's actually pretty genius. Ed can kill me and they can deal with you tomorrow or maybe you're telling the truth, doesn't really explain why you told the doc not to protect you and doesn't explain why you repeatedly refuse to answer my question. But if thats the case then you and whatever town are left can figure out who the last wolf is. I'd like to be here to see this through but I win with town regardless of when I get killed.

I honestly dont see any reason to draw it out with you at L-1. I don't know what Turin will have to say but I don't see it leading in a direction away from you at the moment because of everything that's happened this day phase. Vote: Heavy

Because I'm not trying to lynch just anyone. I'm trying to look at the possibilities too, the ones least likely to most likely. I just don't see any benefit of holstering. Maybe it's above my head I just do not see it. So I'm working through those possibilities and asking questions to get as close as possible to the truth. This game looked bleak after D1 and N1. But the tables have turned so I want to continue down that path.

Are we really thinking that 5 out of 8 townies have or had abilities?

Would definitely be one for the books. As I've said, I feel slightly better about dice since SD turned out to be a goon in comparison to Darthe's role. It still really nags at me that Turin handled his claimed role like he did. I don't understand how, at that time, it benefited town. Heavy, man I've felt good about you all game but the good feeling is starting to dwindle. I agree that Ed is vig. @DPR, you said you Roleblocked Dice right? And used the JK on Heavy so that would keep any of his actions from working but also keep any from working on him? I just want to make sure I'm clear on those things and how they work. Fwiw, I believe DPR's claim. Our options for the lack of NK are that the mafia holstered which is highly unlikely mafia!Dice submitted the NK Heavy was targeted Heavy submitted the NK Or scum didn't believe Turin and targeted him which I also find unlikely. @HeavyHalfMoonBlade What is it that makes you doubt DPR's claim and Ed's? Do you have the same reservations about Turin? @Turin Turambar and @dicetosser1 where do you all stand on believing the claims of everyone so far? Turin, what made you announce for the doc not to protect you? I know you can argue "well so they could protect someone else" but I honestly dont think and I don't think you thought there was any danger in that (maybe I'm wrong) i want simple words for my simple mind. Yes I believe, no I don't not believe. @ed2funy what's it looking like from the cheap seats?

Where did you pull the word informant from?

Yeah, I probably should've clarified it lol

Why did you think he had a NK?

No that's my point. If he's scum, why jump to the person with at least some of a role instead of staying put and not making yourself stand out.

I have a zoom meeting at 8:30 for my kid to enroll in summer blind camp (i didn't know that was a thing). I'll be back after.

The previous post was supposed to say breadcrumbing lol Seeing as SD was a talentless goon, it makes me feel better about Dice. It made sense for him to switch from one scummate to another (if he's scum) Only if the former had a better role. Or at least, that's how I see it. I hate that I dont know game mechanics from a mods point of view. It would help make more sense of is it logical to give town a 1x role just cause the cop fecked it all up.

Turin breadcrumbs his role has always rubbed me the wrong way. If I'm a hider or a commuter or absolutely anything that protects me at night, I'm not announcing it for no reason. Reason? Because by alerting the masses for the doc not to protect him, he's giving the mafia team a heads up and almost guaranteeing they don't target him. You should want them to target you at night, that means there is a possibility of 1) saving another townie and 2) helping town numbers by having no NK. I dont see that as the reason there was no NK (although with everything that has been claimed, I dont think we can figure out why there was no NK unless someone slips.) I just dont understand giving away the advantage of a hider type role. Man, you need to let that go. I'm not saying that saying you're town is not town. I just thought it was odd that Darthe's very first post was an "ahhh I'm town" (not verbatim). It pinged for me as something that was just an odd first statement. That and his "let's take it slow" remark then voting were the two things that stood out the most to me about Darthe. Although I would like to state for the record that Darthe announcing he was town, was in fact, not town. Nananabooboo 😛 I am Vanilla Town. Idk what it's like to mod, but I can imagine it's pretty difficult to balance a game out perfectly. With that being said, so far we've seen the roles of 2 of the mafia. 1 was a 50/50 bus driver? I'll check the OP to make sure and a goon. How many roles would it make sense for town to have? That's a genuine question because as I said, I'm no mod. Gonna post this then go to my next point.

Okay! I thought that's what you said but when I looked up JoaT it said a kill, rb and a protection

We are under a tornado watch...let me tell y'all, a tornado gets in these mountains and it's going to be like a ping pong game round here. What does everyone think of Heavy's claim? Turin already said he doesn't believe him. But what does everyone else think?

Okay, I looked up Joat I forgot they had a kill.

DPR has a NK? I missed that altogether

That's literally the best possible scenario...we might turn this around after all!

Y'all wanna know what it's like living in Eastern Kentucky? The school board sent out auto calls at 2:20 to let parents know they were dismissing school at 2 🤦‍♀️

This word is right up there with shenanigans, it just isn't used enough.

I'm gonna guess Toffee is a rich brown color lol

I didn't have Darthe as scum but SD has been up there. I can see SD stalling and not knowing what to do about whether to go after a teammate or unsure of how to look the most innocent while protecting a teammate. But I'm not sure Dice would get caught up like that.

Bloody hell! @HeavyHalfMoonBlade nope, you didn't miss any questions, I thought I had asked one but dont know what it was anyway . Also, it wouldn't let me delete the tag on Ed fyi