[Advanced] Lost Mafia--Game Over!

[Eldrick4221]

He could also literally be the cult leader, and this was all smoke to make us think otherwise

[BFG]

Man I wish I knew what claim generator was. My search for it is bringing up a role maker

Man I wish I knew what claim generator was. My search for it is bringing up a role maker

There are a couple of DM mafia role threads floating around this board, but a search for the role comes up with nothing. Would guess it's a safe claim thing

[Eldrick4221]

I get the feeling Lenlo has some kind of vampire hunter type role. Targets someone and if they are cult they die.

This better fits his concept of expecting this to be a PR heavy game. It's an obscure role

[Eldrick4221]

 

Man I wish I knew what claim generator was. My search for it is bringing up a role maker

Man I wish I knew what claim generator was. My search for it is bringing up a role maker

There are a couple of DM mafia role threads floating around this board, but a search for the role comes up with nothing. Would guess it's a safe claim thing

I tried looking on MafiaScum :P

[Eldrick4221]

I assume you're caught up, bfg?

[BFG]

He could also literally be the cult leader, and this was all smoke to make us think otherwise

Would be bold

[BFG]

where i'm at:

 

villas:

shad(peeked AJ)

eld(tracked cald)

darthe(claimed 2x vig)

wildfire(consensus)

calder(pushed AJ, pushed by AJ)

tiinker(d1 interactions made me think him/AJ weren't w/w)

 

???:

pralaya

 

concerned:

lenlo(claimed some sort of role that implies there is a cult,)

marsh

 

wolfy:

BFG

not bob

 

lenlo(claimed solies there is a cult,)

Gets complicated if there's a cult

 

Ignoring a cult; Pral, Lenlo, Marsh, maybe NB (need to check AJ/NB interactions, but independently he looks ok)

 

With a cult ???

[BFG]

I assume you're caught up, bfg?

Let's say yes

[Eldrick4221]

You just answered half my question lol.

 

Top 2 town, not counting claims?

[Eldrick4221]

As in besides Darthe, me, and shad

[Eldrick4221]

The grammar Nazi in me is screaming about how I said "me" second. I did it in order of claims :P

[BFG]

You just answered half my question lol.

 

Top 2 town, not counting claims?

Without considering a cult Calder, Tiinker, WiFi

 

With a cult WiFi and probably Calder

[BFG]

The grammar Nazi in me is screaming about how I said "me" second. I did it in order of claims :P

Semi sure you should have said Darthe, Shad and I anyway :p (the grammar fairy in me is weak)

[Eldrick4221]

 

The grammar Nazi in me is screaming about how I said "me" second. I did it in order of claims :P

Semi sure you should have said Darthe, Shad and I anyway :p (the grammar fairy in me is weak)

"me" is correct, as it was referencing the second part of the sentence

 

Who are youready town reads besides [insert list]

 

But it should have been listed last.

[Eldrick4221]

Omg. I hate my phone's autocorrect.

 

Backspace to get rid of space and last letter of word. Fix last letter. Hit space and it thinks the letter I fixed is the start of a new word and "finishes it"

[Eldrick4221]

 

You just answered half my question lol.

 

Top 2 town, not counting claims?

Without considering a cult Calder, Tiinker, WiFi

 

With a cult WiFi and probably Calder

Are those in order?

 

And I asked for 2 not 3 :P

[Eldrick4221]

Also curious where bop falls on your list.

 

Because it very much looks like you are quoting his list to agree with it and then copying his list to answer me.

[Eldrick4221]

Maybe not copying per say, but he is noticeably lacking from these groups.

 

Your scum list is like half of the game. After excluding the 3 claimed roles you were left with 4 people and named everyone but him.

[Eldrick4221]

 

where i'm at:

 

villas:

shad(peeked AJ)

eld(tracked cald)

darthe(claimed 2x vig)

wildfire(consensus)

calder(pushed AJ, pushed by AJ)

tiinker(d1 interactions made me think him/AJ weren't w/w)

 

???:

pralaya

 

concerned:

lenlo(claimed some sort of role that implies there is a cult,)

marsh

 

wolfy:

BFG

not bob

 

lenlo(claimed solies there is a cult,)

I like your reasons for calder and tink. They both don't make much sense to be aj's teammate

 

(Assuming that aj is mafia which I'm still not 100% on. Weeeiiird flip)

 

Not sold on shad and darthe's claims though.

 

Darthe for hopefully obvious reasons.

 

Shad because of what I quoted earlier. If he knew aj wasn't town all day, why did he push for bfg first, and try to link them?

[Eldrick4221]

Btw I'm gonna let the nice/naughty thing die with aj. It was fun while it lasted but so hard to remember and some terms are just awkward to change.

[BFG]

Also curious where bop falls on your list.

 

Because it very much looks like you are quoting his list to agree with it and then copying his list to answer me.

Bop is someone I need to look into more closely.

 

Outside claims, I agree that Calder (in particular) and Tiinker are unlikely to be teamed with AJ.

 

WiFis list and posts quoted by Shad ~sound like town!Wifi (another lazy read though), I still haven't come across a post that screams town for her, but a quiet shout is still pretty good. I also haven't ISOd her yet so the possibility that I've missed it is high.

 

 

That's basically Bops town list, people who have claims made in a way that implies town (Shad never fake claims to kill a teammate, you probably don't claim to help Calder if mafia, Darthe is unlikely to fake claim vig since it's a proveable role), the 2 players who are most spewed by AJs death and a consensus town, whose there because concensus not because he's reading her town

 

So the generic list is fine.

 

His posts generically are fine, from what I recall he was (very?) early calling you town and I always like early game play. He tangled with DPR(?) Day 1 as opposed to being more passive

 

Gut vibe from Day 1 would be town, but I want to check his reactions to Calders case

 

He's also ideal recruit material, and the fact that there's been so much discussion about a cult without either panic or a complete shut down of it, coupled with AJ flipping Other instead of mafia implies at the least a faction game and likely a cult :/

[BFG]

Shad never busses AJ like that, I would guess he was looking for info

[Eldrick4221]

Calder doing a 180 and catching aj looks really good for him. I still disagree on the premise of the 180. It read to me as trying to figure tink out.

 

But the fact that he did it and was right is worth keeping in mind.

[Eldrick4221]

And aj still very well could have been a solo 3rd party. We don't know.

[Eldrick4221]

The fact that so many people were wary of him was why I was going to track him. I was convinced he was town, but that obviously doesn't mean I'm right.

 

And the fact that he knew I felt that way would mean he shouldn't suspect me to track him