Grim Frostbitten Scumlust -- MAFIA WINS

[Cory Caboose]

on like page 2 and i already really like sooh.

[alannalynn]

Anything else from me? Sleeping soon/nowish

[Cory Caboose]

reads on everyone

 

do like what i did. can just be short blurbs

 

even if the answer is "idk eh"

[Cory Caboose]

just wanna see where you're at in like totality. even the people you know little about.

[alannalynn]

I would like to reference back like 1-2 pages where I tried

[alannalynn]

CorNyn - probably town; not going to dig into the reasons since it's probably concensus anyways

 

Dice - probably town, I'm liking his tone primarily and he seems really upfront when he posts

 

Sooh - null with townish lean for tone earlier d1

 

Kat - was townish on my list (I don't remember why) but I don't recall much from her today so I dunno. I know it's almost the weekend and she wont be around. Might have to go back and see what exactly I liked for me to move her up

 

Darthe - likely town - doesn't feel shifty - likely v/v with CorNyn

 

Tiinker - null, don't know how to read him, have liked most his posts thus far

 

Pral - also have liked posts, but unsure/mixed

 

GF and NB - totally null???

 

Crusher - didn't understand his beef with Cory, also he's kind of dropped off, possible scum lean

 

Hallia - null/townish maybe - she picked up a bit from where I was at a the beginning

 

Lenlo - not overly impressed right now, scummish nullish lean

[Cory Caboose]

i can't read from the beginning to the end while also reading from the end to the beginning ALANNA. it would be chaos. time going one way, time going the other all at once. science isn't capable of that yet. even Memento wasn't  anyway near that confusing

[Cory Caboose]

come on. 

 

we could be taco fronds.

[alannalynn]

Wibbly wobbly timey wimey

 

Watch some doctor who, time is far from linear

[alannalynn]

come on.

 

we could be taco fronds.

we're not already Taco fronds? =/

[Cory Caboose]

Id have read len town anyhow methinks, I have nothing on anyone else, shape up folks. Who's here?

 

What made you think Lenlo was acting villagery at this point? Can you explain that?

 

This isn't about the peek, this is about your perception of him.

[Cory Caboose]

 

come on.

 

we could be taco fronds.

we're not already Taco fronds? =/

 

i only share my tacos with villagers and i don't know i can give you one yet :(

[Cory Caboose]

it's just a moral rule

 

i can't override my love for the genuine no matter what i do

[Cory Caboose]

 

Have you seen Tiink as town?  I only ever played with him that one game where he was scum.

I haven't, but that's so towny though. 

 

I have thought the same so many times. Someone posts a simple hello and others clear them for it. 

 

 

I think this is a genuine read from Sooh re: Tinker. Unfortunately I think she may be wrong about Tiinker but that's the game :(

 

But this reads real from Sooh. Her cover and the snap decision to do it are things that come from a villager way more often than a wolf.

 

I won't discuss the cover thing any further but I have to speak up about this in particular because I think Tiinker is a wolf.

 

He's hiding behind this "read me wolfy for doing nothing, punk" kind of tone I see tired wolves emulate. well named used to do this all the time. "Too wolfy to be a wolf" sort of taunting where you're able to mail a game in on the merit of being somewhat more involved as a wolf.

 

Different isn't always good in mafia. People's games develop and change.

[Cory Caboose]

[v]Tiinker[/v]

 

Perhaps you will just never rand villager again.

 

Oh, fickle fate.

[Cory Caboose]

through ten:

 

Hallia

Sooh

Katiora
Dice

Darthe

Crusher

Graendal

Lenlo

Tiinker

 

taking a break but will be back

[Cory Caboose]

starting to feel like cory caboose again after a long time dormant.

 

sorry in advance if i turn out to be wrong but i'm feeling like a young man again

[Cory Caboose]

 

no one's asked me but i'm town

 

^^^scum^^^

 

 

NotBob might be secret GOATing?

[Cory Caboose]

NotBob when you are around can you tell me what you found wolfy about that Tiinker post.

 

Want to see something.

[Cory Caboose]

 

NB are you reading backwards or what are you doing?

 

My modus operandi is to start reading where I left off and post my thoughts as I read them...I just started this game so you my thoughts as I read them...Occasionally, I see when someone quotes me and I read that and respond if I think it could help.  So its not exactly a timeline but meh...you get the idea.

 

 

 

That doesn't make sense but ok.

 

this was an epic conversation

[Cory Caboose]

 

 

 

Up through page 10

 

 

Sooh, can you do that thing you did last game? I'd appreciate it.

Will attempt to. 

 

Should we generate some talk and then I'll do something crazy?

 

Can't do the same this game though, or I'd just be copying a town game which I probably could do as a scumbag.

 

 

Honestly?  I like this response from Sooh.  Feels very transparent

 

 

 

let's see.... here's the list... 

 

666. Darthe - here

666. Tiinker - here

666. Hallia - here

666. Alanna ?

666. Pralaya - here? 

666. Crusher - ?

666. Katiora - here in body but absent in mind

666. Lenlo - here

666. Corny (Cory + Nyn) The corn has arrived... 

666. Graendals favourite - here

666. NotBob - no

666. Sooh - here

666. Dice - here

 

 

Honestly I've slept since the game started so i'm not sure if I remember who's not here yet lol 

Does Kat go through the trouble to do this as scum?  I don't think so (I mean, sure anyone can physically do it, it's not difficult, but I don't see scumKat going through the thought process to do so.)

 

 

 

 

Crusher you gonna play play or just harbor resentment in me playing to my WC - as I'm supposed to do - in another game

Lmk friend

I was planning on doing both. Dude I haven't been fooled in Mafia like you fooled me in years. Reason I'm actually excited to play again. Still want to never get fooled like that by you again. If you are suggesting I'm not playing? I did make a point about Kat not reading

the game. She said she was tired. Tired at DM? Nap capital of the interwebz? Should offer Nolder as a nap tutor . What you think about that. I mean I voted, unvoted and had a vote on the last vote count .

 

 

Crusher feels pretty villagery, Cory.  Not just this post, but I feel like he actually is excited to play again.

 

Almost forgot today was a short day. 24 hours as of this post to deadline and still in jokey phase.

 

[v]Alanna[/v]

 

I posit that Alanna is wolf. Why? No activity. Alanna is known to not like playing wolf. Ex: When I recruited her in GnD.

 

Problem with theory: 10 pages in, not alot of time to get in and post. Even Pral has posted is the thing though, so like... cmon?

 

Even with the short deadline, I wasn't bugging about the not posting, but as I said, when she did arrive tone would be a big thing for me there, and so far she's in the null to scum range.

 

Hallia what do you think of Crusher hun?

 

See above; I am getting villavibes.

 

 

eh?

 

Why not?

 

non committal post as a scumbag but looks like she's doing work?

 

Not saying she's scum. Just saying you're giving out town points very easily.

 

 

 

 

But I like giving town points. ; . ;

 

I'm off to bed for now though, five-thirty comes early. 

Nighty night :)

 

 

 

 

 

let's see.... here's the list... 

 

666. Darthe - here

666. Tiinker - here

666. Hallia - here

666. Alanna ?

666. Pralaya - here? 

666. Crusher - ?

666. Katiora - here in body but absent in mind

666. Lenlo - here

666. Corny (Cory + Nyn) The corn has arrived... 

666. Graendals favourite - here

666. NotBob - no

666. Sooh - here

666. Dice - here

 

 

Honestly I've slept since the game started so i'm not sure if I remember who's not here yet lol 

 

Does Kat go through the trouble to do this as scum?  I don't think so (I mean, sure anyone can physically do it, it's not difficult, but I don't see scumKat going through the thought process to do so.)

 

 

Uh why not? It's contributing without contributing. You're seeming pretty generous with some of your reads.

 

 

considering post #2 is all inbetween post #3 and post #1 this doesn't seem like a particularly original contribution re: a suspect.

 

very weak.

[Cory Caboose]

 

let's see.... here's the list... 

 

666. Darthe - here

666. Tiinker - here

666. Hallia - here

666. Alanna ?

666. Pralaya - here? 

666. Crusher - ?

666. Katiora - here in body but absent in mind

666. Lenlo - here

666. Corny (Cory + Nyn) The corn has arrived... 

666. Graendals favourite - here

666. NotBob - no

666. Sooh - here

666. Dice - here

 

 

 

Honestly I've slept since the game started so i'm not sure if I remember who's not here yet lol 

 

Don't like this. Like Hallia said, this looks like an attempt to show she is being busy. It is literally just 7 pages at this point, so I don't see what the point of the last sentence is. 

 

 

 

 

Thoughts:

CorNyn and Sooh look good

Crusher jumpy and feuding with Cory why?

Too much joking going on for most of d1

Lenlo + points for trying to get things going

Dice town

Hey I can actually read this game, nice! Nyn loss wolfy to me, Ditto cory

What does this mean?

Sooh/Nyn happy to keep fluff going? Sooh tone still vry light

@Crusher what does Kat stand to gain by miscounting who had checked in or not? Why would that make her scum?

@Crusher what is your reasoning for being sus of CorNyn? (#163)

Fluff from Halla. -

Graendal null

#191 lol~Lenlo

[v]Lenlo[/v] for the terrible push

@Cory explain Hally town read, why does Crusher's response make you feel good, who is your maybe wolf? #203 is good

Crusher: #214?

 

 

Isn't that the point?

 

 

These both feel a bit "easy" don't they?

 

Kat had just been harped on by a few players pretty reasonlessly, and the Laine thing is something that isn't at all wolfy but some people might be fooled into thinking is "wolfy"

[Cory Caboose]

God Pral and Tiinker if you reunited as scum again and didn't invite me back i am going to be so offended

[Cory Caboose]

 

Darthe - Reads crusher and len town. And, Cory scum. Kind of weird and null. 

Tiinker - Agree with his read on Kat. The conversation with NB regarding his town statement is random at best. Slight townie.

Hallia - I like her analysisng posts and trying to get the game going. Similar to her townie play in other games. 

Lenlo -  The main thing that stands out is him calling out both Darthe and Alanna to "start the game going". And, Alanna votes back Lenlo for his play. Gun to the head, I don't see them v/v. 

Alanna - See above

Crusher - Have played with him in only one game. Null, but his aggressive play with Cory is not something a scum would do. Maybe leaning town because of it.

Katiora - Like I said, she seemed to act busy even when it didn't matter. And, this is what makes me feel she is slightly scum. 

Corny (Cory + Nyn) - The tone of Cory is quite like he is trying his best to solve the game. Town, undoubtedly.

Graendals favourite. Null.

NotBob. Null, nothing much stands out.

Sooh - A lot of her posts seem too goodie-goodie. Like her random defense of kat or her response to Nyn or posts like these. She is usually much more impulsive than she is in this game. I would say slightly scummy.

Dice - Sounds a but towny but would put him in null. NOt enough moves from him yet. 

 

 

Tinker post highlighted because I think that could easily be w/w.

 

Hinging most of his action on his read of Sooh, most of the other reads are very bare and kind of shallow.

[Cory Caboose]

 

 

Darthe - Reads crusher and len town. And, Cory scum. Kind of weird and null. 

Tiinker - Agree with his read on Kat. The conversation with NB regarding his town statement is random at best. Slight townie.

Hallia - I like her analysisng posts and trying to get the game going. Similar to her townie play in other games. 

Lenlo -  The main thing that stands out is him calling out both Darthe and Alanna to "start the game going". And, Alanna votes back Lenlo for his play. Gun to the head, I don't see them v/v. 

Alanna - See above

Crusher - Have played with him in only one game. Null, but his aggressive play with Cory is not something a scum would do. Maybe leaning town because of it.

Katiora - Like I said, she seemed to act busy even when it didn't matter. And, this is what makes me feel she is slightly scum. 

Corny (Cory + Nyn) - The tone of Cory is quite like he is trying his best to solve the game. Town, undoubtedly.

Graendals favourite. Null.

NotBob. Null, nothing much stands out.

Sooh - A lot of her posts seem too goodie-goodie. Like her random defense of kat or her response to Nyn or posts like these. She is usually much more impulsive than she is in this game. I would say slightly scummy.

Dice - Sounds a but towny but would put him in null. NOt enough moves from him yet.

Re defense of Kat. My joke vote is still on her.

 

The Nyn response I get. I would probably read that as suspicious as well. Not sure exactly what that last post is supposed to prove? Too goodie goodie? Well, I haven't been very involved yet. It'll change, and I suspect your read will as well.

 

Well, the point is that you seem to be trying to look more townie making posts that town would love to read. Much similar to how Clov was playing in the Danger in Demons Cove game. I am getting a similar vibe here.

 

I don't get what you were trying to say regarding Kat. My comment was on your comment rather than the vote

 

 

Nyn mentioned to me several times that Pral was approaching Sooh the same way that he approached Clov in Danger in Demons Cove.

 

Pral is cognizant of this and is a better wolf than you guys give him credit for. He grows from game to game in his own way, and would have little problem integrating something he recently did as a villager into his villager game.

 

Think this also spews Sooh villager if Pral is a wolf completely.