[Basic] I <3 the 90's Mafia: Music Edition - TOWN WINS!

[Clovdyx]

Just the way you phrased it.  

 

"Those seem like easy and necessary reads for him to make."

"As mafia."

 

It didn't sound like you were hedging that stance at all.  

[Sili Quirrels]

Sili, so why did you tell me you didn't think he was mafia?

Where and when did I do this?

[Sili Quirrels]

Just the way you phrased it.  

 

"Those seem like easy and necessary reads for him to make."

"As mafia."

 

It didn't sound like you were hedging that stance at all.  

Bfg asked what I meant by 'necessary reads'. I said, 'necessary reads as mafia' which I felt gave enough context for bfg to connect the dots.

 

I was just being brief.

[BFG]

@Lenlo, I don't know if this still needs explaining or not. I'm not saying that if Laine is town that Seph is mafia, I'm saying that they're not m/m. What do you mean by feisty for Hallia?

[Sili Quirrels]

Feisty like a panda is feisty.

 

[Sili Quirrels]

Was actually going to quote statistics of deaths by pandas but then I found that meme lol.

[BFG]

 

sili have I ever wolfed against you?

Unsure.

 

So you think Seph is mafia?

No.

 

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

 

sili have I ever wolfed against you?

Unsure.

 

So you think Seph is mafia?

No.

 

I had a null read then.

 

It was after I dropped Seph.

[BFG]

BFG linking ??? I don't remember who and Lainey, who hasn't posted, is still weird for me. Whoever pointed that out gets a cookie. Her explanation of the person ??? talking about Lainey in a way that was never w/w feels contrived.

I'm not sure I understand how you can be poking this when you don't remember the post or people involved?

 

 

Who was it that BFG tied to Lainey? Zander claimed cookie credit, will go back and check, bah humbug

 

 

 

 

Worth noting that if Seph flips mafia Laine is probably town, but Seph is probably town anyway :p

ummmmmm what?????

 

Has Laine even posted yet......???

 

Okay, I found it. Zander gets a cookie, but only half a cookie because reaction seems able to be contrived, and I don't like how nice he was when he entered the thread and joked around with the videos (sorry to me for not spoilering). Probably an awful read but idc. Just a bunch of doubt because he seems to be more abrasive when he's town [exception: tunneling on a wolf bro], and I'm not seeing it as much here.

 

Weird to link Seph and Lainey. Going to go and find the post that BFG must be referring to in order to see if this read is legit at all.

 

Did you ever follow through with this? If so what do you think now?

[Clovdyx]

Sili, so why did you tell me you didn't think he was mafia?

 

 

@Lenlo, I don't know if this still needs explaining or not. I'm not saying that if Laine is town that Seph is mafia, I'm saying that they're not m/m. What do you mean by feisty for Hallia?

 

 

 

BFG linking ??? I don't remember who and Lainey, who hasn't posted, is still weird for me. Whoever pointed that out gets a cookie. Her explanation of the person ??? talking about Lainey in a way that was never w/w feels contrived.

I'm not sure I understand how you can be poking this when you don't remember the post or people involved?

 

 

Who was it that BFG tied to Lainey? Zander claimed cookie credit, will go back and check, bah humbug

 

 

 

 

Worth noting that if Seph flips mafia Laine is probably town, but Seph is probably town anyway :p

ummmmmm what?????

 

Has Laine even posted yet......???

 

Okay, I found it. Zander gets a cookie, but only half a cookie because reaction seems able to be contrived, and I don't like how nice he was when he entered the thread and joked around with the videos (sorry to me for not spoilering). Probably an awful read but idc. Just a bunch of doubt because he seems to be more abrasive when he's town [exception: tunneling on a wolf bro], and I'm not seeing it as much here.

 

Weird to link Seph and Lainey. Going to go and find the post that BFG must be referring to in order to see if this read is legit at all.

 

Did you ever follow through with this? If so what do you think now?

 

 

You randed town, didn't you? 

[BFG]

 

Worth noting that if Seph flips mafia Laine is probably town, but Seph is probably town anyway :p

this makes sense. But I do find it a little strange seph called me out at all.

 

Actually that is interesting, I still can't recall which game I called Seph out as mafia

[BFG]

Course I did <3 you need a twisted mind (like Leelou or Eldrick) to rand me as anything other than town out of the BT

[BFG]

Seph is the person I feel best about at this point.  It's definitely not an incredibly strong read, but solid.  I like how he came out swinging against Sili, especially consideirng Sili's argument made no sense, and I don't feel he was stumbling over himself trying to answer questions about it.  I kinda think Sili was kicking dirt on him to see if it would stick, which is a good look for him too.

 

I really don't understand why anybody has an issue with BFG's argument about Seph/Alanna.  I said before I would guess she's probably right, and I would stand by that even if I didn't feel particularly good about Seph.  I can't rule out the possibility Mafia!Seph wrote it with the deliberate intention of townspewing a teammate, but I would be very, very surprised if that's the case.  More importantly, I think that's a pro-town observation for her to make.  The only way that thought comes from a mafia motivation is if all three of them are mafia together and she's looking for something to clear one of Alanna/Seph in case the other one dies, since Mafia!BFG would essentially be forced to clear town!Alanna if Seph is a teammate and clear Seph as town should Alanna flip mafia.

Hmmmmm, I'm not sure my statement is strong enough to preclude backtracking on either of them if the other flipped mafia, but agree with the rest

[Clovdyx]

Course I did <3 you need a twisted mind (like Leelou or Eldrick) to rand me as anything other than town out of the BT

 

Christmas wasn't that long ago... 

 

 

But I do believe you, fwiw

[BFG]

Anyway back later :)

[BFG]

 

Course I did <3 you need a twisted mind (like Leelou or Eldrick) to rand me as anything other than town out of the BT

 

Christmas wasn't that long ago... 

 

 

But I do believe you, fwiw

 

<3

 

That's my only mafia rand in over 2 years on this board... Pral's game over Christmas was the only game in the BT I've randed town in for well over a year as well holiday spirit or something?

[Clovdyx]

 

Seph is the person I feel best about at this point.  It's definitely not an incredibly strong read, but solid.  I like how he came out swinging against Sili, especially consideirng Sili's argument made no sense, and I don't feel he was stumbling over himself trying to answer questions about it.  I kinda think Sili was kicking dirt on him to see if it would stick, which is a good look for him too.

 

I really don't understand why anybody has an issue with BFG's argument about Seph/Alanna.  I said before I would guess she's probably right, and I would stand by that even if I didn't feel particularly good about Seph.  I can't rule out the possibility Mafia!Seph wrote it with the deliberate intention of townspewing a teammate, but I would be very, very surprised if that's the case.  More importantly, I think that's a pro-town observation for her to make.  The only way that thought comes from a mafia motivation is if all three of them are mafia together and she's looking for something to clear one of Alanna/Seph in case the other one dies, since Mafia!BFG would essentially be forced to clear town!Alanna if Seph is a teammate and clear Seph as town should Alanna flip mafia.

Hmmmmm, I'm not sure my statement is strong enough to preclude backtracking on either of them if the other flipped mafia, but agree with the rest

 

 

Okay, "forced" might be a bit of an exaggeration, but I think it would take one hell of an argument (or absolutely terrible play from the townie) to not seem completely contradictory.  

 

Unless I'm misinterpreting your point. 

 

FEO BFG:

 

 

 

Because it took me reading it three times to figure out what you were getting at

 

 

[Clovdyx]

Or for eyes of everybody, apparently.

[Sili Quirrels]

Actually it seems like the sort of thing I might say as a wolf to wolf Seph, but don't take my word for it. WAFO

[BFG]

 

 

Seph is the person I feel best about at this point.  It's definitely not an incredibly strong read, but solid.  I like how he came out swinging against Sili, especially consideirng Sili's argument made no sense, and I don't feel he was stumbling over himself trying to answer questions about it.  I kinda think Sili was kicking dirt on him to see if it would stick, which is a good look for him too.

 

I really don't understand why anybody has an issue with BFG's argument about Seph/Alanna.  I said before I would guess she's probably right, and I would stand by that even if I didn't feel particularly good about Seph.  I can't rule out the possibility Mafia!Seph wrote it with the deliberate intention of townspewing a teammate, but I would be very, very surprised if that's the case.  More importantly, I think that's a pro-town observation for her to make.  The only way that thought comes from a mafia motivation is if all three of them are mafia together and she's looking for something to clear one of Alanna/Seph in case the other one dies, since Mafia!BFG would essentially be forced to clear town!Alanna if Seph is a teammate and clear Seph as town should Alanna flip mafia.

Hmmmmm, I'm not sure my statement is strong enough to preclude backtracking on either of them if the other flipped mafia, but agree with the rest

 

 

Okay, "forced" might be a bit of an exaggeration, but I think it would take one hell of an argument (or absolutely terrible play from the townie) to not seem completely contradictory.  

 

Unless I'm misinterpreting your point. 

 

FEO BFG:

 

 

 

Because it took me reading it three times to figure out what you were getting at

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I think I'm just being pedantic :/ and I think you understood

 

 

 

Actually it seems like the sort of thing I might say as a wolf to wolf Seph, but don't take my word for it. WAFO

But you're not me ldo :)

[Sili Quirrels]

Oh, I was talking about something else. Nevermind.

[BFG]

 

Who would you have expected to be among my top mafia candidates

Hm.

 

Probably no one. Maybe hallia, lenlo but I don't know.

 

Normally when someone has a mafia suspect they spend a little time establishing that.

 

I have a hard time believing that - at least any of my posts of actual content.  Nobody had posted for half an hour when I came in tonight, and the last person who had posted was you.  If the thread had been active, I might buy that you skimmed over my posts in favor of something you thought was more important.  But there was nothing else.

 

Believe what you want. What does it matter anyway?

 

Why Hallia over wish-tree?

[BFG]

Chris, do you have any other thoughts on Dice?

[BFG]

Gotta run :/

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

Who would you have expected to be among my top mafia candidates

Hm.

 

Probably no one. Maybe hallia, lenlo but I don't know.

 

Normally when someone has a mafia suspect they spend a little time establishing that.

 

I have a hard time believing that - at least any of my posts of actual content.  Nobody had posted for half an hour when I came in tonight, and the last person who had posted was you.  If the thread had been active, I might buy that you skimmed over my posts in favor of something you thought was more important.  But there was nothing else.

 

Believe what you want. What does it matter anyway?

 

Why Hallia over wish-tree?

 

Is Chris suspecting Wish-tree?