Ghostbusters Mafia - Game Over - Mafia Wins!

[Eldrick4221]

Stupid broken spoiler tag. I tried :(

[Eldrick4221]

But I highly doubt we have a naive cop in this game. Turin's just probably scum.

 

I know it's nothing to base a read on, but if the mafia is the ghostbuster team, like it's starting to look like it is, then Turin is clear by being neighbor.

[Eldrick4221]

Keep in mind, Turin didn't "set up a Naive Cop scenario" - I'm the one who mentioned it, because my character is such a nobody, and most assuredly NOT psychic...

Additionally, I only said I tinfoiled the possibility, but I don't see Ithi going Bastard Mod on us.

 

Out of curiosity, what information did you get about me?

[alannalynn]

[Eldrick4221]

alignment, obviously. role? character?

[Tsukibana]

Hmm, broken tag, indeed... Since we are both on in RT, ask your questions straight-up without a confusing WoT...

[Eldrick4221]

 

Just saying :P

[Tsukibana]

Paranoid?? A cop never gets role or character... you should know that.

[Eldrick4221]

Hmm, broken tag, indeed... Since we are both on in RT, ask your questions straight-up without a confusing WoT...

 

I didn't have a question pertaining to your lynch train. I was just collecting the data so if anyone else noticed something I didn't.

[Eldrick4221]

Paranoid?? A cop never gets role or character... you should know that.

 

Not paranoid. And not true. There are several varieties of cops.

 

I was wondering if you were able to confirm anything else. It doesn't matter if you can't. I was just curious.

 

Like if you could tell character, and you find a mafia non-ghostbuster, we could blow that idea wide open. It was just a thought.

[alannalynn]

Anyways. What we have is 13 players. Normal setup is cop, doc, potential vig, 3 scum team.

 

Being that this game is heavily roled and with a symp, it gets a little complicated. We could be looking at 1-2 scum left or a third party. But I doubt the cop is anything but normal.

[Eldrick4221]

I'm currently digging through Shad's ISO. I came across his response to your claim and thought it was worth looking into.

[Eldrick4221]

Anyways. What we have is 13 players. Normal setup is cop, doc, potential vig, 3 scum team.

 

Being that this game is heavily roled and with a symp, it gets a little complicated. We could be looking at 1-2 scum left or a third party. But I doubt the cop is anything but normal.

 

If there's a 3p, my money would be on dice.

 

I think the symp, and whatever freaky multi role mafia thing they got going on balances the more heavily roled town

[Eldrick4221]

Cuz Shad didn't flip roleblocker, he flipped as having done a roleblock, which is a weird way to word it.

[alannalynn]

It said he had a role block and a protect or something, right? So I'm assuming they were both used

[Eldrick4221]

Also, can't remember if I said this ITT  yet, but I think the symp was recruitable.

 

His character was Winston, who in the movie is the guy that got hired on to the ghostbuster team. Thematically makes sense for the symp to be "hireable"

[alannalynn]

Being that we were told that Shad's powers were used, I'm pretty sure RTE's coroners report would show that he was recruited/full mafia.

[Eldrick4221]

I said I thought he was recruitable, not recruited.

[alannalynn]

Yeah. I'm trying to figure how how and why that matters.

 

Like, does that change the # of mafia you assume there are?

 

I'm trying to get where you're getting at.

[Eldrick4221]

 

Really wanna see a reads list from you brother.

Off the cuff not thinking too hard about this

 

Tsuki*

Turin*

 

Eldrick

Laine

 

Zander

Hallia

Reyoru

Lenlo -- I keep forgetting you're in this game dude, and I know you've been active.  I dunno if you're flying super under the radar or if it's just me.  Need to ISO but the fact that you haven't pinged me in the slightest is probably a good sign.

 

Dice

Niniel

BFG

 

RTE

 

Consider the order fairly interchangeable in each of those groups.

 

 

Shad's first official reads list.

 

Only one in his greens that i'm not currently worried about is Lenlo.

[Eldrick4221]

Yeah. I'm trying to figure how how and why that matters.

 

Like, does that change the # of mafia you assume there are?

 

I'm trying to get where you're getting at.

 

It matters only as much as the discussion of whether the symp was recruitable matters. I think he was.

 

It's not particularly important. I believe there are 3 mafia and explained recently my thoughts on the balance.

 

It was just a side thought that I realized I hadn't shared with you guys. It doesn't matter at all in terms of game solve.

[Eldrick4221]

It matters in the sense that if he was recruitable, that mafia knew a symp existed. which might affect how they were playing the game. If they could recruit him, they were looking for signs as to who he was.

[alannalynn]

We wont know that until the end of the game, so it just seems a waste of time imo but meh

[Eldrick4221]

Tsuki called my actions white-knighting. Shad used this as a reason to suss him. Feels to me like setting up a mislynch.

 

Zander couldn't remember Dice's case on Turin. Shad helped him out by pointing out that he could Ctrl+f dice's ISO to look for "Turin". Doesn't seem like something scum would do to help incriminate a teammate, so this looks good for Turin. Null for Dice.

 

#508 IRT Laine's content on pg21. Liking her content while also making the comment that suggests it could be within her scum range now. Feels like casting shade.

 

I didn't realize how much Shad has been defending me this game until I started going through his ISO. I can see why you think we are connected, Turin.

 

Shad agrees that Zander and Turin should be the focus. If they are both town, tis looks like a great way to start setting up a mislynch by promoting this idea.

 

#526 Response to Hally's sub in post. He was already townreading John. Comments to Hally "Hi. You're probably town." I dunno, just feels weird.

 

Shad's efforts regarding the Zander/Turin QT discussion feel like someone trying to figure out what the truth is, not someone that already knows. For that to be the case, either Scum!Turin didn't divulge his information on the mafia QT (unlikely), or Turin is town.

 

#605 Shad's first "reads list"

 

Town: Tsuki, Eldrick, Hally, Laine, maybe Rey

 

Wants to chew on the Turin/Zander/Dice situation. Nto assigning reads to that group yet.

 

Weird part about this list is atp I think everyone he mentioned is town. So weird for scum to not mention a teammate in this kind of situation.

 

#1009 Reading this from mafia POV, it sounds like Shad was planning on keeping Turin alive to LYLO to make him suspicious for still being alive.

 

Shad steps back from lynching between Zander/Turin. Calls them v/v.

 

Notes on first 5/11 pages of Shad's ISO.

 

So far, noticed a point for both Tsuki and Laine for them not to be Shad's teammate, and several points for Turin not to be.

[Eldrick4221]

We wont know that until the end of the game, so it just seems a waste of time imo but meh

 

/shrug

 

I tend to have waste time posts lol