[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

[seph]

[V] eldrick [/v]

[Eldrick4221]

I've mulled it over, and I really have no idea who could be mafia here. I'll follow whichever path seph and dice want to take.

 

I said this before I went to bed.

 

Then you and Seph both decided lynching Sili was the way to go today.

 

So I went with it too.

 

I said I would follow seph and dice. I'm ok with all 3 trains right now for different reasons, but I know the ones voting Sili are town.

 

[unvote]

[v]Sili[/v]

 

And I'm the new plan because I stuck to what I said?

[Eldrick4221]

I didn't even stay on it very long. I'm back to my gut read. Talya.

[seph]

 

 

 

 

Sili. I don't care how it looks to you guys for me to do it. I know that the other people voting you don't have alterior motives. It's the smart move IMO

 

sheeping the cleareds just because they're clear is really really bad.

Is is better or worse than saying I'm going to, but then not do it?

probably bad either way. just trust the force if you're luke. it's how he blew up a deathstar.

Ooh. In mafia terms, that means "go with your gut"

 

[unvote]

[v]Talya[/v]

This post.

 

Tell me why tayla is scum anyhow

[Eldrick4221]

Feel free to lynch me. I'm not sure how much more I can figure out in this game. It feels like shooting in the dark.

[seph]

Feel free to lynch me. I'm not sure how much more I can figure out in this game. It feels like shooting in the dark.

Eldrick if you are town re read that post please.

If you are town that is not a post to help us win.

 

If we ml you we lose. I want you to show me your townyness

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

 

 

 

Sili. I don't care how it looks to you guys for me to do it. I know that the other people voting you don't have alterior motives. It's the smart move IMO

sheeping the cleareds just because they're clear is really really bad.

Is is better or worse than saying I'm going to, but then not do it?

probably bad either way. just trust the force if you're luke. it's how he blew up a deathstar.

Ooh. In mafia terms, that means "go with your gut"

 

[unvote]

[v]Talya[/v]

This post.

 

Tell me why tayla is scum anyhow

 

She's the puzzle piece that doesn't fit. It really is only a gut read. Everything else makes some sort of sense. She doesn't.

 

And if I'm wrong, and she's a stump, it's not as big of a loss.

[seph]

What?

You realize she is still gone..she can't vote as a stump..

IT'S A HUGE LOSS if she is town. There is 357 pages.. you don't have any reason besides it just doesn't fit?

[seph]

Anyways I'm Goin to bed.

Be up in 5 hours

[Eldrick4221]

 

Feel free to lynch me. I'm not sure how much more I can figure out in this game. It feels like shooting in the dark.

Eldrick if you are town re read that post please.

If you are town that is not a post to help us win.

 

If we ml you we lose. I want you to show me your townyness

 

You're kidding, right? That's what I've been trying to do all game. notice stuff. Find scum. Work with other townies. If I knew how to "show you my townyness", then a lot of what has happened recently on my end wouldn't be an issue.

 

I know lynching me is a bad idea. I just don't handle pressure well.

[Eldrick4221]

What?

You realize she is still gone..she can't vote as a stump..

IT'S A HUGE LOSS if she is town. There is 357 pages.. you don't have any reason besides it just doesn't fit?

That would be the same for any townie. At least a stump still gets to contribute. so it's not AS BAD.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

I said I would follow seph and dice. I'm ok with all 3 trains right now for different reasons, but I know the ones voting Sili are town.

 

[unvote]

[v]Sili[/v]

 

 

new plan  vote eldrick

 

unvote vote eldrick

Lol ok. Wrong move there. I will yield the least information out of all of us.

I don't like this post too. Seems defensive.

[Sili Quirrels]

Feel free to lynch me. I'm not sure how much more I can figure out in this game. It feels like shooting in the dark.

Now you're okay being lynched?

[Sili Quirrels]

Eldrick, I don't get you sometimes.

[csarmi]

If we aren't sure about the masons, it's probably still better to try and take care of them tomorrow.

 

If they are mafia, that's all the anti town left. That means everyone else's claim is true and thus we surely have time to take care of them at N=7.

 

If they are town (I'm leaning towards that) then we definitely don't want to lynch them ever if we can help it and anyone else flipping non-town auto-clears them.

[Eldrick4221]

I've mentioned before that I don't know how to read Talya. I haven't seen her do anything scummy, but that can be said for everyone alive right now.

 

There have been things over the game that have been weird, and I mentioned them when they caught my eye, but I no longer have any scum reads. I have to look at it by who doesn't fit.

[csarmi]

 

What?

You realize she is still gone..she can't vote as a stump..

IT'S A HUGE LOSS if she is town. There is 357 pages.. you don't have any reason besides it just doesn't fit?

That would be the same for any townie. At least a stump still gets to contribute. so it's not AS BAD.

 

Nonsense. At this position the stump is worthless. It's a good role when you don't have other confirmed players because they can lead town but it's not the case there. We have Seph and Dice as lock clear. Having a confirmed townie speaking from the grave doesn't help any.

[Eldrick4221]

 

Feel free to lynch me. I'm not sure how much more I can figure out in this game. It feels like shooting in the dark.

Now you're okay being lynched?

 

No I'm not. I was just annoyed.

 

But if you haven't noticed already, I get the serious case of foot in mouth. When I get going, I don't think through what I'm saying.

[csarmi]

Feel free to lynch me. I'm not sure how much more I can figure out in this game. It feels like shooting in the dark.

We can't afford mislynches at this point. Yesterday we did, now we don't. We have 1 mislynches left, 2 if we are lucky.

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

What?

You realize she is still gone..she can't vote as a stump..

IT'S A HUGE LOSS if she is town. There is 357 pages.. you don't have any reason besides it just doesn't fit?

That would be the same for any townie. At least a stump still gets to contribute. so it's not AS BAD.

 

Nonsense. At this position the stump is worthless. It's a good role when you don't have other confirmed players because they can lead town but it's not the case there. We have Seph and Dice as lock clear. Having a confirmed townie speaking from the grave doesn't help any.

 

Geez. This isn't coming out the way I meant it to either.

 

Let me try again.

 

It makes the most sense to me for Talya to me scum right now, out of all the remaining players. But, if I'm wrong, we don't completely lose her. it's not a total loss, like it would be for anyone else (possible exception with Seph). THAT is what I meant by "not as bad". It's still not good, by any means. I don't want to lose any more townies.

[csarmi]

Eldrick, your role is

 

1) don't get mislynched

2) find other townies

 

With 9 players alive, we need 5 clear players to win.

 

We got Dice, Seph. I would say I'm as good as cleared, but no mechanical reason there. Yates/Sili are either two clears or two mafia. We are very close to have this locked still.

[csarmi]

@Eldrick - It's still an invalid reasoning. Talya remaining as a stump doesn't help and arguing like "if we are wrong it's still not so bad" is usually the road to disaster.

[csarmi]

Dice, could you tell me what you think of all the players?

[seph]

[unvote] before bed

[Eldrick4221]

Eldrick, your role is

 

1) don't get mislynched

2) find other townies

 

With 9 players alive, we need 5 clear players to win.

 

We got Dice, Seph. I would say I'm as good as cleared, but no mechanical reason there. Yates/Sili are either two clears or two mafia. We are very close to have this locked still.

 

No. Yates and Sili are either 2 mafia or 1 clear by the other dying. They aren't two clears.