A Tale of Middle Earth: Game OVER

[Leelou]

@leelou - when pizza claimed I thought heist be. But if you read my post last night he was on my list to thread. I wasn't too enamoured by A lot. But need to read. I think Hally might be too. Need to go over stuff as well. Also think Cass is.

 

So tell me, who do think is on the other team as you seem reluctant to go for Sooh. Do you think EP is a wolfie? Do you think Hally's is as well? Not necessary together.

 

I think I've been pretty clear as to who I think is scum. Here it is updated. 

 

Town

Dice 

Thane* pending per Pizza's role 

Hally

 

Pizzaguy* pending more info 

Krak* pending per Pizza's role

Andrej

Scummy

Taborline White Knight

Talya 

Alanna Aiel Heart

seph - mentored by Kaylee 

Alot Eternal Phoenix 2.0

 

Sooh - mentored by Corn

Cass/Monstr - Batassery

Alannalynn 

 

Deceased

Yates - Faramir, Town Forensic Investigator Lynched Day One

Tress - Tulkas, Town Vanilla Killed Night Two

Zander - Elu Thingol, Town Mason Killed Night Two

Sili - Beren, Town Vanilla Modkilled Day Two

Verbal - Beorn, Town 2x Gladiator Lynched Day Two

Eldrick - Tar Atanamir, Town Vanilla Killed Night Two

Eternal Phoenix - Finwe, Town Mason Killed Night Two

TinaHel - Tom Bombadil, Fatherless Mafia Nexus Lynched Day Three

John Snow Yates 2.0 - Pallando, Town Vanilla Killed Night Three

[Talya]

Couldn't go back and look. Thank you

 

Remind me why you think Hally's is town?

[Leelou]

Her play and her claim. 

[Talya]

What is it about her play that makes you think she is town. I find that she has jumped on votes without really saying why or with little background to her vote.

[Talya]

I wonder if anyone else is going to join the party

[Askthepizzaguy]

It is unusual to go for the "bodyguard" instead of straight doctor claim. It means if she doesn't die soon from being targeted or from being successful, she's outing herself as scum, whereas a standard doctor could claim to protect me and I could bluff which nights I protect them back, and then randomly scan them.

 

The claim is meh, but I wouldn't lynch her today. That claim resolves itself, any mafia team will want her dead regardless of whether she's a bodyguard or if she's scum.

 

We need to use the lynch on folks the mafia teams do not want to lynch, such as EP, who I couldn't get demised yesterday even if I had faked a red peek on him.

 

Obviously a wolf as well, I mean you can't even deny it at this point. The reactions make no sense from a town perspective and neither does the namedrop / vanilla claim later combo, plus the meta defense which is awful.

[Askthepizzaguy]

And the wolf teams did not want to lynch him despite one of them being a huge wagon.

 

He might be a wolf with Tina, due to the reluctance, but then again, he might just be opposing scum. But he's a wolf, that much is established by now. Gotta love the "my reads havent changed therefore I must still be town" defense.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Leelou, I like Seph and Alannalynn for town. I probably don't get there while I'm still alive, but can you tell me what makes you find them scummy?

 

I'll give it another honest look, but I gotta admit I'm not likely to vote there.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Thats it for this morning. I just ran a stupid errand for my boss, so now I'm going to take a nap (or, more likely, flirt with sooh and then take a nap later and be even more exhausted)

[Talya]

Thought I would look at Tab:

 

There isn't really much to begin with, nothing of substance, the following ones seem the most and then seem lacking

 

I don't get the vibe from Thane, not yet. One or the other Pizza and Verb stand out to me the most after reading today. It would be interesting to see where we're left sans Verb.

 

going for Verb and Pizza above - maybe

 

 

 

I don't get the vibe from Thane, not yet. One or the other Pizza and Verb stand out to me the most after reading today. It would be interesting to see where we're left sans Verb.

So you're saying you want to lynch me?

 

 

Quite possibly.

 

 

Quite possible going for Verb

 

 

 

 

From my admittedly limited experience, scum.

 

How?  If you can't answer that, you shouldn't vote me.

 

 

Just how jumpy you've seemed, and defensive. It's just a guess.

 

Her reason for voting Verb.

 

And that is about it really. All a bit woolly and not much to go on.

 

All I remember so far about WK is that he believes everything AH says.

[Aiel Heart]

Ok kind of skimmed those last few pages but I AM BACK

 

 

Now to get anecdotes done before work...

 

 

And I truly am sorry I've not been around guys

[Talya]

WK - Why do you think that Ah is not mafia...

 

And she posted as I typed...spooky...

[Talya]

ok to my look at EP...dreading all those posts...haha

[Askthepizzaguy]

Aiel Heart, your activity will improve, yes?
 

Ignore reading the whole thread, just stay in the thread and discuss in real time as much as possible, imo.

[Aiel Heart]

Blue--confirmed dead town

Green--town claim

Purple--Confirmed dead Mafia (#1?)

Black--nothing yet

 

1. Hally—claimed town bodyguard—N1 AJ N2 Pizza

2. Sooh 

3. Alot Eternal Phoenix 2.0

4. Alanna Aiel Heart

5. Dice

6. John Snow Yates.2 - Pallando, Vanilla town has been killed by spiders.

7. Thane--Town according to Pizza

8. Verbal- Beorn - town 2x gladiator has been bested in the arena

9. Talya

10. Eldrick - Tar Atanamir, Town Vanilla—Killed Night 2

11. Leelou—Claims 2x voting ability

12. Sili - Beren Erchamion, town vanilla--modkilled for editing

13. Krak—town according to Pizza

14. Taborline White Knight—claimed 2x voting ability

15. Andrej

16. Alannalynn

17. Tress - Tulkas, Town Vanilla has been found dead.

18. Zander - Elu Thingol, Town Mason has been eviscerated by spiders.

19. seph 

20. Eternal Phoenix - Finwe, Town Mason—Killed Night 2

21. TinaHel - Tom Bombadil, Fatherless Mafia Nexus

22. Yates.1 - Faramir, Town Forensic Investigator

23. Cass/Monstr - Batassery

24. Pizzaguy—Claims Celebrimbor, maker of rings of power—can do Scanning, protect or role block (all x2)—used x2 scan on Thane and Krak night one and got both as town—Missed if he said what he did night 2

[Askthepizzaguy]

ok to my look at EP...dreading all those posts...haha

 

Remember you literally only have to read his yesterday, especially if you already read alot of Alot's posts in the allotted time and either did or did not like them alot.

[Aiel Heart]

Aiel Heart, your activity will improve, yes?

 

Ignore reading the whole thread, just stay in the thread and discuss in real time as much as possible, imo.

First I get ostracized for not catching up before voting, and now your encouraging me to not catch up?

 

I can't always be here in real time. I work and I love sleep. I will do my best, but I honestly play better when I'm reading the games in small chunks at a time (not these enormous ones I've been trying to do)

 

Yes, I will try to be around more. 

[Askthepizzaguy]

N2 I protected the mason EP version 1.0 and he died anyway.

[Talya]

Oh, I have seen something EP wasn't get rid of all the women in the game - worth stringing up just for that!!

[Askthepizzaguy]

 

First I get ostracized for not catching up before voting, and now your encouraging me to not catch up?

 

 

You can catch up later, right now your in-thread interactions are lacking.

 

And keep in mind, I'm not being contradictory, someone else got on your butt for not catching up before voting, and his name is gigantic ball of wolfy fur, if I'm pronouncing that correctly.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Oh, I have seen something EP wasn't get rid of all the women in the game - worth stringing up just for that!!

Say again?

[Talya]

 

ok to my look at EP...dreading all those posts...haha

 

Remember you literally only have to read his yesterday, especially if you already read alot of Alot's posts in the allotted time and either did or did not like them alot.

 

 

I'm not going that far back, and only planned on recent stuff...so not so bad!

[Talya]

 

Oh, I have seen something EP wasn't get rid of all the women in the game - worth stringing up just for that!!

Say again?

 

 

all his list of suspects are women...I was being a little tongue in cheek.

[Talya]

ahhh...I put wasn't and not wants...sorry no wonder you couldn't understand it

[Askthepizzaguy]

Yeah ummm I have to admit my bias against lynching the dudes in this game is pretty strong.

 

But I will call out the scummy women. I just likely won't vote for them hahaha. I may investigate them tho.