[Basic/Standard] A Wind in the Door Mafia - GAME OVER, TOWN WINS

[Songstress]

dammit

 

 

TRESS!!! can you count that?? IE wont let me colour it and my firefox wont start.

Is ok hon - you're already voting him, but if you weren't I said in the rules I wasn't going to be picky about voting format as long as it was obvious it was intended to be a vote

 

I'm picky about unvoting first though

[Yates]

We have been voting Err for a while...

[csarmi]

goat = greatest of all time

Good Ol' Astute Tina

[csarmi]

Greatest Of All Tina?

[csarmi]

Also, you just made a child the boss of the village… good luck with that ;)

You took control when you claimed.

[Babar Hasan Khan]

[v]Err[/v]

 

I'm trusting the Correh.

i really dont understand why would you rely someone else’s read on D1 and not on you own based on what we have learned from D1-D4 ?? it seems to me the only reason you would vote for me???

[Babar Hasan Khan]

 

 

 

i was in the phase of writing my analysis but i will post what ever i have now anyway....

 

@ corry and Yates stand off:

apart from references that i didnt understand (VT game, Krak game, POG, VS, discoworld, Des reference, doc who, Firefly) throughout the standoff cory was pushing yates for lynch. i thought yates didnt crack under pressure. for which i leaned town on both corry and yates. until yates reveled his role. which i believe is the truth. 

something interesting happened tough in between.... which cory was building momentum for yate lynch and trying to convince others to join in. jmm and manbat casually also started suspecting yates over things that i thought were very innocent. potentially making grounds for there lynch vote on yates look legit later on. 

 

after yates revealed his character. manbat changed his vote for sili... while i would think he would have voted for leno, jmm, Pral or Yates, based on his suspicion list.. (which will also be uploaded soon)

 

so for the time being im leaning mafia for manbat. and will vote for him unless something else pops up in the last few pages 

 

I THINK this is a good observation because it's a pretty big contradiction from me

 

err looking slightly better, ldo

 

 

monstr did err ever follow up on this?

 

 

I don't recall.

 

I did vote for you that day.... on which cory said he was 'knight shielding' you... that time there was only one vote on you (mine)..... and i still suspect you as mafia..... then after you yates.... 

[Babar Hasan Khan]

my scum list 

 

Manbat

Yates

 

i do not know y we let Yates go after her hinting at a doc role in day one.... we marked it as everyone lies to confuse the scum.... 

[Babar Hasan Khan]

DAY1

 

 1. Lenlo : CoryMish,  Tommy, CoryMish, CoryMish, Manbat,Yates, Sili ,  Tommy, Err, CoryMish ,
 2. jmm :  DiceCsarmi, Manbat, Sili, CoryMish, Manbat,  Tommy,  Tommy, Silli, Err,
 3. Sili Quirrels :  Tinna,  Tommy, Silly, CoryMish, jmm, Manbat , CoryMish , Manbat , CoryMish, Yates
 4. CoryMish : Lenlo, Sili ,
 5. Err : CoryMish, Yates, Sili,  Tommy,
 6. Manbat :  DiceCsarmi,  Tommy, Pral,Err,
 7. Sleeper :  Tommy, Manbat, CoryMish, Sili, Manbat,  Tommy,  Tommy, CoryMish, Err ,
 8. DiceCsarmi :  Tommy, DiceCsarmi,  Tommy,  Tommy,

 

 9. Tommyrod : CoryMish, Tommy,,  DiceCsarmi, CoryMish, Tina, Lenlo, Manbat ,  Tommy, DiceCsarmi,
10. Praya :  Tommy, Sleeper,  Tommy,  Tommy, Manbat, CoryMish, Manbat,  Tommy  DiceCsarmi,  Tommy, Tommy, CoryMish
11. TinaHel :
12. HalliaYates : Sili, Manbat,  Tommy, CoryMish,  Tommy, CoryMish , 

[Babar Hasan Khan]

 

[v]Err[/v]

 

I'm trusting the Correh.

i really dont understand why would you rely someone else’s read on D1 and not on you own based on what we have learned from D1-D4 ?? it seems to me the only reason you would vote for me???

 

and if you really want to follow that path then cory also thought that i was townish

[csarmi]

 

 

[v]Err[/v]

 

I'm trusting the Correh.

i really dont understand why would you rely someone else’s read on D1 and not on you own based on what we have learned from D1-D4 ?? it seems to me the only reason you would vote for me???

I am trusting him on his manbat and Tina reads.

 

So Yates and you remain. I don't know which one of you it is.

 

If you are town your job is to clear a single person that can't be Mafia (in addition to the mechanical clear ones). Do it pls.

[csarmi]

 

 

[v]Err[/v]

 

I'm trusting the Correh.

i really dont understand why would you rely someone else’s read on D1 and not on you own based on what we have learned from D1-D4 ?? it seems to me the only reason you would vote for me???

I am trusting him on his manbat and Tina reads.

 

So Yates and you remain. I don't know which one of you it is.

 

If you are town your job is to clear a single person that can't be Mafia (in addition to the mechanical clear ones). Do it pls.

[csarmi]

 

 

[v]Err[/v]

 

I'm trusting the Correh.

i really dont understand why would you rely someone else’s read on D1 and not on you own based on what we have learned from D1-D4 ?? it seems to me the only reason you would vote for me???

I am trusting him on his manbat and Tina reads.

 

So Yates and you remain. I don't know which one of you it is.

 

If you are town your job is to clear a single person that can't be Mafia (in addition to the mechanical clear ones). Do it pls.

[csarmi]

 

 

[v]Err[/v]

 

I'm trusting the Correh.

i really dont understand why would you rely someone else’s read on D1 and not on you own based on what we have learned from D1-D4 ?? it seems to me the only reason you would vote for me???

I am trusting him on his manbat and Tina reads.

 

So Yates and you remain. I don't know which one of you it is.

 

If you are town your job is to clear a single person that can't be Mafia (in addition to the mechanical clear ones). Do it pls.

[csarmi]

 

 

[v]Err[/v]

 

I'm trusting the Correh.

i really dont understand why would you rely someone else’s read on D1 and not on you own based on what we have learned from D1-D4 ?? it seems to me the only reason you would vote for me???

I am trusting him on his manbat and Tina reads.

 

So Yates and you remain. I don't know which one of you it is.

 

If you are town your job is to clear a single person that can't be Mafia (in addition to the mechanical clear ones). Do it pls.

[csarmi]

 

 

[v]Err[/v]

 

I'm trusting the Correh.

i really dont understand why would you rely someone else’s read on D1 and not on you own based on what we have learned from D1-D4 ?? it seems to me the only reason you would vote for me???

I am trusting him on his manbat and Tina reads.

 

So Yates and you remain. I don't know which one of you it is.

 

If you are town your job is to clear a single person that can't be Mafia (in addition to the mechanical clear ones). Do it pls.

[Babar Hasan Khan]

Day 2:

 

 1. Lenlo :  Tommy, Manbat , jmm,
 2. jmm : Sili,
 3. Sili Quirrels :  DiceCsarmi,  jmm, Manbat, Tina, Sleeper,  Tommy, Sleeper, Tommy, Jmm, Tommy, Sleeper, Tommy, Yates, Sili
 5. Err : Yates,  Tommy, Sili, Manbat,  Tommy,
 6. Manbat :
 7. Sleeper : Manbat,  Tommy,  Tommy, Sili,  DiceCsarmi,  Tommy, Sili, Tommy,
 8. DiceCsarmi : Sili, Sleeper,

 

 9. Tommyrod : DiceCsarmi, DiceCsarmi,
11. TinaHel :
12. HalliaYates :

 

No Lynch: Yates, DiceCsarmi, Yates,

 

[Babar Hasan Khan]

well if i say my scum list is as follows out of the remaining players (non-mechanical cleared roles)

 

Manbat,

Yates,

Tina

 

you can look it the other way around too... tina looks most townish to me.... the only thing that wasbothering me about tine was that tom and sili never went after her... especially tom if you look at the votes and also the suspicion list.... but then no one else did either

[Babar Hasan Khan]

look at the votes especially day 2..... doesnt manbat, tom, sili seems more likely team?? look at the train on Sleeper on day 2

[Babar Hasan Khan]

sorry messed up the copy pasting again... i should strike out the unvotes

[Babar Hasan Khan]

Day 2:

 

 1. Lenlo :  Tommy, Manbat , jmm,
 2. jmm : Sili,
 3. Sili Quirrels :  DiceCsarmi,  jmm, Manbat, Tina, Sleeper,  Tommy, Sleeper, Tommy, Jmm, Tommy, Sleeper, Tommy, Yates, Sili
 5. Err : Yates,  Tommy, Sili, Manbat,  Tommy,
 6. Manbat :
 7. Sleeper : Manbat,  Tommy,  Tommy, Sili,  DiceCsarmi,  Tommy, Sili, Tommy,
 8. DiceCsarmi : Sili, Sleeper,

 

 9. Tommyrod : DiceCsarmi, DiceCsarmi,
11. TinaHel :
12. HalliaYates :

 

No Lynch: Yates, DiceCsarmi, Yates,

[csarmi]

 

 

[v]Err[/v]

 

I'm trusting the Correh.

i really dont understand why would you rely someone else’s read on D1 and not on you own based on what we have learned from D1-D4 ?? it seems to me the only reason you would vote for me???

I am trusting him on his manbat and Tina reads.

 

So Yates and you remain. I don't know which one of you it is.

 

If you are town your job is to clear a single person that can't be Mafia (in addition to the mechanical clear ones). Do it pls.

[Babar Hasan Khan]

Day 3

 

 1. Lenlo : Manbat
 2. jmm :  
 5. Err :
 6. Manbat :
 7. Sleeper :
 8. DiceCsarmi :

 

 9. Tommyrod : DiceCsarmi, Tina, Sleeper, Yates, Tommy,
11. TinaHel :
12. HalliaYates : 

 

[csarmi]

my scum list

 

Manbat

Yates

 

i do not know y we let Yates go after her hinting at a doc role in day one.... we marked it as everyone lies to confuse the scum....

Confusing Mafia is good.

 

My gut says its most likely Yates on play/toan.

 

But.

 

They were the only ones covering for my doc role. Do you think I would have managed a save twice on a row if Yates was Mafia and thus they could always knew (unless they just thought I was bluffing) that I should be blocked?

 

Possible ye but unlikely.

 

Err, do you believe Tina is town?

[Babar Hasan Khan]

now then there is day 3.... everyone is voting for tommy for soft claiming weak doctor while manbat casually places his vote on lenlo