[Advanced] Revenge of the Marlfox

[monstrman]

I think I'm gonna try to read the corlia slot via hallia

 

HALLIA TOP THERE LYNCHES TOP THREE VILLAGERS AND WHY

 

GOGOGO

[Sili Quirrels]

I...

 

 

hesitantly agree as well. i am wrong about someone i don't want to be wrong about

 

 

Dingus, please with all your wisdom, explain what I'm doing wrong to send scum signals to these people who do not know me.

[Sili Quirrels]

it feels like all the core irrational people could fit in a pile of six. icky.

[dicetosser1]

 

Who are your top 3 lynches for the day?

 

I looked at your catch-up and thought it was + that you're trying to get in the head of the other players

 

But what I guess I didn't see to well is who you would prefer to lynch

Top three lynches:

 

Berf, Tommy, for reasons already said. Distant third, would be Rags. I found his catch up less than desired and voting AJ seems an easy out to me, since AJ has claimed third party.

 

If you want me to disinclude Tommy, I would hesitantly put Alanna in because so far I haven't seen anything of hers that couldn't come from scum and in my experience she plays reasonable scum well.

 

I would NOT lynch Des, Yates/Leelou, or Monstr.

 

 

did not like this. Two of her 3 preferred lynchess are inactive with hardly any posts. happy with my current vote

[monstrman]

Take these buckets

 

Villagers:

 

Slight villagers:

 

Null:

 

Wolfy:

 

Slightly wolfy:

 

People you think you may be clearing incorrectly:

 

Fill them with players in the game you feel you're reading well.

 

Give mme three paragraphs why you are doing this

 

If you're telling the truth about never having been scum and being a villager this shouldn't be difficult for you.

[Tommyrod]

Or, you know, we could all just sponge DiceGOAT and lynch Key.

[monstrman]

I actually don't like a key lynch

 

I felt a villagery mindmeld from bfg

 

And key is reading me correctly in what feels like a genuine way

 

Maybe I'm being foiled by the pocketing thing again

 

But I think our best bet is in the list tommy posted of people being incorrectly cleared or a slanker

[monstrman]

Alanna I have been tinfoiling on all game and I have requested several times for her to elaborate on her scumread of me but she seems hesitant to do it. Granted that feels like much of the thread, however.

[dicetosser1]

some truth for cory

 

 

I dont like that Berf lynch. he does not have anywhere near enuff content for people to say "I think you are mafia." they cant point at something and say because of this.

 

In regards to you Cory....right now Hallia is your saving grace. If not for her Id be putting you down as mafia. and i know exactly why. What I am not seeing is the active, trying to group townies together then POEing cory im used to.

 

Im waffling on verb. I have been thinking of him as a bit scummy but not hugely. I have a town read on leelou/yates and i know leelou reads him much much better then me so am willing to follow.

 

Since page 106 Sili has me thinking he is mafia. Would happily lynch him but after key/bfg

[Tommyrod]

Tommyrod 481

Sili Quirrels 316

Thane Vakarian 214

corycurren 181

Yates. 166

manbat 140

Andrej 127

Arsis 124

Verbal32 117

Leelou 104

Hallia 87

Despothera 61

Alanna 48

dicetosser1 37

Nynaeve 36

keyholder21 36

Krakalakachkn 32

TheRagnarok 23

BFG 19

Pralaya 6

ineedfourberfs 2

 

FYI

[monstrman]

Eh

 

To be fair to the berf wagon

 

We can't just let slankers slank with no pressure

[monstrman]

No quiero living slots disconnected from the thread at must lynch

[dicetosser1]

BFG is the one i read as mafia in the first place. key was null for me but that post i quoted stood out to me.

[monstrman]

Berf

 

Alanna

 

Arsis

 

Maybe verbal

 

Maybe des

 

People i would like to see more pressure on

[monstrman]

Not that berf doesn't have pressure

[Sili Quirrels]

Key.

 

Honestly would not mind voting someone who thinks i'm scum but is unwilling to explain why. It comes from the part of me that feels it's really unfair to unendingly stress a person out just because. It's stupid, ridiculous, and inhumane.

 

 

Take these buckets

Villagers: Tomcat, Despothera, you

Slight villagers: Cory and Hallia, Alanna, Yates and Leelou, Berf, Ragnarok

Null: Arsis

Wolfy: No one so far

Slightly wolfy: AJ, Verb

People you think you may be clearing incorrectly: Alanna, Tom Ripley,  you, Yates, Hallia

Fill them with players in the game you feel you're reading well.

Give mme three paragraphs why you are doing this

If you're telling the truth about never having been scum and being a villager this shouldn't be difficult for you.

[monstrman]

Yeah there's no way Sili isn't a villager here btw

[Verbal32]

I'm still annoyed that few people are championing lynches.

 

Where's Verb's verve?

 

Sorry, today ended up being a really busy day for me.  I'm leaving work now and will stay caught up via phone.  I'll be around for EOD.

 

 

 

 

Verbal, AJ, Pral, BFGKey?

Herbal and Key are both good. My vote is on Verb right now.

 

So underwhelmed by him. But maybe I should go key since she pinged me the most out of anyone and meets the criteria of "trying to stay alive like scum would"?

 

 

Me too.  I feel that my one blue was messed up, even if I use the excuse of "oh hey I knew he wasn't scum!"......still makes me pretty wrong on that.  I don't like being that wrong so early on - sets a bad tone for me.  So I'm trying to filter through everything and figure out my stance on a few folks.  You are one of those few folks.

 

 

 

 

I think it's funny that barely anyone has a decisive stance on Verbal.

 

That happens to me a lot early on.  I normally aim for that line between 'too scummy to NK' and 'too townish to lynch'.  I say I aim, but that's not accurate - it just happens that way naturally.  I should probably tweak that based on who I'm playing with, but I haven't yet.

 

 

 

 

I suspect that if Verb was town, wolves would be clamoring to get a free Verb lynch on D1 at my behest.

 

And yet -- resistance.

 

Funny, I was wondering why I wasn't already lynched once I saw who was coming at me.

 

 

 

Yeah, the thread feels all wrong.

 

Someone in the cleared category is a wolf.

 

In the Alanna/Dice/Des/Cory/Thane pile.

 

Posts like this make my head spin on you.  I feel you're scummy, and then poof - this post makes me think town on how you're entertaining all angles.

 

You say you flip-flop on me a lot - lemme tell ya, I'm doing the same with you.

[monstrman]

My town core is probably something like

 

Aj/tom/key/lates/corlia/Sili

 

Lynch from rest today imo

[monstrman]

Lower Tier tone reads:

 

Thane/des/rags

[monstrman]

Lower Tier tone reads:

 

Thane/des/rags

[monstrman]

Lower Tier tone reads:

 

Thane/des/rags

[monstrman]

Lower Tier tone reads:

 

Thane/des/rags

[monstrman]

Lower Tier tone reads:

 

Thane/des/rags

[monstrman]

Lower Tier tone reads:

 

Thane/des/rags

 

Dice why did you read bfg as mafia?