[Advanced] Revenge of the Marlfox

[Tommyrod]

I'm still thinking Sili will flip town but would prefer to be wrong because this game is going to be a disaster if so.

[Sili Quirrels]

Am I allowed to speak?

 

It's a disaster.

[Nynaeve]

Things not to do:

 

3. If lynched do not post anything significant during the time between the hammer and death scene.

 

ie scoot.

[Tommyrod]

It Sili is town we can't keep dicking around and going after townies because at some point scum can kill me and get an extra NK and it won't matter if cop gets another action because we will have already lost.

 

I'm going after Verb tomorrow barring better information.

[Leelou]

I'm still thinking Sili will flip town but would prefer to be wrong because this game is going to be a disaster if so.

If Sili is town, which I doubt, he did nothing to help his case either time he was run up or when he was accused.

[Tommyrod]

 

I'm still thinking Sili will flip town but would prefer to be wrong because this game is going to be a disaster if so.

If Sili is town, which I doubt, he did nothing to help his case either time he was run up or when he was accused.

Yeah except be obvious town all game, amirite?

 

This kind of post game armchair quarterbacking looks scummy to me.

[Tommyrod]

Oh no wait I'm so sorry guys, the FIRST TIME EVER WOLF has 400 posts and has discussed every player and topic. That's a reasonable expectation!

 

Or maybe he's just town? Hmmmm!

[Leelou]

He is not obvious town. He's been saying scummy things all over the thread and instead of being helpful he's been rude and annoying to anyone who has questioned him. Hell, Arsis was just asking him to point out where he said something and he said no. Plus, that last bit there before you hammered him, how did that help town?

[Tommyrod]

It's much more townlike to be scummy and fool around than it is scumlike.

 

Regardless I don't think it's fair or good practice to shame someone and not discuss the things about them that indicate town behavior.

 

GG Sili.

[hazelkrs1]

Oh no wait I'm so sorry guys, the FIRST TIME EVER WOLF has 400 posts and has discussed every player and topic. That's a reasonable expectation!

 

Or maybe he's just town? Hmmmm!

 

 

He is not obvious town. He's been saying scummy things all over the thread and instead of being helpful he's been rude and annoying to anyone who has questioned him. Hell, Arsis was just asking him to point out where he said something and he said no. Plus, that last bit there before you hammered him, how did that help town?

 

^^^ What Leelou said. He certainly wasn't obvtown, not even close. I would be EXTREMELY surprised to see him flip town here.

 

And he has about 800 posts btw Tommy, if not more. But I think he was planning on being this active in his first scum game regardless, he said it himself. You can't judge all players on the same scale- some are able to be fearless as scum, even if they're newbies.

[Tommyrod]

Coming in after a town lynch and saying stuff in absolutes like "he did NOTHING to help" or "he was ALWAYS scummy" looks like pushing rhetoric to me. I know because I do the post flip demonizing as scum myself. You know, to "justify" it in the thread.

[hazelkrs1]

It's much more townlike to be scummy and fool around than it is scumlike.

 

Regardless I don't think it's fair or good practice to shame someone and not discuss the things about them that indicate town behavior.

 

GG Sili.

 

I think it's fine to shame him for his crummy attitude tho, insulting DM towns and whatnot. That was downright annoying.

 

Good to see him be that bold and posting so much in his first wolf game, but still, jesus. Lay off the roid rage.

[Tommyrod]

 

 

Oh no wait I'm so sorry guys, the FIRST TIME EVER WOLF has 400 posts and has discussed every player and topic. That's a reasonable expectation!

 

Or maybe he's just town? Hmmmm!

He is not obvious town. He's been saying scummy things all over the thread and instead of being helpful he's been rude and annoying to anyone who has questioned him. Hell, Arsis was just asking him to point out where he said something and he said no. Plus, that last bit there before you hammered him, how did that help town?

^^^ What Leelou said. He certainly wasn't obvtown, not even close. I would be EXTREMELY surprised to see him flip town here.

 

And he has about 800 posts btw Tommy, if not more. But I think he was planning on being this active in his first scum game regardless, he said it himself. You can't judge all players on the same scale- some are able to be fearless as scum, even if they're newbies.

Whatever man. Let's move on.

 

What are you thinking now?

[hazelkrs1]

Coming in after a town lynch and saying stuff in absolutes like "he did NOTHING to help" or "he was ALWAYS scummy" looks like pushing rhetoric to me. I know because I do the post flip demonizing as scum myself. You know, to "justify" it in the thread.

 

How do you know it's a town lynch? We certainly haven't seen a flip yet, and every indication is that he'll flip scum...

 

If he actually flips town here Tommy, you're LOCK SCUM. I mean that wholeheartedly btw.

[hazelkrs1]

 

 

Oh no wait I'm so sorry guys, the FIRST TIME EVER WOLF has 400 posts and has discussed every player and topic. That's a reasonable expectation!

 

Or maybe he's just town? Hmmmm!

He is not obvious town. He's been saying scummy things all over the thread and instead of being helpful he's been rude and annoying to anyone who has questioned him. Hell, Arsis was just asking him to point out where he said something and he said no. Plus, that last bit there before you hammered him, how did that help town?

^^^ What Leelou said. He certainly wasn't obvtown, not even close. I would be EXTREMELY surprised to see him flip town here.

 

And he has about 800 posts btw Tommy, if not more. But I think he was planning on being this active in his first scum game regardless, he said it himself. You can't judge all players on the same scale- some are able to be fearless as scum, even if they're newbies.

Whatever man. Let's move on.

 

What are you thinking now?

 

 

I'm thinking you're a bit premature with the "Yall are scummy for coming in after a town lynch and acting like it was his fault" even tho we have no town flip yet

[Tommyrod]

 

 

Coming in after a town lynch and saying stuff in absolutes like "he did NOTHING to help" or "he was ALWAYS scummy" looks like pushing rhetoric to me. I know because I do the post flip demonizing as scum myself. You know, to "justify" it in the thread.

How do you know it's a town lynch? We certainly haven't seen a flip yet, and every indication is that he'll flip scum...

 

If he actually flips town here Tommy, you're LOCK SCUM. I mean that wholeheartedly btw.

The tone of his posting after the hammer points heavily toward him being town.

 

You can't say stuff like this unless you're scum.

[Tommyrod]

 

 

 

 

Oh no wait I'm so sorry guys, the FIRST TIME EVER WOLF has 400 posts and has discussed every player and topic. That's a reasonable expectation!

 

Or maybe he's just town? Hmmmm!

He is not obvious town. He's been saying scummy things all over the thread and instead of being helpful he's been rude and annoying to anyone who has questioned him. Hell, Arsis was just asking him to point out where he said something and he said no. Plus, that last bit there before you hammered him, how did that help town?

^^^ What Leelou said. He certainly wasn't obvtown, not even close. I would be EXTREMELY surprised to see him flip town here.

 

And he has about 800 posts btw Tommy, if not more. But I think he was planning on being this active in his first scum game regardless, he said it himself. You can't judge all players on the same scale- some are able to be fearless as scum, even if they're newbies.

Whatever man. Let's move on.

 

What are you thinking now?

I'm thinking you're a bit premature with the "Yall are scummy for coming in after a town lynch and acting like it was his fault" even tho we have no town flip yet

Read between the lines better then.

[hazelkrs1]

I don't think him saying "it's a disaster" indicates he is town. I wouldn't expect him to be gracious after his play this game upon his exit. I think it was more posturing.

 

What about him saying "my wolf pack has betrayed me"

 

???

[Tommyrod]

Looked like his brand of humor to me.

 

Let's hope you're right and I'm wrong.

 

But let's start discussing anyway. He flips town. Who do you suspect most?

 

He flips scum. Think Key is more likely lying?

[Tommyrod]

The way I see it, apart from me there's only two kills I can see happening tonight if everyone was telling the truth.

 

Arsis or Key.

 

If we see shots outside of those two I'll be confused.

[Tommyrod]

Key being the more dangerous of the two for scum and the more lucrative kill, which is why it was better to let them be resolved at night after that claim despite my distrust.

 

I don't see how Verb is not scum. Hallia is up there also. Berf back in the hot seat for being completely forgettable. Not sure who the fourth would be yet.

[hazelkrs1]

If Sili flipped town, I'd prob suspect Alanna and Key still. Both WKed him early on then shifted him to null to scum later in as consensus seemed to shift that way

 

Scumflip on him actually doesn't tell me much on others tbh.

[Tommyrod]

If Sili flipped town, I'd prob suspect Alanna and Key still. Both WKed him early on then shifted him to null to scum later in as consensus seemed to shift that way

 

Scumflip on him actually doesn't tell me much on others tbh.

There's one thing about Alanna that I think indicates pretty heavily that she's town. Ask me about this when day breaks.

 

I think if Key, with arguably the most bothersome and can't self protect role for scum to fight against, does NOT die tonight, we have problems. Unless she can block a kill again.

 

I wish Monstr was around.

[Tommyrod]

Des can you recall a single strong case from Verb?

 

Who are his strong leans?

[monstrman]

Omg I missed Sili getting lynched

 

You guyssss