[Advanced] Kronos and Kaylee's Firefly Mafia Won

[csarmi]

Wombat, just walk away from salami. Arguing with him will only drive you mad.

So is your assessment that he actually believes what he's saying? Cause i'd have a very, very hard time buying it. Like... Ever.

 

But you do know him, please chime in.

[csarmi]

Claiming scum eh Salami?!

Nope?

[Tommyrod]

 

Claiming scum eh Salami?!

Nope?

Four QTs? You're outed.

[Yates]

Csarmi - I'm not saying you should build your case around it but it's totally okay to ask about it.  If he said something like "oh I keep my notes on a QT and copied them from there" or something like that?  Then whatever.  He played dumb.  So it's not that he had weird formatting that's the issue.  It's the fact he tried to play it off like he had no idea what she was talking about.  That actually *IS* suspicious.  So I'm not having problems with this line of questioning.
 

Look back at it and look at how it happened IN THIS GAME.  No need for generalities when it happened right here 3 pages or so ago.

[csarmi]

I'm saying i have quicktopics. Though I strongly prefer to keep notes on my dropbox these days.

[WWWwombat]

Csarmi - I'm not saying you should build your case around it but it's totally okay to ask about it.  If he said something like "oh I keep my notes on a QT and copied them from there" or something like that?  Then whatever.  He played dumb.  So it's not that he had weird formatting that's the issue.  It's the fact he tried to play it off like he had no idea what she was talking about.  That actually *IS* suspicious.  So I'm not having problems with this line of questioning.

 

Look back at it and look at how it happened IN THIS GAME.  No need for generalities when it happened right here 3 pages or so ago.

 

I think there are much, much worthier points against Thane.

[WWWwombat]

Also,

 

[unvote]

[Yates]

 

Csarmi - I'm not saying you should build your case around it but it's totally okay to ask about it.  If he said something like "oh I keep my notes on a QT and copied them from there" or something like that?  Then whatever.  He played dumb.  So it's not that he had weird formatting that's the issue.  It's the fact he tried to play it off like he had no idea what she was talking about.  That actually *IS* suspicious.  So I'm not having problems with this line of questioning.

 

Look back at it and look at how it happened IN THIS GAME.  No need for generalities when it happened right here 3 pages or so ago.

 

I think there are much, much worthier points against Thane.

 

Oh I agree.  I just didn't understand why you guys were jumping down Nyn's throat for what I perceive is a legit angle.  There's no reason NOT to include something like that as an "icing on the cake" sort of detail.

[WWWwombat]

Starting to have second thoughts about Salami, and regardless, he's not getting lynched today.  Debating between Thane, Clov, Hally now.  Thane and Hally are overtly scummy to the point of playing the mafia vs. scummy townie game in my head.  Clov is on a lot of peoples' lists and has been dodging Leelou's question.  I'd like to see him answer it before I make a move though.  I'd also like to see some more thoughts from Thane and Hally.

[Yates]

I'm saying i have quicktopics. Though I strongly prefer to keep notes on my dropbox these days.

Did he say he had a quicktopic?  No.  Did he say he had notes in his dropbox?  No.  He pretended like he didn't know what they were talking about.  Again, SPECIFICALLY in this game this is what happened.  I don't know why you would propose a theory or back story excuse that isn't supported by his posts or responses.  This is another example, I think, of you running interference in a weird way.

[WWWwombat]

 

 

Csarmi - I'm not saying you should build your case around it but it's totally okay to ask about it.  If he said something like "oh I keep my notes on a QT and copied them from there" or something like that?  Then whatever.  He played dumb.  So it's not that he had weird formatting that's the issue.  It's the fact he tried to play it off like he had no idea what she was talking about.  That actually *IS* suspicious.  So I'm not having problems with this line of questioning.

 

Look back at it and look at how it happened IN THIS GAME.  No need for generalities when it happened right here 3 pages or so ago.

 

I think there are much, much worthier points against Thane.

 

Oh I agree.  I just didn't understand why you guys were jumping down Nyn's throat for what I perceive is a legit angle.  There's no reason NOT to include something like that as an "icing on the cake" sort of detail.

 

 

It's really not that reliable though.  I'm not even sure if I could tell you if town or scum is more likely to have formatting bugs.  Which means that it just detracts from the rest of the case rather than putting icing on it.

[WWWwombat]

I find the content of that post to be much sketchier than the formatting.

[Yates]

Alright.  Still don't see why Nyn is taking heat, though.

[WWWwombat]

I don't see anyone FoSing her over it.

 

Thane's insistence that he didn't c/p is interesting as c/p from QT, DM, or elsewhere is the only specific way I know to duplicate that bug, but I hardly find it incriminating given how prevalent the bug is.  It was kind of a big thing a ways back when a whole bunch of people got lynched for it.  Some were scum, some were town.

[csarmi]

QT odd number post:

[color=#000000][font='Lucida Grande', verdana, sans-serif][background=#e9f0f7]Never trust anyone.[/size][/font][/color][/background]

QT even number post:

[color=#000000][font='Lucida Grande', verdana, sans-serif][background=#f0f0f1]Always the ones who want to keep you down.[/size][/font][/color][/background]

Thane's post:

[color=#282828][font=helvetica][background=#fbf8f2]Tommy[/font][/color][/background]

Development tools on DM page:

font: normal 13px helvetica, arial, sans-serif;

[Leelou]

 

Wombat, just walk away from salami. Arguing with him will only drive you mad.

So is your assessment that he actually believes what he's saying? Cause i'd have a very, very hard time buying it. Like... Ever.

 

But you do know him, please chime in.

 

 

Yes

[WWWwombat]

I also don't like how Thane has like 9 town reads vs. 2 non-controversial scum reads.

[csarmi]

Csarmi - I'm not saying you should build your case around it but it's totally okay to ask about it. If he said something like "oh I keep my notes on a QT and copied them from there" or something like that? Then whatever. He played dumb. So it's not that he had weird formatting that's the issue. It's the fact he tried to play it off like he had no idea what she was talking about. That actually *IS* suspicious. So I'm not having problems with this line of questioning.

 

Look back at it and look at how it happened IN THIS GAME. No need for generalities when it happened right here 3 pages or so ago.

I refuse to take anything related to this questioning into account.

[Yates]

QT odd number post:

[color=#000000][font='Lucida Grande', verdana, sans-serif][background=#e9f0f7]Never trust anyone.[/size][/font][/color][/background]

QT even number post:

[color=#000000][font='Lucida Grande', verdana, sans-serif][background=#f0f0f1]Always the ones who want to keep you down.[/size][/font][/color][/background]

Thane's post:

[color=#282828][font=helvetica][background=#fbf8f2]Tommy[/font][/color][/background]

Development tools on DM page:

font: normal 13px helvetica, arial, sans-serif;

So we can drop this, then?  Cool.

[WWWwombat]

Also, Pral's reads seem almost too weird to be scum to me.  Has anyone else scum read both Nyn and Leelou?

[csarmi]

 

Csarmi - I'm not saying you should build your case around it but it's totally okay to ask about it. If he said something like "oh I keep my notes on a QT and copied them from there" or something like that? Then whatever. He played dumb. So it's not that he had weird formatting that's the issue. It's the fact he tried to play it off like he had no idea what she was talking about. That actually *IS* suspicious. So I'm not having problems with this line of questioning.

 

Look back at it and look at how it happened IN THIS GAME. No need for generalities when it happened right here 3 pages or so ago.

I refuse to take anything related to this questioning into account.

This is on principle. If you find it weird you're welcome to it. There are some things in mafia i wont do. I prefer to play the game.

 

Leelou told me once not to look for ways to break the game. I took that advice cause i find it good.

[csarmi]

 

 

 

Wombat, just walk away from salami. Arguing with him will only drive you mad.

So is your assessment that he actually believes what he's saying? Cause i'd have a very, very hard time buying it. Like... Ever.

 

But you do know him, please chime in.

Yes

I shall reconsider this on my next reread then. Thank you.

[csarmi]

Also, Pral's reads seem almost too weird to be scum to me. Has anyone else scum read both Nyn and Leelou?

I don't think so. I am pretty sure that if Nyn is town so is Leelou. And still pretty sure that Nyn is town.

[WWWwombat]

Although, your game-breaking inclinations did come in handy for the Scooby game.

[Tommyrod]

Also, Pral's reads seem almost too weird to be scum to me. Has anyone else scum read both Nyn and Leelou?

Don't think so. I got the sense he wasn't paying great attention, maybe he read too fast. Maybe he's scum and didn't expect it to blow up. Idk.