[Basic] The Walking Dead Mafia - Game Over. Theo Wins!

[Theodora]

Theo and Err keep calling me scummy.  For what?  Please lay out cases...cause neither of you have once done so.

Not only Err and myself, Peace. The trains are obvious.

[peacesells]

 

Theo and Err keep calling me scummy.  For what?  Please lay out cases...cause neither of you have once done so.

Not only Err and myself, Peace. The trains are obvious.

 

The trains are obvious?  How?  Instead of saying they are obvious..explain them. 

 

Why are you making general statements like this without point outing your reasoning?  Err just did the same thing...and I called him for it. 

[peacesells]

Theo,

 

One more thing..why are you ignoring my points on Err? I don't think you've commented once this subject.

[Babar Hasan Khan]

 

You better be sure to spell your reasons out for Mish or she'll call you stupid.

 

 

I wasn't calling YOU stupid. I was calling your play stupid. It's not how you play mafia. I swear, if you weren't the cop, you'd be one of the scummiest people in the game. Townies should talk as much as possible, explain their reads as much as possible. Because this helps the rest of town, and differs them from mafia. Mafia doesn't want to give presise reasons on reads; they don't want to risk being pinned down on it later. They prefer to be vague. Do whatever you want this game, but remember for next time, when you don't have a cop claim to fall back on. Townies should talk as much as possible and be as open as possible about their reads and reasons.

 

 

 

 

Now, I've seen everyone and their grandma call me possible scum. I see two sides forming; mainly Ishy, Des and me on one side, and Dora, Err and BFG on the other side. Each side calls the other side scummy and is convinced the other side is the mafia... Well, let's throw this into the equation. I'm the Doc. How does THAT effect your reads and who you think are teammates, hm?

 

Also, I think Golden should tell us who he viewed. We are lucky that AJ decided to push the deadline for us, because how things are going now, we'd never be able to reach a majority lynch.

 

:) that is a game changer...... i think now that golden viewed u at night and was just bating to see who would join in condemning u to a lynch.... i now believe thats y he asked me about my opinion about u..... nice.... i must say.... if that is the case then we will not have any information about any other player... or he probably inspected theo and got a thumbs down thats y he refused to vote for her.....

 

what ever the case it... i think revealing who golden inspected would be a good idea.... but if we have till monday then may be we can wait half a day........ and come up with a situation where u would now fit in as a towny...  and check if goldens inspection fits into it... if not we can debate some more

[michellem]

Err, I just... *shakes head* Wow.

 

 

 

And there Dora, you just revealed yourself once and for all. If I was fake-claiming, there would be no need for me to reveal a character; a counter-claim from the real Doc would come. You are just looking to discredit me. Why, if you were a townie, would you need my character claim? The role claim is way stronger than any character claim. Trying to figure out wich characters are in the game so you'll know who'a safe for your team to fakeclaim eh?

[Theodora]

I meant it is obvious that a lot of people voted for you, don't turn only to Err and myself.

 

Why don't you ask: Desp, Ishy, Err, Theo, all of you, why am I considered scum?

 

I already told you my view: two claims, one of which smells (bomb in a Basic game?), rarely here to give a position (something for which you actually blame me).

 

I am ready to sacrifice like I said by lynching you "the bomb", so people would be at ease here. Sometimes town had to sacrifice, right?

 

About Err, I do not have a read on him, the only strange thing I got from him is why he still did not  join my "fanclub" with Despo as a President or he being a newbie may still think some people claim the truth in Mafia.

[Theodora]

Err, I just... *shakes head* Wow.

 

 

 

And there Dora, you just revealed yourself once and for all. If I was fake-claiming, there would be no need for me to reveal a character; a counter-claim from the real Doc would come. You are just looking to discredit me. Why, if you were a townie, would you need my character claim? The role claim is way stronger than any character claim. Trying to figure out wich characters are in the game so you'll know who'a safe for your team to fakeclaim eh?

I haven't thought of that, I am still confused with the roles. And stop with this discrediting you! Besides, you  are being over-paranoic. I feel you think you are playing with someone extraordinary clever to come up with such strategies!

[michellem]

Over-paranoid is what the game is all about.

[peacesells]

First..theo you claiming a Bomb wouldn't be in a basic game.  Then you go on to tell Mish you are still learning and are not sure what to make of the roles???

 

There is a HUGE disconnect there.

 

 

BTW..on DM, there are 2 types of game.  Advanced and Basic.   Basic includes what others may call "Standard" games.  Which routinely have multiple roles.  We already know this isn't a pure basic set up since there is the proven existence of lovers.  Add Bomb to the mix and that is more evidence that this game is more of a standard than basic variety.

 

 

Lastly, your sacrifice statements are ill-conceived.  If you are town and you do "sacrifice", you lose the game for all of us...not just you.   So while you may be whiling to take that risk..don't ask the rest of us to do the same and just be happy about it.

[Theodora]

At this stage, what could I do to proove I am telling the truth? I said, I would sacrifice for the town if this has to be done, although you will lose another town. Think logically, I barely could keep up and you make me the God Mother, whatever, weaving a web of deceit. I would be even amused about it afterwards but Town needs every townie now as I want to win as much as you do.

 

How do you know Peace is not scum?

[Theodora]

First..theo you claiming a Bomb wouldn't be in a basic game.  Then you go on to tell Mish you are still learning and are not sure what to make of the roles???

 

There is a HUGE disconnect there.

 

 

BTW..on DM, there are 2 types of game.  Advanced and Basic.   Basic includes what others may call "Standard" games.  Which routinely have multiple roles.  We already know this isn't a pure basic set up since there is the proven existence of lovers.  Add Bomb to the mix and that is more evidence that this game is more of a standard than basic variety.

 

 

Lastly, your sacrifice statements are ill-conceived.  If you are town and you do "sacrifice", you lose the game for all of us...not just you.   So while you may be whiling to take that risk..don't ask the rest of us to do the same and just be happy about it.

Me claiming a bomb?

[peacesells]

I meant it is obvious that a lot of people voted for you, don't turn only to Err and myself.

 

Why don't you ask: Desp, Ishy, Err, Theo, all of you, why am I considered scum?

 

I already told you my view: two claims, one of which smells (bomb in a Basic game?), rarely here to give a position (something for which you actually blame me).

 

I am ready to sacrifice like I said by lynching you "the bomb", so people would be at ease here. Sometimes town had to sacrifice, right?

 

About Err, I do not have a read on him, the only strange thing I got from him is why he still did not  join my "fanclub" with Despo as a President or he being a newbie may still think some people claim the truth in Mafia.

 

Read my post again..look at the bold.

[Theodora]

Desp, I am T-dog.  I am a bomb.  Hence, the reason for the soft claim.  Cause, you know me...I don't soft claim.

 

I would peg Shane as a serial killer.

 

VOTE THEO

?

[Theodora]

So are you now saying you fake claimed?

[peacesells]

So are you now saying you fake claimed?

 

Where are you even getting this from?

[Theodora]

Peace, you claimed you are a bomb, is it so or it isn't?

[peacesells]

Peace, you claimed you are a bomb, is it so or it isn't?

Yes...and why would you even think I had changed that?

[peacesells]

And..why are you ignoring my previous posts?

[michellem]

Dora, he is saying that YOU said that you doubted there was a bomb in a basic game, and now you say that you don't understand the roles.

 

At this stage, what could I do to proove I am telling the truth? I said, I would sacrifice for the town if this has to be done, although you will lose another town. Think logically, I barely could keep up and you make me the God Mother, whatever, weaving a web of deceit. I would be even amused about it afterwards but Town needs every townie now as I want to win as much as you do.

 

How do you know Peace is not scum?

 

I can't know 100%. But he has not done anything to make me think he is yet.

 

 

Peace: Are you willing to switch your vote to Theo? With no-one moving their votes, we aren't getting anywhere.

 

 

And why is over half the players not voting?!

[Theodora]

I cant see anything bolded, please underline  change colour.

 

And I still don't get the answer are you a bomb or not (fake claiming)?

[Theodora]

I was probing, Mish. If he is fake claiming or not. As indeed I am a bit confused about roles and someone said so many roles are not for a basic game. And on another game, they had ghosts, lovers and it was a basic game.

[michellem]

I was in that game, so I know. And we all agreed afterwards that the original set-up was not a basic set-up.

[Theodora]

Also, you didn't answer, Mish. What if I am right?! Like the last game (in the Aiel) and I am a townie. Besides, someone must be scum. Imagine me dead and a townie (hypothetically if you wish), who are the three people?

[michellem]

If you're right, we loose. Big deal. And all the newbies will learn how not to play. But I don't think you are town, at all, so the point is moot.

[Theodora]

Really how will they learn? Besides, why do you think Golden doesn't vote me? Are there corrupted cops too?