Merlin Mafia [Advanced!]- Town Wins!!!

[WWWwombat]

That's a pretty sad excuse for a vote and it seems like you're worried about a retaliation

 

Vote Alannalynn

It seems a lot of you think that every D1 vote either has to be a joke-vote or a well-justified vote. It appears I have been away too long.

 

Vote: Tiinker

[WWWwombat]

unvote

Vote: Tiinker

[Tiinker]

 

That's a pretty sad excuse for a vote and it seems like you're worried about a retaliation

 

Vote Alannalynn

It seems a lot of you think that every D1 vote either has to be a joke-vote or a well-justified vote. It appears I have been away too long.

 

Vote: Tiinker

 

What's the in between? A careless lazy vote? Town votes should be justified.

[WWWwombat]

 

 

 

That's a pretty sad excuse for a vote and it seems like you're worried about a retaliation

 

Vote Alannalynn

It seems a lot of you think that every D1 vote either has to be a joke-vote or a well-justified vote. It appears I have been away too long.

 

Vote: Tiinker

What's the in between? A careless lazy vote? Town votes should be justified.

Then why do townies ever joke vote?

[Tiinker]

 

 

 

That's a pretty sad excuse for a vote and it seems like you're worried about a retaliation

 

Vote Alannalynn

It seems a lot of you think that every D1 vote either has to be a joke-vote or a well-justified vote. It appears I have been away too long.

 

Vote: Tiinker

What's the in between? A careless lazy vote? Town votes should be justified.

Then why do townies ever joke vote?

 

So it's a joke vote or a justified vote then.

[WWWwombat]

 

 

 

 

 

That's a pretty sad excuse for a vote and it seems like you're worried about a retaliation

 

Vote Alannalynn

It seems a lot of you think that every D1 vote either has to be a joke-vote or a well-justified vote. It appears I have been away too long.

 

Vote: Tiinker

What's the in between? A careless lazy vote? Town votes should be justified.

Then why do townies ever joke vote?

So it's a joke vote or a justified vote then.

False dichotomy.

 

unvote

Vote: Darthe

 

What kind of vote was that?

[Tiinker]

 

 

 

 

 

That's a pretty sad excuse for a vote and it seems like you're worried about a retaliation

 

Vote Alannalynn

It seems a lot of you think that every D1 vote either has to be a joke-vote or a well-justified vote. It appears I have been away too long.

 

Vote: Tiinker

What's the in between? A careless lazy vote? Town votes should be justified.

Then why do townies ever joke vote?

So it's a joke vote or a justified vote then.

False dichotomy.

 

unvote

Vote: Darthe

 

 

What kind of vote was that?

 

Seems nonsensical.

[WWWwombat]

So what would you classify it as?

[alannalynn]

So, youre saying adding votes to a train to gauge reactions isn't worthwhile? I'm not afraid of retaliations, just dipping a toe in to see what comes up.

 

Tinker, why are you so scared of a third vote?

[Tiinker]

It doesn't, since it's a scummy vote and unjustified. A town vote is either justified by some means or it's for the laughs. If you vote someone with no justification then it's a scummy move. Which is why AJ's vote is scummy. Am I missing something here?

[alannalynn]

Seems I'm gettin behind. I'm slow. And new replies don't show on my phone

[alannalynn]

Flawed logic, a vote of anyone doesn't have to be justified. No rules on that. Its not like I built a case to get a train rolling. Lol i just voted.

[WWWwombat]

It doesn't, since it's a scummy vote and unjustified. A town vote is either justified by some means or it's for the laughs. If you vote someone with no justification then it's a scummy move. Which is why AJ's vote is scummy. Am I missing something here?

You are missing the logical consequences of your stance:

 

Premise 1: If you vote someone with no justification then it's a scummy move.

Premise 2: Joke votes are not justified.

Conclusion: Therefore a joke vote is a scummy move.

 

 

So why wasn't everyone jumping over the first person to joke vote?

[Tiinker]

So, youre saying adding votes to a train to gauge reactions isn't worthwhile? I'm not afraid of retaliations, just dipping a toe in to see what comes up.

 

Tinker, why are you so scared of a third vote?

Other than replying to your own vote, what have I done that shows I am "so scared"? It's worthwhile if you genuinely believe they aren't playing a town game. Up until that point I had barely posted and you had cast your vote based on 3 words and nothing else.

[alannalynn]

Do yoy really think i think you are scum?

[Tiinker]

 

It doesn't, since it's a scummy vote and unjustified. A town vote is either justified by some means or it's for the laughs. If you vote someone with no justification then it's a scummy move. Which is why AJ's vote is scummy. Am I missing something here?

You are missing the logical consequences of your stance:

 

Premise 1: If you vote someone with no justification then it's a scummy move.

Premise 2: Joke votes are not justified.

Conclusion: Therefore a joke vote is a scummy move.

 

 

So why wasn't everyone jumping over the first person to joke vote?

 

 

Jokes aren't meant to be taken seriously and don't classify as real votes. Whether or not you think that the person making the vote is really joking is up to you to judge. 

[WWWwombat]

 

 

 

It doesn't, since it's a scummy vote and unjustified. A town vote is either justified by some means or it's for the laughs. If you vote someone with no justification then it's a scummy move. Which is why AJ's vote is scummy. Am I missing something here?

You are missing the logical consequences of your stance:

 

Premise 1: If you vote someone with no justification then it's a scummy move.

Premise 2: Joke votes are not justified.

Conclusion: Therefore a joke vote is a scummy move.

 

 

So why wasn't everyone jumping over the first person to joke vote?

Jokes aren't meant to be taken seriously and don't classify as real votes. Whether or not you think that the person making the vote is really joking is up to you to judge.

So joke votes aren't real? In that case, let's joke vote you up to 12 votes and see what happens.

[WWWwombat]

@Mod: With 20 players, shouldn't it be 11 to lynch, not 12?

[WWWwombat]

Also,

 

unvote

Vote: Tiinker

 

Because I don't like words with consecutive i's.

[Tiinker]

Flawed logic, a vote of anyone doesn't have to be justified. No rules on that. Its not like I built a case to get a train rolling. Lol i just voted.

If your votes aren't justified then you may as well just randomize your vote every time it's Day. What I'm trying to say is that you did in fact justify your vote but your justification was crappy.

 

 

 

 

It doesn't, since it's a scummy vote and unjustified. A town vote is either justified by some means or it's for the laughs. If you vote someone with no justification then it's a scummy move. Which is why AJ's vote is scummy. Am I missing something here?

You are missing the logical consequences of your stance:

 

Premise 1: If you vote someone with no justification then it's a scummy move.

Premise 2: Joke votes are not justified.

Conclusion: Therefore a joke vote is a scummy move.

 

 

So why wasn't everyone jumping over the first person to joke vote?

Jokes aren't meant to be taken seriously and don't classify as real votes. Whether or not you think that the person making the vote is really joking is up to you to judge.

So joke votes aren't real? In that case, let's joke vote you up to 12 votes and see what happens.

 

Lol? They're not real in the sense that they don't count to how I view the player. Whether or not you think that the person making the vote is really joking is up to you to judge.

[WWWwombat]

*Ahem*

 

Let it be known that my vote on Tiinker is a "joke vote" and therefore is not a real vote and should not be held against me should Tiinker be lynched and flip town.

[Tiinker]

So explain to me how a town vote doesn't need justification please because I don't get it.

[Tiinker]

*Ahem*

 

Let it be known that my vote on Tiinker is a "joke vote" and therefore is not a real vote and should not be held against me should Tiinker be lynched and flip town.

Whether or not you think that the person making the vote is really joking is up to you to judge.Whether or not you think that the person making the vote is really joking is up to you to judge.Whether or not you think that the person making the vote is really joking is up to you to judge.Whether or not you think that the person making the vote is really joking is up to you to judge.Whether or not you think that the person making the vote is really joking is up to you to judge.Whether or not you think that the person making the vote is really joking is up to you to judge.Whether or not you think that the person making the vote is really joking is up to you to judge.Whether or not you think that the person making the vote is really joking is up to you to judge.Whether or not you think that the person making the vote is really joking is up to you to judge.

[WWWwombat]

Most townie votes should be justified. I'm merely objecting to the belief that a vote with no explanation should be seen as scummier than a vote with an obviously contrived explanation.

 

Unexplained votes do have their uses, however.

[WWWwombat]

 

 

*Ahem*

 

Let it be known that my vote on Tiinker is a "joke vote" and therefore is not a real vote and should not be held against me should Tiinker be lynched and flip town.

Whether or not you think that the person making the vote is really joking is up to you to judge.Whether or not you think that the person making the vote is really joking is up to you to judge.Whether or not you think that the person making the vote is really joking is up to you to judge.Whether or not you think that the person making the vote is really joking is up to you to judge.Whether or not you think that the person making the vote is really joking is up to you to judge.Whether or not you think that the person making the vote is really joking is up to you to judge.Whether or not you think that the person making the vote is really joking is up to you to judge.Whether or not you think that the person making the vote is really joking is up to you to judge.Whether or not you think that the person making the vote is really joking is up to you to judge.

What if I were to tell you that I think that 80% of the votes so far this game have been jokes.