[Advanced] The Dresden Files Mafia - Game Over - Ed loses, Verbal wins

[John McClane]

Not being able to edit sucks.

[Tyler Glembo]

Character + role reveals are the norm on DM.

[BooBoo]

My name is Bob

Ape is a slob 

[John McClane]

My name is Bob

Ape is a slob 

 

 

lol

[Tyler Glembo]

So you're claiming Bob, the spirit who live inside a skull and helps Harry out by being, basically a library of knowledge?

[BooBoo]

So you're claiming Bob, the spirit who live inside a skull and helps Harry out by being, basically a library of knowledge?

 

I have no idea

You'd know my dear

I dont know the content

my skills are abundant

[Tyler Glembo]

CC anyone?  Bob + town reporter are not exactly a perfect match, but Bob does help reveal knowledge to Dresden so it's possible.

[John E. Kelley]

 

 

I VOTE BOOBOO

 

 

His posts are mostly either attacks against the most active scum hunter in this game, or BooBoo posts lots of random stuff that, to me, almost sounds like his game style is very erratic or even kind of schizophrenic in nature. If we on the Town team are going to defeat the Mafia, then I don't understand how BooBoo is being helpful, even if he is Town. Throughout Day 1 and Night 1, most of Booboo's votes have come without any explanation. That is rarely a  good thing to do. But,  I think that he is Mafia attempting to masquerade as Town. 

 

I'd just like to point out

I dont like this post, no doubt

 

 

Yup. It stinks like he was stoking the fire on your train after it fizzled. 

 

I'm also concerned with Ishy and Tina and their cryptic little routine. It's like they are soft claiming.

 

I've already fully claimed, no soft about it. I'm vanilla town, no power role.

[John E. Kelley]

 

You can't possibly be as dense as you're coming off as. You don't get what I read into Tina's vote? Really?

 

I know what it looked like, I'd rather here you state your intentions rather than trying to be cryptic and manipulative.

 

And out someone that should stay hidden? No thanks.

[John McClane]

 

 

You can't possibly be as dense as you're coming off as. You don't get what I read into Tina's vote? Really?

 

I know what it looked like, I'd rather here you state your intentions rather than trying to be cryptic and manipulative.

 

And out someone that should stay hidden? No thanks.

 

 

Now who is being dense Ishy? You already dropped the cryptic acknowledgement of following Tina because you "squinted your eyes" and realized something. Now you are saying you don't want to "out" someone that should stay hidden.

 

Just by saying these things you've called attention to her, and put her in the spotlight. So don't ACT all pro-town and feign the desire NOT to call attention to it, when it's you that put her front and center. You shined light on it, now you are acting like whu? As if nobody else noticed your reaction to her?

 

So, I'm not a fan of cryptic nonsense. You obviously said what you said in order to posture for something, so take ownership of it, or enjoy the dead thread.

[Hybrid]

I haven't caught up yet -- just got off from work -- but it's worth noting that AVM's name is a different color than the other 3. Not sure yet what that means, if anything, but it might come in useful further down the line.

[John E. Kelley]

 

 

 

You can't possibly be as dense as you're coming off as. You don't get what I read into Tina's vote? Really?

 

I know what it looked like, I'd rather here you state your intentions rather than trying to be cryptic and manipulative.

 

And out someone that should stay hidden? No thanks.

 

 

Now who is being dense Ishy? You already dropped the cryptic acknowledgement of following Tina because you "squinted your eyes" and realized something. Now you are saying you don't want to "out" someone that should stay hidden.

 

Just by saying these things you've called attention to her, and put her in the spotlight. So don't ACT all pro-town and feign the desire NOT to call attention to it, when it's you that put her front and center. You shined light on it, now you are acting like whu? As if nobody else noticed your reaction to her?

 

So, I'm not a fan of cryptic nonsense. You obviously said what you said in order to posture for something, so take ownership of it, or enjoy the dead thread.

 

And yet, no one else noticed or commented on what I said until you started pounding on your chest. Why don't YOU stfu and not call attention to it.

 

And I'm not ACTING pro-Town, I AM pro-Town.

[Hybrid]

And yet, no one else noticed or commented on what I said until you started pounding on your chest. Why don't YOU stfu and not call attention to it.

 

And I'm not ACTING pro-Town, I AM pro-Town.

 

Ape's post pointing it out definitely didn't help, but it's not like you were particularly subtle in the first place.  I mean, you quoted her freaking post and then you "squinted at Tina's vote".

[Hybrid]

The Ape is liar

We should set him on fire

 

LOL.

[John E. Kelley]

 

And yet, no one else noticed or commented on what I said until you started pounding on your chest. Why don't YOU stfu and not call attention to it.

 

And I'm not ACTING pro-Town, I AM pro-Town.

 

Ape's post pointing it out definitely didn't help, but it's not like you were particularly subtle in the first place.  I mean, you quoted her freaking post and then you "squinted at Tina's vote".

 

GFY.

[John McClane]

 

And yet, no one else noticed or commented on what I said until you started pounding on your chest. Why don't YOU stfu and not call attention to it.

 

And I'm not ACTING pro-Town, I AM pro-Town.

 

Ape's post pointing it out definitely didn't help, but it's not like you were particularly subtle in the first place.  I mean, you quoted her freaking post and then you "squinted at Tina's vote".

 

 

Let's be clear on one thing. I didn't "point it out", he did. I asked for clarification on it.

[John McClane]

 

 

And yet, no one else noticed or commented on what I said until you started pounding on your chest. Why don't YOU stfu and not call attention to it.

 

And I'm not ACTING pro-Town, I AM pro-Town.

 

Ape's post pointing it out definitely didn't help, but it's not like you were particularly subtle in the first place.  I mean, you quoted her freaking post and then you "squinted at Tina's vote".

 

GFY.

 

You are acting like a cornered rat.

[John E. Kelley]

 

 

 

And yet, no one else noticed or commented on what I said until you started pounding on your chest. Why don't YOU stfu and not call attention to it.

 

And I'm not ACTING pro-Town, I AM pro-Town.

 

Ape's post pointing it out definitely didn't help, but it's not like you were particularly subtle in the first place.  I mean, you quoted her freaking post and then you "squinted at Tina's vote".

 

GFY.

 

You are acting like a cornered rat.

 

I'm not cornered. If I were anywhere near close to being lynched, maybe I'd feel that way. But since this crew would never lynch me.....yeah, I feel pretty secure. Keep trying though.

[Hybrid]

I had BooBoo at the top of my list but he gets a respite for now due to his reveal.

 

Revised list: Ishy, Nolder, Tglems, ed, Katiora in that order.

 

Vote Ishy

[John Snow]

Official Vote Count:

 

Boo(5): Peace, AVM, Verb, Kat, Vam

Ishy(4): Leelou, Nol, Ape, Hybrid

Kat(1): Ishy

 

Not voting:

TGlems, Song, Lenlo, Tina, Rand, boo, Ed

 

With 17 alive, it takes 9 to lynch

 

Deadline: http://www.timeandda...=Day 2 Deadline

 

This is noon on the 4th in Mountain Timezone. I also believe that's DM time.

[John McClane]

 

 

 

Leelou is pinging me too right now, she's in lock-step with me. I always get most paranoid about those too willing to be closely aligned with the alpha scum hunter.

Leroy has been playing the Follow the Ape game now that you mention it....

 

 

CHOMP!!!!!!! Can't be this easy, can it?

 

^^^ Ishy bit on this trap pretty hard. If his logic was that there's no way there's a game mechanic that would out two townies at once (his words) then why at no point has he voted AVM? Instead he's hanging around and nudging every bit of FOS I throw out there. He didn't really take a position on JIF though, he avoided that. 

 

 

Ah, a reply box... Nice. 

 

Lets see. AVM and Ishy might be vanilla, or maybe not. 

 

Ishy offers to get lynched and Booboo selfvotes. 

 

TGlems has different suggestions on different roles. Katiora has as well. 

 

I don´t like when people suggests jester every game.

 

 

 

But half of my post got eaten. Arrrrgh... *daily kill Cloudflare scream*

 

I´m vary about Verbal at this point. Also think Leelou is on a team with someone. 

 

 

lol @ Booboo

 

 

 

 

style="margin-top: 0px; margin-right: 0px; margin-bottom: 0px; margin-left: 0px; "> 

Vote AVM  

 

Second time you've done the whole vote with no explanation and move on thing.

 

This is a strange comment from someone who plays on a site where noone ever explains their votes.

 

 

Also, Vote: BooBoo

 

Verbal surfing. 

 

 

 

 

I agree that Booboo´s reactions looks scummy. But he immedeately asked what a Chicago Citizen is after the coroner´s report. That would be kind of clumsy  to ask if scum.

 

Ishy don´t add anything except for letting us know he is willing to get lynched. Any thoughts, Ishy? 

 

Vote Katiora.

 

 

 

 

I agree that Booboo´s reactions looks scummy. But he immedeately asked what a Chicago Citizen is after the coroner´s report. That would be kind of clumsy  to ask if scum.

 

Ishy don´t add anything except for letting us know he is willing to get lynched. Any thoughts, Ishy? 

 

Vote Katiora.

 

 

Talk about a hedging statement. "I agree JIF looks scummy, but here's a reason why he's probably not scummy, and here's some redirected pressure at Ishy (possible distancing) and a random vote on Katiora"

 

You are on my short list for good reason. Now, I really want to know JIFs alignment. You should have put him at L1.

 

I would if I thought he was mafia. 

 

 

 

 

I agree that Booboo´s reactions looks scummy. But he immedeately asked what a Chicago Citizen is after the coroner´s report. That would be kind of clumsy  to ask if scum.

 

Ishy don´t add anything except for letting us know he is willing to get lynched. Any thoughts, Ishy? 

 

Vote Katiora.

 

Why Katiora? 

 

To me it looks like she is trying to look town rather than being town. I can find some quotes if you want. 

 

 

 

I agree that Booboo´s reactions looks scummy. But he immedeately asked what a Chicago Citizen is after the coroner´s report. That would be kind of clumsy  to ask if scum.

 

Ishy don´t add anything except for letting us know he is willing to get lynched. Any thoughts, Ishy? 

 

Vote Katiora.

*squints thoughtfully at Tina's vote*

 

Okay, I get it. Vote Kat.

 

^^^ These are all Tina's posts BEFORE she finally votes Kat. So she's building towards suspicion on Verbal, and gives Leelou a push too, then somehow finds herself on Kat, with Ishy quickly putting the soft-sell on there being some sort of "informed" vote hint in her post.

 

I don't anything in her vote. I see him calling attention to it though. Doesn't add up. So it's worthy of being questioned, imo.

 

Now he's playing "super townie" trying to villainize me for asking what they are being cryptic about, when he was the one that spotlighted her vote and insinuated there was more to it than just a guess.

[John E. Kelley]

Good God you're  a douche....

[John McClane]

I'm not cornered. If I were anywhere near close to being lynched, maybe I'd feel that way. But since this crew would never lynch me.....yeah, I feel pretty secure. Keep trying though.

 

Yeah, you sure are all about the town right now. So, if I have this right, you are willing to take one for the team... but because you are sloppy, you divulge absolute arrogance about the likelihood that this crew would never lynch you. Therefore I'd conclude that you in no way meant what you said about "taking one for the team".

 

Got it.

[John McClane]

Good God you're  a douche....

 

Personal attacks will not phase me, or discourage me. They only make me stronger. 

[Hybrid]

I would think that it would almost have to be one that reads true and one that doesn't. Like I said earlier, I just can't see a game mechanic that allows two Townies to be confirmed everyday. If you add in a Cop viewing, the pool of potential scum would be narrowed so fast that it would break the game in two or three days. I don't want to be seen as trying to game the mod, but that would just be a horrible mechanic and one that I don't think JS would inject into the game.

 

That being said, view me again if that's what everyone wants, I welcome it. My report, at least, was dead on.

 

^ This was anti-town as hell.