Wombat's A Song of Ice and Fire Mafia (Advanced) Game Thread

[John E. Kelley]

Just to clarify, isn't cult treated as any other faction? In that, once the CL goes, don't the rest become unaligned survivors?

[WWWwombat]

Most factions have a Faction Leader. Some factions have backup Faction Leaders. Factions that started with Faction leaders must have a faction leader alive in order to win. Should any faction (besides the Cult) no longer have any living faction leaders, the remaining living members of that faction will become unaligned survivors.

[John E. Kelley]

Gotcha. Thanks boss.

[Christine]

Cult is always an issue until they are all dead.

[Paperblade]

Clearly they should have just recruited you then

[Christine]

Clearly.

[WWWwombat]

After what seems like an eternity, the sun rises again. Two of you are found dead.

 

The first is found in the Tower of the Hand. His throat has been crushed.

 

鲍勃不是我的名字, Robb Stark, Tracker, Backup Faction Leader, House Stark has been killed.

 

 

The next body is found in the Great Hall. It seems she was climbing the rafters and slipped, falling from no small height. Her skull is broken and her head is lying in a pool of blood.

 

Amadine, Arya Stark, Vanilla, House Stark is dead.

 

It is now Day 8. Deadline is Thursday, March 8 at midnight EST.

[WWWwombat]

With 9 voting players, it takes 5 to lynch.

[Christine]

House Stark is getting screwed in the butt.

[Christine]

Updated through Night 7.

 

Still Alive

 

 

Song

Vicious

Keyholder

Ishy

dapianoplay3r

trench

JF80

Paperblade

The Crusher

Christine (can't vote)

 

 

Houses/Factions

 

 

Night’s Watch

- Wins : with factional survival

- Dead : 3 : Jon (Pac), Mormont (GF), Sam (BG)

- Alive? : Benjen

 

King in the Narrow Sea - Stannis

- Not Discovered

- Known Enemies : Tyrell, Greyjoy, Lannister

- Dead : None

- Alive? : Stannis, Davos, Davos

 

House Stark

- Enemies : Cult, Lannister, Greyjoy

- Dead : 5 : Catelyn (Red), Rickon (Tina), Sansa (Songstress), Robb (Notbob), Arya (Ama)

- Alive? : Ned, Bran

 

Highgarden - Tyrell

- Enemies : Cult, Stannis, Greyjoy, Lannister

- Dead : 5 : Loras (Verbal), Randyll Tarly (AH), Margaery (Despo), Mace (Pats), Brienne (Leelou)

- Alive? : Olena

 

House Greyjoy

- Enemies: Cult, Stark, Stannis, Tyrell, Lannister

- Dead : 3 : Victarion (Amega), Euron (Thorum), Theon (Razen)

- Alive? : Balon, Aeron, Asha

 

House Lannister

- Enemies : Cult, Stark, Stannis, Tyrell, Greyjoy

- Dead : 4 : Tyrion (Nolder), Cersei (Aemon), Joffrey (Sakaea), Jaime (Meesh)

- Alive? : Tywin, Tommen, Myrcella, Kevan

 

Cult

- Enemies : Stark, Stannis, Tyrell, Greyjoy, Lannister

- Likely recruited 3 total (Recruiter died Day 4)

- Dead : 2 : Littlefinger (Ape, Recruiter), Mace Tyrell (Pats, Recruited)

 

Unaligned Survivors

- The Spider - Fex - Wins with Survival and Death of Cult

- Others?

 

[Christine]

How the hell is stannis in this game?! There is only 10 left alive.

 

 

None of the Faction Leaders have died yet. That means 4 are faction leaders (known factions).

 

I am not a Faction Leader. Wouldn't be fair, with being Stump as well.

 

Then, there is the two others that Cult recruited.

 

This puts us at 7 of the total left NOT STANNIS. Leaving only 3 people for a faction?

 

 

Which, that is really odd, given that Stark and Highgarden both have at least 6. And Lannister at least 5.

 

 

WTF MOD.

[John E. Kelley]

Just wanting to point out, that since D1, this is the extent of what we've heard from Trench.

Only one way to find out for sure, and it is worth it, if it gets us our first cultist.Vote Ape

I'll admit, we were all on the same page here, but an easy place to hide as well.

 

Ok well, that's settled.

Obviously. Lazy post.

 

Wait, doesn't Cult Finder mean he was hunting cult, and telling the truth, or am I being thick?

Ditto to my last point.

 

Well I dont want to lynch you again, but if for any reason I want to vote no lynch, i'll just vote for you.

And waste a vote. Seems like useless spammy banter to me.

 

The redneck riviera itself

Spam.

 

Maybe year round, but they all vaction right here, and get as drunk as humanly possible.

Spam Part 2.

 

I wouldn't live anywhere else

And Part 3.

 

yhea if it was down to San Diego or Jacksonville, I would definelty go for Jacksonville.

Yawn.

 

Well if the group wants to pursue a Razen lynch I can get behind it. But I think we should be focusing on the Cult, we have some threads that could be pulled, Leelou and Patsfan are very good options and if we can break the cults back I say its better to do it sooner rather then later.

Finally a meaningful post. Yet it was only half right and Pat's case was so obvious that most all of us pointed it out.

 

I agree with Vic, if I had been accused of being given a Gun I would have run right in and denied it till my fingers bled. Not watch someone get shot and try to blend into the background.Vote PatsFan

As we all did. Again a good place to hide.

 

If Patsfan flipped cult, there is no reason to think Leelou would not flip cult as well. I think we need to go ahead and use this day to weaken the cult further. I don't doubt that she is Brienne, but I also dont doubt she is cult as well.Vote Leelou

How'd that turn out? And again not making a stand and blending in.

 

Not Bob's info not withstanding, I would like to see why Leelou and Christine wanted to lynch Vic so bad yesterday. I could get on Mmeesh's train but I would rather give her sometime to explain herself and would also like to slow down the speed at which we have been lynching people the last few days.

Here he calls for us to slow down Meesh's lynch....

 

Well were just shy of 12 hours into this day and we have Meesh at L-1, im sure there is no harm in going this fast at all Key

And here he says rushing it along is a good thing. Contradiction much?

 

Well I would say most people's thought process is, "hey as long as the group doesn't want to speed lynch one of my teammates, I'm good with it". But personally I think we have to drop this idea of multiple factions, and start finding solid reasons why they may be cult or Greyjoy/Lannister, because its those groups that are the enemy of all. I dont doubt Not Bob's reveal or his results, but they dont tell us for sure that Meesh is cult or Greyjoy/Lannister, and I just want to be the voice of reason here. We should give Meesh a chance to reveal or refute before we put her at L-2, let alone L-1.

And finally, with Meesh's NK ability, that I and a few others suspected her of having, it was pretty evident that she was a Lannister.

 

My analysis? Chrissy has been wondering why we haven't seen Stannis or his King in the Narrow Sea cohorts. Probably because they've been posting sporadically, hiding within easy and obvious trains, filling their lack of meaningful posts with spam, and when actually trying to case players, using info already offered by others. If we want to finally look at revealing Stannis and his faction, Trench seems a good place to start imo.

[John E. Kelley]

That should have read since D3**

[Christine]

...

 

That could be it.

 

 

Or Ishy is Stannis.

[dapianoplay3r]

VOTE VIC

I still think he is cult

Im so tired right now that I can't really think but tomorrow I should be better

[hotpocket2006]

Thereare quite a few people who were uber active, but then now slowed down.

 

Vic hasn't really been active very much, but I can definitely see the Ape recruiting his JN buddies, so they could pwn the DM newbs *rolls eyes*. He did recruit pats fan. SO we could look at crusher, Vic and 80 possibly being cult.

 

I also agree with Ishy's assessment. Tench has been on the lynches, but hasn't really been contributing much besides spammage.

 

So I would be okay to roll with Vic or Trench at this point.

[The Crusher]

Thereare quite a few people who were uber active, but then now slowed down.

 

Vic hasn't really been active very much, but I can definitely see the Ape recruiting his JN buddies, so they could pwn the DM newbs *rolls eyes*. He did recruit pats fan. SO we could look at crusher, Vic and 80 possibly being cult.

 

I also agree with Ishy's assessment. Tench has been on the lynches, but hasn't really been contributing much besides spammage.

 

So I would be okay to roll with Vic or Trench at this point.

 

 

Good point Song but I think it's a little naive to remove you from the people that played at JN he may have recruited. Just to let everyone know I am not cult. I am the Faction leader of the faction Highgarden that Verb and Leelou belonged to. At this point Im basically aligned with the stark because they are the only ones I left that are not a threat to my house. I have no special powers except the bullet proof vest that was shot off the night following the death of my Doc Leelou. May she rest in piece.

 

Im guessing Jaimie Bannister made the attempt on me since Im alive today.

 

I'm gonna vote Vic cause Leelou made me promise. Have to be honest that Songs post feels more like a play than reasoning considering she should be on the list of JNer's.

 

 

vote vic

[The Crusher]

Thereare quite a few people who were uber active, but then now slowed down.

 

Vic hasn't really been active very much, but I can definitely see the Ape recruiting his JN buddies, so they could pwn the DM newbs *rolls eyes*. He did recruit pats fan. SO we could look at crusher, Vic and 80 possibly being cult.

 

I also agree with Ishy's assessment. Tench has been on the lynches, but hasn't really been contributing much besides spammage.

 

So I would be okay to roll with Vic or Trench at this point.

 

 

Good point Song but I think it's a little naive to remove you from the people that played at JN he may have recruited. Just to let everyone know I am not cult. I am the Faction leader of the faction Highgarden that Verb and Leelou belonged to. At this point Im basically aligned with the stark because they are the only ones I left that are not a threat to my house. I have no special powers except the bullet proof vest that was shot off the night following the death of my Doc Leelou. May she rest in piece.

 

Im guessing Jaimie Bannister made the attempt on me since Im alive today.

 

I'm gonna vote Vic cause Leelou made me promise. Have to be honest that Songs post feels more like a play than reasoning considering she should be on the list of JNer's.

 

 

vote vic

 

vote vic

[JF80]

Vote Vic

[Vicious89x]

I'm open to the pressure but would like a justification as to why. If it's due to my inactivity I'd have to say look at quality over quantity. I find it odd how people are sleeping on 80. Take a look at his activity going back to the 27th. He simply votes and leaves and has not contributed to anything else to the game. If I am to be blamed for hiding in the shadows I think there are better places to look. I'm just at the forefront of people's minds.

 

At this stage I would say Ishmael's case on trench looks well put together and 80 are who I'm willing to vote.

 

Vote 80

 

In Topic: Wombat's A Song of Ice and Fire Mafia (Advanced) Game Thread

 

Today, 06:47 AM

Vote Vic

In Topic: Wombat's A Song of Ice and Fire Mafia (Advanced) Game Thread

 

02 March 2012 - 07:13 AM

Vote Meesh.

In Topic: Wombat's A Song of Ice and Fire Mafia (Advanced) Game Thread

 

01 March 2012 - 05:54 AM

Vote Leelou

In Topic: Wombat's A Song of Ice and Fire Mafia (Advanced) Game Thread

 

28 February 2012 - 05:59 AM

Vote Razen

In Topic: Wombat's A Song of Ice and Fire Mafia (Advanced) Game Thread

 

27 February 2012 - 11:21 AM

What the hell. I'm not allowed to send PM's for some reason.

[The Crusher]

I'm open to the pressure but would like a justification as to why. If it's due to my inactivity I'd have to say look at quality over quantity. I find it odd how people are sleeping on 80. Take a look at his activity going back to the 27th. He simply votes and leaves and has not contributed to anything else to the game. If I am to be blamed for hiding in the shadows I think there are better places to look. I'm just at the forefront of people's minds.

 

At this stage I would say Ishmael's case on trench looks well put together and 80 are who I'm willing to vote.

 

Vote 80

 

In Topic: Wombat's A Song of Ice and Fire Mafia (Advanced) Game Thread

 

Today, 06:47 AM

Vote Vic

In Topic: Wombat's A Song of Ice and Fire Mafia (Advanced) Game Thread

 

02 March 2012 - 07:13 AM

Vote Meesh.

In Topic: Wombat's A Song of Ice and Fire Mafia (Advanced) Game Thread

 

01 March 2012 - 05:54 AM

Vote Leelou

In Topic: Wombat's A Song of Ice and Fire Mafia (Advanced) Game Thread

 

28 February 2012 - 05:59 AM

Vote Razen

In Topic: Wombat's A Song of Ice and Fire Mafia (Advanced) Game Thread

 

27 February 2012 - 11:21 AM

What the hell. I'm not allowed to send PM's for some reason.

 

 

The only reason I vote you is was sweet Leelou's dying request. I could kill 80 at a drop of a hat though.

[Christine]

I support the idea of a Vic lynch.

[Vicious89x]

I'm open to the pressure but would like a justification as to why. If it's due to my inactivity I'd have to say look at quality over quantity. I find it odd how people are sleeping on 80. Take a look at his activity going back to the 27th. He simply votes and leaves and has not contributed to anything else to the game. If I am to be blamed for hiding in the shadows I think there are better places to look. I'm just at the forefront of people's minds.

 

At this stage I would say Ishmael's case on trench looks well put together and 80 are who I'm willing to vote.

 

Vote 80

 

In Topic: Wombat's A Song of Ice and Fire Mafia (Advanced) Game Thread

 

Today, 06:47 AM

Vote Vic

In Topic: Wombat's A Song of Ice and Fire Mafia (Advanced) Game Thread

 

02 March 2012 - 07:13 AM

Vote Meesh.

In Topic: Wombat's A Song of Ice and Fire Mafia (Advanced) Game Thread

 

01 March 2012 - 05:54 AM

Vote Leelou

In Topic: Wombat's A Song of Ice and Fire Mafia (Advanced) Game Thread

 

28 February 2012 - 05:59 AM

Vote Razen

In Topic: Wombat's A Song of Ice and Fire Mafia (Advanced) Game Thread

 

27 February 2012 - 11:21 AM

What the hell. I'm not allowed to send PM's for some reason.

 

 

The only reason I vote you is was sweet Leelou's dying request. I could kill 80 at a drop of a hat though.

 

 

Right I understand. Your faction is all but eliminated. I dont' know why Leelou wanted me dead but I'm not sure if you saw my post from a few days back explaining my theory why I thought Leelou was innocent based on PatsFans death. She turned away the gun so that led me to believe she was clean, but by the time I logged on she was dead.

 

I support the idea of a Vic lynch.

 

I suggest you consult your 3 eyed crow and look elsewhere.

[Christine]

Anddddd I now support an 80 lynch.

[Christine]

Also, seriously? This long?

 

 

Where were you 20 pages ago.