Mafia: Wild Wild West

[Safir]

I wish I knew, twitch, i really do...

[Naeann]

Ooh  :o

I'm sorry Twitchy.  Now I'm freaked out cause my idea of who is evil is blown.  *eyes everyone*

[Thorum]

Always look on the bright side of life.

 

tudum, tudum tudum tudum

 

At least he was roleless. Which means, with 6 players left and probably 2 evils (not 3, or it would be game over!!!) and a finder and a healer. That's only 2 unroled players. And it means that, if we lynch an innocent and the healer is not protecting the correct person: it's game over and the wrong side has won.

 

We seriously are in endgame and it is not looking very good.

 

Vemy, I'm not gonna vote for you yet, since your analysis on Nae seems to make sense. And I don't wanna lynch another innocent. If I'm the only one who thinks thus, I'll be glad to strengthen the Vemy-train

[Naeann]

Yeah.... totallly makes sense since he thought Twitchy was the other evil. *shrugs*  That means he thought my partner in crime was ready to lynch me because as you will note Twitch didnt waver on immedietly voting for me and sticking to it yet Vemy thought we were a team.  Good setup for someone to use when he himself is the evil..... doent work when your theory goes up in smoke because your number 2 choice for an evil is an innocent.  I know because I had the same theory with Vemy and Twitchy.

 

In light of what you just put... my attentions swing full force onto you.  I think you had the same analasis as I did with putting it as Vemy and Twitchy as up until now you assumed it was Vemy.  Now suddenly your going for me where just yesterday you said you had no reason to believe i was anything but innocent.

[Thorum]

Yeah.... totallly makes sense since he thought Twitchy was the other evil.

 

I have looked for this, but not found. I don't see a necessity of twitchy as quilty to have you as quilty??? Enlighten me, please.

 

 

In light of what you just put... my attentions swing full force onto you.  I think you had the same analasis as I did with putting it as Vemy and Twitchy as up until now you assumed it was Vemy.  Now suddenly your going for me where just yesterday you said you had no reason to believe i was anything but innocent.

 

I did not make an analysis of Twitchy being evil. There surtenly are two evils left, and vemy was the only one I saw anything against, and with Vemy's analysis, I start seeing reason why it could also be you. I also said I would wait until someone else (soy, leelou or safir) tells me what he/she thinks of it.

 

Suddenly leaving Vemy and turning to me, just because you become co-suspected?? We NEED to have an evil this time, or it's done. The time for voting for someone because he votes for you is over. I'm not gonna put this against you, because it' your first game, but in any other case, this would make it VERY easy for one of the others to convince me of your quiltyness.

[Leelou]

After going through everything again, I want to say Naeann only because in the beginging when Talya  was still alive she was gunning for Vemynal and she was in actuallity bloodhound gang and she had nothing against Calyn.

 

Difficult to actually pick out who is guilty, as some patterns look the same. But at the top of my list at the moment are Boyd, Vemy, LeeLou and maybe Twicthy...I don't trust the vote jumping.

 

Those close behing Thea, Jackdaw, Safir

And the reason Thorum wasn't mentioned is because he didn't fully join the game yet, so on that Talya was suspecting everyone else who was still alive to be guily except herself, Calya and Thorum.

[Vemynal]

Good setup for someone to use when he himself is the evil..... doent work when your theory goes up in smoke because your number 2 choice for an evil is an innocent.  I know because I had the same theory with Vemy and Twitchy

 

Oh irony

 

Nae, me and you think too alike I think XD

 

I still don't know who to vote for. i at least have some suspicions of nae still. But obviously with this being our last day we shouldn't just vote off the bat.

[Naeann]

Ahh Thorum im not voting for you because you voted for me just as I said yesterday with Twich and Vem..... I gave you  a reason if youd care to pay attenion..... You said yesterday you thought I was innocent and now your voting for me though yesterday you also said LETS GO FOR VEM.

 

I'm not gonna go back and look for the countless times Vemy said he thought Twitch was evil.... If you had paid attention you would have seen it.  If you and LeeLou want to believe Vem all of a sudden when thus far most thought him evil then by all means go for it.

 

You will end the game and evil will win.

 

 

Vemy you may say lets not vote off the bat but Thorum and Leelou already have.  Leelou without hardly posting AT ALL to throw suspiciions off of her but she can come right out of the woordworks in time to accuse others.  ::)  and your picking me AT THE END for something you were suspicious of at the beginning. lol

[Leelou]

I have not voted yet.

[Twitchy]

Gaahh!

*Blows imaginary brains out because he can't say anything*

:-P

Just get him/her.

:D

 

[Naeann]

Aww Poor Twitch!

 

Least one person knows its not me....  :P

 

Say theres 4 innocents and two murderers. Which is the most likely.  You pick me and I'm innocent your game is over.  Boyd has been quiet, Safir can't come on much, Leelou doesn't come on much either.  Kinda hard to determine what you are if you don't play past voting someone else.  That leaves Vemy, Thorum and I as active participants.  Two of which are going after me.  Either two murders trying to get everyone to lynch me so that's one less they have to worry about killing/ getting me lynched instead of them.... or a murder manipuating the innocents into looking away from him at me by giving half-@rsed logic that also fits for Him. 

[Safir]

Things are getting really complicated now!  We all know that we need to get an evil this time, no screw ups!

 

I just don't know what to do...

[Vemynal]

Nae, you misunderstand.

 

I'm not trying to to accuse you atm, I'm just saying your still the only person whose on my radar atm. I'm being patient and rereading the thread a couple of times.

 

If others voted for you I don't know whether i'd vote for you. Honestly I'd like to look at everyone and compare.

 

I *STILL* don't freaking have anything on thorum or safir. I know I'm innocent. and Nae I've already "cased" you so while your on my radar I'm not actually looking at you.

 

Right now I'm studying sboyd but can't find anything. He's made 1 right decision off the bat and that was to lynch talya. If her and him set that up in the beginning to make him seem totally innocent then it worked cuz I just don't see it.

 

leelou I haven't looked at yet since I'm still studying sboyd's posts. But if you assume sboyd's innocent. then leelou looks suspicious for voting for him and opposing him this whole time. But if he's evil then she could be the saint whose seen through the issues at hand.

 

leelou, I know I'm askin you this so I *CAN* (and will) case you, but know that I'm walking into it with a blank opinion. I'd just appreciate it if you could explain your posts a little for us.

[Leelou]

I don't really assume he is innocent, I just am at a bit of a loss because his day one suggestion to lynch the other regular player ended up being true that she was Bloodhound gang. That was just a little too convienient. I'm not really saying that I am voting for anyone just yet, I'm trying to re read the posts and I found the quote I picked out from Talya on day 2 about Calyn and herself not being on  her "guilty" or "semi-guilty" lists. So I'm at the point where I'm reviewing everything that has been posted and trying to make a decision. Don't know if that helps you any.

[Vemynal]

Yeah, but if you explain your posts then i will know better whether your the evil trying to kill sboyd or the genius whose figured out the murderer's plans.

 

Sboyd, if you could give a similar review of yourself it would help as well. Some of your methods are over my head

[Leelou]

Ok from the start of SBoydW accusing Talya right off sounded really fishy to me on the first day when we really haven't said much. And I posted:

 

Posted: Sat Jun 23, 2007 9:31 pm

 

I think out of the regulars SBoydW would be the more guilty one because he accused Talya right away. But I don't think I'm going to vote for either of the regulars today.

 

I also randomly voted that day that everyone ended up bandwagoning on. I know that doesn't really look good for me.

 

Then Toy was killed, who spoke out against Boyd the first day. So I posted:

 

Posted: Thu Jun 28, 2007 4:51 pm

 

I still think out of the regulars that Boyd would be the evil one. He was first to point a finger at Talya to get us newbies thinking that a regular is on the evil side. And the kill of Toy was very quick, trying to throw us in two directions. He was against Boyd in the begining and Toy being killed makes us think that Boyd was taking out someone against him, but then it also makes Boyd look innocent because it wouldn't be a smart move to kill off your known enemy so quickly.

 

On friday I voted for him because I still felt the same. But as I said in my above quote Toy's death went two ways, either a set up for Boyd or it made him look completely innocent. When we found out Talya was Bloodhound gang, it kinda makes look Boyd more innocent. But as I said it's all fishy for his assumption on the first day. Boyd was on the top of Talya's list from my earlier quote. But she didn't vote or gun for him. In the same quote that had Boyd at the top of her list:.

 

A few things for - -Boyd I wasn't upset that you had said that, but if I didn't say it then you could possible be dead (if you're innocent) and I would have been accused, as it is now I'm accused of killing Toy to set you up...good way to make yourself look innocent I would say.

 

She went for Vemynal. And she was bloodhound gang. It kinda looks like she took the blame for it all and that her partner was left free. But Calyn was not mentioned in Talya's list. (this goes for my post today) Which could make it seem like Naeann could be part of the Bloodhound Gang. Also Calyn did not vote for Talya but first for someone who is now a known innocent: Jackdaw. So these are the reasonings behind my posts.

 

edit: messed up so everything ended up being a quote. Now fixed

 

[Vemynal]

What about your reason for voting for jackdaw?

 

And thank you, this is helping clear matters up I think

[Leelou]

I have given reasoning for everyone I voted for. Jackdaw was making comments that made him seem guilty at the time. I made a wrong vote, but with Boyd being right about Talya I wasn't really sure who to vote for.

[Leelou]

Now can you please explain yourself for all of your reasonings?

[Safir]

Basically, the reason for my actions is that, I don't know what to do.  I guess this game isn't really for me, cause I really don't know who to vote for.  The only thing I have to go by is jackdaw's accusations of Vem, but I don't know if it's true or what...

 

Seriously, I'm lost.

[Vemynal]

great, so I've finished reading through Sboyd's posts (though sboyd if you'd mind clearing up some of your reasons for voting that would help me)

 

And the reason leelou looked suspicious was because she hadn't explained anything. Now that she has i can understand her votes.

 

& like I said before I don't have enough to be going on for sure w/ Nae so I don't wanna vote her till I've seen every angle

 

So Safir, Thorum, I'm gonna be looking into you guys, plz clarify matters if I bring any up

 

(was writing this while leelou posted, then safir posted while I wrote the second bit and found my previous post)

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

Do you mean all my reasonings for just day 3 or for this whole thread? I don't have time for the whole game atm cuz, well honestly I shouldn't even be online right now, i should be reading a book for an essay due tomorrow.

 

for day 3 I already explained my reasons on day 2 and i stuck to my guns this whole time up till we found out twitchy was innocent.

 

My reasons can be seen here in my big "review" post. You can skip the first half which is the actual review (read talya, twitchy, and Calyn though to help with my accusations) and then my accusations of talya, twitchy and calyn.

 

its my second post here: http://dragonmount.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=17165&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=210

[Thorum]

reply|@safir: ain't we all lost?

[Safir]

I suppose, but this is my very first game and I really don't know what to do.

 

Everythings so complicated.  How do you know if someones lying?

[Safir]

Okay everyone, it is time.  I don't have any other choice but to reveal.

 

I am the Sherif.

 

Night 1 I investigated Vemynal and found him Guilty.

Night 2 I investigated SBoydW and found him Innocent.

Night 3 I Investigated Twitchy and found him Innocent. (but that didn't help much did it?)

 

If there are 2 more evils, then, Healer, could you please protect me tonight?

[Safir]

and with that:  [glow=red,2,300]Vote: Vemynal[/glow]