Sign in to follow this  
Mashiara Sedai

DM News:Fantasy Review: The Stone Sky

Recommended Posts

This “Fantasy Review” is for The Stone Sky, the third and final book in The Broken Earth series, by N.K. Jemisin.



Essun is still determined to find her daughter, Nessun.  The comm of Castrima Under—where Essun currently dwells—has been damaged by their war with Rennaris.  The people must find a new place to ride out the Fifth Season.  Due to Essun’s annihilation of the Rennarin people, the comm decides to travel the far distance to the now-abandoned city.  Essun’s still plans to grab the moon when its orbit circles close, but there is still time before she must leave her place within the com.


Nessun, meanwhile, begins her trek to the other side of the world, with Shaffa and the Stone Eater, Steel, as companions.  Steel can transport them through the earth, but Nassun fears the Stone Eater may “accidently” lose Shaffa on the journey.  This means a longer way is necessary, going to an ancient station capable of taking them through the earth’s core.  But at the earth’s center is something far more frightening than Steel’s mode of transportation.


Mixed in with these two accounts is a flashback into Hoa’s past, where the events that lead to the war with Father Earth are finally revealed.



I loved the addition of Hoa’s storyline.  It was terrible seeing the beginning of orogenes and the atrocities the ancient society did in order to maintain peace and balance.  The choices Hoa and his kind made are understandable, and parallel the conflict within Essun and Nassun.  Essun wishes to save the earth by grabbing the moon.  Nassun, based on Shaffa’s pessimistic—or maybe weary—view of the world, wishes for it, and Father Earth, to die.


I was also pleasantly pleased by the actual ending, the last chapter.  SPOILER: I thought the perfect match for Essun was Innon and Alabaster; the three of them together made a wonderful family.  However, seeing her paired with Hoa was heartwarming.  Essun’s life was so horrible and filled with so much tragedy, it was uplifting to see she wound up with a happy ending.



Once we got the reunion between mother and daughter, the character motivations were understandable, but rather annoying.  The reader has the benefit of seeing the character’s thoughts, so I was frustrated when the two were unable to communicate their desires to the other.  Like I said, understandable considering all that had happened between them, but at the same time, I wanted to shake them both and make them talk it out!  Alas, too much had transpired, too much harm had been done—to both of them.  


This was a fantastic final.  Satisfying and rather hopeful for a brighter future.  I’d been doubting whether this would have a happy ending or not.  And it surprisingly does.  Or maybe—to coin a phrase from the romance genre—a Happy For Now.


I loved everything about this series, the characters, the world, the magic.  It was emotional the whole way through, tugging on my heartstrings over and over and over.  I was very sad when it ended.  I could read so much more in this world.  Perhaps Jemisin will revisit the world a thousand years in the future—like Brandon Sanderson’s ideas for Mistborn.



4 out of 5


For more from N. K. Jemisin, you can check out her website.

View full news item

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Posts

    •   Not gender constricted, no. Anyone can be a Warder or Aes Sedai or Asha'man or Wise One. Usually you're restricted to the path you can follow within a subgroup, though. For instance at the White Tower and Warders you can either choose the Aes Sedai path or the Warder path - you can't be both. You can be an Aes Sedai or Warder at the WT&W AND you can be a member of the Black Tower, though.
    • I'm more curious about the Trump administrations actions (and inactions) on two fronts:   1.) Why are we actively tanking the Turkish currency to free a single prisioner? I understand "doing everything possible" to secure the release of Americans held abroad, but shouldn't the responses be proportional?    2.) Why are we silent on Canada vs. Saudi? Seems like it should be a slam-dunk "We stand for international human rights and expect that our allies do the same."
    • In what way is "Socialist" equatable to Nazi/Klansmen?   As for Omarosa, I find it funny how much of a "great person" she was when she was working for Trump. When people are working for him, on his side, he loves them. Heaps praise and good words on them. Yet the moment they are no longer together suddenly they are "despicable" and "liars". If he knew they were those kind of people already, why hire them in the first place?    Pretty clear he has no actually basis for any of this and just hardline supports/attacks anyone who disagrees with him.   Also, putting one person in a position of moderate power 40 years after the fact does not make previous actions any less racist.
    • "6.) There are now 5 former klansmen/Nazis running on the republican ticket in the fall"   And how many "Socialists" are running in the democratic ticket in primaries and in the fall?     "5.) said that murders/domestic terrorists/ethno-nationalists were “fine people”   No he did not he said that their were fine people on both sides of the Charlottsvile protests. You can be a fine person and be misled into rallying with despicable people (happens all the time on the left when regular left leaning people come out at the same events as ANTIFA).    As for the rest of the things on your list, they are all things that were known before the election and did not stop Trump's election. More importantly, they were all things that Omaraosa knew about long before she took a job in the White House or in Trump's businesses for that matter. Thus her actually believing that he is a racist is more then a little bit suspenct.   Also, you do not rent to black people becuase you are a racist but you repeatedly hire and put into positions of power and influence a black woman? Seems to me that the latter indicates that his previous actions should be attributed to something other then Trump being a racist.