Sailor Moon Mafia [Advanced] Game Thread

[Clovdyx]

 

Cuth. If you're only a 1xdoc, why didn't you protect her n1?

because i didn't think she was going to be shot n1 and i felt like holding it off until it'd make a bigger difference

This is a correct answer imo

[bopolis]

i also think 2 vigs are supremely unlikely.

 

I also think a doctor would have been unlikely too but one of those things at least is real.

 

I also think vigging your mafia bro in the night is pretty ludicrous.

 

 

so color me confused

[Eldrick4221]

 

Cuth. If you're only a 1xdoc, why didn't you protect her n1?

because i didn't think she was going to be shot n1 and i felt like holding it off until it'd make a bigger difference

Thank you for responding. Discussion already cleared that point for me :P

[MrsClov]

 

wrt fred;

 

i kinda think hes just a villager, but im not confident enough to dig my heels in and lynch someone over him based on actions taken via alleged role claims and votes/pushes people have made.

 

best way i know how to explain it

Fred has read as town to me pretty much throughout. But is his chhance to be town less than the chance Eldrick shot a teammate or gambled on the 1x thing? Probably.

 

Given the weird bussing thing in Old West Mafia, I'm not really convinced Eldrick wouldn't go rogue. 

[Eldrick4221]

Bussing and shooting a teammate are very different things.

 

Yes, I'll bus. Not denying that.

 

But I would never shoot a teammate.

[Clovdyx]

i also think 2 vigs are supremely unlikely.

 

I also think a doctor would have been unlikely too but one of those things at least is real.

 

I also think vigging your mafia bro in the night is pretty ludicrous.

 

 

so color me confused

The more I think about, the less I believe your three claims. As a collective whole, I mean.

 

You are by the most believable.

 

Cuths rationale makes sense, but I could imagine a world where he throws up that hail mary. If hes the last scum, he has to assume he has one, maybe two, mislynches left. The holster puts him above a couple.

 

Eldricks in the least inherently believable, but the circumstances make it look better. I refuse to accept a team of eldrick, iron, and fleeing thought burninga rare mafia vig shot in one of their own was viable. If that's what really happened - congratulations. You guys outstupided me.

 

Based on that, the only thing thay I can see is he's being honest or got lucky as the SK.

[csarmi]

I'll fetch you guys an updated players list post cause I understand that's my mod responsability. Incoming.

[Clovdyx]

And if he's the sk, he's removed his ability to kill. We lynch another mafia, and he has to try to argue theirs four scum or holster. Holstering doesn't keep him above the POE line.

[Eldrick4221]

 

i also think 2 vigs are supremely unlikely.

 

I also think a doctor would have been unlikely too but one of those things at least is real.

 

I also think vigging your mafia bro in the night is pretty ludicrous.

 

 

so color me confused

The more I think about, the less I believe your three claims. As a collective whole, I mean.

 

You are by the most believable.

 

Cuths rationale makes sense, but I could imagine a world where he throws up that hail mary. If hes the last scum, he has to assume he has one, maybe two, mislynches left. The holster puts him above a couple.

 

Eldricks in the least inherently believable, but the circumstances make it look better. I refuse to accept a team of eldrick, iron, and fleeing thought burninga rare mafia vig shot in one of their own was viable. If that's what really happened - congratulations. You guys outstupided me.

 

Based on that, the only thing thay I can see is he's being honest or got lucky as the SK.

The collective pr's as a whole is exactly why I think cuth is actually a full doc.

[csarmi]

Updated Mod Thing

 

01. Cory/Clov - THE BEAUTIFUL CORDYX

02. Sooh Dar'Jen Ab Owain

03. Eldrick

04. mmmmmSpades (SpadesZee + bopolis)

05. Celeste (PENNEHHHH) Zander

06. Cuthalion

07.Linz aka Mrs.Clov

08. Derf  - Town Cop - Killed N1

09. Ted Bundy Fredwood

10. Ironeyes aka Marsh - Mafia Goon - Lynched D2

11. Aquilla Fleeing Coward - Mafia Goon - Killed N1

12. Scruffington - Sailor Jupiter - Vanilla Town - Lynched D1

 

---

 

It is now day three two. Deadline is Wednesday, July 19th at 11:30pm PST.

 

---

 

I totally don't remember the vote count. It's probably just THUMBLEWEED though. 8 alive, 5 to lynch

[Clovdyx]

Idk. At this point, there's really no lynch I feel happy about. I guess I go Fred over Eldrick, Eldrick over Cuth.

 

I'll probably change that in an hour

[csarmi]

And now I get to sing us a song, a song to keep us warm cause there is such a chill, such a chill...

[Clovdyx]

 

 

i also think 2 vigs are supremely unlikely.

 

I also think a doctor would have been unlikely too but one of those things at least is real.

 

I also think vigging your mafia bro in the night is pretty ludicrous.

 

 

so color me confused

The more I think about, the less I believe your three claims. As a collective whole, I mean.

 

You are by the most believable.

 

Cuths rationale makes sense, but I could imagine a world where he throws up that hail mary. If hes the last scum, he has to assume he has one, maybe two, mislynches left. The holster puts him above a couple.

 

Eldricks in the least inherently believable, but the circumstances make it look better. I refuse to accept a team of eldrick, iron, and fleeing thought burninga rare mafia vig shot in one of their own was viable. If that's what really happened - congratulations. You guys outstupided me.

 

Based on that, the only thing thay I can see is he's being honest or got lucky as the SK.

The collective pr's as a whole is exactly why I think cuth is actually a full doc.

This makes even less sense to me.

[Eldrick4221]

And if he's the sk, he's removed his ability to kill. We lynch another mafia, and he has to try to argue theirs four scum or holster. Holstering doesn't keep him above the POE line.

In no way would there be 4 mafia if I was an sk. That's almost half the game being non-town.

 

....

 

Oh. Ok. I see what you mean. If I was sk, if be pretending to be vig. Duh.

[Eldrick4221]

This makes even less sense to me.

Why?

[Cuth]

 

And if he's the sk, he's removed his ability to kill. We lynch another mafia, and he has to try to argue theirs four scum or holster. Holstering doesn't keep him above the POE line.

In no way would there be 4 mafia if I was an sk. That's almost half the game being non-town.

 

....

 

Oh. Ok. I see what you mean. If I was sk, if be pretending to be vig. Duh.

 

is

 

is reading this as +1=4 

 

a slip

 

i don't think it is, but

 

still a bit weird

 

happy birthday by the by

[Eldrick4221]

Full doc makes up for the potential of 2 extra kills.

 

We lucked out that neither of us hit town, but doc being able to protect from kills the whole game balances it out.

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

And if he's the sk, he's removed his ability to kill. We lynch another mafia, and he has to try to argue theirs four scum or holster. Holstering doesn't keep him above the POE line.

In no way would there be 4 mafia if I was an sk. That's almost half the game being non-town.

 

....

 

Oh. Ok. I see what you mean. If I was sk, if be pretending to be vig. Duh.

is

 

is reading this as +1=4

 

a slip

 

i don't think it is, but

 

still a bit weird

 

happy birthday by the by

I'm assuming it's 3. Will continue to do so until a scum flip doesn't end the game.

[Eldrick4221]

And thank you :)

[bopolis]

Full doc makes up for the potential of 2 extra kills.

 

We lucked out that neither of us hit town, but doc being able to protect from kills the whole game balances it out.

 

i dont think it works like that

[Cuth]

 

 

 

And if he's the sk, he's removed his ability to kill. We lynch another mafia, and he has to try to argue theirs four scum or holster. Holstering doesn't keep him above the POE line.

In no way would there be 4 mafia if I was an sk. That's almost half the game being non-town.

 

....

 

Oh. Ok. I see what you mean. If I was sk, if be pretending to be vig. Duh.

is

 

is reading this as +1=4

 

a slip

 

i don't think it is, but

 

still a bit weird

 

happy birthday by the by

I'm assuming it's 3. Will continue to do so until a scum flip doesn't end the game.

 

yeah but

 

we've lynched two

 

so when someone says "we lynch another mafia"

 

i assume they mean we lynch one more mafia

 

which is why, like i said, it is

 

interesting

 

that you assumed he meant a total of four mafia at first, seeing as we've only flipped two

[Eldrick4221]

Yeah. His scenario is that 3rd mafia flips, game continues, and I'd have to argue that there's 4 mafia.

 

And I'm arguing that if I was sk, there being 4 mafia would be unbalanced.

[Eldrick4221]

"Another" being 3rd because I'd have to argue 4.

[Cuth]

Yeah. His scenario is that 3rd mafia flips, game continues, and I'd have to argue that there's 4 mafia.

 

And I'm arguing that if I was sk, there being 4 mafia would be unbalanced.

true

[Cuth]

[v]fredwood[/v]

 

all good