[Basic] Peg + Cat Mafia -- TOWN WIN

[Spadeszee]

What is the logical reason for Tigs to not nk Hallia?

[Eldrick4221]

 

%& it I'm not quoting

Tigs' hammer on Darthe could be a bus vote. Her reason for voting him was that I was active.

When she went over all of us, her description on Darthe was that she didn't understand why people were reading him as town. But she listed her too scum as ed and me.

The point in her favor is the same one tress has. That she was aware of hally being seer. She unvoted lzm because of it.

If you're going to fight this take your vote off yourself, for goodness sake!

And put it where?

 

I'm the one being lynched today. If someone else gets mislynched today, I'll be lynched tomorrow and lose it for town?

[Spadeszee]

If you can give me logic for that, I would consider Tigs. I don't recall Cass or dice scum reading her or them being an actual threat to her but I could be wrong. I'm in bed ATM so I'm not about to iso.

[Eldrick4221]

What is the logical reason for Tigs to not nk Hallia?

The things that Adella mentioned. The same reasons it would be logical for Tress.

 

If we wanted to base our decision on Hally living, Shanti is the obvious choice. Everyone else was aware she had claimed.

[Spadeszee]

It's you or Tigs imo, order is only that I have been wolf reading you all game. Both of you are head to head right now.

[Eldrick4221]

[unvote]

[V]Shanti[/v]

 

I really hope I'm right.

[Eldrick4221]

If you can give me logic for that, I would consider Tigs. I don't recall Cass or dice scum reading her or them being an actual threat to her but I could be wrong. I'm in bed ATM so I'm not about to iso.

sleep well :)

[Spadeszee]

 

What is the logical reason for Tigs to not nk Hallia?

The things that Adella mentioned. The same reasons it would be logical for Tress.

 

If we wanted to base our decision on Hally living, Shanti is the obvious choice. Everyone else was aware she had claimed.

Look, either you're setting up Tigs, or Tigs is mafia. This is how I view it.

[Eldrick4221]

It's you or Tigs imo, order is only that I have been wolf reading you all game. Both of you are head to head right now.

Curious. You lynch me and they kill tigs.

 

who would you vote tomorrow?

[Spadeszee]

Just unvote, let Shanti speak, let Tress read this and let Tigs respond.

[Spadeszee]

 

It's you or Tigs imo, order is only that I have been wolf reading you all game. Both of you are head to head right now.

Curious. You lynch me and they kill tigs.

 

who would you vote tomorrow?

Shanti

[Eldrick4221]

Why do I need to unvote for that?

 

My vote is based on the fact that she's the most likely culprit of killing cass/dice over hally

[Spadeszee]

Your vote is on yourself. I don't want a hammer until everyone has had a chance to read.

[Eldrick4221]

Also wanna say right now, kudos to whoever the last scum is. You have played a great game.

[Eldrick4221]

Your vote is on yourself. I don't want a hammer until everyone has had a chance to read.

I already moved to shanti

[Eldrick4221]

Literally 10 posts ago. Scroll up lol

[Spadeszee]

 

Your vote is on yourself. I don't want a hammer until everyone has had a chance to read.

I already moved to shanti

I must have seriously missed that somehow.

[Eldrick4221]

Or, you know, get some sleep

[Spadeszee]

How can people play this on just mobile? My goodness.

[Eldrick4221]

How can people play this on just mobile? My goodness.

I know those feels :(

[Spadeszee]

Or, you know, get some sleep

How can you sleep with this chaos? This is also why I didn't just hammer you. I'm not trying to throw, I want to hear everyone's voice.

[Spadeszee]

It's light outside now, though, so I should try. Going to go over this with my mentor and see if I missed anything.

[Eldrick4221]

Night spades. Sleep well.

[Shad_]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

 

Eldrick (1) - Tigraine

 

Shanti (1) - Eldrick

 

Not Voting: Songstress, Spadeszee, Shanti

 

 

With 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.

 

[Tigraine]

I may be new to this play style but I'm very familiar with the strategy of the game. The chain of events leading up to now make zero sense if I'm scum.

 

Someone brought up my correcting Eldrick at the beginning of the game on his n0 peek. And Darthe claiming me as his n0 peek. The remark on Darthe was clearly meant as a joke, the fact that I was right should prove it as a joke and idk why he claimed me as his n0 peek.

 

I wasn't very active D1 and I'm sorry for that but let's go on to D2. I very obviously had a different option instead of hammering Darthe. I couldve hammered Eldrick and would've been justified in doing so because I feel I have a very good case worked up against him. Obviously others thought he was scummy becauae he was at L-1. I could've even let it go to random as LZM suggested but I chose to hammer Darthe becauae at that point, I liked what I was seeing from Eld and knew that he had been at least putting in effort and keeping people on their toes. I had no reason to keep Eldrick if I'm scum. Moving onto the N2 NK, why would I not go after the claimed seer? I had made my doubt and opposition to her pretty strongly that day and had no reason to believe I wouldn't be a possible peek for her. And if I wanted to get rid of eldrick after whatever reason I didn't hammer him, why wouldn't I just NK him?

 

I believe Ed was our Day 3 Lynch and iirc that went pretty quickly and I could've probably stayed out of that to avoid being on a train I knew was a townie. Everyone else seemed pretty sure he was scum as was I. During that phase it was questioned why Hallia was still alive, people talked about her claim and she was killed that night.

 

I can see as scum going after Adella, because her lack of attention would've made it easy to paint her as the one that wouldn't have killed Hallia becauae she missed the claim. But why LZM? I know he's confirmed town but Spades is by far the most active out of them and I've not been too high on her towns list besides.

 

The problem with all of this is I can work up a pretty good case on everyone still living as to why they would've made the steps they've made but I can also show just as much opposition as to why it doesn't make sense.

 

Even with Shanti being new, I can't figure out why she would leave the claimed seer. Being new doesn't make you oblivious. The fact that I find her SO town keeps giving me pause but how do you work a case on someone for seeming too townie?

 

I can't say that I'm okay with the whole, let's lunch Eld and of he flips town let's Lynch tigs because I KNOW I'm town. You guys don't but in that scenario we still lose.

 

I'm getting ready to leave and won't be back on for a while. Im leaving my vote where it is because Eld is my strongest scum read. That's what I've got atm.