[Advanced] Fight Club Mafia! - Game Thread!

[seph]

I never check the game lol me. Robin was off and I spaced it until the middle of night phase which I spent reading for the most part.

 

I have to say that the thread hs been pretty amusing.

[BFG]

Need to go to work :( looking forward to your thoughts, if I'm not mapping I'll be sort of around to chat

[BFG]

Also spam

[BFG]

To get

[BFG]

Off this

[BFG]

Page before

[BFG]

Any more

[BFG]

Quoting...

[BFG]

Sigh...

[BFG]

Sigh

[BFG]

And... Go :)

[seph]

Well I apparently am the only one who had an issue with the fight lol.

Can whoever asked about no lynch own up to it?

 

The other thing off the top was I didn't vote dpr for his joke vote. I understand I asked him a question in the same sentence lol but cmon I literally stated after that why I was voting him. Though at the time of the vote I was really only voting two very inactive players because at the time I felt good about a few people.

 

I saw people question my vote as to trying to throw sys on me. What worries me is why not question the vote when it happened? The vote had no meaning besides to see how he reacted, I simply voted him for no reason after.he laid down two randomish votes.

 

I'll try to quote things as I get to them and really read from fight night, but I have no problem thunderdoming someone :)

[seph]

Phone typing... the bottom vote was about ed

[BFG]

 

Not enough discussion imo, but I feel good about dice, Ed, Darth and bfg to some extent. [unvote] ed.

I know it's only 9 pages and I forgot how long the day phase is while typing this but [v] crusher[/v] I had some problems with his intro

Was a easy post on a holiday and bounces. We will see but I definitely want a interactive crusher!

[V]dpr [/v] dpr was you post where you voted wildfire a serious one? I read two people viewing it differently.

  

 

Not enough discussion imo, but I feel good about dice, Ed, Darth and bfg to some extent. [unvote] ed.

I know it's only 9 pages and I forgot how long the day phase is while typing this but [v] crusher[/v] I had some problems with his intro

Was a easy post on a holiday and bounces. We will see but I definitely want a interactive crusher!

[V]dpr [/v] dpr was you post where you voted wildfire a serious one? I read two people viewing it differently.

 

 

 

The one where my vote is based on the color of Eeyore? Are you really asking this?

  

Yes cause it looked like Darthe took it more serious than everyone else.

  

 

Yes cause it looked like Darthe took it more serious than everyone else.

 

I assumed it was a joke vote back and nothing serious based on the 3p comment. Wasn't DPR just 3p in a game?

  

I assumed it was as well, I'm sure Darthes comment just went over my head then lol.

  

 

Yes cause it looked like Darthe took it more serious than everyone else.

 

 

Players that listen to Darthe and admit to it...

 

Like I said - trippy 80's movie. 

 

 

Yes cause it looked like Darthe took it more serious than everyone else.

 

I assumed it was a joke vote back and nothing serious based on the 3p comment. Wasn't DPR just 3p in a game?

 

That and it was my first post. On D1. About Eeyore.

 

 

Scrolled a few more pages and didn't see anything else

 

So, can you explain your vote(s) any more?

 

I know you later said they weren't based on much?

[seph]

Is there any questions you have in particular here?

I state my reason for voting crusher, which wasnt really much. And a random vote of dpr. I don't remember if this was after dprs vote but it bugged me and he came into the game three different times and posted 1 thing each time.

[BFG]

That's it I think

[seph]

 

Vote Darthe & Sooh

 

Darthe because he hit & run, Sooh because she's trying too hard to push her points on D1.

This feels extremely random to me at the moment. You really don't have any thought progression in the thread, unless there is something I have not gotten to.

Im not going to lie I feel extremely good about sooh, bfg, dice and wifi. The more I read the more I love them lol

 

This is for dpr as is part of my actual case on him. I get tired of him spinning crap to try and fit his narritive. He seems to do this as any alignment though...

 

 

 

 

Talk to me about dpr cuth. Why do you have him as town?

mmmmostly because who's voting him and who he's voting :P

This makes 0 sense from a town perspective on day 1 where we are making our own info and nothing concrete.

Please expand a bit on this for me to understand.

Dr voted Darth because he hasn't came back into the thread and has made 0 posts or progression there. How besides he is voting your suspect is that townie?

Your then adding him to town for being voted by your suspect who you have 0 knowledge about.

Cuth this doesn't make sense???

[unvote crusher]

[V] cuth [/v]

  

I still stand by this and I am more confused about this with posts he makes later. If they are not in this multi, I will post them after as my phone gets confusing.

 

 

1. I updated my list while reading

2.scum will always try and do so, but I'm viewing dpr as having trouble posting in the thread. Not just lack of game solve.

3. You are right it's not a viable scum tell. But that with his random votes with lackluster reasons. Which the tone doesn't seem natural on bug the cap out of me and I won't get over it.

Town player who isn't going to help is going to be lynched eventually regardless. I'm this game I have 0 idea if he is scum but he is by fr no where near my town list and deserves to be the lynch over sooh/WiFi some people are votinf

 

coughcoughdarthe

  

 

OK good I did have at least 1 in here. So he apparently is voting darthe and town reading dpr for the same thing, he isn't denying dpr as doing this but just says but yea darthe is doing it as well. I'm not sure how this works cuth, and yes I know there is more to your darthe case than just that, but your using something to vote 1 person your town reading another for. In light darthe d1 wasn't as bad as dpr's besides his eod probably

 

hm

 

in a game like this the scums are not going to hang off the top wagons

 

they're going to be on ones like ours and maybe Tress if they can get away with it

 

por eso and for other reasons we get down to, like

 

darthe/sooh/seph 

 

that's my revised scum poe, though i'd definitely lynch seph over sooh

 

seph... was blatantly towny last game, i thought

 

this game he comes in, just blanket townreads half of the game without ever saying why, and then is inconsistent in talking about who his suspects are and why

 

he has pretty high equity at this point

 

 

In light of soohs death this post intrigues me. And actually fits more into his scum game.

 

 

oh and yeah i'm not 100% on Darthe obviously, though i still think there's a very good chance there

 

have been purposefully exaggerating

 

oh right seph was also pushing the dpr/me agenda ever since he got back

 

which while it could be town there's also the problematic bit that he's pushing two towns (assuming DPR is, which i'm pretty convinced of)

So he isn't near 100% on his darthe read but is now in turn reading me/sooh/dpr based on his darthe read. I don't understand how town comes at a game like this. The other issue I have is during the fight he likes that dpr and him are on the same train of thought, however all dpr is doing is literally sheeping cuth, and has maybe came up with maybe 1 originally idea on darthe.

 

I would agree with cuth if it was like wild west where me and him were both in the thread posting in unison with the same ideas, but like I said it just seeping and I think cuth looks worse here for it.

[V]cuth [/v]

 

[V]darthe [/v] for now

[seph]

Also it might just be a coincidence. But that noynch seemed like good timing lol.

 

My 1st read I thought that they both could have been town, or they both could be mafia, and it was just really well orchistrated.

But re reading and seeing the discrepancy with cuts play I'm just extremely bothered with it

That idea

[Clovdyx]

Vote count!

 

Darthe - 3 - Cuth, DreadPirateRoberts, Seph

Seph - 4 - Cuth, DreadPirateRoberts, Ed2funy, BFG

Songstress - 1 - Ed2funy

Cuth - 1 - Seph

 

Day Two nomination phase ends at 11pm Eastern. Thats roughly 16 hours.

 

I'm on my phone, so apologies for format (but not really ).

[BFG]

Seph, why Darthe?

[seph]

he is the lower end of my list and isn't really playing, besides that there has been a dec amount of discussion revolving around him. if im goiing to have 2 people fight him and cuth will provide the most info. tbh i wouldn't mind fighting cuth either though.

im not sure if any other fights make sense? maybe iron/cuth iron i believe said he thought cuth was towny after the fiight, and not much about dpr i remember if anything. and was voting cuth when the phase ended. i think it looks bad regardless, but more so if cuth is town.

[seph]

darthe/dpr wouldn't be bad. but i have dpr a little higher than yesterday, if only slighty.
bfg didnt you town read crush for somehting? if you did can you tell me why because i dont remember any of his posts.

 

• Members
• 6,755 posts

• Gender:Male

Posted 16 March 2017 - 08:42 PM

Player Roster!

 

1. BFG <3

2. Darthe
3. Sooh - ???, killed N1
4. Ironeyes
5. Cuth
6. Seph
7. Songstress
8. Wildfire Sedai

9. Crusher

10. DreadPirateRoberts

11. Dicetosser1

12. Hallia

13, Ed2fun

[seph]

err that didnt work.
darthe
iron
cuth
tress
crush
hallia
possibly dpr

[seph]

 

[v]DPR and Tress[/v]

 

 

Okay, it was 3 posts later - out of the blue - and after she was discussing other people.

 

***

 

I'm running out of time to case more. Her posts stay non-commital and support Darther and Seph while voting for me.

 

Seph is just as bad, if not worse. Go back and re-read his jumps in logic and watch him try to grill Cuth to well-done and then accuse him of tunneling. He'll also go on to crit me for not "game solving" while he votes with no real cases and actually prevents others from offering their view. It's precious.

 

Gotta run. Should be back before 5.

 

ok i did like a few of dpr's posts about darthe, more than i remember but lol @ this one.. 

 

bold never happened.

 

my case on you wasn't the best and was more opinion orientated but i stand by it and would have still voted you d1 over anyone else.

 

please tell how i prevented people from forming reads in any way. roflmao

[seph]

 

 

hm

 

in a game like this the scums are not going to hang off the top wagons

 

they're going to be on ones like ours and maybe Tress if they can get away with it

 

por eso and for other reasons we get down to, like

 

darthe/sooh/seph 

 

that's my revised scum poe, though i'd definitely lynch seph over sooh

 

seph... was blatantly towny last game, i thought

 

this game he comes in, just blanket townreads half of the game without ever saying why, and then is inconsistent in talking about who his suspects are and why

 

he has pretty high equity at this point

 

Can you show where Seph 'blanket town reads half the game'?

 

Disagree a fair amount on Sooh, possibly Seph although I want to see what he does now and want to know why he didn't vote last fight

 

oh and yeah i'm not 100% on Darthe obviously, though i still think there's a very good chance there

 

have been purposefully exaggerating

 

oh right seph was also pushing the dpr/me agenda ever since he got back

 

which while it could be town there's also the problematic bit that he's pushing two towns (assuming DPR is, which i'm pretty convinced of)

What agenda? Why are you so sure DPR is town?

 

1 blanket town reads iirc he comes into thread with like three or four, and by EoD is down to "only every lynch four" but was really inconsistent about who those four were, and whether he wanted to lynch them, and what his reads actually were at all

 

2 and voting dpr and myself without really looking at the other options in any visible way 

 

DPR is voted by and voted darthe and sooh

 

his reaction to the fight was towny

 

there's nothing scummy about his play

 

soo 1. I was tone reading dice and actually really liked his op post (described most of this in thread. I read ed based of his reaction to my vote and how damn towny his play was d1, sooh was a pretty easy read. she was poking , prodding asking the right questions and all around on her town game. (which dpr sussed her for i think lol) Bfg imo has been on her town meta and to a degree has had similar views as i have.

 

my town reads are pretty easy to understand if you followed the thread. where i am struggling which i stated is the nulls or people who did not post. which i felt dpr was the scummiest out of. both tress and hallia had 1 game related post i did not mind, and I didn't really get a read on darthe. the thing that obviously bugs me is how he came into this game and has continued and i feel perfectly fine voting for him this phase.

 

Last phase you and dpr act like i wanted you two all game. dpr was a hunch and I never got a reaction or even any interaction with him d1 so i wasn't going to change my read based off your town read of him. besides yourself cuth who actually engaged me about dpr??? anyone?  dpr says i asked about your case and tunneled you which is untrue.

 

I disagreed with how you are playing the game and do not see it in a towny light. I actually had a chance to interact with you and it seems like your voting me is more in reaction to my voting you. which you took clear advantage to try and paint me in a bad light. 

 

cuth at any point in the fight did you take the opportunity to solidify your dpr read, ask him any questions that might further your read?  no? why not?

its confusing because you only town read him d1 becuase of his darthe vote. which you state in the fight isn't 100% and if that is the case why would you not try and formulate a better read when you have a perfect opportunity.

 

In all honesty it looks like your town reading dpr because you know he is town. and your play fits right along this line. If I am wrong on you i think your sus on darthe could be correct, even if its not much to go on. but that why i want those 2 fighting