Both of them appear!

___TERI__S  _IP_ER  E___ES  ___E  BREAKERS

Letters guessed: A B E I K P R S T

0 notches

3 Ss, 1 K

___TER___S  __P_ER  E___ES  ___E  _REAKERS

Letters guessed: A E K P R S T

0 notches

Lots of Es and one P - I think I remembered all of them...

___TER____  __P_ER  E___E_  ___E  _REA_ER_

Letters guessed: A E P R T

0 notches

There's both an R and an A!

___T_R____  _____R  ______  ____  _R_A__R_

Letters guessed: A R T

0 notches

There is a T!

___T______  ______  ______  ____  ________

Letters guessed: T

0 notches

Okay, here's a new one - do your best everyone:

__________  ______  ______  ____  ________

The Executioner's word was guessed: HeavyHalfMoonBlade only gets 10 points!

LedZepman and EirikDaude participated: They each get 15/2 = 7 points - I assume we round down in Shayol Ghul

EirikDaude solved the puzzle: He gets another 15 points for a total of 22 points.

Ah, could it be "Sisters of Silence", possibly?

How about Is? Could there possibly be an I there?

Yeah, I am just having trouble with that last word. Probably some kind of lore I don't know well enough 😅

R next

Let's go for a T next

How about esses? Are there any esses in your words? Guessing on an S.

For HeavyHalfMoonBlade's game:

The Executioner's word was guessed: HeavyHalfMoonBlade only gets 10 points!

LedZepman and EirikDaude participated: They each get 15/2 = 7 points - I assume we round down in Shayol Ghul

LedZepMan solved the puzzle: He gets another 15 points for a total of 22 points.

For LedZepMan's game:

The Executioner's word was guessed: LedZepman only gets 10 points!

Dar'Jen Ab Owain, HeavyHalfMoonBlade and Delenn participated: They each get 15/3 = 5 points

HeavyHalfMoonBlade solved the puzzle: He gets another 15 points for a total of 20 points.

Gonna guess an A for your game, Heavy.

Let me try a T

The Executioner's word was guessed: Delenn only gets 10 points!

LilyElizabeth, HeavyHalfMoonBlade and EirikDaude participated: They each get 15/3 = 5 points

HeavyHalfMoonBlade solved the puzzle: He gets another 15 points for a total of 20 points.

I'll guess at an "E" for the new game, Heavy

P, please

I'll go for S next

V

Let's try a Y next >_>

I'll go for an A

Let's try an E, Delenn

The Executioner's word was guessed: Lily only gets 10 points!

Delenn, HeavyHalfMoonBlade and EirikDaude participated: They each get 15/3 = 5 points

Delenn solved the puzzle: She gets another 15 points for a total of 20 points.

If I may make a suggestion Great Mistress of the Dark. While it may make sense that the Executioner gets less points for making a puzzle in which the solution is not guessed, it may incentivise using hard to guess solutions which are also not very fun, e.g. __ => "OX". It may not be the best example, as once you have the vowel there are a limited number of words it can be, but I think you can understand my point. Just something to think about.

That last word puzzles me... Let's try an "O"

N!