I just woke up. Did we kill rand?

[v] Unvote [/v]

I retract.

 

I would switch him with infinti except I haven't liked what infiniti has said. Or maybe lessa except I don't fully understand what lessa is saying. So... Who would've thought that doing nothing is good for your health. Effort does not indicate alignment. So like ironeyes I will wait. Unless you think ironeyes is evil. Do you know something I don't?

I just cant recall him posting so the placing looked odd

 

Where would you put him?

I would switch him with infinti except I haven't liked what infiniti has said. Or maybe lessa except I don't fully understand what lessa is saying. So... Who would've thought that doing nothing is good for your health. Effort does not indicate alignment. So like ironeyes I will wait. Unless you think ironeyes is evil. Do you know something I don't?

I know you said it was a hunch, which is anything anyone has to go on D1, but was there anything else that made you feel that way? Or are you trying to get discussion going?

 

I have to agree with RandA about your claim LZM. I don't see what you'd gain from claiming as town but if you're scum, trying to get some town leans for "that's not something scum would do" would be beneficial. 

 

As I'm curious as to your thoughts [v]Vote SK[/v]

Is that a question for me? I am not entirely sure about it being for me.

Yes I voted for ben based on a justifiable hunch that I intentionally pushed hard. I wanted to see if someone would call me out or ask why not DJ as well. Or why isn't DJ just as guilty as ben. The hard push on people when the game starts It causes a loss of motivation as town when someone tunnels on you, scum would blow up or fake blow up in my opinion. Town might blow up more often town would just vote me back. Which is what I was waiting for from Ben, but scummier fish to fry. There was nothing else that made me feel that way. And discussion would happen either way I am not responsible for what others posts, but if I am indirectly involved I am more than happy to move things along. And I have not forgotten about Dj's what could be considered entry faux pas into the game. Randal seems almost to happy to move things along. Nyn and ben trying to be game solvey really looks good for them.

But let's put things in perspective. You haven't proffered any reads. Just a vote. Several things have happened and you have remained neutral. Like a rock. Someone in thread said a lot more significant posts have been made than in 10 pages. So...onto your post

 

ATM I think a lot of posts up to this point could be either town or scum trying to under/over play their responses to the situation. DJ's response to Nyn's random vote on her being overly critical, or over- analyzing as DJ puts it, and then her later responses to questioning could be town/scum.

 

SK going after Ben pretty hard for what he called a joke vote seems scummy to me. You called out one player when another had done something quite similar.

 

So Ben.... lets get serious here... it can't be all just fun and games....

 

You scum broseph? Cause you ain't fooling me again :P

 

It is hard to follow the intent in this post. Your rudimentary analysis of the situation isn't done here. You have listed 'possibilities', but have not given your reasoning on why which theory is most likely.

To be completely honest I am not sure to who you are talking to in your posts. I can't actually read your mind, so can we go through it step by step.

1. Which posts can be town or scum alternatively who can be town or scum based on their posts i.e. Whomst are you refering to at the beginning.

2. What about Dj's response to nyn is it town or scum? Which is more likely? and why.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I am still waiting for ironeyes and that other person I forget that players name. Effort does not indicate alignment. Infiniti tell me something that makes you town in poem form, or not y'know?

@Ben Do you think Randal is right that their is no benefit as town to claim therefore it follows that the person that claimed had nefarious intentions?

@infiniti Do you think town should lie? Just unfettered curiousity.

@everyone did you know that it is actually not appropriate to toast during yom kippur (I am watching the good wife).

Reads list:

Ben

Nyn

ironeyes

infiniti

lessa

Rand

Dj

lzm

I counter claim sammael.

@Randal i did not see any question I was to focused on ben.

@Lessa let me get on my laptop and answer you.

[v] unvote [/v]

[v] LZM [/v]

I'll post my reads on the other people so far.

worked up? This is nothing. You shouldnt worry too much. I'm more interested in what others say. Specifically the people who haven't posted. I was about to start talking at randal and eventually pull nyn into the discussion, but I'm just bored.

Sounds forced in what way? Or are you saying Ben wasn't trying to change the subject? Talk to me dood.

Actually only four people have said anything. So...

Lol trying to change the subject ben? That was painful. Someone needs to put you out of my misery.

SK is there more to it than him not voting DJ? You just came out of a game where you were Ben's scummate... are you seeing some similarities or just a hunch?

Him not voting Dj, it is a hunch, and I didn't like the emoji. Felt like fake news. Scum ben didn't vote day 1 for who he thought was scum. Ben this game made an rvs vote, but didnt vote for his scum read ahem non scum scum read. It gets convoluted when you follow the logic. :This person is kinda scum I think you are scum lol jk bro it's not catch scum o clock yet:

#lolwhat? #deservesavote #hashtag

 

@ben do you think my vote on you is fair?

At this early stage, I understand it. I see why you are voting for me, but I think you are missing part of the picture.

I'm grasping at straws, but my vote is understanable? If you say my cote is good I'm not moving it.

 

[v] Ben [/v] for death

Grasp your straw, then.

Do we go straight to petulance when you dont get your way?

(Pssst your facade is breaking).

@ben do you think my vote on you is fair?

[v] Ben [/v] for death

Hmmm that sounds like an apology or an excuse not a null read. "It's still to early to get a reasonable read". Is what jumps out at me. You had a read and then backtracked because of game time.

[v] Unvote [/v]

@Gentled ben a null read? I didnt see any null read from you. Where is it?

I didn't realize that everything was completely random in mafia, so in my first game, I assumed that I had been withheld from consideration as scum. I mean, why take a brand new player and make them scum? It seemed intuitively obvious that playing scum added an extra layer of stress to the game because you have to lie the whole time, and for a new player who is trying to figure it out, it seemed absurd to lay that additional condition on them, and so I stated that I was town and couldn't be mafia because it was my very first game, as it seemed obvious to me that the mod wouldn't make me a wolf right away, and they all piled on me for it and started accusing me of being a wolf, and being disingenuous, and all but insulting their intelligence for saying such a stupid thing, and I was really freaked out by it, because that seemed like the least-wolfy thing that I could have possibly said, so I understand. 

 

But I still think you're a wolf.

Wheres your vote?

[v] Gentled ben [/v]

[v] Ironeyes [/v]

I thought we were waiting for everyone to confirm.

/confirm

In