Just now, Verbal32 said:

Whoa, I thought this was slank mafia?  35 pages over the first weekend D1?  FML.

 

Can I get the cliff notes on D1 so far?  No way I'm poring over that many pages.

TLDR

Who are your Scummates?

Man I wish we could ISO.....

Like I had this nightmare last Night that the Wolf team had 5 players and it was Derf Cory Hallia Clov and AJ.....

Just now, Zander? said:

 

I think Hallia has been more Villagery then Dice fwiw.

 

Haven't seen any real Spicey Dicey posts....also him sussing Hallia without dropping a vore feels very unDicelike to me.

 

I feel there's very likely min a Wolf between them and Lee

That said if Dice is villa then my Hallia read gets wrecked.

3 hours ago, whiskey delta said:

Darthe - Great D1 so far but I sense he’s gotten to the point where he just needs a flip to progress. I think the way he has navigated the game goes beyond being right or wrong in his reads before any flips.

dicetosser1 - Dice coming in with against the grain reads tends to get my attention. He hasn’t voted Hallia yet but I do expect that’s where he wants to go. Burying his vote is not outside his wolf range but the lead up matters. I also liked his answer to Tripped’s question where he said Darthe would never be aligned with Hally. I have a pretty good idea why he answered that way which I take as a good sign.

Cory Caboose - shook the game up as one would expect. I want to say his suspicion is genuine because despite all the mention of Spirited Away I have wolfed against Cory numerous other times and lost so he has probably seen the most of my scum range out of anyone. pinging loose/lazy play makes sense with that one (and only) time I was lynched as scum D1. All that’s to say is the basis of the read is there. It stings a little because it’s shades of “you’re better than this” but I get it. How are you seeing Hallia/Dice currently? 

Clovdyx - same territory as Darthe. I don’t have anything really unique to say here. 

VooDooNut - has a mix of the same attitude from his first game with signs of growth you might expect in the second. I think the interactions with Darthe were largely beneficial and his last bigger post where he says he’s outclassed read genuine to me.

Leelou - Good tone in fluffy stage of game which made me throw out an early town read but like Tripped noted they are trending down a bit and light in content now that the water is deeper. The SD sus I could see either way

Verbal32 - nothing really to say until he joins in. Will probably be pissed there is 35+ pages to read lol

Hallia - it’s like a flip switched and I’m struggling not to scum read most of her posts now. I’ve seen this a similar scenario between dice and Hally play out and she flipped mafia. Something that gives me pause is I don’t think she’s said much about me at all which I think she’d try to do more as scum, but maybe it’s because Darthe has already occupied that space 😉 

TrippedOnReality - Tripped is really good. She seems to sense the dynamic between Hally/Dice brewing and I like how she interjected immediately to question both. I liked her leelou observation. I also thought her takeaway from the SD randgate talk was reasonable 

SinisterDeath - Who moderates the moderators? I wouldn’t go out as far onto the limb as Clov and declare SD unlynchable because I do think he is at least entertained by the idea of being a trolly wolf based on some of the stuff he said. He was only alive D1 in Fireball but his play did have similar elements of memey votes and open speculation that can seem ~random. TWTBAW/LHF territory. 

Zander? - Has sort of slipped behind others but not in a bad way per se. There are a lot of chiefs itt so I don’t fault him for not being front and center. Would really appreciate your insight on Hally since you noted how you/Dice have it opposite and you want to lunch him

I think Hallia has been more Villagery then Dice fwiw.

Haven't seen any real Spicey Dicey posts....also him sussing Hallia without dropping a vore feels very unDicelike to me.

I feel there's very likely min a Wolf between them and Lee

9 hours ago, SinisterDeath said:

With VooDoo, he jumped on my hunch Dice is a Villager pretty fast. If Dice is a Wolf, VooDoo could have used my non-sus of Dice as a spring board to bandwagon on Dice not being wolf.

As for Hal, aside from LeeLuo, Clov is just pure speculation.

Take your vote off yourself pls

Curious as to what every ones take on this Dice vs. Hallia thing?

Sup

Just now, Darthe said:

Instead of caught, right?

If he said no I meqnt caught id have cleared him lololool

Just now, dicetosser1 said:

on page 31. I still think Hallia. I briefly saw her vote on me when i was posting earlier tho and that just makes me want to double down.  im one of scumhallias fav mislynch targets

 

Did you see my vote on you...lol

Just now, dicetosser1 said:

 

 

Verbs not bad  he cant be as he hasnt been here  he was just the choice in that poarticular group

 

re you and tripped  you are just being outright obvious. I wont be lynching you unless we have a verified cop view.

 

Tripped is more tone/feel  She feels open, i havent pinged on anything she has said.

 

 

 

 

The second of these is what made me react. Before that she was pretty null to me. Didnt seem to be really doing much, just chiming in occasionally.

 

 

 

not sure. I havent played with her as much as I have others and never really developed any meta on her. I usually paid attention to verbal to try and figure her out.

Fwiw I do remember dice reading Lee thru verb in games they were all in

Just now, Cory Caboose said:

 

No hammer on D1 ftr

Oh there isn't?? lolololok. Still stand by Hallia looks good by not voting tho

Just now, Hallia said:

Do you think scum not unlucky and is just low hanging fruit

No I think min one of Villagery people/goat players is a Wolf

I think min 1 in Dice Lee Verb SD Voodoo

And prolly 1 in ones I'm giving d1 passes too lol

Ya I'm not voting Derf, Tripped or Hallia today and prolly not SD or Voodoo to leaser extent.

Ya I mean unless Hallia and Dice and Scum mates she coulda votes there and not looked bad so I think her not.voting looks real good if Dice is town but still looks good imo

Just now, Hallia said:

More from me?  Like what?  I've been pretty chatty

I just have a general rule.of life that is the more Hallia the better!!!!  ❤️

Just now, Hallia said:

What feels forced were your couple of low content posts friend 

 

Dang that's a lot of dice votes I was gonna add one but uh, probably should wait

 

Consider this my intention

Villagery 

I really don't recall a game where this many players feel.this Villagery this early in the game lololol

I'd bet there's min 1 Deep Wolf tho

Just now, Clovdyx said:

 

None.  That's why I wanted his thoughts on Verbal - because outside of literal mathematical probabilities, there's really no rational argument for Verb to probably be town.  Statistically speaking, of course he's probably town - everybody is, but we know some people aren't, and given the number of people he said felt townie, you'd think the inactives would be LESS likely to be town.  So I was debating if that was new!mafia not wanting to throw an inactive!butexperienced!teammate under the bus.

 

I asked about Cory because I figured, in the universe where he and Verbal ARE teamed, a brand new scum player would probably feel more comfortable opening a discussion if I didn't lead with "hey, why are you townreading your completely inactive scummate?"

Thanks makes some sense to me lol

Cory can you help me out pls?

Can you give me your current reads list with some reasoning for each?  

1 minute ago, Clovdyx said:

 

It played out.  I didn't find the answer he gave particularly meaningful but reasonable enough, and he didn't give me the answer I was ACTUALLY hoping for.  What were your thoughts?

 

 

 

 

Town: Read posts, ask a lot of questions, try to figure things out.

Mafia: Read posts, ask a lot of questions, look like figuring things out.

 

I realize that sounds really damn obvious, but IDK what else to tell you.  She works through the game how you'd expect from strong, experienced villagers that use thought processes the way she does, and she's aware of her method, so she does that as scum.  Spotting the difference comes down to making the distinction between her asking questions and sharing thoughts because she wants to know/they're her thoughts versus she needs to portray that she wants to know/she has thoughts.

 

She does tend to have better reads as town overall. 

 

Tyvm what's your read on tripped atp?

1 hour ago, Clovdyx said:

@VooDooNut You said you have no pulse on Verb/Cory/me but all three of us were "probably" town.  Can you elaborate on each of us, especially Cory?

Well what pulse could anyone really have on Verb atp?  Lol

I thought your question felt what's the best way to say it leading kinda... Which pinged but seeing your last spell not as bothered.

What intrigued me was your choice of Cory as well cause I'm not real sure what you were expecting and hoping to achieve from his answer.

Just now, Cory Caboose said:

 

Sure, cool

 

This is kind of awkward now

 

I like ur reads btw

I love you btw

Just now, Darthe said:

g2h gimme a person you want wagoned, and vote them.

VOTE:DICE

Just now, Cory Caboose said:

 

??? 

I really can't address this

 

Anything I can address?

Honestly imma see how rest of day goes,  see EOD and Wagons and if im still here flesh out my read...like I said it was a bit suss to me but not enough to make me think you're def a Wolf.