1 minute ago, Zanatron said:

@Niniel

 

@Krakalakachkn

 

Please get caught up on today and weigh in please!!!!!!!

I agree we need their commentary but I'm not voting either of these two.  Looks like town decides between Verbal or I.  Unless we have reason to suspect Crusher which at this point I have none. 

Just now, 鲍勃不是我的名字 said:

 

We were all one-shots.  I'd expect a cop and yes I was hoping someone would you or Verb.

^^^peak^^^

Just now, Zanatron said:

 

Unless hes ccd or we all claim and try to see what fits.

 

Only investigative type role seen so far is tracker and that by itself certainly wouldn't rule out a cop.  

We were all one-shots.  I'd expect a cop and yes I was hoping someone would you or Verb.

3 minutes ago, Verbal32 said:

And he'd totally bus Sooh in that situation, so I'm putting nothing by him.  Bussing is mafia 101 on JN.

 

Something doesn't add up.  I know I'm town, so I can't see how Crusher would be Cop and clear a likely lynch candidate for today based on how JC was gearing up for him and even Cory was not sure.......this doesn't seem right.

Only way he has to win if he's scum.  Lynch you or I today, tomorrow the other with 2 NKs he wins.  I'd have to think there is an investigative role in the game so unless he's countered we play this out, no?

1 minute ago, Zanatron said:

 

My only issue man is the fact you refuse to reevaluate afyer consistently being wrong previously and with different info/things changing during the game.

Save it for post game.

Just now, Zanatron said:

@everyone

 

Should the rest of us claim (if abilities have been used obv) to see if the claim fits?!?!?!

Yes, but unfortunately I have zero to offer at this point.

1 minute ago, Zanatron said:

NB and Verbal.

 

Would Scum!Crusher have the balls to fake claim atp?!?!?!

 

 

 

Yes, he would.

Just now, Zanatron said:

 

Fair enough.  I dont wanna go overboard just wanted to give you a nice fresh slice of....

 

 

I'm a Jets fan, trust me I'm humble.  This won't in any way change my approach to this silly game but I'll listen politely to show you I care.

Just now, Zanatron said:

 

Sweeeet i can torment you post game

..lawl

I'm used to that.  No worries.

I can vote Verbal.  

Vote Verbal

9 minutes ago, Zanatron said:

 

I really do hope youre a Villa fwiw.  

I'm town.  

1 minute ago, The Crusher said:

Zander is not mafia. 

Spill it already so we can make a reasoned choice.

3 hours ago, The Crusher said:

vote verbal

3 hours ago, Zanatron said:

 

Can you lay out your reasoning on your 2 suspects plz?

This should get interesting.

4 hours ago, Niniel said:

 

I´ve read up to end of D1. Crusher really looks town until he starts "defending" Sooh, if that is what he is doing. One post from NotBob could be seen as that as well. (Or both just trying to honestly compare Sooh´s games.) From this vc I take it as Zander could be mafia. Without his vote on Dice, Sooh could have been lynched. I have found him townie but that is something to remember. Verb voted before he left for the weekend and wouldn´t have been able to move things one way or another. Not sure what I think about NotBob and Crusher not voting. Will continue to re-read but might disappear later. 

Good catch on Zander.  I admit botching the Day 1 vote.  I should have pivoted to Sooh but I struggle to read her and missed an opportunity.

Ugh, that hurts.  Anyone want to lynch Zander?

59 minutes ago, Cory Caboose said:

still awake

we could talk politics.  Democrat Party debate tonight.  Who looked good?  I'd like a beer with Williamson.

48 minutes ago, Zanatron said:

 

It's an addiction...lololololol 

Don't forget to put in your NK. lolololol.

On 7/28/2019 at 3:12 PM, 鲍勃不是我的名字 said:

 

My vote on Zander comes from this post of Nyn's.  She has Zander near the top of her town pile.  Maybe, it's my contrarian nature but I see it likely for Zander to kill off a villager who just threw him some props.  With that said, I hesitated to speak during night phase so never gave Nyn my own reads list.  Here it is.  Fresh as a Sunday afternoon.

 

Niniel

Krak

Crusher

Cory

Verb

Sooh

Zander

 

Dig in.  Let me know if I can help.  Appreciate anyone else who wants to chime in with a reads list.

 

FWIW.  Here is my reads list from earlier this day.  I can't say much has changed.  I could swap the order of Crush, Cory and Verb but not sure what good it does.  I don't see Crush pushing that "slow-paced Sooh" narrative as her team mate but maybe.  Cory has earned the center board and props for driving home Sooh's lynch.  I guess he could have bussed but my gut suggest his actions came from a towny.  Verb has stayed at the fringes.  If I had an investigation I'd prolly peak here. 

FTR:  Zander is still at the top of my scum pile. 

1 minute ago, Cory Caboose said:

 

Huh?

Do you think my post was attacking you?

No.  Not at all.  I see you working hard to figure this game out and wanted to offer you my perspective.  I'm town, expect to stay that way, and want to help lynch scum.  You do you.

1 hour ago, Cory Caboose said:

Verb is JC=town your strongest read?

Cory, you have a better chance of flipping scum than I do.  

11 hours ago, Zanatron said:

 

 

Both Sooh and Crusher neglected to vote both times FWIW.

 

Notbon gets absolutely 0 Town cred for this literally asking to see if he could everyone to CFD onto me.

 

Cory look good from this tho obv doesnt him but def helps to alleviate some of my paranoia.

 

Crusher just seems to be like in it but not in it if that makes any sense.  Maybe others can weigh in on it.  

 

Krak I wanna say is just Townie and just wrong on me.  Tho admittedly I suck at reading him 

 

Nini is prolly my only "comfortable" Town read atp.

 

Verb trended up with his return but then disappears again so....

 

Kinda where my heads at atm.

I just had my order reversed.  You're the other scum in the equation as I suggested in my reads.  Tomorrow, you swing.

17 minutes ago, Cory Caboose said:

Batter up

Swing, batter.  Be done with it.

Unvote, Vote Sooh

3 minutes ago, Zanatron said:

 

He doesn't.

2 minutes ago, Cory Caboose said:

Ive reached the point in my mafia career where if I don't have any idea how to read somebody I just dont even bother and focus on the people I CAN read ?

This is actually smart.  Although there was a time I used to just policy lynch the player.