[Basic]What's the theme? - ad lib mafia

MrsClov · January 20, 2017

I have comment about Wiffy, but I'm saving it for day.

Hrmm. Makes me wonder if they are similar to my thoughts I'm saving for day.

MrsClov · January 20, 2017

FWIW it looks good that you collected that list MrsClov

Thanks!

Eldrick4221 · January 20, 2017

I was about to comment something about Hally, then remembered she's already dead lolme.

Eldrick4221 · January 20, 2017

I have comment about Wiffy, but I'm saving it for day.

Hrmm. Makes me wonder if they are similar to my thoughts I'm saving for day.

Race you to say them first :P

Eldrick4221 · January 20, 2017

Hally ISO Part 1

Hi all! Um. Darthe...gonna...Darthe??

<blockquote class='ipsBlockquote' data-author="Hallia" data-cid="3749268" data-time="1484612943">Hallia, on 16 Jan 2017 - 5:29 PM, said:<p><blockquote class='ipsBlockquote' data-author="MrsClov" data-cid="3749264" data-time="1484612646">MrsClov, on 16 Jan 2017 - 5:24 PM, said:<p>

Hi all! Um. Darthe...gonna...Darthe??

Halli

Eldrick4221 · January 20, 2017

Hally ISO Part 2

if somoeone can confirm what basic game means on this site i would be very much appreciated.

If it is how i described it then i would think darthe's claim is him just muckign around and eldrick's push into it is wofly.

Other people got around to answering; but yeah, I am with you.

This pinged me.

vote halli

Reason being?

I know you have played games where what he did is done. yet you dont seem to have even considered that. you are assuming hes mucking around apparently

So...you....say what, he is actually watcher?

Because I doubt it.

Halli, curious as to what your thoughts are. Are you still on the fence about Nolder and Eldrick?

I'm waiting to see, but both are reading scummy to me.

I know you have played games where what he did is done. yet you dont seem to have even considered that. you are assuming hes mucking around apparently

So...you....say what, he is actually watcher?

no thats not what i am saying.

What are you saying then??

For all the people that have voted Derf, he's the one actually throwing out reads and stuff.

real talk: other than the 20 or so posts before I entered the thread this morning(or posts quoted inside them) i didn't read much before that and in the last 40 minutes everytime i sit down and go to look at them i instead find something else to do, so i've given up trying and decided to go for some real time interactions.

this is where i'm currently at(based on tone/impressions or a combination of the two):

villagy:

clov

leaning villagy:

aj

villagy but less confident than above

lenlo

verbal

dice

wifi

???:

ironeyes

hallia

darthe

niniel

stinkeye:

nolder

wolfy:

eldric

thoughts concerns comments

I....really like this. Bop can join Mrs. Clov and AJ in my town pile. Darthe is there too.

For all the people that have voted Derf, he's the one actually throwing out reads and stuff.

don't know what a derf is,

but the defense of one is noted

Derf is Darthe :)

For all the people that have voted Derf, he's the one actually throwing out reads and stuff.

I was thinking something similar.

Glad I'm not the only one.

i would move darthe up a section because hallia is correct

I'm always correct.

I....can't read Wifi. I leave that for the professionals. Typically Sooh, but she's modding, so she can't help me (or can she? )

I....can't read Wifi. I leave that for the professionals. Typically Sooh, but she's modding, so she can't help me (or can she? )

if everyone calls her a villager the wolves have to kill her at somepoint since they can't lynch her. So call her a villa.

Then let it marinate for a few days and if it becomes ripe you re-evaluate

It is science

You'll see. You'll see.

Eldrick4221 · January 20, 2017

Apparently part 1 died. I'll do it again

Eldrick4221 · January 20, 2017

Hally ISO Part 1 (attempt 2)

...and action!!

Hi all!

Um. Darthe...gonna...Darthe??

Hi all!

Um. Darthe...gonna...Darthe??

Halli <3 <3

Hi Linz! <3 <3 <3

Hally!!!

Hi Eldrick!

[unvote]

[v]Darthe[/v]

Claiming watcher and prompting discussion on it is the wolfiest thing so far.

It's Darthe...are you really surprised? I'm with the people saying he's likely vanilla posting it, though I put nothing past him.

I agree with Iron.

Six people have yet to check in. Why would mafia want to draw attention to them by making us discuss the only PR?

It's not like he was the first one to bring up the watcher role in the game. You were ten minutes into the game. Granted, he was claiming it and you were drawing attention to how it's essentially our cop role.

Yeah. Very much not the same thing.

I discussed how the setup differs from the norm.

Darthe brought attention to the role itself, and who is or isn't the watcher.

You claimed what I was doing was role fishing. What Darthe is doing is leagues closer to that, yet you have an issue with me and not him.

Yours rubbed me the wrong way because it seemed more like you were drawing attention to the role itself whereas Darthe's felt more like he was drawing attention to himself. I feel there is a difference there, especially considering if my memory serves me right, the one time I can remember playing with Darthe he was kind of out there early in the thread to get reactions/start discussions. He got a lot of heat for it and nearly got lynched because of it. Luckily, he wasn't lynched and was town and he and I ended up working pretty well together. So I'm giving him a little bit of slack for right now.

These along with her recent posts, I'm happy to have Linz in my town pile.

How much of that is personal bias Nold? Or is it because of his claim? I'm legit curious, not trying to be a smarty pants.

if somoeone can confirm what basic game means on this site i would be very much appreciated.

If it is how i described it then i would think darthe's claim is him just muckign around and eldrick's push into it is wofly.

Other people got around to answering; but yeah, I am with you.

[v]Darthe[/v]

See you guys tomorrow.

[v]Darthe[/v]

It's time you find a new trick, Pony boy.

Bah I'm stupid.

[unvote]

[v]Nolder[/v]

[unvote]

[v]AJ[/v]

"accidently" voting Darthe instead irt Nolder voting him really bugs me. Can't put a finger on why, but it feels out of place.

I'm caught up, I like Verb and AJ's response to this.

[v]Darthe[/v]

See you guys tomorrow.

[v]Darthe[/v]
It's time you find a new trick, Pony boy.

Bah I'm stupid.

[unvote]

[v]Nolder[/v]

[unvote]
[v]AJ[/v]

"accidently" voting Darthe instead irt Nolder voting him really bugs me. Can't put a finger on why, but it feels out of place.

Epic facepalm.

My brain and fingers betrayed me while I was typing because I was seeing Nolder's vote on Darthe and typed that while half asleep.

But let's follow that line of thought here. Do you think I did it on purpose? You put quotations around the word accident. What do I gain from pretending to make a mistake and then immediately fixing it? Are typos alignment indicative?

The fact I even have to ask these sort of questions is pretty silly.

Yeaahhh...

How much of that is personal bias Nold? Or is it because of his claim? I'm legit curious, not trying to be a smarty pants.

If he gives me a good reason I will vote him every time.

Tell me claiming Watcher D1 is anything but anti town behavior.

Nothing good can come of it.

So you believe him? Then you wouldn't vote him.

No one will argue that Darthe's post is not scummy.

This is because everyone knows it was.

It's scummy in a generic sense but this game isn't black and white.

Agreed.

I'm on the fence between Eldrick and Nolder atm.

(You'd like to be ;)

Eldrick4221 · January 20, 2017

Hally ISO Part 3

Could not get on last night due to that error thing. I'm even more behind -.- It appears to be working at least, now.

Self pres ofc, but also, you're scum reading me because I defended Darthe? Wha?

Vote: Wifi

So...what exactly are you scumreading me for, besides defending Darthe?

So...what exactly are you scumreading me for, besides defending Darthe?

Why are you only aiming at the 1 person who could be the lynch instead of you...........instead of asking the others on your train?

Because she was here, I'm trying to skim along, but would like to talk to people in real time - If anyone else is here though, I would hope they would speak up

Eldrick4221 · January 20, 2017

Part 1 her main focus was defending darthe. She sussed Nolder and me because of it. She never went after anyone ekse. She townread MrsClov in part because she wad against my suss of darthe.

Part 2 she discusses how Darthe probably isn't the watcher, comments on bop agreeing with her and moving darthe up and on hiw she can't read Wiffy.

Part 3 she fights against her lynch and votes Wiffy. Self pres vote. Asks wiffy if there's anything more to the suss besides her defending darthe. Comments on how she wants to talk to people in RT, yet ignores those that are on.

Eldrick4221 · January 20, 2017

TL;DR Hally's game has been redominantly about Darthe. She sussed those that were against him and attmpted to pocket those that were against the suss.

Darthe is still my target for tomorrow.

Eldrick4221 · January 20, 2017

TL;DR Hally's game has been predominantly about Darthe. She sussed those that were against him and attempted to pocket those that were against the suss.

Darthe is still my target for tomorrow.

Fixed typos.

bopolis · January 20, 2017

I think it's safe to say that one of Bop or Verbal is scum, based on their late votes of Hallia. I'm not sure how likely it is that they're both scum with her, that being said, they don't have much interaction with one another.

When Bop posted his reads he listed Verbal as "Villagy but less confident".

This is what I found of their interactions in an ISO.

wifi,

why do you think hallia is a wolf, because up until that list I don't thnk you ever mentioned her except for quoting one of her posts asking 'what it means'?

This is a pretty good point, actually. I don't recall seeing an answer as I caught up - did you get one?

So are you thinking it's a scum slip then, Bop?

I know you didn't ask me, but I'm gonna say I think it might be (subconsciously). I've seen it happen many times before, on multiple sites. Usually comes from newer players who don't re-read their posts before clicking the button.

I could switch to Wifi.

verbal,

haven't gotten a response from wifi yet about hallia

solely the late votes of hallia are not a great reason for suss,

once wifi claims watcher anyone on her should be switching off of her regardless of alignment. Villas should never lynch a claim there since it is self resolving(assuming they are around at eod), wolves want to look like villagers and thus will switch off of the claim(assuming they are around at EoD).

A much stronger reason why it would look bad for me is the fact that i was pushing wifi as a counterwagon when hallia was the main wagon so it looks like i was trying to save a wolfbro.

You should all be wary of me, i get that, I was wrong about wifi and now you have to parse whether I was wrong as a villager or a wolf pushing a mislynch, but lets suss me for the right reasons and not for the ones that don't mean anything about my alignment.

bopolis · January 20, 2017

claimed watcher

wifi

probably town for vote reasons:

mrsclov

AJ

dice

nolder

lower confidence town reads:

darthe

lenlo

POE:

eldrick

niniel

ironeyes

verbal

Reason i have them as POE instead of wolfy is because i don't actually read them wolfy, I just don't read them villagy. There isn't anyone in the game at the moment that I have a wolf read on. I thought nolder's tunnel on darthe was wolfy but he voted hallia in a place where wifi was a serious option so I think that makes him likely a villa. The second person i sussed yesterday claimed watcher so RIP that read. And my only other suspect was hallia and she flipped wolf, but since I wasn't on her before the claim it matters not(and it shouldn't).

Lenlo i think has been villagy and tone and has contributed reads. He was on wifi but he was on her well before hallia was a serious counterwagon

Eldrick, don't like his tunnel on darthe, but have reasons why I have him as a null read rather than a wolf read that i'll talk about after the start of the day.

roughly where im at

niniel

lenlo

Eldrick4221 · January 20, 2017

You can call it a tunnel if you want. As the pieces fall they point in that direction. I point them out as I see them.

Iso there anything I've said you disagree with? What and why?

Eldrick4221 · January 20, 2017

Feel free to wait until day to respond.

Eldrick4221 · January 20, 2017

I'm wary of you for my own reasons that I don't wish to discuss yet.

Verbal32 · January 20, 2017

Apparently my scum streak has me still playing too much like scum, lol.

Marsh does not look good switching to Eldrick instead of Hallia. What was the count when Marsh switched? If Eldrick had a chance to catch Hallia, I'm prob voting Marsh tomorrow.

I will RL LOL if Wifi yoloread the entire scum team in 1 post based on a random QT interaction from a single past game.

Verbal32 · January 20, 2017

MrsClov - me switching from Wifi to Hallia should not be something to sus. As bopolis said, the unvote should be happening. It is much more "off" when somebody moves off the claim and onto somebody else.....and then we don't lynch them and lynch scum instead.

Like what happened here.

Verbal32 · January 20, 2017

Also, people might want to re-read the interaction with Dice if they think they want to come @ me tomorrow. There is no contradiction whatsoever. I'm not knocking Dice for trying to hunt there, all good - but he is wrong and it should be clear if that's all you've got for me.

Eldrick4221 · January 20, 2017

Apparently my scum streak has me still playing too much like scum, lol.

Marsh does not look good switching to Eldrick instead of Hallia. What was the count when Marsh switched? If Eldrick had a chance to catch Hallia, I'm prob voting Marsh tomorrow.

I will RL LOL if Wifi yoloread the entire scum team in 1 post based on a random QT interaction from a single past game.

Not sute what you mean by me having a chance to catch Hally. Even if I had been on, which I wasn't, D1 didn't have a hammer.

Eldrick4221 · January 20, 2017

Also, people might want to re-read the interaction with Dice if they think they want to come @ me tomorrow. There is no contradiction whatsoever. I'm not knocking Dice for trying to hunt there, all good - but he is wrong and it should be clear if that's all you've got for me.

I'm on dice's side about this. Talking about one player and voting another in the same post is disconnecting. It's not enough by itself, but it's something worth mentioning as it could be a clue into figuring out scum.

If you don't explain your vote, expect it to be a problem.

Eldrick4221 · January 20, 2017

You did explain your vote. Ignore me.

Verbal32 · January 20, 2017

Apparently my scum streak has me still playing too much like scum, lol.

Marsh does not look good switching to Eldrick instead of Hallia. What was the count when Marsh switched? If Eldrick had a chance to catch Hallia, I'm prob voting Marsh tomorrow.

I will RL LOL if Wifi yoloread the entire scum team in 1 post based on a random QT interaction from a single past game.

Not sute what you mean by me having a chance to catch Hally. Even if I had been on, which I wasn't, D1 didn't have a hammer.

I mean your train.

Verbal32 · January 20, 2017

You did explain your vote. Ignore me.

;-)

[Basic]What's the theme? - ad lib mafia

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook