[Basic] Pirates of the Caribbean (Curse of the Black Pearl) Game Thread - D2

[Guest]

I'm not selective. I literally added everything. I use everything. Did you even notice how many times I said I'd probably look scummy to myself in certain situations? 

 

Did you even try comparing Sooh's interactions to me vs you before saying that?

[Wildfire Sedai]

Oh I'ma going crazy....oh wait. been there done that.   

 

I just can't make up my mind between tiink and besie.  I thought it was tiink but, then he comes in changes my mind.  Well that's not right either.  HE doesn't change my mind, what he posts, gives me some thought and I rethink what I was thinking and that changes my mind.  I've looked at sooh's ISO myself, though not today, a couple of days ago and I found her scummy.  Same with Manbat. The thing with Tiink and besie is I found them both townie so I am having a hard time finding them scummy now.  I really kinda feel tiink over besie but thats cause I don't know besie and I know tiink is a good wolf. Though, I don't think he did this one thing as wolf when he was wolf in the other game.  I am not saying cause I don't want him to know what it is and correct it.  It will be my little meta secret on tiink.  I just gotta find the game where he was wolf and see....I think it was JC?? tiink??

[Guest]

Let’s see your case on me then, Tiink.

 

Here you say I’m “nervous”. If you knew anything or even bothered reading any of my mafia games you’ll see that I come off very confident. You saying I’m nervous is already against that meta.

Here you say Nego and I are buddying.

Here you say you didn’t vote me because you thought I had a vote. Then you don’t vote me. You kept your vote on my “scummate” Nego. Not sure how that makes sense to you in any way.

Here you say that I am scum with Dice and Nego. Dice was town. Nego is cleared by cop. Does that not change your thought at all? Your reasoning was the buddying, which didn’t make sense. And I did bring it up.

You asked me here if I thought you were villager, and I said no, with reasons.

I brought up the fact that you said you didn’t vote me due to votes and you said: “I said I wanted to bring attention to Nego since you already had plenty.” here - which is faulty since I didn’t have plenty, which means that you should’ve switched to me when you saw it. Logic?

Here you voted me for bogus reasons. We spent a few pages discussing this and it still seemed like you were trying to shade me. Posts are here, here, here, with the hghlight being that you said I tried misrepping you whilst you added things that I wasn’t even talking about. You tried moving the focus of the disagreement elsewhere. Bolded was the conclusion.

You then continue to be super annoyed and defensive in the thread, and just want me to be voted. Did you dislike being wrong that much?

Some case from me on you: You had all those posts about NK which is absolute bogus. You didn’t even begin to look like a PR AND many peeps seemed to think you might be scummy. There was literally no reason for scum to want to NK you. Same with me. I’m still here because I’m not PR, and many peeps see me as scummy.

Here you asked me whether I consider something with regards to Sooh’s “defence” on you, and I said yes. And I did. That’s evident in the post I did about Sooh’s interactions.

Here you repeat that I’m scum in a OMGUS way.

[Guest]

That's barely a case on me, Tiink. Would you like to expand on it?

 

And please try answering some questions I had asked everyone in the previous pages?

[Guest]

The fact that I'm not mislynched yet means that Wild isn't scum.

[Guest]

[v]Tiink[/v]

[dyachei]

I'll stare at the votes I posted and try to find some logical deduction from it. I just want to eat first.

 

Pral & Dya, while you're here please answer this?

 

1. Do you think there is a deepwolf?

2. If yes, who do you think the deepwolf is, and why? Or at least, between who?

I think you kind of qualify as deepwolf

 

Can I have Tiink, Wildfire, Dya and Pral's opinions on who the scum are, please?

 

The deepwolfing thing will only actually help next day, if there is one.

it's between you/tink, and wifi I think

 

Tiink/besie never w/w ya

I said this earlier and I still agree

[Guest]

Tiink/besie never w/w ya

 

I said this earlier and I still agree

 

I also agree. I thought we could be v/v, but his bogus case on me makes me think he's not v. So it's v/w.

[dyachei]

If I vote besie, it's hammer, isn't it :/

[Guest]

Yes, Dya.

[dyachei]

I don't want to hammer. But I think I prefer to vote besie over tiink

[Guest]

I'm town.

[Guest]

I'm sorry I couldn't be here yesterday. Maybe if I could I'd have been able to prove myself better to you guys. 

[Guest]

Been a while since there's been a pirate gif

 

[dyachei]

I'm town.

i think I need a better defense than this.

[Guest]

What do you need me to defend against? What is scum about me in your eyes?

[Guest]

Here's previous games if you want to compare.

 

Here.

 

Mafia games

Basic: Diablo - WOLF hydra with Zander - Mafia goon - Lost (lynched D2)

Advanced: World's End - WOLF - Mafia goon - Lost (lynched D1 with Correh <3)

Basic: Stick Figure - WOLF - Mafia Roleblocker - Lost (vigged N2)

Advanced: Lost - TOWN - Vanilla - Lost (mislynched D2)

Basic: I <3 the 90's: Music Edition - subbed in as WOLF D1 - Mafia Odd Night Tracker - Lost (lynched D7)

 

I've been scum almost every time. I tend to think from a scum perspective more than not. 

 

I am very logical. I don't like using meta that much, but more because I don't really know people. Which means that I try to find things that either stick out, or doesn't make sense for a town to say or be aware of.

[dyachei]

What do you need me to defend against? What is scum about me in your eyes?

I provided an iso earlier.

[monstrman]

Dyachei is not godfather because the game would be over

 

Tinfoil hats away

[dyachei]

also you seem to be lacking....*something* that I can't put my finger on.

 

I mean, if you're town and we lynch you, town loses, but you lack passion maybe?

[monstrman]

[unvote]

 

Though

 

Because no hammer yet

[dyachei]

I feel like the fact it wasn't hammered means either Besie is wolf or we had 1 wolf on her wagon early

[monstrman]

Which would have to be tiink

 

Im reading her other games to see if maybe there's a difference

 

So far I see a lot of catchup posting in her wolf games and didn't see much in her town game but in her only town game she was mislynched d2

[monstrman]

Could be tiink Pral

 

Can't be tiink wild

 

I think, somehow, this proved as a clearing mechanism to both clear wild and eliminate all possibility of dyachei godfather

 

That's pretty sweet so we just have to lynch correctly because it's Besie/wild or tiink/Pral mechanically

[monstrman]

I wonder if Pral was on during the time I had voted besie lemme check