MAFIA KART WII [BASIC] - Mafia Sweep

[Sili Quirrels]

 

Wait should thane and hallia stop voting Celeste?

 

If they know they are town they know Celeste is a wolf, given that Zander is town.

 

Except in that scenario, Town!Thane and Town!Hallia wouldn't know the OTHER is town.  

 

but they would know, if zander is town, that two town are on celeste and celeste hasn't been hammered.

[Clovdyx]

Everyone should honestly unvote right now to prevent wolve shenanigans.

 

What's your list look like now?

[Sili Quirrels]

everyone is a wolf but him of course.

[Sooh]

I'm here, and I'm baffled by the events that have happened.

 

Also I was trying to read Clov and Sili's "If x is mafia then y has to be town" and I'm super confused because I have no idea where it's going.

[Clovdyx]

 

 

Wait should thane and hallia stop voting Celeste?

 

If they know they are town they know Celeste is a wolf, given that Zander is town.

 

Except in that scenario, Town!Thane and Town!Hallia wouldn't know the OTHER is town.  

 

but they would know, if zander is town, that two town are on celeste and celeste hasn't been hammered.

 

 

That's true.  And I would hope that if they weren't reasonably comfortable with Zander, neither would have been parked on a lynch with him.

[Sili Quirrels]

I'm here, and I'm baffled by the events that have happened.

 

Also I was trying to read Clov and Sili's "If x is mafia then y has to be town" and I'm super confused because I have no idea where it's going.

YAY so now we can judge celeste by determining hallia and thanes' allignments.

[Sooh]

 

 

Wait should thane and hallia stop voting Celeste?

 

If they know they are town they know Celeste is a wolf, given that Zander is town.

 

Except in that scenario, Town!Thane and Town!Hallia wouldn't know the OTHER is town.  

 

but they would know, if zander is town, that two town are on celeste and celeste hasn't been hammered.

 

Are we close enough to the end that it makes sense for the mafia to self reveal by speed lynching?

 

I guess if they only need one more mislynch we are.

[Sili Quirrels]

which is basically only a little better. damn.

[Clovdyx]

I'm here, and I'm baffled by the events that have happened.

 

Also I was trying to read Clov and Sili's "If x is mafia then y has to be town" and I'm super confused because I have no idea where it's going.

 

Trying to make heads or tails out of the possibility of a quick hammer, should Celeste actually be town this game.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

 

Wait should thane and hallia stop voting Celeste?

 

If they know they are town they know Celeste is a wolf, given that Zander is town.

 

Except in that scenario, Town!Thane and Town!Hallia wouldn't know the OTHER is town.  

 

but they would know, if zander is town, that two town are on celeste and celeste hasn't been hammered.

 

Are we close enough to the end that it makes sense for the mafia to self reveal by speed lynching?

 

I guess if they only need one more mislynch we are.

 

 

 

It is mylo and the doc is dead. So yes. Mafia should time their votes to win, and in so doing reveal themselves.

 

now granted you may not be able to time your votes just yet, so we can wait a day for confirmation, but basically yes.

[Thane Vakarian]

 

Wait should thane and hallia stop voting Celeste?

 

If they know they are town they know Celeste is a wolf, given that Zander is town.

 

Except in that scenario, Town!Thane and Town!Hallia wouldn't know the OTHER is town.  

 

this game would be a lot easier if everybody simply knew every-bodies alignment. But that wouldn't be fun.

[Calder]

 

Everyone should honestly unvote right now to prevent wolve shenanigans.

 

 

What's your list look like now?

Kind of want to lynch Zander.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

Everyone should honestly unvote right now to prevent wolve shenanigans.

 

What's your list look like now?

Kind of want to lynch Zander.

 

no.

[Sooh]

 

I'm here, and I'm baffled by the events that have happened.

 

Also I was trying to read Clov and Sili's "If x is mafia then y has to be town" and I'm super confused because I have no idea where it's going.

 

Trying to make heads or tails out of the possibility of a quick hammer, should Celeste actually be town this game.

 

You're here, Sili is here, I'm here and Calder?

 

If Celeste is town and two of Zander/Hallia/Thane are mafia, only one of us remaining townies need to vote her before presumably a hammer falls.

 

That is if Celeste is innocent.

 

If Celeste is mafia it's unlikely that more than one of Zander/Hallia/Thane are scum with her I think, and the remaining is in us four currently here.

[Sili Quirrels]

i don't really care if he is putting in this much effort as a wolf. he can win if he is. we nearly sacked this game by basically killing two strong villagers.

 

besides, the chances he put in that much effort as a wolf is rather low.

[Clovdyx]

 

 

Everyone should honestly unvote right now to prevent wolve shenanigans.

 

What's your list look like now?

Kind of want to lynch Zander.

 

 

You want to the lynch the guy that, rather than hammer the now-confirmed townie, put forth the most effort in trying to determine if Alanna's claim made sense?  That seems like a really bad idea.  

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

I'm here, and I'm baffled by the events that have happened.

 

Also I was trying to read Clov and Sili's "If x is mafia then y has to be town" and I'm super confused because I have no idea where it's going.

 

Trying to make heads or tails out of the possibility of a quick hammer, should Celeste actually be town this game.

 

You're here, Sili is here, I'm here and Calder?

 

If Celeste is town and two of Zander/Hallia/Thane are mafia, only one of us remaining townies need to vote her before presumably a hammer falls.

 

That is if Celeste is innocent.

 

If Celeste is mafia it's unlikely that more than one of Zander/Hallia/Thane are scum with her I think, and the remaining is in us four currently here.

 

you got it.

[Sooh]

Thane, you obviously think Celeste is guilty. Why should I vote her?

[Sili Quirrels]

hallia calder celeste make sense to you clov?

[Calder]

 

 

 

Everyone should honestly unvote right now to prevent wolve shenanigans.

 

 

What's your list look like now?

Kind of want to lynch Zander.

 

You want to the lynch the guy that, rather than hammer the now-confirmed townie, put forth the most effort in trying to determine if Alanna's claim made sense?  That seems like a really bad idea.

I didnt say it was a great idea. Just that I want to.

 

Although Laine was dead no matter what. Town in any game for all time has to kill the person that killed the doctor the previous night when there was no other kill. So putting in effort and waiting to lynch doesnt mean much when its a guarantee.

[Sili Quirrels]

calder celeste obviously makes sense. almost makes too much sense.

[Sooh]

I'll have to go look at Hallia's reasons for wanting to lynch Celeste. I don't remember them being very clearly put in her post.

[Calder]

calder celeste obviously makes sense. almost makes too much sense.

Honestly the game is over for town. So if we have to lynch Celeste for piece of mind, in that she has no reason to survive, then fine. I just have not thought she was scum this game.

[Clovdyx]

hallia calder celeste make sense to you clov?

 

Calder and Celeste makes a hell of a lot of sense to me, in terms of m-m equity.  It makes not nearly as much sense when I consider them outside of their interaction vacuum - she's been pretty objectively scummy, but I think he's played a solid game.  

 

Hallia is a puzzle piece I don't know how to fit in.  There's definitely nothing that makes me think they COULDN'T be aligned.

[Thane Vakarian]

Thane, you obviously think Celeste is guilty. Why should I vote her?

The feeling I got from her this game is the following (with no offense intended): 'You people are not used to my style, I have opinions and nobody believes them.' Other than defending herself, she has not actively been hunting for wolves. I don't recall any full reads lists to work with, not providing any insight in her way of thought or take of the game. That is definitely not pro-town play imo.