[Advanced] Revenge of the Marlfox

[Tommyrod]

You're saying our way of solving the game is wrong and yours is right.

 

Kay.

[Yates]

im leaning scum on verb and arsis.

 

arsis just seems to be taking pot shots from the sidelines

 

verb is a gut reaction to his intial reaction to thanes foot in mouth. im willing to hold off and see more from him

Yeah. I actually agree with you on both of these points. You saw what I said about being okay with an Arsis counterwagon so enough said there, I think.

 

I don't think Verb is scummy for how he treated Thane, but I do have some trepidation there. How long did it take for me to convince Thane he was likely wrong about his theory? One link. BUT - I'm also someone who read Thane's posts as him just putting his unfiltered thoughts out there and thought it was Townie. Leelou wanted to clear Verb earlier than I wanted to and I put the brakes on that for exactly this reason. Plus, I think Verb will agree that Leelou might clear him a bit too easily. So I want to see more from him about other slots before making a final determination.

[Pralaya]

lol, 40 pages in one day. Yeah, this will take some time to read. 

[Thane Vakarian]

hmm.. i can get the votes on Arsis. Don't understand the votes on Tommy though. 

 

Personally i find it a bit early to hardclear players this early D1. Feels like people temmng "He's ok, look elsewhere." when wxe still need to look at every single player D1. And further on in the game. 

 

Welcome Pral have fun catching up

 

I'm around a bit now. 

[Yates]

 

 

oh, Arsis... if you check the location just next to my siggy, you would have known

I'm on mobile so I have no idea what you're talking about. I'll just assume Belgians are generally rude people.

 

 

 

;P

 

potshot.

 

If he's more active than usual, why would that be town motivated?

 

What do you think of the incredibly early game setup talk?

 

couldnt just ask leelou  had to push on thane a bit too

 

I'm going to pretend Verbal has town cred for coming out strong and "scumhunting" but I'm really suspicious of him jumping on something small so soon.

 

arguing both sides

 

LOL - I actually think the posts you quoted here are TOWNIE for Arsis. That looks like someone trying to get reads to me. You might be convincing me Arsis is Town!

[Thane Vakarian]

temmng= telling*  

 

my bad

[Thane Vakarian]

 

im leaning scum on verb and arsis.

 

arsis just seems to be taking pot shots from the sidelines

 

verb is a gut reaction to his intial reaction to thanes foot in mouth. im willing to hold off and see more from him

Yeah. I actually agree with you on both of these points. You saw what I said about being okay with an Arsis counterwagon so enough said there, I think.

 

I don't think Verb is scummy for how he treated Thane, but I do have some trepidation there. How long did it take for me to convince Thane he was likely wrong about his theory? One link. BUT - I'm also someone who read Thane's posts as him just putting his unfiltered thoughts out there and thought it was Townie. Leelou wanted to clear Verb earlier than I wanted to and I put the brakes on that for exactly this reason. Plus, I think Verb will agree that Leelou might clear him a bit too easily. So I want to see more from him about other slots before making a final determination.

 

just putting in my thoughts on the last part: it would be possible that both Verb and Leelou rolled scum again, and the play is similar to what i saw in the firefly game. I don't know how likely it would be, but we'll need to see more about that. 

[Yates]

I'm reading Hallia as townish right now, she is voting where she is looking at people, not just going with the flow.

FTR - This is what I'm loving about her play right now. Even when we disagreed, she was at least giving me actual meta/game related reasons and appeared to be trying to understand the argument. There's a sincerity there that I'm absolutely loving. I will be pretty broken hearted if this is a scum slot because I feel like THIS is the Hally I've been wanting to see.

[Yates]

just putting in my thoughts on the last part: it would be possible that both Verb and Leelou rolled scum again, and the play is similar to what i saw in the firefly game. I don't know how likely it would be, but we'll need to see more about that.

As Leelou's hydra head? I can tell you that it's impossible since Leelou has been mod confirmed Town to me.  

 

What looks similar to you with regards to how they interacted in Firefly?  I don't recall Leelou having much interaction with her in that game.  I actually used some of that meta to paint Verb as scum in the Discworld game.  That's why I ask.

[Thane Vakarian]

It's mostly from her reaction to the interaction between Verb and me that i got the feeling. I can be wrong, seeing i work on feleing more than anything else though. 

[Thane Vakarian]

and i really shouldn't be typing too fast 

[Tommyrod]

It's mostly from her reaction to the interaction between Verb and me that i got the feeling. I can be wrong, seeing i work on feleing more than anything else though.

We'll see. I wouldn't be shocked but I'm not gonna bank on that theory.

[Yates]

It's mostly from her reaction to the interaction between Verb and me that i got the feeling. I can be wrong, seeing i work on feleing more than anything else though.

Okay. But you understand that Leelou and I are the same slot, right? We are two people playing as Lates. So I have her role PM in my inbox.

[Thane Vakarian]

i know Yates, i never said you were cleared either

[Leelou]

 

It's mostly from her reaction to the interaction between Verb and me that i got the feeling. I can be wrong, seeing i work on feleing more than anything else though.

Okay. But you understand that Leelou and I are the same slot, right? We are two people playing as Lates. So I have her role PM in my inbox.

 

^this

 

Also, I didn't clear Verb, I said 90% from his first few posts. Not ready to actually clear him yet. 

[Tommyrod]

I completely forgot Yates and Lee are a hydra.

 

Lee do you think I'm scum?

[Leelou]

I completely forgot Yates and Lee are a hydra.

 

Lee do you think I'm scum?

 

I am leery of you. 

[Thane Vakarian]

So, Tommy, who should we investigate N1 and why?

[Thane Vakarian]

Leelou, same for you please

[Thane Vakarian]

Does anybody have playing experience with Berf btw? i can't really figure him out... hasn't posted much either, but i can't get anything here.

[Yates]

i know Yates, i never said you were cleared either

And that's fine. But what I'm trying to tell you is that you should look at how *I* am treating Verb as well when you are trying to make this alignment determination.

[Thane Vakarian]

There's this thing with hydra's: i don't really like them. One player could be doing really well, and the other one could slip/mess up. Usually a hydra gets judged by its weakest member. 

 

If i can't make up my mind about you Yates, i'll look more into Leelou and vice/versa. 

[Yates]

I completely forgot Yates and Lee are a hydra.

See? I don't ACTUALLY have you on ignore. My rustle brush just happens to be a Vericoli. Handmade hairbrush manufactured in Italy, carved out of illegal whalebone, its perfectly balanced, with low drag and minimal torque to be applied during each brush. Price is around $12000 USD or 30 million lira.

[Yates]

I decided to come clean on that because I don't want to push this too far and make the game unfun for my own amusement/scum hunting purposes.

[Tommyrod]

So, Tommy, who should we investigate N1 and why?

Someone who won't be NK'd will have a tough time defending themselves in late game. Someone like Berm.