SCOOBY GAME THREAD - TOWN WINS

[Mafia-3]

If Cutler flips scum main but 10k Volt doesn't, then we have a preliminary list but nothing definite.  I expect 10k Volt to flip scum though.  I was somewhat unsure on Cutler but the vote shenanigans make me think scum there too.

[Mafia-3]

If 10k and Cutler flip scum mains, we can cross-reference lynches for confirmed town and find the last scum main.

 

This should be "confirmed not scum mains" not "confirmed town"

[PTERODACTYL mafia]

So your entire reasoning for voting me is that you think I'm simply bussing with my votes? What say you to my direct question Tar about me watching you try and steal from me?

[DPR]

[Mafia-17]

So your entire reasoning for voting me is that you think I'm simply bussing with my votes? What say you to my direct question Tar about me watching you try and steal from me?

 

Good job minimizing my case.  Even if that were my entire reason, it's still sufficient to lynch you.  You also haven't been scumhunting at all this game.

 

As for the self-watch, scum have a role that watches themselves too, so I see it as a null tell.  Idk why you're trying to use it to vet yourself, especially when we haven't seen more than 1 person get caught stealing in the same night and SNOW BEAST was caught N2.  It's basically as ludicrous as Wax saying that 10k Volt has to be town because not everyone who targeted her is dead.

[PTERODACTYL mafia]

Wasn't minimizing the case, just that's all the point you recently posted about me except that I was back and forth on mummy.

[Mafia-17]

You're still doing it.

 

And you have yet to offer a defense.

[Mafia-8]

 

Current Vote Count:

 

10,000 (8) - Ghost, Phantom, Hyde, Cat, Coffin, Mantis, Tar, Zombie

Ptero (2) - Phantom, Elias, Skeleton

10 names, 9 votes.  Probably 10k as scum main.

Why aren't we doing the easy one?

 

@Skeleton vote for Mantis

@Elias vote for Wax

@10K vote for Tar

@Ptero vote for Hyde

 

I guess it's also possible [as I suspect] 10k and Ptero are both scum and one of the others on each of their lynches is also scum.  We can test that next.

[Mafia-17]

Look at the vote counts again dude. DPR's not stupid. We can't test anything that way. To my knowledge, the uncounted vote mechanic has only kicked in so far when someone is ostensibly hammered. Up 'til hammer, DPR seems to be counting normally. The only way to test it is to try to lynch mafia (which we should be doing anyways).

[Mafia-17]

Although, the fact that one of the votes on Ptero disappeared at the same time is interesting. I wonder if the same happened with Heap. It could be as simple as a vote steal though.

[Mafia-8]

Although, the fact that one of the votes on Ptero disappeared at the same time is interesting. I wonder if the same happened with Heap. It could be as simple as a vote steal though.

Wouldn't it be hilarious if Phantom was scum with 10k and Ptero??

[Mafia-17]

IIRC, Phantom released an inno on Black Knight tha ended up leading to Mummy's lynch. I'd have to check the timing to see if it gets town points or not though. Could also be that Elias is scum. Or someone is messing with him. Either way, Cutler, 10k, and Ptero have all played scummy enough to be lynched. Also rethinking Elias now too. And the vote shenanigans on Cutler look pretty suspicious. I'm pretty sure there's at least 2 scum in {Cutler, 10K Volt, Ptero}.

[Mafia-17]

IIRC, Phantom released an inno on Black Knight tha ended up leading to Mummy's lynch. I'd have to check the timing to see if it gets town points or not though. Could also be that Elias is scum. Or someone is messing with him. Either way, Cutler, 10k, and Ptero have all played scummy enough to be lynched. Also rethinking Elias now too. And the vote shenanigans on Cutler look pretty suspicious. I'm pretty sure there's at least 2 scum in {Cutler, 10K Volt, Ptero}.

[Mafia-17]

Anyways, gonna go to bed.

 

Cutler should be hammered but I'd like confirmation from DPR. I want to lynch 10k as well. I want Ptero to die, and I'm ambivalent on Elias. Would be nice if some other people started playing. There has been almost no action since Wax went nuts about resolving the bear traps before we run people up. We should either release Elias or leave him to die. Stop this waiting game. It doesn't help the town at all.

[Mafia-7]

I say leave him to die.

[Mafia-10]

Yea game died. When is the deadline?

[CREEPER mafia]

A call was placed to police. A name was reported. A location was given.

 

When the blue lights came crashing down, the suspect was there, just as reported and it didm;t take long to apprehend them.

 

WITCH DOCTOR, VAMBRAM (replaced by DAP), TOWN, HAS BEEN CAUGHT STEALIN'. 

 

It is now Day 5. With 18 players, it takes 10 to lynch.

 

 

Should be 72 hours from this post.

[Mafia-10]

So sometime tomorrow?

 

Appears to be ~18h from now.

[CREEPER mafia]

A bit shy of 16 hours I think.

 

We need 2 more votes to release Elias if we're going to... I think the consensus pretty much is to keep Ptero in the trap.

 

Ready and willing to add votes to Cutler and 10KV once Elias is free - or in about 12 hours, if he's not been freed by then, he probably won't be.

[DPR]

Current Vote Count:

 

10,000 (8) - Ghost, Phantom, Hyde, Cat, Coffin, Mantis, Tar, Zombie

Cutler (10) - Mantis, Hyde, Kook, Tar, Cat, Coffin, Elias, Wax, Ghost, 10,000, Zombie - CUTLER IS LYNCHED

Ptero (3) - Phantom, Elias, Skeleton

Skeleton (1) - Wax

 

With 18 players, it takes 10 to lynch

 

3 BEAR TRAPS HAVE BEEN ACTIVATED:

 

Ptero (3) - Ghost, Ptero, Wax

 

Cat (11) - Hyde, Kook, Ghost, Elias, Creeper, Cat, mantis, Coffin, Wax, Tar, Zombie - CAT IS RELEASED.

 

Elias (8) - Elias,10,000, Tar, Zombie, Wax, Creeper, Cat, Hyde

 

DEADLINE @ 9:10 PM 

[Mafia-10]

 

So your entire reasoning for voting me is that you think I'm simply bussing with my votes? What say you to my direct question Tar about me watching you try and steal from me?

 

Good job minimizing my case.  Even if that were my entire reason, it's still sufficient to lynch you.  You also haven't been scumhunting at all this game.

 

As for the self-watch, scum have a role that watches themselves too, so I see it as a null tell.  Idk why you're trying to use it to vet yourself, especially when we haven't seen more than 1 person get caught stealing in the same night and SNOW BEAST was caught N2.  It's basically as ludicrous as Wax saying that 10k Volt has to be town because not everyone who targeted her is dead.

 

I never said that.

[Mafia-8]

Vote: Release Elias

[CREEPER mafia]

Current Vote Count:

 

10,000 (8) - Ghost, Phantom, Hyde, Cat, Coffin, Mantis, Tar, Zombie

Cutler (10) - Mantis, Hyde, Kook, Tar, Cat, Coffin, Elias, Wax, Ghost, 10,000, Zombie - CUTLER IS LYNCHED

Ptero (3) - Phantom, Elias, Skeleton

Skeleton (1) - Wax

 

With 18 players, it takes 10 to lynch

 

3 BEAR TRAPS HAVE BEEN ACTIVATED:

 

Ptero (3) - Ghost, Ptero, Wax

 

Cat (11) - Hyde, Kook, Ghost, Elias, Creeper, Cat, mantis, Coffin, Wax, Tar, Zombie - CAT IS RELEASED.

 

Elias (8) - Elias,10,000, Tar, Zombie, Wax, Creeper, Cat, Hyde

 

DEADLINE @ 9:10 PM

Interesting.  The voting shenanigans have suddenly been reversed.

[Mafia-17]

No they haven't.  There's 11 names on that train.

 

There are 3 votes on Ptero again though.  Guess that one was just mod error?

[Mafia-17]

Less than 9 hours to deadline btw.