SCOOBY GAME THREAD - TOWN WINS

[Mafia-9]

Also I'd rather lynch Skeleton instead of VOLT. Volt's play is a huge WiFoM, but I'm not convinced that we have to solve that right now.

 

Why should there be an instead? Skeleton can be a viable lynch for tomorrow and we can put all the pressure you want on him then. Don't try to swallow more than you can chew, Wax. We've got three scummy lynch candidates that we seem to have a consensus on (two to lynch and one in the bear trap). Volt would be the last one I'd back down from since he pings the most out of the three.

[Mafia-7]

@Cat Why release Elias? In what way is Elias helping town?

[Mafia-13]

 

Also I'd rather lynch Skeleton instead of VOLT. Volt's play is a huge WiFoM, but I'm not convinced that we have to solve that right now.

 

Volt's play is straight up scummy.  Garbage roleclaim + holstering forever + getting out of trap = likely scum.  No need to WIFOM about it.

 

 

I like my vote on Volt, it's not being moved.

[PTERODACTYL mafia]

@Tar - So how mafia kill at night is they catch people stealing, yes? N2 you tried to steal from me. I watched myself and saw you visit me. Ergo, if I was mafia and caught you trying to steal from me... you'd be a goner, thus proving to at least you, me, Mantis, and Wax that I cannot be mafia.

 

So please... re-explain to me why I'm mafia?

[Mafia-9]

@Cat Why release Elias? In what way is Elias helping town?

 

I already noted that I don't approve of his lazy blind follow of Waxmantis. Looking at his casing, he did at first put an effort to try and sort out the information and try to scumhunt. But once Waxmantis were vetted and they started to organize the information, he seemed to have switched into following them instead of developing an opinion of his own. I'm not convinced that he's scum, ergo I won't leave him in the bear trap. But, I would highly encourage him to put on his thinking cap and start helping us scumhunt.

 

I'm not contesting the fact that he's not actively being helpful in brainstorming, btw. But I'd like to give him a chance to correct that before we string him up for it.

[Mafia-17]

Fair points to me Phantom Pain.

 

Vote Mummy

 

Weak sheep vote on Mummy.

[Mafia-17]

 

A 1x super role that only has a 33% chance of working doesn't sound plausible to me. It has 33% chance of essentially being game breaking if it works.

 

Good post.

 

 

I believe the Mummy claim for now. If he was lying then his results would be impossible to fabricate because of how many people they can potentially implicate.

 

Sorry about not being here much the past couple of days. I don't have a ton of time at the moment but will be posting a Jaguaro case when I do.

 

I will quickly mention that Black Knight, Mummy, and Pterodactyl all appear pretty confirmed to me ATM based on their claims, but that will need more analysis later.

 

Terrible post.  How is a one-shot role that didn't give results hard to fabricate?  Charlie should die for this alone.

 

 

Anyone up for a werewolf train?

 

Odd post but whatever.  Werewolf was annoying so I get the sentiment.

 

 

Unvote

 

I think that unless something bad happened to these 3, then we can assume he's telling the truth. If he was mafia and had a role that could target 3 people, it seems like there would be some sort of negative utility involved.

 

Complete backtrack on Mummy's claim.  This is garbage.

 

 

Unvote Vote Mummy

 

cause deadline n' stuff

 

As Ghost pointed out this was well before deadline.  Stinks like a bushammer.

 

 

 

Vote Pterodactyl

 

 

Backtracks on Mummy's claim then bushammers 9 hours before deadline.

[Mafia-17]

 

 

 

Final Vote Count:

 

Wax Phantom (1) - Jaguaro

Mummy (15) - Tar Monster, Hyde, Ghost, Kook, Elias, Werewolf, Zombie, Snow Beast, Mantis, Cat Creature, 10,000, Demon Shark, Dr. Coffin, Wax, Pterodactyl

Pterodactyl (1) - Miner

Ghost (3) - Skeleton, Phantom, Black Knight

Dr. Coffin (1) - Cutler

Jaguaro (1) - Charlie

 

With 26 players, it takes 14 votes to lynch

 

 

 

 

CURRENT VOTE COUNT:

 

Witch Doc (3) - Wax, Werewolf, Shark

Jaguaro (14) - Ghost, Zombie, Tar Monster, Pterodactyl, Hyde, Cutler, Shark, 10,000, Phantom, Charlie, Black Knight, Cat Creature, Miner, Dr. Coffin

Mantis (5) - Zombie, Tar Monster, Pterodactyl, Cutler, Skeleton

Elias (1) - Charlie

Zombie (2) - Mantis, Jaguaro

Cutler (3) - Mantis, Jaguaro, Charlie

Shark (3) - 10,000 , Black Knight, Hyde

Creepy Heap (3) - Werewolf, Phantom, Ghost

 

With 24 players, it takes 14 to lynch. Twice.

 

Deadline Saturday, 9:15 am EST

 

JAGUARO IS TODAY'S FIRST LYNCH. HE HAS THE OPTION TO PLAY ON UNTIL THE END OF THE DAY

 

Recalibrating current vote count...

 

 

 

Aaaand a CURRENT VOTE COUNT:

 

Shark (1) - 10,000

Creepy Heap (1) - Phantom

Werewolf (14) - Tar Monster, Mantis, Jaguaro, Zombie, Hyde, Ghost, Elias, Charlie, Shark, Kook, Skeleton, Coffin, Witch Doc, Black Knight

Zombie (2) - Werewolf, Wax

 

With 24 players, it takes 14 to lynch.

 

That's a wrap.

 

 

D2-D3 lynch trains

 

 

 

 

 

Current Vote Counts:

 

Zombie (1) - Mantis

Charlie (11) - Ptero, Tar, Zombie, Creeper, 10,000, Hyde, Cat, Creepy Heap, Phantom, Elias, Wax

Creepy heap (1) - Ghost 

 

With 22 players, it takes 12 to lynch

 

DR. COFFIN (13) - Wax, Zombie, Charlie, Creeper, Witch, Tar, Cat, Ghost, Miner, Coffin, Elias, Ptero, Phantom  COFFIN IS RELEASED

 

Deadline at 11:22 EST

 

 

 

 

 

unvote, vote Charlie Robot

 

 

CHARLIE ROBOT BEGAN TO OVERHEAT, EYES GLOWING MORE AND MORE RED BY THE MOMENT. SPARKS BEGAN TO SHOOT FROM HIS MOUTH, FOLLOWED BY A POP AND A CURL OF SMOKE. THEN HE SLUMPED FORWARD AND HIS HELMET FELL OFF. THE POLICE ARRIVES SHORTLY THEREAFTER AND CARTED HIM OFF TO JAIL.

 

CHARLIE ROBOT, DARTHE, TOWN, HAS BEEN ARRESTED.

 

IT IS NOW NIGHT. YOU HAVE 24 HOURS TO COMPLETE YOUR NIGHT ACTIONS.

 

D4 Lynch

 

 

 

 

 

Current Vote Count:

 

Ghost Clown (15) - Hyde, Capt., Snow Beast, 10,000, Witch Doc., Kook, Knight, Skeleton, Elias, Creeper, Cat Creature, Charlie, Miner, Creepy heap, Tar Monster

Snow Beast (1) - Phantom

Black Knight (7) - Jaguaro, Pterodactyl, Phantom, Ghost Clown, Mummy, Ghost, Werewolf

Miner 49'er (1) - Dr. Coffin

 

With 27 players, it takes 15 to lynch

 

 

Dragging up D1 too even though it prob doesn't mean as much.  Still should be noted that Phantom has another useless vote here.

 

 

 

 

Current Vote Count

 

Witch Doc (6) - Ghost, Sharky, Tar, Cat, Phantom, Zombie

Heap (14) - Ghost, Mantis, Cutler, Tar, Zombie, Cat, Skeleton, Wax, Coffin, Creeper, Witchy, Hyde, Phantom, Kook, Ptero, Elias

Tar (4) - Kook, Cutler, Phantom, Heap

Sharky (11) - Mantis, Coffin, Hyde, 10,000, Wax, Creeper, Heap, Witchy, Cat, Phantom, Ptero

Black Knight (1) - Sharky

 

With 21 players, it takes 11 to lynch.

 

10,000 (7 ) - Wax, Cutler, Skeleton, Heap, Tar, Zombie, Witchy

 

 

/Ape'd

 

Let me know if I messed it up.

 

 

 

 

So we have:

 

 

Heap (11) - Ghost, Mantis, Cutler, Tar, Zombie, Cat, Skeleton, Wax, Coffin, Creeper, Witchy

 

vs.

 

Heap (14) - Ghost, Mantis, Cutler, Tar, Zombie, Cat, Skeleton, Wax, Coffin, Creeper, Witchy, Hyde, Phantom, Kook, Ptero, Elias

 

 

 

Please note that there are actually 16 names on the second train.  That means all but 5 players had to vote Heap.  We know that the scum had at least 5 members at this point.  Bussing extremely likely.

 

 

 

Preliminary busser candidate list:

 

Coffin

Hyde

Phantom

Kook

Ptero

Elias

 

 

 

Hyde, Phantom, Kook, and Elias all have some town cred imo based on previous night actions and/or votes.

 

 

 

So I think the people we should focus on tomorrow are Coffin, Ptero, and possibly anyone who didn't vote Creepy Heap (it's possible that we're looking at a semi-bus).

 

 

Peopel who didn't vote Creepy Heap:

 

5. BLACK KNIGHT mafia - allegedly viewed town by Phantom IIRC

12. 10,000 VOLT mafia

14. CREEPY HEAP mafia - Kaylee, lynched D5

24. MINER 49'er mafia

26. DEMON SHARK mafia - empty suit

 

 

That makes 10k Volt and Miner look pretty bad.  Both were in the trap interestingly enough.

 

I know Miner's been inactive, but meh.  Can't really let people get away with that at this point.

 

 

Tier 1:

 

Coffin

Ptero

10k Volt

 

 

Tier 2:

 

Elias

Miner

 

Some more stuff on Ptero.  His votes on scum all look like busses.

[Mafia-17]

Ptero's been on every scum lynch so far, but look at his positioning:

 

Mummy: Hammer

Creepy Heap: L - 1 (after the extra vote requirement thing)

Demon Shark: Hammer

 

 

Most transparent busser ever.  Also, if you recall, Ghost and Ptero werer my top candidates for Demon Shark's main.

[DPR]

Current Vote Count:

 

10,000 (8) - Ghost, Phantom, Hyde, Cat, Coffin, Mantis, Tar, Zombie

Cutler (10) - Mantis, Hyde, Kook, Tar, Cat, Coffin, Elias, Wax, Ghost, 10,000

Ptero (3) - Phantom, Elias, Skeleton

Skeleton (1) - Wax

 

With 18 players, it takes 10 to lynch

 

3 BEAR TRAPS HAVE BEEN ACTIVATED:

 

Ptero (3) - Ghost, Ptero, Wax

 

Cat (11) - Hyde, Kook, Ghost, Elias, Creeper, Cat, mantis, Coffin, Wax, Tar, Zombie

 

Elias (7) - Elias,10,000, Tar, Zombie, Wax, Creeper, Cat

[DPR]

It appeared as if Cutler had been lynched. But then...

[DPR]

Current Vote Count:

 

10,000 (8) - Ghost, Phantom, Hyde, Cat, Coffin, Mantis, Tar, Zombie

Cutler (9) - Mantis, Hyde, Kook, Tar, Cat, Coffin, Elias, Wax, Ghost, 10,000

Ptero (2) - Phantom, Elias, Skeleton

Skeleton (1) - Wax

 

With 18 players, it takes 10 to lynch

 

3 BEAR TRAPS HAVE BEEN ACTIVATED:

 

Ptero (3) - Ghost, Ptero, Wax

 

Cat (11) - Hyde, Kook, Ghost, Elias, Creeper, Cat, mantis, Coffin, Wax, Tar, Zombie - CAT IS RELEASED.

 

Elias (7) - Elias,10,000, Tar, Zombie, Wax, Creeper, Cat

[Mafia-13]

release Elias

 

And it looks like we need more votes on Cutler.

[Mafia-17]

 

Also, FoS Cat Creature.  I could have told everyone that Miner and Creepy Heap are null based on posts without making massive waffling walls of text.  Cat Creature's "cases" looks like faux-scumhunting garbage to me.

 

This.

 

 

Also, unvote Ptero, vote Creepy Heap

 

 

Bus vote from Demon Shark.  Please recall that Demon Shark was oddly insistent that Ptero was scum.  I believe Demon Shark was trying to vet himself by lynching his main and when that didn't gain enough traction, he switched to Creepy Heap for a bus vote.

 

 

Unofficial Vote Count

 

Witch Doc (6) - Ghost, Sharky, Tar, Witch, CAT, PHANTOM

Heap (5) - Ghost, Mantis, CUTLER, TAR, Sharky

TAR (5) - KOOK, COFFIN, CUTLER, HYDE, PHANTOM

SHARKY (3) - COFFIN, Mantis, WAX

SKELETON (1) - WAX

 

With 21 players, it takes 11 to lynch.

 

10,000 (-)

 

Zombie (12) - Mantis, Tar, Ghost, Heap, Witch, CAT, PHANTOM, KOOK, COFFIN, CUTLER, HYDE - released, CREEPER

 

Miner (12) - Mantis, Tar, Ghost, Heap, Witch, PHANTOM, CAT, KOOK, COFFIN, CUTLER, HYDE - released, CREEPER

 

[Mafia-17]

Also, when rereading I noticed that both 10,000 Volt and Creepy Heap pushed the idea of not wanting to blind lynch Mummy.

[Mafia-17]

10 names there but only 9 votes.  Sending up the Zombie signal.

[Mafia-3]

Vote Capt. Cutler

[Mafia-3]

I think I figured something out.

[Mafia-3]

I don't think the gang members' votes count when they're placed on each other.  I think they can vote their mains with their suits or their suits with their mains, but I don't think a mafia main can vote a main.  I mean they can place a vote and DPR will put it on the list, but it won't actually count.  I think that's why we're seeing shenanigans on some mafia lynches (and that also makes me think Cutler is mafia).

[Mafia-10]

Do you have the lynches and vote sheenanigans summarized? Or do your last posts contain all those?

[Mafia-3]

 

Current Vote Count:

 

Wax Phantom (1) - Jaguaro

Mummy (14) - Tar Monster, Hyde, Ghost, Kook, Elias, Werewolf, Zombie, Snow Beast, Mantis, Cat Creature, 10,000, Demon Shark, Dr. Coffin, Wax

Pterodactyl (1) - Miner

Ghost (3) - Skeleton, Phantom, Black Knight

Dr. Coffin (1) - Cutler

Jaguaro (1) - Charlie

 

With 26 players, it takes 14 votes to lynch

 

The villains gathered in anticipation of a de-masking, but after a very careful vote count, it appeared that there were only 13 votes...

 

They were still one short.

 

Deadline today at 4:05 pm EST  < 8 hrs.

 

 

14 names and 14 votes shown on the count but DPR makes a point of telling us that there are only 13 votes.  I think there's exactly one scum main on the Mummy train and I think it's 10k Volt.

 

 

 

Final Vote Count:

 

Wax Phantom (1) - Jaguaro

Mummy (15) - Tar Monster, Hyde, Ghost, Kook, Elias, Werewolf, Zombie, Snow Beast, Mantis, Cat Creature, 10,000, Demon Shark, Dr. Coffin, Wax, Pterodactyl

Pterodactyl (1) - Miner

Ghost (3) - Skeleton, Phantom, Black Knight

Dr. Coffin (1) - Cutler

Jaguaro (1) - Charlie

 

With 26 players, it takes 14 votes to lynch

 

 

Looks like Ptero probably isn't a scum main as his vote counted.  Could still be a suit though.

[Mafia-3]

 

Current Vote Count

 

Witch Doc (6) - Ghost, Sharky, Tar, Cat, Phantom, Zombie

Heap (14) - Ghost, Mantis, Cutler, Tar, Zombie, Cat, Skeleton, Wax, Coffin, Creeper, Witchy, Hyde, Phantom, Kook, Ptero, Elias

Tar (4) - Kook, Cutler, Phantom, Heap

Sharky (11) - Mantis, Coffin, Hyde, 10,000, Wax, Creeper, Heap, Witchy, Cat, Phantom, Ptero

Black Knight (1) - Sharky

 

With 21 players, it takes 11 to lynch.

 

10,000 (7 ) - Wax, Cutler, Skeleton, Heap, Tar, Zombie, Witchy

 

 

16 names, 14 votes.  2 scum mains on this train.  Cutler could be one.

[Mafia-10]

Interesting theory.

[Mafia-3]

 

Current Vote Count:

 

10,000 (8) - Ghost, Phantom, Hyde, Cat, Coffin, Mantis, Tar, Zombie

Cutler (9) - Mantis, Hyde, Kook, Tar, Cat, Coffin, Elias, Wax, Ghost, 10,000

Ptero (2) - Phantom, Elias, Skeleton

Skeleton (1) - Wax

 

With 18 players, it takes 10 to lynch

 

3 BEAR TRAPS HAVE BEEN ACTIVATED:

 

Ptero (3) - Ghost, Ptero, Wax

 

Cat (11) - Hyde, Kook, Ghost, Elias, Creeper, Cat, mantis, Coffin, Wax, Tar, Zombie - CAT IS RELEASED.

 

Elias (7) - Elias,10,000, Tar, Zombie, Wax, Creeper, Cat

 

 

10 names, 9 votes.  Probably 10k as scum main.

[Mafia-3]

If 10k and Cutler flip scum mains, we can cross-reference lynches for confirmed town and find the last scum main.