SCOOBY GAME THREAD - TOWN WINS

[PTERODACTYL mafia]

release Ptero

[Mafia-10]

*** Files being updated ***

 

Files updated. Everyone doublecheck his own please.

[Mafia-11]

 

 

Vote: Lynch Cutler

Vote: Lynch Ptero

 

These are my votes until full night actions are confirmed.

 

I will just follow you.

 

Vote Cutler

Vote Ptero

 

 

Release Cat

Release Elias

 

It sounds like Wax found some action that doesn´t add up with mine. I will wait to hear what it is.

 

 

What are your thoughts on.......well.......anything?

 

 

I have no clue about anything so I will just add a vote or two to whoever Mantis and/or Wax vote. I have also let them decide my night actions.

[Mafia-10]

OK everyone had the time by now:

 

PTERO claims that they have watched himself on some night. They give a list of people who visited. That list doesn't include PTERO. I asked the mod about what result would someone get if they targeted themselves with a watcher, the answer was "themselves + whoever visited).

 

HYDE claims that they have watched themselves night. That list doesn't include HYDE. I asked the mod about what result would someone get if they targeted themselves with a watcher, the answer was "themselves + whoever visited).

 

I'd like to hear some explanations please.

 

CUTLER: lots of actions behind on claims, most of his actions posted are holsters, and a single watch on a scum HEAP who were supposed to have been visited by another scum.

[Mafia-10]

Also there is a possible contradiction in claims that is being sorted out as we speak. Hopefully with the result of someone being scum.

 

Also:

 

@MOD: Assume PlayerB has some role(s). PlayerA targets PlayerB (stealing). Player A gets caught (arrested). Would PlayerB's role(s) be stolen? In other words, which comes first, the stealing or the arresting?

[Mafia-13]

OK everyone had the time by now:

 

PTERO claims that they have watched himself on some night. They give a list of people who visited. That list doesn't include PTERO. I asked the mod about what result would someone get if they targeted themselves with a watcher, the answer was "themselves + whoever visited).

 

KOOK claims that they have watched themselves night. That list doesn't include KOOK. I asked the mod about what result would someone get if they targeted themselves with a watcher, the answer was "themselves + whoever visited).

 

I'd like to hear some explanations please.

 

 

Don't you mean me instead of Kook? And the mod only told me I was visited by 2 people *edit* - my name wasn't included in the list.

[Mafia-13]

Also, in all your actions, can't you verify that those 2 people visited me from what you were told?

[Mafia-10]

I'm waiting for actions from the following people:

 

CUTLER

BLACK KNIGHT

SKELETON

MINER

COFFIN

 

I know that Miner is very busy (and quite inactive). He is likely town, however.

I have mixed feelings about Black Knight, but his actions seem to add up + why frame MUMMY D2.

Skeleton has been missing about 3 days of actions. I mean, he just wasn't around. Go figure. Claimed RL troubles tho. Still, not very helpful.

Coffin lost a Magis to me on N2, seems alright for now.

[Mafia-10]

 

OK everyone had the time by now:

 

PTERO claims that they have watched himself on some night. They give a list of people who visited. That list doesn't include PTERO. I asked the mod about what result would someone get if they targeted themselves with a watcher, the answer was "themselves + whoever visited).

 

KOOK claims that they have watched themselves night. That list doesn't include KOOK. I asked the mod about what result would someone get if they targeted themselves with a watcher, the answer was "themselves + whoever visited).

 

I'd like to hear some explanations please.

 

Don't you mean me instead of Kook? And the mod only told me I was visited by 2 people *edit* - my name wasn't included in the list.

 

Yes, I mean HYDE, thanks for the correction.

Yes, the actions do add up in both cases, except for the fact that the list should include the extra name (as far as I know).

[Mafia-13]

 

 

OK everyone had the time by now:

 

PTERO claims that they have watched himself on some night. They give a list of people who visited. That list doesn't include PTERO. I asked the mod about what result would someone get if they targeted themselves with a watcher, the answer was "themselves + whoever visited).

 

KOOK claims that they have watched themselves night. That list doesn't include KOOK. I asked the mod about what result would someone get if they targeted themselves with a watcher, the answer was "themselves + whoever visited).

 

I'd like to hear some explanations please.

 

Don't you mean me instead of Kook? And the mod only told me I was visited by 2 people *edit* - my name wasn't included in the list.

 

Yes, I mean HYDE, thanks for the correction.

Yes, the actions do add up in both cases, except for the fact that the list should include the extra name (as far as I know).

 

 

I told you exactly what I was told. I was targeted by person A and person B and I was not in that list. I asked the mod for clarification.

[CREEPER mafia]

I have a good town vibe from Cat - she's beat me to posting quite a few of the things I was thinking.  There have been times this game where if I didn't know better I'd think she was me.  Good quality posts > high quantity posts any day in my book.

 

Release Cat Creature

 

I'll be looking through Elias Kingston's posts as time allows today.  I'd prefer to leave Ptero trapped.

 

10KVolt's claim really doesn't make sense to me.  What I understand from what he/she has said is that they have had no one shot abilities this entire game and presumably no ability to steal since they haven't tried to steal anything... and when someone tried to steal from them they got a mod PM that included a scene in which they saw a tail... so they somehow deduced from this that Demon Shark had the keys to the Mystery Machine?  I find it extremely implausible.  He/she says they think they have a passive detector role, but has not said this is confirmed in any way, and I also find that implausible that they would not have been told by the mod that they had such a role. 

 

Cutler is likely to be my second vote.  Holding off on voting until the bear traps on Cat has been released and I look further into Elias.

[Mafia-10]

Current Vote Count:

 

10,000 (5) - Ghost, Phantom, Hyde, Cat, Coffin

Phantom (1) - Ghost

Cutler (6) - Mantis, Hyde, Kook, Tar, Cat, Coffin

Ptero (3) - mantis, Phantom, Tar

 

With 18 players, it takes 10 to lynch

 

3 BEAR TRAPS HAVE BEEN ACTIVATED:

 

Ptero (-)

 

Cat (-)

 

Elias (-)

Elias: don't release yet, soemthing needs to be clarified.

Ptero: don't release yet, something needs to be clarified.

Cat Creature: would you like to claim?

[Mafia-10]

Also, don't finish both lynches just yet.

 

Now runnign home, back in 1.5h.

[Mafia-9]

 

 

OK everyone had the time by now:

 

PTERO claims that they have watched himself on some night. They give a list of people who visited. That list doesn't include PTERO. I asked the mod about what result would someone get if they targeted themselves with a watcher, the answer was "themselves + whoever visited).

 

KOOK claims that they have watched themselves night. That list doesn't include KOOK. I asked the mod about what result would someone get if they targeted themselves with a watcher, the answer was "themselves + whoever visited).

 

I'd like to hear some explanations please.

 

Don't you mean me instead of Kook? And the mod only told me I was visited by 2 people *edit* - my name wasn't included in the list.

 

Yes, I mean HYDE, thanks for the correction.

Yes, the actions do add up in both cases, except for the fact that the list should include the extra name (as far as I know).

 

 

But erm... how would Mr.Hyde know the names of the two people who visited him if he's fibbing and didn't use the Watcher role on himself?  I'd understand your distrust if there were contradictions in the people he claimed visited him.. but there aren't. I don't know, this doesn't add up to me. Not to mention that it seems like it would be an intricate lie that could easily be disapproved... when an easy alternative would have been to say that he holstered.

 

Did the people/person that ptero said that visited him truly did according to the night action they sent to you?

[Mafia-9]

Elias: don't release yet, soemthing needs to be clarified.

Ptero: don't release yet, something needs to be clarified.

Cat Creature: would you like to claim?

 

 

 

Yes, I claim that catnip is quite tasty, despite common belief.

[Mafia-9]

Also, Release Cat Creature.

 

 

I'm looking into Elias right now. I'll decide about him soon. Right now I'm opting to leaving Ptero where he is.

[DPR]

OK everyone had the time by now:

 

PTERO claims that they have watched himself on some night. They give a list of people who visited. That list doesn't include PTERO. I asked the mod about what result would someone get if they targeted themselves with a watcher, the answer was "themselves + whoever visited).

 

HYDE claims that they have watched themselves night. That list doesn't include HYDE. I asked the mod about what result would someone get if they targeted themselves with a watcher, the answer was "themselves + whoever visited).

 

I'd like to hear some explanations please.

 

CUTLER: lots of actions behind on claims, most of his actions posted are holsters, and a single watch on a scum HEAP who were supposed to have been visited by another scum.

 

I have released Watcher results and not included the self-watcher's name. When you asked, I defined the role. When I reported results, I rested on the implied meaning of self watching. I should have been more specific, hence this clarification.  

 

 

Also there is a possible contradiction in claims that is being sorted out as we speak. Hopefully with the result of someone being scum.

 

Also:

 

@MOD: Assume PlayerB has some role(s). PlayerA targets PlayerB (stealing). Player A gets caught (arrested). Would PlayerB's role(s) be stolen? In other words, which comes first, the stealing or the arresting?

 

PAFO

[Mafia-9]

Hahaha. Brilliant.

[Mafia-13]

 

OK everyone had the time by now:

 

PTERO claims that they have watched himself on some night. They give a list of people who visited. That list doesn't include PTERO. I asked the mod about what result would someone get if they targeted themselves with a watcher, the answer was "themselves + whoever visited).

 

HYDE claims that they have watched themselves night. That list doesn't include HYDE. I asked the mod about what result would someone get if they targeted themselves with a watcher, the answer was "themselves + whoever visited).

 

I'd like to hear some explanations please.

 

CUTLER: lots of actions behind on claims, most of his actions posted are holsters, and a single watch on a scum HEAP who were supposed to have been visited by another scum.

 

I have released Watcher results and not included the self-watcher's name. When you asked, I defined the role. When I reported results, I rested on the implied meaning of self watching. I should have been more specific, hence this clarification.  

 

 

TY for the clarification.

[Mafia-8]

Release CAT CREATURE

[Mafia-8]

I'm keeping Elias in until a night action discrepency gets sorted out. 

 

I'm keeping Ptero in for kind of the same reason.

 

But I will do this:

 

Unvote Ptero

Vote Lynch 10000Volt

[Mafia-8]

I'm actually starting to think Ptero might be okay.  But that's not really a good thing...  If Cutler is scum, I'm good with voting Skeleton.

[Mafia-1]

release Cat Creature

[Mafia-10]

 

 

 

OK everyone had the time by now:

 

PTERO claims that they have watched himself on some night. They give a list of people who visited. That list doesn't include PTERO. I asked the mod about what result would someone get if they targeted themselves with a watcher, the answer was "themselves + whoever visited).

 

KOOK claims that they have watched themselves night. That list doesn't include KOOK. I asked the mod about what result would someone get if they targeted themselves with a watcher, the answer was "themselves + whoever visited).

 

I'd like to hear some explanations please.

 

Don't you mean me instead of Kook? And the mod only told me I was visited by 2 people *edit* - my name wasn't included in the list.

 

Yes, I mean HYDE, thanks for the correction.

Yes, the actions do add up in both cases, except for the fact that the list should include the extra name (as far as I know).

 

 

But erm... how would Mr.Hyde know the names of the two people who visited him if he's fibbing and didn't use the Watcher role on himself?  I'd understand your distrust if there were contradictions in the people he claimed visited him.. but there aren't. I don't know, this doesn't add up to me. Not to mention that it seems like it would be an intricate lie that could easily be disapproved... when an easy alternative would have been to say that he holstered.

 

Did the people/person that ptero said that visited him truly did according to the night action they sent to you?

 

There is a maffia role that tells you if you are being targeted. So we were told by DPR, at least. In the post where he told us what new roles to expect. No idea of its number.

[Mafia-13]

 

 

 

 

OK everyone had the time by now:

 

PTERO claims that they have watched himself on some night. They give a list of people who visited. That list doesn't include PTERO. I asked the mod about what result would someone get if they targeted themselves with a watcher, the answer was "themselves + whoever visited).

 

KOOK claims that they have watched themselves night. That list doesn't include KOOK. I asked the mod about what result would someone get if they targeted themselves with a watcher, the answer was "themselves + whoever visited).

 

I'd like to hear some explanations please.

 

Don't you mean me instead of Kook? And the mod only told me I was visited by 2 people *edit* - my name wasn't included in the list.

 

Yes, I mean HYDE, thanks for the correction.

Yes, the actions do add up in both cases, except for the fact that the list should include the extra name (as far as I know).

 

 

But erm... how would Mr.Hyde know the names of the two people who visited him if he's fibbing and didn't use the Watcher role on himself?  I'd understand your distrust if there were contradictions in the people he claimed visited him.. but there aren't. I don't know, this doesn't add up to me. Not to mention that it seems like it would be an intricate lie that could easily be disapproved... when an easy alternative would have been to say that he holstered.

 

Did the people/person that ptero said that visited him truly did according to the night action they sent to you?

 

There is a maffia role that tells you if you are being targeted. So we were told by DPR, at least. In the post where he told us what new roles to expect. No idea of its number.

 

 

Okay, I'm just making this perfectly clear here the path the watcher role came to me: WD had it, Kook stole it N3, I stole it N4 and used it N5. I've given you all my actions, so has Kook. WD verified their watcher role was stolen on N3, the confusion around that role was cleared by DPR in thread.