SCOOBY GAME THREAD - TOWN WINS

[Mafia-18]

 

Morning :)

Surprised I can post, net sux around here.

 

@role thieves: You should clarify how your role works before trying to accuse someone based on it. I'm pretty sure that if someone's using their tracker role at night, it can't be stolen from them.

 

@everyone: with multiple magistrates in the game, train speed should be picked up maybe? also I'm going down to the beach again, have a nice day

 

Let's assume for now that TBK is telling the truth. He says MUMMY visited multiple people. How is that even possible?

 

@The Black Knight: are you sure your tracker role does what you think it does?

 

 

This pinged too. aside from obviously trying to start a speed lynch on the weekend, maybe trying fill the no-talky vacuum with game info? those with knowledge of the theft should hold it tight - we don't know if the mafia do or do not have that ability right now. Best play it safe, yes?

 

 

The pace of this game is horrible. I have some experience with DPR games. The fact that we have magistrates means that we must use them to have as many lynches in as possible (and stealing/using a magistrate role might even clear people). So we'll have to do 2 lynches per 72h.

 

This madness with slow play and slow votes has to stop - and it has to stop NOW.

[Mafia-18]

Yea it would be damned nice if we knew that PHANTOM was town. I don't think we do. But his reveal looks genuine.

[PHANTOM mafia]

Here's an idea. Lynch me and you get Black Kniht 100% cofnrimed, Ghostie. 

[csarmi]

*********

[Mafia-1]

 

Really? I have a town viewing on him; DPR has told us here is no godfather. We've been told that it's not possible to steal abilites in use, wich clears the WIFOM around those trying to steal his role. What else do you have that means Black Knight isn't cleared? 

 

I would need to know that you are actually town.  It's not difficult for mafia to come up with a strategy of " fake 1x cop view on themselves" in a DPR game where we all know there may be some interesting mechanics. 

 

 

 

 

Good catch.  Wolf sounds a lot like mafia worried about the thievery.

 

 

 

I don't think Black Knight is cleared.  Just that pursuing him at this stage in the game is counter-productive. 

 

This reaction to 1000 volt's FOS on werewolf is gross. Volt provided the FOS on a post that pinged him, Ghost is providing a narrative to bolster the FOS and perhaps create the premise for momentum.

 

Really? I have a town viewing on him; DPR has told us here is no godfather. We've been told that it's not possible to steal abilites in use, wich clears the WIFOM around those trying to steal his role. What else do you have that means Black Knight isn't cleared? 

 

This.

 

Ghost is still doing the "he's not in the clear" bit? 

 

Ghost is directing traffic on suspicion, and adding narrative where needed, while introducing illogical snags where they aren't needed.

 

Nothing pro-town about anything he's doing.

 

Ghost, Tar Monster = scum.

 

I'll vote either.

 

 

So you know 100% that Phantom is town and that he used a cop viewing on Black Knight?  Why don't you tell us all how you know this? 

 

I stated that going after Black Knight is not productive.  But I don't know Ptero is town and that means I don't know Black Knight is town. 

 

Unlike you who seems to know 100% they are town and mafia is the only faction that could possibly know who is and who isn't town. 

 

 

If you asked assbrain questions like this, you'll get treated like an assbrain.

 

You are encouraging the pursuit of a non-issue, we have all the information we need for now regarding Phantom and Black Knight. Nobody is saying either is 100% town, but given the circumstance around their reveals - we can move on. If they are NOT town, it will become abundantly clear. It's not like we're all going to suddenly forget their reveals, and the commentary around it. So, why crater on undermining what we might as well assume is two townies?

 

There is a large field of players, it makes more sense to move on. Yet, you are insistent upon redirecting the conversation back to Phantom/Black Knight every time someone else tries to poke around. 

 

If you are town, then STFU and let the competent people scum hunt - you aren't helping anyone but yourself to the center of attention.

[Mafia-1]

 

 

Morning :)

Surprised I can post, net sux around here.

 

@role thieves: You should clarify how your role works before trying to accuse someone based on it. I'm pretty sure that if someone's using their tracker role at night, it can't be stolen from them.

 

@everyone: with multiple magistrates in the game, train speed should be picked up maybe? also I'm going down to the beach again, have a nice day

 

Let's assume for now that TBK is telling the truth. He says MUMMY visited multiple people. How is that even possible?

 

@The Black Knight: are you sure your tracker role does what you think it does?

 

 

This pinged too. aside from obviously trying to start a speed lynch on the weekend, maybe trying fill the no-talky vacuum with game info? those with knowledge of the theft should hold it tight - we don't know if the mafia do or do not have that ability right now. Best play it safe, yes?

 

 

The pace of this game is horrible. I have some experience with DPR games. The fact that we have magistrates means that we must use them to have as many lynches in as possible (and stealing/using a magistrate role might even clear people). So we'll have to do 2 lynches per 72h.

 

This madness with slow play and slow votes has to stop - and it has to stop NOW.

 

 

Gaming the mod's meta to support a "let's go lynch crazy" agenda is pinging big time. There may be something to what you are advocating, but it needs to be tempered with more of an understanding of the setup. So far, we've seen a bunch of derps make believe they know what they are doing on D1, and basically only pressure 1 - 2 people in a game with what 20+ people in it?

 

Now you want to get lynch crazy and just start cranking them out, without actually putting in the scum hunting work?

 

Riiiiight. Good plan. I stand over here and watch... then when it's time for someone to fix your mess, I'll take care of it. LOL

[Mafia-1]

Here's an idea. Lynch me and you get Black Kniht 100% cofnrimed, Ghostie. 

 

Would rather lynch Ghostie, because town or scum, he/she is pushing a doo doo agenda.

[Mafia-10]

Hi all, sorry for being late.

 

Did I miss anything?

[BLACK KNIGHT mafia]

Vote Wax Phantom

I'd personally like to get rid of the inactives, so let's start with you.

[Mafia-10]

Vote Wax Phantom

I'd personally like to get rid of the inactives, so let's start with you.

Then maybe you should vote an inactive. That's an interesting play, attack someone on his first post.

[CAPT. CUTLER mafia]

You're here now though, right?   What are your thoughts?

[Mafia-10]

On a first read?

 

What stands out to me the most is that MUMMY isn't talking on D2.

 

Lots of people not voting at all. Some have very few posts.

 

MR HYDE, what's your case on CAT CREATURE?

WITCH DOCTOR: you voted GHost Clown D1, then disappeared. Like, completely. What are your views now?

 

I don't have much of a read on anyone. But then I only read a thread once (now) and in a haste.

[Mafia-10]

I believe we should summarize who claimed what today, and focus on people who aren't "cleared". As far as I understand:

 

(1) PHANTOM viewed The Black Knight as town

(2) JAGUARO and PTERO (is that right?) claimed to have tried to steal a role from The Black Knight (failed)

(3) The Black Knight have claimed to have seen MUMMY visit multiple people

(4) MINER stole Magistrate from Elias

 

The strongest could be (4), that might clear both players (especially if MINER gets to use the magistrate.

MUMMY should speak up.

The 15 non-voters should speak and vote.

If The Black Knight is town indeed, then the D1 kynch was controlled by the maffia. Shouldn't let that happen.

[Mafia-10]

vote MUMMY

[Mafia-6]

vote ghost mafia

 

I too am interested why Werewolf sent that pm instead of on thread.

[Mafia-5]

Unvote

I may have jumped the gun a bit on Black Knight. I didn't like his game, saw him as scum, then wasn't able to steal his role and assumed it was bogus. *shrug*

You live you learn.
 

On a first read?

What stands out to me the most is that MUMMY isn't talking on D2.

This is a good point. Mummy isn't talking. At all. Are you pushing this angle because you know he has been silenced by one of your scum buddies?

 

Vote Wax Phantom

 

I would like to know the tracking information on mummy if he doesn't respond by the end of the day tomorrow [real time not mafia time].
 

[DPR]

 

Current Vote Count:

 

Creepy Heap (1) - Werewolf

Wax Phantom (1) - Jaguaro

Tar Monster (1) - Dr. Coffin

Mummy (5) - Tar Monster, Phantom. Pteodactyl, Hyde, Wax, 

Cat Creature (2) - Miner, Ghost

Space Kook (1) - 10,000

Ghost (1) - Skeleton

 

With 26 players, it takes 14 to lynch

 

Deadline Monday @ 4:05 pm - 20 HRS

[PHANTOM mafia]

 

Here's an idea. Lynch me and you get Black Kniht 100% cofnrimed, Ghostie. 

 

Would rather lynch Ghostie, because town or scum, he/she is pushing a doo doo agenda.

 

 

Well, me too of course. I was trying to go for sarcasm, and failed completly. Oh woe! 

 

Since Mummy seems awol, and we have 20 hours to deadline, and I'm very interested in hearing what he'll say, I suggest we leave the mummy until next Day, and get rid of Ghostie now. 

 

Unvote vote Ghost

[Mafia-7]

 

So you know 100% that Phantom is town and that he used a cop viewing on Black Knight?  Why don't you tell us all how you know this? 

 

I stated that going after Black Knight is not productive.  But I don't know Ptero is town and that means I don't know Black Knight is town. 

 

Unlike you who seems to know 100% they are town and mafia is the only faction that could possibly know who is and who isn't town. 

 

 

If you asked assbrain questions like this, you'll get treated like an assbrain.

 

You are encouraging the pursuit of a non-issue, we have all the information we need for now regarding Phantom and Black Knight. Nobody is saying either is 100% town, but given the circumstance around their reveals - we can move on. If they are NOT town, it will become abundantly clear. It's not like we're all going to suddenly forget their reveals, and the commentary around it. So, why crater on undermining what we might as well assume is two townies?

 

There is a large field of players, it makes more sense to move on. Yet, you are insistent upon redirecting the conversation back to Phantom/Black Knight every time someone else tries to poke around. 

 

If you are town, then STFU and let the competent people scum hunt - you aren't helping anyone but yourself to the center of attention.

 

 

Obviously you're too dense to see a sarcastic question without me putting [sarcasm] tags on it.  I'll remember to make it clear enough for even you to follow next time. 

 

And yes, people were saying, "well, black knight is town so anyone voting him needs to be lynched now."  So BS on your saying nobody thought they were town and was running with it.  Next time read the thread before making stupid comments.

 

As for moving on, I agree. 

 

I believe we should summarize who claimed what today, and focus on people who aren't "cleared". As far as I understand:

 

(1) PHANTOM viewed The Black Knight as town

(2) JAGUARO and PTERO (is that right?) claimed to have tried to steal a role from The Black Knight (failed)

(3) The Black Knight have claimed to have seen MUMMY visit multiple people

(4) MINER stole Magistrate from Elias

 

The strongest could be (4), that might clear both players (especially if MINER gets to use the magistrate.

MUMMY should speak up.

The 15 non-voters should speak and vote.

If The Black Knight is town indeed, then the D1 kynch was controlled by the maffia. Shouldn't let that happen.

 

I'd also like to hear from Mummy on how he could have visited multiple people.  I can't think of a town role that allows you to do so.  Can anyone else.  The only roles I can think of are scum roles.

 

unvote, vote Mummy

[Mafia-7]

Well, me too of course. I was trying to go for sarcasm, and failed completly. Oh woe! 

 

Since Mummy seems awol, and we have 20 hours to deadline, and I'm very interested in hearing what he'll say, I suggest we leave the mummy until next Day, and get rid of Ghostie now. 

 

Unvote vote Ghost

 

 

Apparently sarcasm is lost on people around here.

[Mafia-1]

 

Well, me too of course. I was trying to go for sarcasm, and failed completly. Oh woe! 

 

Since Mummy seems awol, and we have 20 hours to deadline, and I'm very interested in hearing what he'll say, I suggest we leave the mummy until next Day, and get rid of Ghostie now. 

 

Unvote vote Ghost

 

 

Apparently sarcasm is lost on people around here.

 

 

Chalking it up as sarcasm, doesn't make it sarcasm.

 

You were dead serious and I knocked you on your ass, because your defense was stupid.

 

Unvote

Vote Ghost

[Mafia-1]

My top 3: Ghost, Tar Monster and Werewolf

[DPR]

Current Vote Count:

 

Creepy Heap (1) - Werewolf

Wax Phantom (1) - Jaguaro

Mummy (5) - Tar Monster, Pterodactyl, Hyde, Wax, Ghost

Cat Creature (1) - Miner

Space Kook (1) - 10,000

Ghost (3) - Skeleton, Dr. Coffin, Phantom

 

With 26 players, it takes 14 to lynch

 

Deadline Monday @ 4:05 pm - > 18 HRS

[Mafia-7]

 

 

Well, me too of course. I was trying to go for sarcasm, and failed completly. Oh woe! 

 

Since Mummy seems awol, and we have 20 hours to deadline, and I'm very interested in hearing what he'll say, I suggest we leave the mummy until next Day, and get rid of Ghostie now. 

 

Unvote vote Ghost

 

 

Apparently sarcasm is lost on people around here.

 

 

Chalking it up as sarcasm, doesn't make it sarcasm.

 

You were dead serious and I knocked you on your ass, because your defense was stupid.

 

Unvote

Vote Ghost

 

 

I was serious about the stupidity so I used sarcasm to show it.  And I'm not sure what world you live in but you certainly didn't "knock me" anywhere.  I stand by my points, and you agreed with them and still somehow claim victory, which is just strange.  You even said, "but nobody was saying that they were town" showing that you agreed.  Then, when I pointed out people were assuming BK is completely town you don't respond to that point, glide right past it, and say "ZOMG I totally won that, YEAH!" 

 

Why don't you actually respond to my point before claiming victory, clown?

 

And why don't you drop it and move on?  You yourself said we needed to move on, but for some reason you keep coming back to the point even after I moved on.  Seriously, you make absolutely no sense when you can't even bother to be logically consistent.

[Mafia-3]

I don't think Black Knight is cleared.  Just that pursuing him at this stage in the game is counter-productive.

 

 

 

 

Really? I have a town viewing on him; DPR has told us here is no godfather. We've been told that it's not possible to steal abilites in use, wich clears the WIFOM around those trying to steal his role. What else do you have that means Black Knight isn't cleared?

 

I would need to know that you are actually town.  It's not difficult for mafia to come up with a strategy of " fake 1x cop view on themselves" in a DPR game where we all know there may be some interesting mechanics. 

 

 

 

Good catch.  Wolf sounds a lot like mafia worried about the thievery.

 

 

I don't think Black Knight is cleared.  Just that pursuing him at this stage in the game is counter-productive.

 

This reaction to 1000 volt's FOS on werewolf is gross. Volt provided the FOS on a post that pinged him, Ghost is providing a narrative to bolster the FOS and perhaps create the premise for momentum.

 

Really? I have a town viewing on him; DPR has told us here is no godfather. We've been told that it's not possible to steal abilites in use, wich clears the WIFOM around those trying to steal his role. What else do you have that means Black Knight isn't cleared?

 

This.

 

Ghost is still doing the "he's not in the clear" bit? 

 

Ghost is directing traffic on suspicion, and adding narrative where needed, while introducing illogical snags where they aren't needed.

 

Nothing pro-town about anything he's doing.

 

Ghost, Tar Monster = scum.

 

I'll vote either.

 

 

So you know 100% that Phantom is town and that he used a cop viewing on Black Knight?  Why don't you tell us all how you know this? 

 

I stated that going after Black Knight is not productive.  But I don't know Ptero is town and that means I don't know Black Knight is town. 

 

Unlike you who seems to know 100% they are town and mafia is the only faction that could possibly know who is and who isn't town.

 

 

If you asked assbrain questions like this, you'll get treated like an assbrain.

 

You are encouraging the pursuit of a non-issue, we have all the information we need for now regarding Phantom and Black Knight. Nobody is saying either is 100% town, but given the circumstance around their reveals - we can move on. If they are NOT town, it will become abundantly clear. It's not like we're all going to suddenly forget their reveals, and the commentary around it. So, why crater on undermining what we might as well assume is two townies?

 

There is a large field of players, it makes more sense to move on. Yet, you are insistent upon redirecting the conversation back to Phantom/Black Knight every time someone else tries to poke around. 

 

If you are town, then STFU and let the competent people scum hunt - you aren't helping anyone but yourself to the center of attention.

 

 

Hey guys I don't understand this:

 

-Ghost says Black Knight isn't cleared but he doesn't want to push him yet.

 

-Dr. Coffin says Ghost is "adding narrative" and "directing traffic on suspicion" and "introducing illogical snags."  Is it just me or did Dr. Coffin just spew a whole bunch of narrative with almost no content while accusing Ghost of doing the same?

 

-Dr. Coffin then says almost exactly what Ghost said in the first quote except he took about 6 or 7 times as many words to do it.  He also accuses Ghost of encouraging the pursuit of a non-issue when this whole pointless argument started with Dr. Coffin misrepping Ghost's original statement.

 

 

So either I'm missing something or Dr. Coffin has dumb brains.  0/10 would not eat.