SCOOBY GAME THREAD - TOWN WINS

[Mafia-13]

Happy with my vote on Skeleton. If he doesn't flip Fred, then I'll gladly vote Elias tomorrow.

[Mafia-9]

Ok, well, Skeleton seems to have one steal try on a known scum (Cutler). And all the rest is holstering. This is the classic night action report for a scum member that can't steal at night.

 

So, I'm sticking to Skeleton.

 

Elias tried to steal from various people. Kook, Miner, Charlie Robot, Creeper. If she's making up her night actions, a lot more would pop out... not just a time stamp discrepancy.

[Mafia-10]

There is like one left, so YES damn it! We are trying to scum hunt and play this damn game and everything we move on you undermine with stupidity. I give you the flashlight thing, but you won't even answer me that question in PM. Let everyone make freaking decisions going forward with the information you gathered by browbeating everyone to do your will. I'm tired of you trying to run the whole game for everyone. This is a group effort and people are tired of playing with you telling them WHAT TO DO.

There is Fred and at least one scum left. There are also two inactives. That's not counting Skeleton who I take for scum.

We are in a much worse position than you think we are.

It's actually quite possible that we can't finish a lynch today. It takes 7/12 to lynch and we have 8 town votes in the game. If any sort of voting sheenanigans happen, we might just lose the lynch right here.

 

A mislynch and a bad night result or two and we will have lost.

 

So don't come downplay the situation for us. I won't waste my breath FOS'ing you for suggesting to come out with full information. I'll let ZOMBIE handle this.

[Mafia-13]

 

There is like one left, so YES damn it! We are trying to scum hunt and play this damn game and everything we move on you undermine with stupidity. I give you the flashlight thing, but you won't even answer me that question in PM. Let everyone make freaking decisions going forward with the information you gathered by browbeating everyone to do your will. I'm tired of you trying to run the whole game for everyone. This is a group effort and people are tired of playing with you telling them WHAT TO DO.

There is Fred and at least one scum left. There are also two inactives. That's not counting Skeleton who I take for scum.

We are in a much worse position than you think we are.

It's actually quite possible that we can't finish a lynch today. It takes 7/12 to lynch and we have 8 town votes in the game. If any sort of voting sheenanigans happen, we might just lose the lynch right here.

 

A mislynch and a bad night result or two and we will have lost.

 

So don't come downplay the situation for us. I won't waste my breath FOS'ing you for suggesting to come out with full information. I'll let ZOMBIE handle this.

 

 

Look, I'm fairly certain that there is only Fred left. You are the one going on about suits.

[Mafia-10]

I'm pretty sure this game would have more than 5+1 scum.

 

I'm done with this conversation. Talk to the Leader.

[Mafia-13]

I'm done with you too

[Mafia-10]

That's me out of the game.

 

I'll do my votes, my night actions and update the excel sheets when actions are sent and help MANTIS/ZOMBIE when they ask me to.

 

I'm done talking to you. <-- that's not at HYDE personally

 

/waxout

[Mafia-3]

Okay, I'm going to ask this here. I'm tired of you just analyzing the actions and we only get bits and pieces. I think since it's so close to end game you let us see everything so we can piece it together and come to conclusions on our own and not be spoon fed info by you.

 

Not happening.  Only confirmed townies get the info.

[Mafia-3]

Release Creeper

[Mafia-10]

Release Creeper

[Mafia-3]

iso VC

[Mafia-3]

I'd like to lynch Skeleton but I want to see Creeper released first. Not sure where the votes stand.

[Mafia-13]

Can't do a vc on my phone, but that should be 7 for creeper. It was 5 prior to your two votes and you weren't on the release train.

[Mafia-10]

I'll get working on a VC, I just need to do some work here.

[CREEPER mafia]

Vote Skeleton

[csarmi]

Current Vote Count:

 

Phantom (3) - Cat, Hyde, Elias

Skeleton ( 1 ) - Zombie

 

Bear Traps

 

Hyde( 7 ) - Hyde, Cat, Mantis, Zombie, Kook, Elias, Creeper - HYDE IS RELEASED

 

Cat ( 7 ) - Hyde, Creeper, Cat, Mantis, Zombie, Kook, Elias - CAT IS RELEASED

 

Creeper ( 5 ) - Hyde, Cat, Creeper, Mantis, Elias

 

With 12 players, it takes 7 to lynch

 

Deadline is Thursday the 29th, 8:03 am EST.

 

 

Announcement:

• I used a flashlight tonight on Phantom and got "not Fred". That doesn't mean she isn't scum - theoretically, she might be a suit.
• Elias Kingston seems to be scum. One of her actions don't add up [and that's after checking, double-checking and asking the mod as well].
• We're still debating whether to use a magistrate today (we probably won't, not much time left).
• We're still debating whether Creeper should be left in the trap. Probably not. But not sure yet.

unvote vote Elias Kingston

 

Don't hammer yet (see points 3/4), but feel free to follow. We'd like to keep the hammer to ourselves (librarians), if you guys don't mind.

 

 

 

Which reminds me... unvotes Phantom for now (even though she deserves to die).

 

 

unvote Phantom

 

I still want my question in pm answered though.

 

 

vote Skeleton

 

 

ANYWAYS. In the meanwhile, seeing as  Skeleton was my second choice today...  Vote Skeleton.

 

 

Release Creeper

 

 

Release Creeper

 

 

Vote Skeleton

[Mafia-10]

Current Vote Count:

 

Phantom (1) - Elias

Skeleton (5) - Zombie, Wax, Hyde, Cat, Creeper

 

Bear Traps

 

Hyde( 7 ) - Hyde, Cat, Mantis, Zombie, Kook, Elias, Creeper - HYDE IS RELEASED

 

Cat ( 7 ) - Hyde, Creeper, Cat, Mantis, Zombie, Kook, Elias - CAT IS RELEASED

 

Creeper ( 7 ) - Hyde, Cat, Creeper, Mantis, Elias, ZOMBIE, WAX

 

With 12 players, it takes 7 to lynch

 

Deadline is Thursday the 29th, 8:03 am EST.

[Mafia-10]

@DPR - Could we move that deadline forward by a couple of hours so that it's a bit more comfortable for those playing from the US? Night's going to be on the weekend anyway, so it shouldn't matter.

 

I suggest noon or early afternoon. Also, can you clarify whether you mean EST or EDT?

[DPR]

Current Vote Count:

 

Phantom ( 1 ) - Elias

Skeleton ( 4 ) - Zombie, Cat, Hyde, Creeper

Elias ( 1 ) - Wax

 

Bear Traps

 

Hyde( 7 ) - Hyde, Cat, Mantis, Zombie, Kook, Elias, Creeper - HYDE IS RELEASED

 

Cat ( 7 ) - Hyde, Creeper, Cat, Mantis, Zombie, Kook, Elias - CAT IS RELEASED

 

Creeper ( 7 ) - Hyde, Cat, Creeper, Mantis, Elias, Zombie, Wax - CREEPER IS RELEASED

 

With 12 players, it takes 7 to lynch

 

Deadline is Thursday the 29th, 8:03 am New York time. 

[DPR]

@DPR - Could we move that deadline forward by a couple of hours so that it's a bit more comfortable for those playing from the US? Night's going to be on the weekend anyway, so it shouldn't matter.

 

I suggest noon or early afternoon. Also, can you clarify whether you mean EST or EDT?

 

That's funny.

[Mafia-6]

Announcement:

1. I used a flashlight tonight on Phantom and got "not Fred". That doesn't mean she isn't scum - theoretically, she might be a suit.
2. Elias Kingston seems to be scum. One of her actions don't add up [and that's after checking, double-checking and asking the mod as well].
3. We're still debating whether to use a magistrate today (we probably won't, not much time left).
4. We're still debating whether Creeper should be left in the trap. Probably not. But not sure yet.

unvote vote Elias Kingston

 

Don't hammer yet (see points 3/4), but feel free to follow. We'd like to keep the hammer to ourselves (librarians), if you guys don't mind.

 

That's hilarious.

 

 

I'm laughing.

 

 

A ha.  Ha ha. Ha ha hear my laugh.

 

 

The only thing about Elias though is she claims to have stolen a mirror from Charlie N1 and he confirmed that on thread and he flipped town.

If the maffia had a suit (or any player who could steal) by N1, that'd have been an easy claim to make.

We do know for a fact that Elias started with a magistrate role.

 

If it wasn't for the N4 controversy, I'd say that she's likely town.

  

Okay, I'm going to ask this here. I'm tired of you just analyzing the actions and we only get bits and pieces. I think since it's so close to end game you let us see everything so we can piece it together and come to conclusions on our own and not be spoon fed info by you.

I know it's a hard situation for you, but seriously? Do you suggest we reveal information for maffia use?

 

 

The only thing about Elias though is she claims to have stolen a mirror from Charlie N1 and he confirmed that on thread and he flipped town.

 

Yep.

 

Sorry, I don't buy Elias being scum. Clarify what the contradiction was.

 

Sure.

 

Elias and HYDE has claimed to have stolen from SPACE KOOK on N4.

The timestamps they claimed seems to indicate that it was Elias who sent the action sooner. But it was HYDE who received the role.

 

 

If you compensated for different time zones, and there's still something off, then I think the better choice is to lynch Elias tonight and if he/she flips town and you all still aren't satisfied with me and my play, then we can lynch me tomorrow.  We're hardly at LYLO, and despite what Wax claims, I highly doubt there's more than one scum left.  I'd have a hard time believing that even if the scum still have a suit lying around that the suit would count against the town as far as end game.

 

I think it's Skeleton. Why would he randomly pick Cutler to track N1?

 

Cutler was mildly suspicious and on the fringes, so why not?  Better than one of the more obvious/loud players on D1.

 

 

 

 

Release Creeper

[Mafia-10]

 

@DPR - Could we move that deadline forward by a couple of hours so that it's a bit more comfortable for those playing from the US? Night's going to be on the weekend anyway, so it shouldn't matter.

 

I suggest noon or early afternoon. Also, can you clarify whether you mean EST or EDT?

 

That's funny.

 

 

Not sure what's the joke on me.

 

I've been asking about the timezones because I've seen them being interchanged (EST/EDT) and they confuse me. Timezones in PM's are even worse. When you quote them, even more weird things happen.

 

I asked if the deadline could be delayed a bit so that no one might be inconvenienced by having to post in a hurry in the morning, that's all.

 

I'm sorry if If I was out of the line.

[Mafia-10]

N4 action timing discrepancy - I have added everyone to the Elias Kingston actions, please make sure to point out any mistakes there.

 

MR HYDE claimed their steal to be on Aug-14, 10:29 PM EDT - you need to take our word for it, or ask Hyde to confirm that: we've been going through that several times.

 

If there is any error in the logic, please point this out for us - there's the reason we're putting this on thread: we are not infallible.

 

• HYDE sent in a steal on KOOK at TimeA, received a role
• ELIAS sent in a steal on KOOK at TimeB, received nothing
• TimeA is later than TimeB
• No mod mistake involved.
• When determining multiple steals, timestamp is used, the earlier gets it.

 

Conclusion: one of them is lying about their action.

Moreover, if HYDE is the one lying, then either

• KOOK covers for them (which seems impossible because there should be only one scum main left and they are not the same players)
• we have a role steal unaccounted for (no one else claimed to have stolen it)

[Mafia-10]

@DPR: is the votecount above correct? Does skeleton have only 1 vote with 4 people voting for them?

 

unvote, vote Skeleton

[DPR]

 

 

@DPR - Could we move that deadline forward by a couple of hours so that it's a bit more comfortable for those playing from the US? Night's going to be on the weekend anyway, so it shouldn't matter.

 

I suggest noon or early afternoon. Also, can you clarify whether you mean EST or EDT?

 

That's funny.

 

 

Not sure what's the joke on me.

 

I've been asking about the timezones because I've seen them being interchanged (EST/EDT) and they confuse me. Timezones in PM's are even worse. When you quote them, even more weird things happen.

 

I asked if the deadline could be delayed a bit so that no one might be inconvenienced by having to post in a hurry in the morning, that's all.

 

I'm sorry if If I was out of the line.

 

 

You're awfully sensitive for a ball of wax. 

 

Deadlines are New York time. There will be no more delays in the game and no more extensions of any deadlines.