fearbrog
Member-
Posts
60 -
Joined
-
Last visited
fearbrog's Achievements
Rookie (2/16)
-
-
Rare
-
-
Rare
-
Recent Badges
-
BookMattBetterThanShow reacted to a post in a topic:
The Show Has Been Cancelled
-
HeronMarkedBlade reacted to a post in a topic:
The Show Has Been Cancelled
-
HeronMarkedBlade reacted to a post in a topic:
The Show Has Been Cancelled
-
WoTwasThat reacted to a post in a topic:
The Show Has Been Cancelled
-
BookMattBetterThanShow reacted to a post in a topic:
The Show Has Been Cancelled
-
It is a shame that despite being such a fan of the book somebody changed events and tone of the book so much
-
zacz1987 reacted to a post in a topic:
The Show Has Been Cancelled
-
Samt reacted to a post in a topic:
The Show Has Been Cancelled
-
Flamen reacted to a post in a topic:
The Show Has Been Cancelled
-
This is a bit laughable. Noone who read bonding scene said: "Well Rand is a bit unreasonable here." Because we sympathize with him already, we already understand why he distrusts Aes Sedai. Scene in the book already impactful enough. And it would be also impactful if Rand was actually main character and focus of show. But he wasn't because showrunner really wanted focus on female characters instead of male. That's why Alanna more important character, less time to spend with guys who already have WAY to many screentime in the books (and his boyfriend could be in show more).
-
fearbrog reacted to a post in a topic:
The Show Has Been Cancelled
-
Flamen reacted to a post in a topic:
The Show Has Been Cancelled
-
Flamen reacted to a post in a topic:
The Show Has Been Cancelled
-
Well, it's not. It Fix Fic based on WoT books
-
There's so much, but not enough for somebody. Better create new characters and storylines because evidently it books were lacking. "the "hard" magic system" is too hard, everyone superhealer now "the relationships between characters" is changed because character must be changed, who needs book's Rand and his relationships, show has something better: different love triangle, this time with Egwene and Lanfear. What, Rand in books have enough will and conviction no to fall for seductress? Can't have that, now he's fool and tricked by forsaken over and over. "the brisk and vivid storytelling for so many important scenes" so many it's shame writers had to cut many of them, like Rand meeting with Morgase, or Tarwin's gap, or battle in the sky of Falme. At least show included such iconic scenes as Stepin's funeral, or Nyn's sword training, or Egwene healing of Nyn.
-
fearbrog reacted to a post in a topic:
The Show Has Been Cancelled
-
Because Egwene is his favourite character. There is no power in the world to force him to make her look less relevant. Even global pandemic, which used by some fans as get out of jail free card to first season, didn't push him to change e8, Egwene needed to be center of attention, so she performed literal miracle. I even think "Who's dragon" was born from brainstorming how to make Egwene more important than Rand. So by pretending everyone equally could be Dragon, Rafe had chance to correct injustice and let Egg shine as she shoud. If only they didn't have star power behind Moiraine, different character would be main focus
-
It's Avi and Elayne It's not like you want to have sex with your siblings if you say to them:"I love you." There are different types of love and their was as sisterly as can get. But anyway, Rafe said he'll make straight character gay and he did. It wasn't in jest
-
How it's in jest if he literally turned straight characters gay?
-
Sure it's just coincidence that person's favorite character got multiple new hype moments, some of them somebody's else's, and all changes to her book scenes made her even stronger, a'dam, while all Rand's scenes taken away or changed to make him weaker.
-
fearbrog reacted to a post in a topic:
The Show Has Been Cancelled
-
Took away Rand moments and gave em to Egwene and Moiraine
-
Is that thematic perspective is growth, right? Funny how Egg wasn't restricted like he was. She was best healer in the world, and broke out from the situation only true power in the book could help with. You know book also had growth as a theme? Whole journey with Loyal and Hurin helped him grow as a leader, not in the show. He was absolutely overshadowed by Moiraine, Egg and Nyn. They did things he should have did. I am not trying to convince you, I'm trying show it's not haters fault show cancelled. It's absolutely on Rafe, he thought he's better than Jordan by inventing some "theme" what wasn't in the book, by burying main character to make his favorite more important. He should have written a book or a WoT fanfiction to scratch his creative itch, instead of spending multiple millions to try to tell his story instead of Jordan's.
-
But you claiming show didn't make Rand unimpressive. But is absolutely did. Rafe took away his Caemlyn, his Tarwin's gap, his lessons from Ingtar and Lan, his friendship with Loyal, his Cairhein, his flicker, his battle with Turak, his battle in the sky. Some of those he gave away to different characters. What he got instead? Being tricked by Ishy and seduced by Lanfear. Great showing by main character here.
-
Yeah he only removed his swordsmanship and leadership and friendship arcs. Oh and also removed multiple impressive moments. Very well done is him actually falling for Forsaken's seduction, or spending his confrontation with Amerlin on his knees, or making battle with Ishy about anyone but himself? Oh maybe being stabbed by Mat is great story bit, even better than whatever book tried to show, choices, sacrifices, who cares about that, his friend just fell for a trick, lmao
-
But aspect of the story Rafe clearly disliked is THE main character. From the start he needed to elevate Egwene (his favourite character) and Moiraine (biggest star and producer), so he didn't see anything wrong with making Rand as unimpressive as possible. This couldn't end any different
-
That's simply not true. Covid prevented Egg and Nyn interacting and as a result made way to super healing-resurrection. Rand was sidelined way before because showrunner admitted he can't get all spotlight and girls MUST do something. If anything book ending would work better during COVID. It's one Rand in blue screen versus 5 women.
-
fearbrog reacted to a post in a topic:
The Show Has Been Cancelled
-
Books took singular POV and expanded into big beautiful story. But Rafe couldn't let his favourite character be second fiddle to some guy so made complex multi-POV from the get-go, oh well. We didn't get Tarwin's gap, we didn't get battle in the sky. Like hell show wouldn't keep sidelining Rand