[Basic] Pirates of the Caribbean (Curse of the Black Pearl) Game Thread - D2

[monstrman]

 

 

Going by Sooh's interactions with us, she treated me and Tiink very much the same. She defended us both and sussed us both. 

 

This is why I think Tiink is town with me. Then I'm inclined to think Wildfire is scum.

 

 

I don't think it can be v/v still

I left my vote on you a full day and the game isn't over

 

 

Exactly why I think either you or Tiink are scum. And the second was waiting to hammer. Unless you're both scum and was just hopefully waiting.

Okay wait a second

Which one do you think because it can't be both

 

That is the question. Are you and Tiink v/w, w/v or w/w? Nothing else makes sense.

 

If you're v, then he's w and Sooh interactions when compared to mine means that she did it without thinking, maybe not on purpose, or maybe on purpose???

If he's v, then you are deepwolf.

Or you are both wolf and I suck at this.

You realize you are simultaneously arguing that you and tink are v/v but also that one of me/tink if not both is a wolf, right?

[Guest]

Tiink I need to see your endgame thought process

 

We're getting the lynch correct today and I'm making sure of it

 

I second this.

[monstrman]

I think I understand why you're scum reading me now if you're a villager

[Guest]

 

 

 

Going by Sooh's interactions with us, she treated me and Tiink very much the same. She defended us both and sussed us both. 

 

This is why I think Tiink is town with me. Then I'm inclined to think Wildfire is scum.

 

I don't think it can be v/v still

I left my vote on you a full day and the game isn't over

 

Exactly why I think either you or Tiink are scum. And the second was waiting to hammer. Unless you're both scum and was just hopefully waiting.

Okay wait a second

Which one do you think because it can't be both

 

That is the question. Are you and Tiink v/w, w/v or w/w? Nothing else makes sense.

 

If you're v, then he's w and Sooh interactions when compared to mine means that she did it without thinking, maybe not on purpose, or maybe on purpose???

If he's v, then you are deepwolf.

Or you are both wolf and I suck at this.

You realize you are simultaneously arguing that you and tink are v/v but also that one of me/tink if not both is a wolf, right?

 

 

Yes. 

[monstrman]

You don't want to say it explicitly because you don't want me to attack you for it, but you've already decided I was a wolf long ago and you're never gonna change your mind

[monstrman]

That thought process proves it, because by your own reads you are LOCKED into a wolf read of me

[Guest]

That's not it, but that is probably part of the reason why I prefer you to be a deepwolf above the other two.

 

Who do you think the deepwolf is and why?

What do you think the chances are of a godfather?

[Guest]

That thought process proves it, because by your own reads you are LOCKED into a wolf read of me

 

lol yes.

 

I don't understand why else I've not been mislynched. 

 

Unless I'm wrong about Sooh's interactions with me vs. her interactions with Tiink. In which case it could still be w/w, but could also be w/v.

[Guest]

What do you think? When you look at Sooh's interactions with us remaining 6, who do you think are her teammates?

[monstrman]

That's not it, but that is probably part of the reason why I prefer you to be a deepwolf above the other two.

 

Who do you think the deepwolf is and why?

What do you think the chances are of a godfather?

It's okay you can admit it because if you're a villager we both look silly

 

Darthe said if there was a vig that the mafia had a gf, so I kind of think there is one.

 

The question is whether or not dyachei is one and idk, I go back and forth. I want to say no because I don't want to live in a world where the town got that screwed but I can't take it out of my head

 

If there's a deepwolf, it's pral. Kat has done nothing all game. Literally. She showed up to say she was gonna play, then didn't. It might not be 100% fair to base everything off of one slot but when it drags you down that hard, it drags you down that hard.

 

I think there's a decent chance wild is a wolf but again dont want to live in a world where the village was forced to take a wolf out of the PoE because they didn't show up to the game.

 

Either way, really not fair to the village that we're in this dire a spot, though I suppose we should be in a dire one after v/v/s wagons d1 and if you and tiink are both villagers v/v/v wagons d2

[Guest]

And then it could be Wildfire/Tiink. What do you think?

[Guest]

Because maybe I'm overcomplicating it with thinking there's a deepwolf.

[monstrman]

Then s/v wagons d3

 

Dice is the only reason we even have a chance if you and tiink are both villagers

[monstrman]

Because maybe I'm overcomplicating it with thinking there's a deepwolf.

It's possible.

 

I think Tiinks d1 still looks bad because there was lots of promise of work with no delivery and then he made one giant reads list, but since then he hasn't been focusing on making reads so much as defending his position

 

I felt like he was being genuine when he said "me besie w/w doesn't make sense to me" it just sounded like the truth idk how else to explain it

[Guest]

 

Not lynching Monstr or Wildfire. Sooh is within my town reads as well.

Curious as to why not Wildfire. People who haven't played with her before tend to want to lynch her all the time. Why not you?

 

 

This is literally her only proper post in terms of the Hellian/Wildfire slot.

[monstrman]

Hellian not showing up to the game sucked for the town

[monstrman]

We missed ANY wolfing interaction with that slot so the reads on it will be pretty much random at best

[Guest]

Then s/v wagons d3

 

Dice is the only reason we even have a chance if you and tiink are both villagers

 

Thank you Dice.

 

 

You just gave me an idea. I'm going to find the vote counts. I'll post it in short

[monstrman]

Can someone who plays here often tell me how often mafia coordinate endgame majority lynches when the villagers have voted the wrong person?

 

I.e. how likely it is that the fact that I voted besie for a full day and the game isn't over means that one of besie/tiink is a wolf

 

Tyty

[Pralaya]

Can someone who plays here often tell me how often mafia coordinate endgame majority lynches when the villagers have voted the wrong person?

 

I.e. how likely it is that the fact that I voted besie for a full day and the game isn't over means that one of besie/tiink is a wolf

 

Tyty

They always usually do. Typically players in this site are spread around the world, so it may not always work efficiently. Also, some people are new. But, in general, it always is. Especially since Bessie was on two votes an entire day - which means either Bessie is scum or one or both of you and tink is scum.

[monstrman]

Cool

 

I'll wait for tiink to show up and see what he says then

[dyachei]

 

Can someone who plays here often tell me how often mafia coordinate endgame majority lynches when the villagers have voted the wrong person?

 

I.e. how likely it is that the fact that I voted besie for a full day and the game isn't over means that one of besie/tiink is a wolf

 

Tyty

They always usually do. Typically players in this site are spread around the world, so it may not always work efficiently. Also, some people are new. But, in general, it always is. Especially since Bessie was on two votes an entire day - which means either Bessie is scum or one or both of you and tink is scum.

 

yeah, I agree with this.

 

Highly likely that one of besie/tink is scum at minimum

[dyachei]

when does day end?

[monstrman]

Tonight

[monstrman]

Not sure exactly when