[Basic] Pirates of the Caribbean (Curse of the Black Pearl) Game Thread - D2

[monstrman]

otherwise it might just be besie/wild

not sure. I'll reread again to make teams make sense

[Guest]

Okay guys. No. I am town.

 

I'm currently taking a break and will be here for about 20 minutes. I still have a minimum of 2 hours to drive home and can only properly be here in about 3 hours.

 

I read up to date last night whilst my company was watching a movie, but obviously couldn't give my full attention here, where it's obviously very needed.

 

When I can be here I want to do 3 things.

1 - iso Sooh to see what interactions she had with us that are remaining.

2 - state my case on the person I think is deep wolfing.

3 - figure out which of my two suspects the third wolf is.

 

I'll give an overview of my thoughts now.

[Guest]

[unvote]

 

So firstly I think it's very strange that the Tiink train didn't pick up. According to me most of you have him as scum and yet none of you are voting? Been thinking about that.

 

So either [1] he's scum. In this case the remaining scum member isn't voting him yet so as not to give her-/himself away, imo. Maybe he/she is hoping to move the attention elsewhere.

 

Or [2] Tiink is town. In this case I look scummy for starting his train. I think whoever the two scum are are either hoping to have only one on his train later so as not to look too eager. I don't know.

 

It's actually in total weird to me that the only people that have been voted this day is me and Tiink - who was voted by me.

[Guest]

Scummy imo has been Tiink and Wifi. If it's not Tiink, since most of my town seems to doubt that he is now, then I think it's Wifi. I highly doubt - or feel strongly - that Wifi and Tiink are w/w. Either one is, and the other is not.

 

In the case that it's Wifi, it would suck. We basically gave Hellian a pass because we wanted him to be active first. Then we gave Wifi a pass when she subbed in so that she could get caught up and such. Her thoughts have not made overly sense to me.

 

Will people who think it's not Wildfire please state your reasoning as to why not?

[Guest]

Imo Dya is town. I thought Nego was town since D1, they were cop cleared, and Dya further confirmed their town slot to me. I will not tinfoil on her.

 

Pral has been working towards game solving when he has been here. Kat I'll have to look at again. Their slot has barely been suspected of anything. Together with their overall gameplay and the voices of my dead townies, I will still keep him town. I can tinfoil on this slot though.

 

The slot I tinfoil on most is Monstrman. I believe he's the deepwolf. He's been here constantly, yes. But he's also been throwing AtE a LOT. I know many said that's normal for him, but I currently think he's using that to his advantage.

 

To all that solidly believe Monstrman is town, can I please have your reasoning?

[Guest]

I caught cloudflare. Good timing :(

 

We have just less than 12 hours to go. I should be here in 3 hours from now.

[Guest]

I'm not ready to give up yet. If I was I'd self-vote so that - unless both Dya and Monstrman are both scum, which I doubt - the last scum can swoop in and hammer.

 

Come on,  town.

[Guest]

Oh nvm that. My train is Tiink and Monstrman. They may both be scum. Maybe. Although, thinking about my prevous thoughts, it could well be Monstrman and Wifi rather, with her waiting for my third vote.

 

(Sorry, for some reason I thought it was Dya and Monstrman on me). Driving. Going to go off my phone now.

[Pralaya]

I'm not ready to give up yet. If I was I'd self-vote so that - unless both Dya and Monstrman are both scum, which I doubt - the last scum can swoop in and hammer.

 

Come on,  town.

 

I don't get it. Why would you self vote even if you are ready to give up? If you are town, you would never, ever even suggest that

[Pralaya]

(Probably she will come back and say she was joking, lol)

[Guest]

I wasn't entirely joking. If I, meaning town, give up, then by self-voting we lose. If I am correct, which I still don't know I am, but if I am, then a mislynch will mean 4 players tomorrow - 2 town and 2 scum. Isn't that win conditions?

[Guest]

Win for scum. Very much lose for town.

[Guest]

I'm around. Just reached home. Going to look at Sooh's interactions with us 6 soon.

[monstrman]

Imo Dya is town. I thought Nego was town since D1, they were cop cleared, and Dya further confirmed their town slot to me. I will not tinfoil on her.

Pral has been working towards game solving when he has been here. Kat I'll have to look at again. Their slot has barely been suspected of anything. Together with their overall gameplay and the voices of my dead townies, I will still keep him town. I can tinfoil on this slot though.

The slot I tinfoil on most is Monstrman. I believe he's the deepwolf. He's been here constantly, yes. But he's also been throwing AtE a LOT. I know many said that's normal for him, but I currently think he's using that to his advantage.

To all that solidly believe Monstrman is town, can I please have your reasoning?

False. I threw ate once

[monstrman]

Literally my only AtE this game was "I hate this game"

 

You have just enlisted yourself in the task of "show me my ate"

[Guest]

I will. I said I would state my case on you. Doing Sooh's interactions atm.

[Guest]

fwiw I thought you going on about how you can't lose again and you should never doubt yourself and all those posts - I count that as AtE. I think when I get to your case I might even just post links cause there's too many to quote. DM doesn't accept too many quotes.

[monstrman]

Meh. I'm an emotional person and that shows in my posts

 

Kinda dumb that it's always interpreted as AtE tbh

[monstrman]

Like I havent used ate as a tactic as a wolf to not get lynched since like 05

[monstrman]

I use AtE as a tactic as a wolf to emulate my village game tho

 

But that's the "i hate everything and everyone" ate

 

Me saying "I'll never lose again" is me getting myself pumped up

 

Doesn't matter though because if you're a villager you're gonna see what you want to see and there's nothing I can do or say to change that

[monstrman]

All I know is that mechanically one of you and tiink is a wolf because otherwise you'd be lynched and game would be over right now

[monstrman]

I mean, unless wolves AREN'T coordinating to drop the hammer

 

Which I guess is like possible a nonzero percent of the time

 

But it's much more likely one of you two is a wolf

[monstrman]

[V]tiink [/v]

[monstrman]

[unvote]

 

Lemme reread again after I do my homework

[monstrman]

There is major resistance to both wagons it feels like tbh

 

No one wants to make a vote between the two

 

Which means it's all villagers voting between two wolves or the one wolf not in the PoE doesn't want to vote not their wolfbro because it will out them if their bro is lynched