[Advanced] Revenge of the Marlfox

[Sili Quirrels]

Aj:

 

 

might be a bit sketchy as i recount the order things happened.

 

i realized from the vs game he has a large town range. my earliest ping was of him acting satirical, but almost in a stale way i guess. or rigid, or whatever. hallia said his joke in a spoiler was forced, which i thought could be on point, but was also too specific to tell. often times small details like that don't make or break a case. from there i didn't really pay attention to him until he claimed survivor in a round about way. i dont have much experience with the different roles so i didn't actually make much of it at first. my eyes were instead drawn to his reads, and i realized he had two towns as his scum picks, so i figured something was curious.

 

he explains the reason why im scum is because of my spew. but for that reason in the vs game he cleared me, so it pinged. i think he later clarifies that it was my boasting of the blue clears, but not entirely. i don't honestly think that those two things put together would make aj want me to be lynched d1. at most maybe he'd be suspicious. he should also know thane is a popular mislynch, but i forget his reasoning for thane.

 

eventually after several people had expressed that aj was likely a survivor of some sort, i came around to the idea. but i still believe his initial pushing of me was irrational, so i intuited he had another agenda.

 

near eod and after eod he starts showing a lack of wim for obvious reasons.

 

most of the reason why i dont let go of the idea he has an agenda is because i want to be right.

 

[Sili Quirrels]

oh, presently about aj, i'm concerned he's pushing villagers because he thinks he knows who the scum are.

[Sili Quirrels]

it seems like i should do alanna XD

[monstrman]

I almost want to start readinreading alanna for spew

[Sili Quirrels]

this is honestly quite tiring though, so ill take a small break.

[Sili Quirrels]

i think alanna is strongly town.

[hazelkrs1]

So despot about Sili being vague

 

Yeah? He's still being extremely vague, and I don't know why you think he isn't

 

All he's doing by posting these little stream of consciousness paragraphs on people is showing he has a reasonable handle on the game...

 

But how in the world would someone with 620 posts, over 16% of the total posts in the game, NOT have a decent handle on the game and what's gone down? Jeeze Lou Wheeze, he almost has as many posts as Tommy "Spam the ever living hell out of every DM mafia game I play" Rod

 

Think about it bro. When pushed for actual scum reads, or when he decides to lazily fos or nudge other people, the stuff he actually says is incredibly vague and when called out on it he backtracks like a scared little wolf pup. Just look at how he did with Hallia- said she was being emotionally manipulative (she wasn't- that's entirely out of both her town and wolf range), she and I both call him out for it, and he says he wasn't saying that, Hallia quotes him saying that, and he gives a Graendal's Favourite type answer and says she wasn't "in the box" or something weird like that and backs off the scumread or fos of her entirely

 

THAT'S SCUMMY VAGUE BEHAVIOR BROSEPH

[monstrman]

You did really well sili.

 

I'm proud of you <3

[monstrman]

Maybe.

 

I'm not convinced on sili but that will take time.

 

I think alanna is in the house at though

[monstrman]

...hot seat

[monstrman]

##alanna

[hazelkrs1]

The funny thing is espeespecially that if alanna is scum it spews all of despot/tommy/arsis clear too from your case, des

 

Us three are all absurdly clear, yes. Kinda without Alanna's scumflip either, tbqh. But that will help lock it in further, yes.

 

Re:alanna saying Sili could be town:

 

You could take that from the perspective that she immediately believed your claim that you were roleblocked and immediately tinfoiled that Sili was the town rber as well

 

Eh, possible, very unlikely however.

 

The way Sili is trying to stay committed to entirely disingenuous scum reads on people like myself and Arsis tho makes me think that's not the case and that he's "wolfpack" along with her

 

He just has way, way too many comments and posts that just make no sense from a townie POV dude

[monstrman]

I mean I only say this ignoring the stuff about contradictions because I know that I as town have contradictcontradicted mymyself in a similar scummy way.

 

I also don't generally have strong wolf leans which is a major reason you suspect me often, I believe, des

[Sili Quirrels]

 

So despot about Sili being vague

 

Yeah? He's still being extremely vague, and I don't know why you think he isn't

 

All he's doing by posting these little stream of consciousness paragraphs on people is showing he has a reasonable handle on the game...

 

But how in the world would someone with 620 posts, over 16% of the total posts in the game, NOT have a decent handle on the game and what's gone down? Jeeze Lou Wheeze, he almost has as many posts as Tommy "Spam the ever living hell out of every DM mafia game I play" Rod

 

Think about it bro. When pushed for actual scum reads, or when he decides to lazily fos or nudge other people, the stuff he actually says is incredibly vague and when called out on it he backtracks like a scared little wolf pup. Just look at how he did with Hallia- said she was being emotionally manipulative (she wasn't- that's entirely out of both her town and wolf range), she and I both call him out for it, and he says he wasn't saying that, Hallia quotes him saying that, and he gives a Graendal's Favourite type answer and says she wasn't "in the box" or something weird like that and backs off the scumread or fos of her entirely

 

THAT'S SCUMMY VAGUE BEHAVIOR BROSEPH

 

i don't get it. how is this not despot laying a trap or being scummy

 

ugh. dammit should i do hallia next and explain what happened there.

 

i mean logically speaking, being vague is just casual play. it doesn't speak 'scum'. i intuit things so i have to figure out why im thinking something and type it out, which is tedious. what do you want from me, the moon? shrug.

[hazelkrs1]

Aj:

 

 

might be a bit sketchy as i recount the order things happened.

 

i realized from the vs game he has a large town range. my earliest ping was of him acting satirical, but almost in a stale way i guess. or rigid, or whatever. hallia said his joke in a spoiler was forced, which i thought could be on point, but was also too specific to tell. often times small details like that don't make or break a case. from there i didn't really pay attention to him until he claimed survivor in a round about way. i dont have much experience with the different roles so i didn't actually make much of it at first. my eyes were instead drawn to his reads, and i realized he had two towns as his scum picks, so i figured something was curious.

 

he explains the reason why im scum is because of my spew. but for that reason in the vs game he cleared me, so it pinged. i think he later clarifies that it was my boasting of the blue clears, but not entirely. i don't honestly think that those two things put together would make aj want me to be lynched d1. at most maybe he'd be suspicious. he should also know thane is a popular mislynch, but i forget his reasoning for thane.

 

eventually after several people had expressed that aj was likely a survivor of some sort, i came around to the idea. but i still believe his initial pushing of me was irrational, so i intuited he had another agenda.

 

near eod and after eod he starts showing a lack of wim for obvious reasons.

 

most of the reason why i dont let go of the idea he has an agenda is because i want to be right.

 

 

This one is exceptionally bad, has bad tone, and falls back on contrived looking catchphrases like "he has an agenda"

 

Pretty much spews AJ clear imo

[monstrman]

You probably should do hallia and explain your contradiction

[Sili Quirrels]

 

Aj:

 

 

might be a bit sketchy as i recount the order things happened.

 

i realized from the vs game he has a large town range. my earliest ping was of him acting satirical, but almost in a stale way i guess. or rigid, or whatever. hallia said his joke in a spoiler was forced, which i thought could be on point, but was also too specific to tell. often times small details like that don't make or break a case. from there i didn't really pay attention to him until he claimed survivor in a round about way. i dont have much experience with the different roles so i didn't actually make much of it at first. my eyes were instead drawn to his reads, and i realized he had two towns as his scum picks, so i figured something was curious.

 

he explains the reason why im scum is because of my spew. but for that reason in the vs game he cleared me, so it pinged. i think he later clarifies that it was my boasting of the blue clears, but not entirely. i don't honestly think that those two things put together would make aj want me to be lynched d1. at most maybe he'd be suspicious. he should also know thane is a popular mislynch, but i forget his reasoning for thane.

 

eventually after several people had expressed that aj was likely a survivor of some sort, i came around to the idea. but i still believe his initial pushing of me was irrational, so i intuited he had another agenda.

 

near eod and after eod he starts showing a lack of wim for obvious reasons.

 

most of the reason why i dont let go of the idea he has an agenda is because i want to be right.

 

 

This one is exceptionally bad, has bad tone, and falls back on contrived looking catchphrases like "he has an agenda"

 

Pretty much spews AJ clear imo

 

LIKE SERIOUSLY AGENDA IS A BAD CATCHPRHASE???

 

I CAME UP WITH IT I MADE IT HAPPEN THIS GAME. ITS WHAT IVE ALWAYS CALLED IT THIS GAME. WHY WOULDNT I SPEAK IN THE SAME WAY HERE????

[hazelkrs1]

I mean I only say this ignoring the stuff about contradictions because I know that I as town have contradictcontradicted mymyself in a similar scummy way.

 

I also don't generally have strong wolf leans which is a major reason you suspect me often, I believe, des

 

I think it's more because you buddy power townies a lot (which always looks suspect imo), get kinda whyme frymeish at times, and also the overdefensiveness thing, which I've learned isn't really a big scumtell for you at all, but well, it still stands out like crazy when I see it.

 

It's like MtG tableflip kid- he may not be a bad person, but if you saw someone do that, you'd pretty much instantly assume some douchebaggery there, ya know?

[Sili Quirrels]

this is why i don't engage desp. he's so annoying.

[Sili Quirrels]

too easy to get worked up.

[Sili Quirrels]

now gonna ignore his next 5 posts until he settles.

[Sili Quirrels]

You probably should do hallia and explain your contradiction

coffee first. its the weekend. must find time for relaxation and hibernation as well.

[monstrman]

Ftr this is one of my town tells on despot

 

His fangs dig deeper as town

 

Not my super secret one though his range must be kept pure

 

!!!

[monstrman]

 

I mean I only say this ignoring the stuff about contradictions because I know that I as town have contradictcontradicted mymyself in a similar scummy way.

I also don't generally have strong wolf leans which is a major reason you suspect me often, I believe, des

 

 

I think it's more because you buddy power townies a lot (which always looks suspect imo), get kinda whyme frymeish at times, and also the overdefensiveness thing, which I've learned isn't really a big scumtell for you at all, but well, it still stands out like crazy when I see it.

 

It's like MtG tableflip kid- he may not be a bad person, but if you saw someone do that, you'd pretty much instantly assume some douchebaggery there, ya know?

Yeah I don't mean to snap at people sometimes but I play when I'm at work and that gets EXTREMELY stressful so I take out my anger on people that don't deserve it.

 

I've tried to stop but my mafia addiction is strong.

[hazelkrs1]

 

 

Aj:

 

 

might be a bit sketchy as i recount the order things happened.

 

i realized from the vs game he has a large town range. my earliest ping was of him acting satirical, but almost in a stale way i guess. or rigid, or whatever. hallia said his joke in a spoiler was forced, which i thought could be on point, but was also too specific to tell. often times small details like that don't make or break a case. from there i didn't really pay attention to him until he claimed survivor in a round about way. i dont have much experience with the different roles so i didn't actually make much of it at first. my eyes were instead drawn to his reads, and i realized he had two towns as his scum picks, so i figured something was curious.

 

he explains the reason why im scum is because of my spew. but for that reason in the vs game he cleared me, so it pinged. i think he later clarifies that it was my boasting of the blue clears, but not entirely. i don't honestly think that those two things put together would make aj want me to be lynched d1. at most maybe he'd be suspicious. he should also know thane is a popular mislynch, but i forget his reasoning for thane.

 

eventually after several people had expressed that aj was likely a survivor of some sort, i came around to the idea. but i still believe his initial pushing of me was irrational, so i intuited he had another agenda.

 

near eod and after eod he starts showing a lack of wim for obvious reasons.

 

most of the reason why i dont let go of the idea he has an agenda is because i want to be right.

 

 

This one is exceptionally bad, has bad tone, and falls back on contrived looking catchphrases like "he has an agenda"

 

Pretty much spews AJ clear imo

 

LIKE SERIOUSLY AGENDA IS A BAD CATCHPRHASE???

 

I CAME UP WITH IT I MADE IT HAPPEN THIS GAME. ITS WHAT IVE ALWAYS CALLED IT THIS GAME. WHY WOULDNT I SPEAK IN THE SAME WAY HERE????

 

 

Go back to ignoring me lawlz

 

 

And yes, it's a bad catchphrase. Scum, both young and old, will often fall back on repeating the same stuff they've said about someone before in lieu of showing more of a development on that read, because it can be hard to fake reads. So you catch something you think can stick, or at least looks like it could have genuinely come from a town version of you, then keep repeating it.

 

You have yet to truly explain what kind of "agenda" AJ might have here, besides just using it to try and discredit any of his pushes against you, and overall make him seem like a big scary person out to commit evil deeds.