SCOOBY GAME THREAD - TOWN WINS

[Mafia-8]

Why I'm Voting Creepy Heap:
 
@Creepy Heap - Please confirm in thread that you holstered Night 1 and started with a Tracker role

@Creepy Heap - Please confirm you tracked Demon Shark on Night 3
 
@Ghost - Please confirm in thread that you attempted to steal from Creepy Heap on Night 1 and got nothing

[Mafia-21]

@ Tar Monster:  what are your thoughts about getting confirmed town alongside WaxMantis and getting added to the braintrust they've established to ensure data is good and Kooks are simply flailing?  Would you be willing to be lynched and confirmed with your Zombie suit?  I know we lose a town vote if you're town.......but we just literally wasted an entire day/night cycle.

[Mafia-8]

Creepy Heap claims he started with a Tracker role. 

Creepy Heap claims he holstered N1. 

Ghost claims he tried to steal from Creepy Heap. 

Ghost didn't steal a Tracker role that should have been available. 

Creepy Heap claims he tried to steal from Demon Shark N2 and got nothing. 

Creepy Heap claims he finally used his Tracker role - which wasn't stolen and which he didn't steal - on Demon Shark on N3.

[Mafia-8]

...but we just literally wasted an entire day/night cycle.

No we didn't.  We spent a night cycle noticing a discrepency that wasn't explainable through the normal course of play.  There was a one-off action that occurred that isn't actually part of normal play that was made in order to correct for a timing issue.  That's it.

 

We still have the Creepy Heap actions that don't add up. So nothing was wasted.

[Mafia-8]

None of that, by the way, impeded us from continuing to analyze the data.

[Mafia-10]

None of that, by the way, impeded town from playing. 

 

 

That it takes 72h to get all data is not something we can help.

That town has done virtually nothing for 48+ hours in a 72h day (D4) is not our fault either.

[Mafia-21]

Whatever, guys.  You feel a little better about my actions now?  Do I look more town to you?

[Mafia-8]

Do I look more town to you?

No.

 

You just look less scum.

[Mafia-21]

LOL

[Mafia-10]

Whatever, guys.  You feel a little better about my actions now?  Do I look more town to you?

 

Your actions seem to add up now. Except for the N2 steal, of course. But that might be explained in several ways. Again, if we had 100% of the actions, it'd be easier to find inconsistencies.

 

As for your play, I find it incredibly scummy.

[Mafia-21]

Explain why, please.

[Mafia-10]

Refusing to claim up before getting released from the trap.

Constant fishing for information.

Pushing some agendas and ideas that are anti-town.

 

That about sums it up.

[CREEPER mafia]

Bottom Line:  you two didn't ask the right questions to DPR based on the info you had.  This is why the question of competence came up.

 

I rest my case.

 

So wait.

 

The mod gave an extra Watcher role to WD that either WD didn't know about, or didn't tell Wax and Mantis about, and they are incompetent because they didn't immediately ask DPR "Hey, did you screw up?" instead of figuring that one or more players were lying?

 

I'm rolling my eyes so hard right now.

 

Release Zombie

Release Miner

 

Not comfortable with releasing 10000 Volt at this time.

[CREEPER mafia]

 

 

Creepy Heap claims he started with a Tracker role.
Creepy Heap claims he holstered N1.
Ghost claims he tried to steal from Creepy Heap.
Ghost didn't steal a Tracker role that should have been available.
Creepy Heap claims he tried to steal from Demon Shark N2 and got nothing.
Creepy Heap claims he finally used his Tracker role - which wasn't stolen and which he didn't steal - on Demon Shark on N3.

 

I'd like to hear more from Creepy Heap regarding the discrepancy but he did say he is going to be camping and unavailable.  I doubt we're going to get any answer from him.

 

I viewed Ghost as town on N2 - I lean toward trusting his account over Creepy Heap's.

[Mafia-21]

Refusing to claim up before getting released from the trap.

Constant fishing for information.

Pushing some agendas and ideas that are anti-town.

 

That about sums it up.

 

I'll grant you the trap thing - that was true.  Fishing for info?  No, I'm trying to learn the mechanics.  I'm trying to figure out a way to catch scum.  Maybe none of the ideas will work, but that won't stop me from putting them out there for all to see.  I don't see that as anti-town.....quite the opposite.

 

 

 

 

Bottom Line:  you two didn't ask the right questions to DPR based on the info you had.  This is why the question of competence came up.

 

I rest my case.

 

So wait.

 

The mod gave an extra Watcher role to WD that either WD didn't know about, or didn't tell Wax and Mantis about, and they are incompetent because they didn't immediately ask DPR "Hey, did you screw up?" instead of figuring that one or more players were lying?

 

I'm rolling my eyes so hard right now.

 

Release Zombie

Release Miner

 

Not comfortable with releasing 10000 Volt at this time.

 

 

I'm not the one that initially brought the competence angle up.  If DPR made a goof and tweaked something on the fly that WD wouldn't realize was needed for WaxMantis to have accurate data, then fine.  But if you keep asking questions, the truth comes out.......like it just did.  My entire point was that they brushed my suggestions aside (see the large quote post I made and bolded each time I said it) and arrogantly stated the data was fine and that I was flailing scum.  It wasn't, and I'm not.

 

I'm not saying that is WaxMantis' fault, btw.  I'm saying that if whatever course of action/questioning that turned up this new evidence was done in the beginning when I suggested a gap in the data, we could have avoided the back-and-forth yesterday arguing about it.

 

Think of it from a townie's POV.  You suggest something, get it tossed back in your face that you're wrong, and it turns out you were right....there was a gap.  The gap is not their fault.  That part is irrelevant.  The gap exists, so you'll have to excuse me having a little fun at their expense after taking a beating from them yesterday both here and in PMs.

[Mafia-17]

@ Tar Monster:  what are your thoughts about getting confirmed town alongside WaxMantis and getting added to the braintrust they've established to ensure data is good and Kooks are simply flailing?  Would you be willing to be lynched and confirmed with your Zombie suit?  I know we lose a town vote if you're town.......but we just literally wasted an entire day/night cycle.

 

 

I think it's a bad idea.  Given the fact that the scum don't have a direct NK and that there's a Cat Burglar and 5684897348634 one-shot abilities and that DPR could be duplicating roles without telling people, I'd rather analyze lynches than night actions right now.

 

Also, lynching me doesn't get us any closer to finding the keys to the van.

 

 

Vote Creepy Heap

 

 

Also, FoS Cat Creature.  I could have told everyone that Miner and Creepy Heap are null based on posts without making massive waffling walls of text.  Cat Creature's "cases" looks like faux-scumhunting garbage to me.

[Mafia-7]

By the way, I haven't responded yet because I want to confirm that I actually tried to steal from Creepy Heap.  When I sent in my NA on N1, I just mentioned stealing from Creepy, and I realize that could be taken as Creeper, not Creepy Heap.  I'm waiting for DPR to PM me back confirming who my action was actually directed toward.

[Mafia-7]

Scum Team: Kook, Hyde, Demon, Heap, Skeleton, and Cutler

[Mafia-2]

Also, FoS Cat Creature.  I could have told everyone that Miner and Creepy Heap are null based on posts without making massive waffling walls of text.  Cat Creature's "cases" looks like faux-scumhunting garbage to me.

 

This.

 

 

Also, unvote Ptero, vote Creepy Heap

[Mafia-2]

Scum Team: Kook, Hyde, Demon, Heap, Skeleton, and Cutler

 

Considering Shaggy was already lynched, and there were five members of the original game, are you claiming that they have two suits?  Or are you just overexcited?

[Mafia-3]

 

Final Vote Count:

 

Wax Phantom (1) - Jaguaro

Mummy (15) - Tar Monster, Hyde, Ghost, Kook, Elias, Werewolf, Zombie, Snow Beast, Mantis, Cat Creature, 10,000, Demon Shark, Dr. Coffin, Wax, Pterodactyl

Pterodactyl (1) - Miner

Ghost (3) - Skeleton, Phantom, Black Knight

Dr. Coffin (1) - Cutler

Jaguaro (1) - Charlie

 

With 26 players, it takes 14 votes to lynch

 

 

 

 

CURRENT VOTE COUNT:

 

Witch Doc (3) - Wax, Werewolf, Shark

Jaguaro (14) - Ghost, Zombie, Tar Monster, Pterodactyl, Hyde, Cutler, Shark, 10,000, Phantom, Charlie, Black Knight, Cat Creature, Miner, Dr. Coffin

Mantis (5) - Zombie, Tar Monster, Pterodactyl, Cutler, Skeleton

Elias (1) - Charlie

Zombie (2) - Mantis, Jaguaro

Cutler (3) - Mantis, Jaguaro, Charlie

Shark (3) - 10,000 , Black Knight, Hyde

Creepy Heap (3) - Werewolf, Phantom, Ghost

 

With 24 players, it takes 14 to lynch. Twice.

 

Deadline Saturday, 9:15 am EST

 

JAGUARO IS TODAY'S FIRST LYNCH. HE HAS THE OPTION TO PLAY ON UNTIL THE END OF THE DAY

 

Recalibrating current vote count...

 

 

 

Aaaand a CURRENT VOTE COUNT:

 

Shark (1) - 10,000

Creepy Heap (1) - Phantom

Werewolf (14) - Tar Monster, Mantis, Jaguaro, Zombie, Hyde, Ghost, Elias, Charlie, Shark, Kook, Skeleton, Coffin, Witch Doc, Black Knight

Zombie (2) - Werewolf, Wax

 

With 24 players, it takes 14 to lynch.

 

That's a wrap.

 

 

D2-D3 lynch trains

[Mafia-13]

 

Scum Team: Kook, Hyde, Demon, Heap, Skeleton, and Cutler

 

Considering Shaggy was already lynched, and there were five members of the original game, are you claiming that they have two suits?  Or are you just overexcited?

 

 

He seems to be overexcited. I'm not scum.

[Mafia-3]

 

Current Vote Counts:

 

Zombie (1) - Mantis

Charlie (11) - Ptero, Tar, Zombie, Creeper, 10,000, Hyde, Cat, Creepy Heap, Phantom, Elias, Wax

Creepy heap (1) - Ghost 

 

With 22 players, it takes 12 to lynch

 

DR. COFFIN (13) - Wax, Zombie, Charlie, Creeper, Witch, Tar, Cat, Ghost, Miner, Coffin, Elias, Ptero, Phantom  COFFIN IS RELEASED

 

Deadline at 11:22 EST

 

 

 

 

 

unvote, vote Charlie Robot

 

 

CHARLIE ROBOT BEGAN TO OVERHEAT, EYES GLOWING MORE AND MORE RED BY THE MOMENT. SPARKS BEGAN TO SHOOT FROM HIS MOUTH, FOLLOWED BY A POP AND A CURL OF SMOKE. THEN HE SLUMPED FORWARD AND HIS HELMET FELL OFF. THE POLICE ARRIVES SHORTLY THEREAFTER AND CARTED HIM OFF TO JAIL.

 

CHARLIE ROBOT, DARTHE, TOWN, HAS BEEN ARRESTED.

 

IT IS NOW NIGHT. YOU HAVE 24 HOURS TO COMPLETE YOUR NIGHT ACTIONS.

 

D4 Lynch

[Mafia-7]

 

Scum Team: Kook, Hyde, Demon, Heap, Skeleton, and Cutler

 

Considering Shaggy was already lynched, and there were five members of the original game, are you claiming that they have two suits?  Or are you just overexcited?

 

 

I'm claiming scum team will have suits.  It was pretty near mod confirmed, so I'm just taking a shot in the dark and saying 2 suits.

[Mafia-7]

For when Space Kook ends up getting her/himself lynched: