SCOOBY GAME THREAD - TOWN WINS

[Mafia-2]

Vote Witch Doctor

Vote Mr. Dactyl

[DPR]

Current Vote Count

 

Witch Doc (2) - Ghost, Sharky

Heap (1) - Ghost

Ptero ( 1) - Sharky

 

With 21 players, it takes 11 to lynch.

 

10,000 (-)

 

Zombie (-)

 

Miner (-) 

[Mafia-8]

Vote Release Zombie

Vote Release Miner

 

Now we can let 10KVolt die in her own trap.

 

There's a theory about that scum can't steal.  10KVolt hasn't stolen the whole game.  Let's test that theory.

 

Vote Lynch Witch Doctor

Vote Creepy Heap

 

 

This day is in the bag.

 

[Mafia-17]

I think that theory is garbage. And even if it isn't, I haven't actually managed to get my grubby little tar-paws on anything yet. Got anything else on her? I'm definitely ok with letting myself and Miner go though.

 

And what's the case on Heap? I wouldn't mind losing him but he wasn't at the top of my list.

 

release Zombie

release Miner

 

Vote: Witch Doc

[Mafia-3]

release Zombie

release Miner

 

Vote: Witch Doc

 

I don't think the lynch requirements are off yet today.

[Mafia-14]

Dealing with an allergic reaction to my dinner...hoping to feel better in a few hours. Then I'll catch up.

[Mafia-7]

release Miner

Release Zombie

[Mafia-14]

I looked a bit into Creepy heap just now.

 

He/she checked in the thread. Opposed Clown's vote on Black Knight. Buddied up with Witch Doctor to vote for Clown, due to his comment about velma. Argues the fact that a good case can be made on D1. He gets voted by Clown and Werewolf.

 

 

So because it's D1 a good case can't be made? That's crap.

 

As you've said, it's D1 and there isn't much else to go on.

 

 

lol Uninteresting argument really...

 

 

So at that point there are two trains:

 

By my count Black Knight is at 9 and Ghost Clown is at 11. It takes 15 to lynch. Let's not go random. I'll switch my vote if need be.

 

He unvotes and votes Black Knight cause Jaguaro convinces him that the Black Knight train seems to have more resistance. Then after Black Knight claims his role, he moves his vote back to Clown but also says that he'll move his vote back if necessary. In the end keeps his vote there.

 

Then the whole mummy thing comes up.

 

 

Don't have a lot of time atm, but I agree with the idea of not blind lynching Mummy.

 

I wasn't able to get back online yesterday. Interesting attempt from Mummy I see. (By that I mean claiming a role nobody's heard of).

 

Dr. Coffin makes some good points about Jag.

 

 

 I was going to case Jag today but it seems he/she is less likely scum.

 

 

Mod confirmation came and

 

Vote Jag

 

appears to be lying.

 

 

Then he unvotes cause he claims he is overwhelmed by everything going on (There was the whole deal of Jag and Mantis being the same person that came into light).

 

 

I also think Black Knight is most likely town as he viewed Mummy and found scum as a result.

 

He/she's not sure where to place his votes.

 

Creepy Heap releases Kook. Agrees with bikiniWax about Charlie, finds Shark fishy (heh, get it? :P). Votes Charlie. He says that Mr.Hyde's view of Kook as town might be misguided due to mirrors existing in the game.

 

Those who have used a 1x cop view:

 

Creeper, Phantom & Werewolf.

 

Those who had a 1x cop stolen from them:

 

Jag (there might be more that I missed)

 

Extra accounts:

 

Mantis & Zombie

Took me awhile to find ^ post. It's not much I realize, but looking at it tells me Phantom and Creeper are likely town. Put that with Mantis and Wax and that's 4 townies and narrows things down a bit. Add that to what Hyde got on Kook (the cop viewing and PM), that's 5. (22 players remain. 21 with Tar being Zombie). 

 

 

Now suddenly Kook is confirmed by Hyde's viewing? heh.

 

 

 

I'm conflicted about Creepy Heap... he/she could come off like someone who is somewhat busy IRL and mostly goes with the flow when he/she manages to get on because it's impossible to catch up. There's indecisiveness aplenty and some minor contradictions that could mean something or nothing at all. Right now he/she doesn't really ping me, but maybe you guys see something I don't.

Blue: to me it seemed like something to go and I wanted to see if there was anything to it.

Bold: Meaning I would switch to consolidate if need be. (I also wasn't able to get back online until after the lynch.)

Green: I know you may not know who I am, but I never fake RL issues. EVER

Purple: Never said it was impossible, just can't stay caught up at all times because I work and can't pull my phone out during work.

 

I admit for the most the game I've been a bit lost. I'm starting to get a better grasp on things, or at least trying to. (Hence my post I believe last day phase, about cop views and people that seem town to me. 

[Mafia-14]

If anybody has questions for me, or an actual case I'm willing to do my best to clear things up. (Remember I'm going out of town tomorrow and won't likely be able to post until Sunday.) I'll be around later tonight on mobile and I'll check in as often as I can.

[Mafia-14]

Release Zoombie

Release Miner

[Mafia-14]

Almost forgot....

 

Shark: I find him/her suspicious. It's not even the not submitting the PM. It's more playstyle. He/she goes from saying nothing of consequence to being more involved and back again. Just seems off to me.

[Mafia-19]

Easy answer then:  WD, what did you do on N2 and N3?

 

 

 

If all suits can steal, then we are farther away from catching scum than I hoped.

  

Mantis and Wax had this info

N2 I holstered

N3 I holstered and had my watcher stolen

 

I'll just fullclaim WD for you:

 

https://www.dropbox.com/s/zlppdgx467pql6o/scooby_09_WITCH_DOCTOR_mafia.txt

 

Note: he was being very unclear about when his Watcher got stolen.

 

I didn't think I was unclear

You asked if my watcher was stolen when kook said he took it on N3. I said yes

I still had my action on N3 to be able to use

 

  

Just triple-checked my role PM actions - I did indeed get 1x Watcher from WD last night (N3).  If he did nothing on N2 or N3, and Mantis got a 1x Watcher from him on N2, then how the hell did he have another 1-shot for me to steal the following night?

I have no idea of hw Mantis got a watcher from me N2

It's not possible. I started the game with a watcher x1

It was still there on N3

N1 I attempted a steal but was not successful

 

  

SPACE KOOK, again, who vetted your actions? Any of them?Your N2 event has not been confirmed by anyone.Your N3 event has not been confirmed by anyone (I mean, the only way we can believe that claim of WD is if he is town, but then you're scum).

I can confirm him if you lynvh me today

I'm town and my action was stolen N3

[Mafia-19]

release Zombie

release Miner

Vote: Witch Doc

 

It'll confirm what I say about my action getting stolen N3

[Mafia-10]

Yea well that don't add up.

 

I have no reason to believe MANTIS would be lying. So Witch Doctor must be.

 

Need many more N4 actions btw. So let's stop to think.

 

The following people haven't revealed:

 

CHARLIE ROBOT  (DEAD now)

The Black Knight (he's been missing since he told me what his N3 action would be).

10000 VOLT (he gave info, but not full) <-- incidentally, I have this nagging feeling that he's town anyway

SKELETON (no claim at all, but he claims to have been busy with RL)

DEMON SHARK (don't wanna comment on that)

[BLACK KNIGHT mafia]

Apologies for absence. Incredibly busy past few days, and I had to catch a 4 hour plane ride yesterday evening.

What were cat creatures actions N3?

[Mafia-10]

Just update me in our PM (with all your actions) and I'll check them vs yours.

Tx.

[DPR]

Current Vote Count

 

Witch Doc (5) - Ghost, Sharky, Mantis, Tar, Witch

Heap (2) - Ghost, Mantis

Ptero ( 1) - Sharky

 

With 21 players, it takes 11 to lynch.

 

10,000 (-)

 

Zombie (5) - Mantis, Tar, Ghost, Heap, Witch

 

Miner (5) - Mantis, Tar, Ghost, Heap, Witch 

[DPR]

I'll be traveling today, and only checking in here and there. 

 

You're going to need the keys to the van. Just sayin'.

[Mafia-10]

Are the release counts correct?

[Mafia-13]

Yea well that don't add up.

 

I have no reason to believe MANTIS would be lying. So Witch Doctor must be.

 

Need many more N4 actions btw. So let's stop to think.

 

The following people haven't revealed:

 

CHARLIE ROBOT (DEAD now)

The Black Knight (he's been missing since he told me what his N3 action would be).

10000 VOLT (he gave info, but not full) <-- incidentally, I have this nagging feeling that he's town anyway

SKELETON (no claim at all, but he claims to have been busy with RL)

DEMON SHARK (don't wanna comment on that)

I can confirm Kook had a 1x watcher since I now have it. I stole from him last night.

[Mafia-13]

Why would they put your suit in the trap?

 

Where is Miner?

[DPR]

Are the release counts correct?

 

They are now. Dangit, I always have trouble when I'm counting past 4...

[Mafia-13]

 

 

Are the release counts correct?

They are now. Dangit, I always have trouble when I'm counting past 4...

Silly Pirate. Didn't get your breakfast of fruit loops this morning?

[Mafia-9]

Vote Witch Doctor. I want to find out who's the source to the contradiction of events revolving him, Kook and Mantis... and that will bring us a step closer. Still pondering where to place my second vote.

 

Release Zombie. I'm still not convinced that it's not favorable to lynch one of his accounts to vet the other (Like we did with Mantis and Wax). However, upon going through his posts in the game I didn't find anything that stood out to me so I'm going to give him the benefit of the doubt for now.

 

 

I decided to case Volt and Miner a bit more extensively because, as opposed to Zombie/Tar Monster, they haven't been posting as much so it's harder to get a read of them.

 

 

Volt casing:

 

Voted for Clown. Complained about the derp. He supported laying off Black Knight after his reveal and said everyone should move on. He then voted for Kook.

 

 

 

Interesting wagon forming.  Opportunistic votes on there for sure.  Or, Ghost Clown is a clown and is getting bussed hardcore.

 

Oh whatever, I'm in.

 

Unvote, Vote Ghost Clown

 

 

quote fail. fml

 

vote space cook for the above. 

 

 

Sure, Kook's reasoning seems shady at best. But considering he was voting for the same person Volt did before seems a bit shady as well.

 

Then he says that Werewolf's post of encouraging the use of magistrates pings. He also suggests to werewolf not to theorize over the mechanics of the stealing ability cause it's giving scum more info.

 

He shows some concern about whether or not Mummy will wake up in time to defend himself before he gets lynched, aka if there will be time to build up a lynch on someone else. He really wants to avoid a blind lynch.

 

 

So it boils down to blind Vs our Best option...... Which is Ghost with 3 votes as the next highest train.

 

 

Ghost - You said you can't think of any town roles with multiple targets but you can mafia - what are those roles? Or is it just something said out of hand to paint mummy mafia and push the blind lynch?

 

Seems like he's trying to push for a ghost lynch, rather than mummy.

 

 

OH hang on a minute. Has anyone tried PM'ing Mummy???

 

Vote Ghost

 

 

A) we need a lynch

B) I don't want to blind lynch this Mummy situation away

C) FOS on Dr Coffin dependendt on the flip.

 

Then once we get the extension he unvotes. Once it becomes clear that mummy wasn't silenced and he makes his claim, Volt switches to voting him (AFTER he already has like 10-11 votes to him). He also FOSes Dr.Coffin, Werewolf, Ghost and adds Mantis and Jaguar as an added thought. He critisizes Mantis for overacting to his FOS. Says that Coffin had a meltdown. Keeps complaining about this day being worse yada yada yada.

 

Next he decides to FOS all the players that have a low amount of posts: Witch Doctor, Demon Shark, Skeleton, myself, Zombie.. and for some reason Elias 'gets a pass'. He also explains a bit more in depth why he's suspicious of Jags/Manis, Miner and Demon Shark.

 

In the next post he proclaims that Ghost, Black Knight and Elias are town. He doesn't really specify how he reached that conclusion. I'd love to know, myself.

 

 

GHOST TOWN

BLACK KNIGHT TOWN

ELIAS TOWN

 

 

He votes Jaguaro and Demon Shark.

 

Next he voes miner. There's a long casing post (http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/83747-scooby-game-thread-game-on/page-73?do=findComment&comment=3002859).

 

Then:

 

Also, one or more of the following are SCUMTASTIC based on my brilliance and intelligence and all round charm and deductive reasoning

 

ENVELOPE PLEASE:

 

*ruffle ruffle tear*

 

DR COFFIN, ZOMBIE, GHOST, WAX PHANTOM

 

Wax corrects him that he's confirmed town so he says he's sticking to the other three. Which is funny, considering the fact that in the beginning of the game he attempted to shift the voting from Clown to Ghost at first, then later on he had him pegged as town and now he's back to thinking he's scum?

 

In response to one of Wax's posts:

 

 

UNVOTE VOTE CHARLIE...Derp, was it? 

 

And then if we manage to have a Magistrate played (In a controlled environment this time GASP! ) we kill from WITCH DOCTOR, CAT CREATURE, SKELETON, DEMON SHARK, CAPT CUTLER

 

I humbly suggest Demon Shark...

 

 

Interesting how his list keeps changing almost completely with every passing day. What happened with Ghost? Miner? Coffin? Zombie? They were all in his list not 24 hours ago and now suddenly it's back to other names without actually providing any reason behind it.

 

 

Nothing to see here!

 

Miner 49er didn't speak up all day after my case.

Demon Shark is insistent on being a jerk

Dr Coffin has sure dropped off the radar, after some initial pingy moves before in the days.

Ghost and Zombie are also good choices to run up with some info and or bonus at the post lynch.

 

*curtsey*

 

Oh right, back to them, are we?

 

 

I don't know. Maybe he's fishing for reactions but his pings and suspicions don't really seem consistent to me and he keeps jumping back and forth between inactives and people he claims seem scummy. His contradicting thoughts about Ghost also bother me. And he did try to shift the votes away from Mummy and only voted him once it was quite apparent that Mummy was going down. I'll be contemplating whether or not I'll be giving him my vote to spring him from the trap. I would like to hear what he has to say, though.

 

 

 

A casing on Miner will be coming soon.

[PHANTOM mafia]

L1 vote Witch doctor

 

 

 

Very good case  Cat.  Let's keep 1000 in his cage a bit longer. 

 

 

Release Zombie

 

Release Miner