Jump to content
We have a Patreon! Support this website and get exclusive content ×

DRAGONMOUNT

 A WHEEL OF TIME COMMUNITY

SCOOBY GAME THREAD - TOWN WINS

DPR

By DPR
in DM Mafia Games

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 2.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Mafia-20 Rookie

Mafia-20

Posted
Posted

 

I believe the Mummy claim for now. If he was lying then his results would be impossible to fabricate because of how many people they can potentially implicate.

 

Sorry about not being here much the past couple of days. I don't have a ton of time at the moment but will be posting a Jaguaro case when I do.

 

I will quickly mention that Black Knight, Mummy, and Pterodactyl all appear pretty confirmed to me ATM based on their claims, but that will need more analysis later.

Bold: He only told us his targets after The Black Knight had revealed them already. Not sure what would be so hard to fabricate here - he said he got nothing (2/3 chance). Not sure how this could be more convenient for him: his results can't be checked at all.

 

 

Well, lack thereof.  But indeed, it is very convenient...if I were scum.  

 

Unless you're ready to accuse TBK and I of being in collusion, then it doesn't really matter who said it first. He would know if I was lying and I would know if he was.  I had a 1x ability and it failed.  I find it hard to believe anyone would expect each to have an individual chance of success - that would be a nicely powerful 1x ability, too powerful I expect.

Mafia-10 Enthusiast

Mafia-10

Posted
Posted

 

 

I believe the Mummy claim for now. If he was lying then his results would be impossible to fabricate because of how many people they can potentially implicate.

 

Sorry about not being here much the past couple of days. I don't have a ton of time at the moment but will be posting a Jaguaro case when I do.

 

I will quickly mention that Black Knight, Mummy, and Pterodactyl all appear pretty confirmed to me ATM based on their claims, but that will need more analysis later.

Bold: He only told us his targets after The Black Knight had revealed them already. Not sure what would be so hard to fabricate here - he said he got nothing (2/3 chance). Not sure how this could be more convenient for him: his results can't be checked at all.

 

 

Well, lack thereof.  But indeed, it is very convenient...if I were scum.  

 

Unless you're ready to accuse TBK and I of being in collusion, then it doesn't really matter who said it first. He would know if I was lying and I would know if he was.  I had a 1x ability and it failed.  I find it hard to believe anyone would expect each to have an individual chance of success - that would be a nicely powerful 1x ability, too powerful I expect.

 

That's a strange logic. Seriously?

Also, why would 3 independent 1/3 rolls be better than a single all-or-nothing roll?

 

I still believe this claim seems too horrible to be untrue, but this is getting too ridiculous.

Mafia-17 Enthusiast

Mafia-17

Posted
Posted

 

 

 

I believe the Mummy claim for now. If he was lying then his results would be impossible to fabricate because of how many people they can potentially implicate.

 

Sorry about not being here much the past couple of days. I don't have a ton of time at the moment but will be posting a Jaguaro case when I do.

 

I will quickly mention that Black Knight, Mummy, and Pterodactyl all appear pretty confirmed to me ATM based on their claims, but that will need more analysis later.

Bold: He only told us his targets after The Black Knight had revealed them already. Not sure what would be so hard to fabricate here - he said he got nothing (2/3 chance). Not sure how this could be more convenient for him: his results can't be checked at all.

Well, lack thereof. But indeed, it is very convenient...if I were scum.

 

Unless you're ready to accuse TBK and I of being in collusion, then it doesn't really matter who said it first. He would know if I was lying and I would know if he was. I had a 1x ability and it failed. I find it hard to believe anyone would expect each to have an individual chance of success - that would be a nicely powerful 1x ability, too powerful I expect.

Your claimed ability is already too powerful. And too convenient.

Mafia-17 Enthusiast

Mafia-17

Posted
Posted

 

 

 

I believe the Mummy claim for now. If he was lying then his results would be impossible to fabricate because of how many people they can potentially implicate.

 

Sorry about not being here much the past couple of days. I don't have a ton of time at the moment but will be posting a Jaguaro case when I do.

 

I will quickly mention that Black Knight, Mummy, and Pterodactyl all appear pretty confirmed to me ATM based on their claims, but that will need more analysis later.

Bold: He only told us his targets after The Black Knight had revealed them already. Not sure what would be so hard to fabricate here - he said he got nothing (2/3 chance). Not sure how this could be more convenient for him: his results can't be checked at all.

Well, lack thereof. But indeed, it is very convenient...if I were scum.

 

Unless you're ready to accuse TBK and I of being in collusion, then it doesn't really matter who said it first. He would know if I was lying and I would know if he was. I had a 1x ability and it failed. I find it hard to believe anyone would expect each to have an individual chance of success - that would be a nicely powerful 1x ability, too powerful I expect.

That's a strange logic. Seriously?

Also, why would 3 independent 1/3 rolls be better than a single all-or-nothing roll?

 

I still believe this claim seems too horrible to be untrue, but this is getting too ridiculous.

It would be more consistent. And easier to balance. But harder to fake claim.

 

For whoever asked:

 

I can't tell if anything bad happened to me last night. My action had no feedback.

DPR Spam Master

DPR

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Current Vote Count:


 


Wax Phantom (1) - Jaguaro


Mummy (8) - Tar Monster, Pterodactyl, Hyde, Ghost, Kook, Elias, Werewolf, Zombie 


Cat Creature (1) - Miner


Space Kook (1) - 10,000


Ghost (4) - Skeleton, Dr. Coffin, Phantom, Snow Beast


Dr. Coffin (1) - Cutler


Witch Doctor (1) - Wax


 


With 26 players, it takes 14 votes (and evidently, an act of Congress...) to lynch


 


Deadline Tuesday @ 4:05 pm - 23HRS


DPR Spam Master

DPR

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Lol Darthe

 

He made okay points but I disagree with his second post. Too much potential for crossfire outing him even based on what little we know.

 

@Mod, any penalties for someone impersonating another player?

 

Yes. We'll all line up and send you through the spanking machine. GTFO

PTERODACTYL mafia Rookie

PTERODACTYL mafia

Posted
Posted

Unvote

 

I think that unless something bad happened to these 3, then we can assume he's telling the truth. If he was mafia and had a role that could target 3 people, it seems like there would be some sort of negative utility involved.

CHARLIE ROBOT mafia Rookie

CHARLIE ROBOT mafia

Posted
Posted

 

 

Lol Darthe

 

He made okay points but I disagree with his second post. Too much potential for crossfire outing him even based on what little we know.

 

@Mod, any penalties for someone impersonating another player?

Yes. We'll all line up and send you through the spanking machine. GTFO

You do know how to make me feel special.

 

Note that nobody is surprised that DPR has a spanking machine.

Mafia-15 Newbie

Mafia-15

Posted
Posted

Unvote

 

I think that unless something bad happened to these 3, then we can assume he's telling the truth. If he was mafia and had a role that could target 3 people, it seems like there would be some sort of negative utility involved.

There was no NK last night

So, to go with a possible narrative, Mummy sends in a NK and his Bus driver role (no evidence it was that but off the top of my head that one hits two players)

NK was blocked so no evidence but for the 3 targets that night

 

Really really simple

BLACK KNIGHT mafia Rookie

BLACK KNIGHT mafia

Posted
Posted

 

Unvote

 

I think that unless something bad happened to these 3, then we can assume he's telling the truth. If he was mafia and had a role that could target 3 people, it seems like there would be some sort of negative utility involved.

There was no NK last night

So, to go with a possible narrative, Mummy sends in a NK and his Bus driver role (no evidence it was that but off the top of my head that one hits two players)

NK was blocked so no evidence but for the 3 targets that night

 

Really really simple

 

 

Or, more obviously, I was doc protected and mafia shot at me. Occams toothbrush.

 

unvote, vote ghost[/color]

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

About Dragonmount

Dragonmount is a fan-maintained website dedicated to Robert Jordan's Wheel of Time fantasy series. It is an online community of people from all over the world who have come here to experience the series to the fullest.

Twitter

Facebook

Copyright © 2024, Dragonmount Powered by Invision Community

© All borrowed artwork is used with permission. The Wheel of Time books & franchise are © Robert Jordan & the Bandersnatch Group.

The phrases "The Wheel of Time‚" and "The Dragon Reborn", and the snake-wheel symbol are trademarks of Robert Jordan & the Bandersnatch Group.

×
×
  • Create New...