SCOOBY GAME THREAD - TOWN WINS

[Mafia-7]

I always come correct, and with purpose.

 

Zombie's post didn't sum up our interaction. Our interaction began when I voted you for your D1 goading. The questions and statements you are asking about are trivial, you are pursuing getting me to admit I wrongly stated that "nobody things BK is 100% town"? Really? 

 

Whoever said "anyone voting BK should be lynched" had their own purpose, you'll have to ask them about that. I think it's pretty clear-cut that unless we are seeing a coroner report that Black Knight is town, that nobody should be assuming he's 100% town.

 

So, that being said - I'm not wrong, and you are derailing. I just can't tell whether you are doing it with intent to stifle my casing on you or Ghost, or because your a damn idiot.

 

Anyway, I guarantee that 4.275 out of my top 3 are scum.

 

 

So now you call it trivial that you spoke for everyone else and my calling you out for it.  You also admit that you were wrong but then that you weren't because really, I'll just have to ask other people about their agenda even though you spoke for them when you categorically used the word "nobody." 

 

Glad to see your up to 4.275 though.  Much better odds. 

 

 

The red is still the biggest ping I've had all game. FWIW

 

I've vote any of my top 3. It would be awesome to just lynch Ghost and Tard Monster right now.

 

 

Also, @TARD MONSTER - were you stolen from last night, or did you steal anything?

 

 

Okay, at least that is more legit.

[Mafia-7]

EBWOP: "So now you call it trivial that you spoke for everyone else and my calling you out for it." 

 

I mean in terms of the correctness of my pushing back against assuming BK was town.

[Mafia-11]

I have finally read the whole thread. Thanks DPR for the new deadline.

 

Vote Mummy

 

Why leave out his targets?

[Mafia-1]

 

I always come correct, and with purpose.

 

Zombie's post didn't sum up our interaction. Our interaction began when I voted you for your D1 goading. The questions and statements you are asking about are trivial, you are pursuing getting me to admit I wrongly stated that "nobody things BK is 100% town"? Really? 

 

Whoever said "anyone voting BK should be lynched" had their own purpose, you'll have to ask them about that. I think it's pretty clear-cut that unless we are seeing a coroner report that Black Knight is town, that nobody should be assuming he's 100% town.

 

So, that being said - I'm not wrong, and you are derailing. I just can't tell whether you are doing it with intent to stifle my casing on you or Ghost, or because your a damn idiot.

 

Anyway, I guarantee that 4.275 out of my top 3 are scum.

 

 

So now you call it trivial that you spoke for everyone else and my calling you out for it.  You also admit that you were wrong but then that you weren't because really, I'll just have to ask other people about their agenda even though you spoke for them when you categorically used the word "nobody." 

 

Glad to see your up to 4.275 though.  Much better odds. 

 

 

The red is still the biggest ping I've had all game. FWIW

 

I've vote any of my top 3. It would be awesome to just lynch Ghost and Tard Monster right now.

 

 

Also, @TARD MONSTER - were you stolen from last night, or did you steal anything?

 

 

Okay, at least that is more legit.

 

 

Nobody is confirmed 100% town until they die and revealed as 100% town. This much, in mafia, is a given no matter what roles exist or whatever. So, when I "spoke for everyone else" I did so assuming everyone here has a higher degree of competency than the 2 of you... I'll go back to the original statement, when a cop is uncountered and giving a cop result of townie on a player, it is at that point safe to assume that player is town until more of the game develops. Let's remember here, it's D2. 

 

So, like I said, safe to assume that he's town, but nobody here is going to chalk him up at 100% town. That would be stupid. Your whole argument over me being wrong, is 1.) not helping the game any, and 2.) propped up on what one person said. 

 

Did it EVER occur to you that whoever said "anyone on BK train should be lynch" might be running a play, seeing how people react. Surely you don't think that because that person said that, they truly believed it?

 

Anyway, you 2 have successfully found something trivial, and yes it's trivial, to crater on to detract from the actual fabric of my cases on you both.

 

Congratulations, you did exactly what I'd say you would if you are scum... can't defend your actions, divert to an argument of semantics and spin until it appears you win that. It's something I've seen good scum players do repeatedly when called out.

[DPR]

This game just got thrown a penalty flag by admin.

 

Any more use of profanity and the game will be locked and scuttled. 

 

Help me out peeps, and stop dropping the f-bombs, etc.

 

I know that me writing this might seem hypocritical, and it is. But, the law is the law. And, I'm a pirate, so there's that.

 

Seriously, keep it PG13.

 

If you need to use profanity, hit me up an facebook and I'll teach you $#@% you never even heard of.

 

Justice done.

 

Vote Count when I get back from a meeting.

[Mafia-1]

This game just got thrown a penalty flag by admin.

 

Any more use of profanity and the game will be locked and scuttled. 

 

Help me out peeps, and stop dropping the f-bombs, etc.

 

I know that me writing this might seem hypocritical, and it is. But, the law is the law. And, I'm a pirate, so there's that.

 

Seriously, keep it PG13.

 

If you need to use profanity, hit me up an facebook and I'll teach you $#@% you never even heard of.

 

Justice done.

 

Vote Count when I get back from a meeting.

 

There is nothing you can teach me... my apologies, because that was all me.

 

I'm just really good at saying the eff word.

[Mafia-7]

This game just got thrown a penalty flag by admin.

 

Any more use of profanity and the game will be locked and scuttled. 

 

Help me out peeps, and stop dropping the f-bombs, etc.

 

I know that me writing this might seem hypocritical, and it is. But, the law is the law. And, I'm a pirate, so there's that.

 

Seriously, keep it PG13.

 

If you need to use profanity, hit me up an facebook and I'll teach you $#@% you never even heard of.

 

Justice done.

 

Vote Count when I get back from a meeting.

 

 

There is nothing you can teach me... my apologies, because that was all me.

 

I'm just really good at saying the eff word.

 

 

I joined you so the blame isn't all yours.  I'll moderate my language and use euphemisms from here on out.  Cleverly worded, of course.

[Mafia-7]

Nobody is confirmed 100% town until they die and revealed as 100% town. This much, in mafia, is a given no matter what roles exist or whatever. So, when I "spoke for everyone else" I did so assuming everyone here has a higher degree of competency than the 2 of you... I'll go back to the original statement, when a cop is uncountered and giving a cop result of townie on a player, it is at that point safe to assume that player is town until more of the game develops. Let's remember here, it's D2. 

 

So, like I said, safe to assume that he's town, but nobody here is going to chalk him up at 100% town. That would be stupid. Your whole argument over me being wrong, is 1.) not helping the game any, and 2.) propped up on what one person said. 

 

Did it EVER occur to you that whoever said "anyone on BK train should be lynch" might be running a play, seeing how people react. Surely you don't think that because that person said that, they truly believed it?

 

Anyway, you 2 have successfully found something trivial, and yes it's trivial, to crater on to detract from the actual fabric of my cases on you both.

 

Congratulations, you did exactly what I'd say you would if you are scum... can't defend your actions, divert to an argument of semantics and spin until it appears you win that. It's something I've seen good scum players do repeatedly when called out.

 

 

I've stood by my points and not backed down.  You just happen to agree with all my points but think I am spinning some loosely defined "narrative" so you continue to come after me.  You're wrong about that.  But feel free to say that I've been "knocked down" and "can't defend" when I continue to stand by my points as originally made. 

 

As an aside, a claim of a 1x cop view does not an uncountered cop make.  But I know we agree on this already, and I understand what you were trying to say.  No doubt you'll call it semantics.

 

And when you say you two who are you referring to?  I thought you were trying to case three people, but now it seems you are working to link me to...who?

[BLACK KNIGHT mafia]

Mummy targetted Miner, Creeper, and TarMonster.

[BLACK KNIGHT mafia]

I have finally read the whole thread. Thanks DPR for the new deadline.

 

Vote Mummy

 

Why leave out his targets?

Parrot.

[Mafia-7]

Scum: Creepy Heap and Cat Creature

[Mafia-1]

 

Nobody is confirmed 100% town until they die and revealed as 100% town. This much, in mafia, is a given no matter what roles exist or whatever. So, when I "spoke for everyone else" I did so assuming everyone here has a higher degree of competency than the 2 of you... I'll go back to the original statement, when a cop is uncountered and giving a cop result of townie on a player, it is at that point safe to assume that player is town until more of the game develops. Let's remember here, it's D2. 

 

So, like I said, safe to assume that he's town, but nobody here is going to chalk him up at 100% town. That would be stupid. Your whole argument over me being wrong, is 1.) not helping the game any, and 2.) propped up on what one person said. 

 

Did it EVER occur to you that whoever said "anyone on BK train should be lynch" might be running a play, seeing how people react. Surely you don't think that because that person said that, they truly believed it?

 

Anyway, you 2 have successfully found something trivial, and yes it's trivial, to crater on to detract from the actual fabric of my cases on you both.

 

Congratulations, you did exactly what I'd say you would if you are scum... can't defend your actions, divert to an argument of semantics and spin until it appears you win that. It's something I've seen good scum players do repeatedly when called out.

 

 

I've stood by my points and not backed down.  You just happen to agree with all my points but think I am spinning some loosely defined "narrative" so you continue to come after me.  You're wrong about that.  But feel free to say that I've been "knocked down" and "can't defend" when I continue to stand by my points as originally made. 

 

As an aside, a claim of a 1x cop view does not an uncountered cop make.  But I know we agree on this already, and I understand what you were trying to say.  No doubt you'll call it semantics.

 

And when you say you two who are you referring to?  I thought you were trying to case three people, but now it seems you are working to link me to...who?

 

 

You two: you and tar monster

 

For the last time, this argument (from my point of view) is not who agrees with who. That part is inconsequential, which is why I'm saying by you focusing on that, not the pertinent aspects of why I voted you and FOS'ed you, you are purposefully side-stepping the relevant (because you can't defend your actions) in order to win a semantic debate over something I don't friggin care about.

 

For the last time, my case on you is that post I bumped that was a ping, and when I said let's assume BK was town for now, you came across as trying to spin it to mean I knew he was town and therefore had to be scum. Both instances were pings, because in both instances you were NOT applying the logic of the game to formulate suspicion, instead you were spinning the circumstance of the game to create opportunity.

 

There's a distinct difference between the 2 ways to flow with what the game gives you, the latter being more indicative of how scum reads and reacts to the game.

 

 

 

I'm 

[BLACK KNIGHT mafia]

Mummy can answer, and then we can lynch him to verify.

[Mafia-10]

Mummy can answer, and then we can lynch him to verify.

 

Verify what?

[Mafia-20]

Mummy targetted Miner, Creeper, and TarMonster.

 

Watched, Tracked, and Copped [a feel].

 

 

It was all or nothing and guess which one I got?

[Mafia-20]

Oh, and vote Elias

 

 

 

 

Polly wanna cracker?

[Mafia-7]

You two: you and tar monster

 

For the last time, this argument (from my point of view) is not who agrees with who. That part is inconsequential, which is why I'm saying by you focusing on that, not the pertinent aspects of why I voted you and FOS'ed you, you are purposefully side-stepping the relevant (because you can't defend your actions) in order to win a semantic debate over something I don't friggin care about.

 

For the last time, my case on you is that post I bumped that was a ping, and when I said let's assume BK was town for now, you came across as trying to spin it to mean I knew he was town and therefore had to be scum. Both instances were pings, because in both instances you were NOT applying the logic of the game to formulate suspicion, instead you were spinning the circumstance of the game to create opportunity.

 

There's a distinct difference between the 2 ways to flow with what the game gives you, the latter being more indicative of how scum reads and reacts to the game.

 

 

 

I'm 

 

 

Very well, since you've finally articulated your case (which, TBH, I never understood before this post).

 

Regarding the post you bumped, I thought it was a good catch by 10k Volt.  I have seen people get caught many times where only one other player mentions it and the point gets glossed over and forgotten.  I made the statement I did because I wanted pressure to build from multiple people so that Werewolf had to respond.  I got side tracked by you and don't remember Werewolf responding to why he/she was fishing for such info, which I'd still like an answer to. 

 

@Werewolf, please respond.  Why were you fishing like that?

 

As for the second, I was scumhunting and testing your reaction by pushing you and "firing the brush."  Your response, in it's specifics, would make me think you were scum.  However, you have been so strident about it that it gives me an overall town feel for you. 

[Mafia-7]

 

Mummy targetted Miner, Creeper, and TarMonster.

 

Watched, Tracked, and Copped [a feel].

 

 

It was all or nothing and guess which one I got?

 

 

I know what I'm guessing, and I just gotta ask, did you shower after?  lol

[Mafia-10]

unvote vote WITCH DOCTOR

 

D1 - starts the Velma talk (votes Ghost Clown), then disappears, never comes back on D2, even when prodded.

 

Moving on - that 3xTarget + MUMMY's triangle role look so bad, they must be true.

[Mafia-1]

 

You two: you and tar monster

 

For the last time, this argument (from my point of view) is not who agrees with who. That part is inconsequential, which is why I'm saying by you focusing on that, not the pertinent aspects of why I voted you and FOS'ed you, you are purposefully side-stepping the relevant (because you can't defend your actions) in order to win a semantic debate over something I don't friggin care about.

 

For the last time, my case on you is that post I bumped that was a ping, and when I said let's assume BK was town for now, you came across as trying to spin it to mean I knew he was town and therefore had to be scum. Both instances were pings, because in both instances you were NOT applying the logic of the game to formulate suspicion, instead you were spinning the circumstance of the game to create opportunity.

 

There's a distinct difference between the 2 ways to flow with what the game gives you, the latter being more indicative of how scum reads and reacts to the game.

 

 

 

I'm 

 

 

Very well, since you've finally articulated your case (which, TBH, I never understood before this post).

 

Regarding the post you bumped, I thought it was a good catch by 10k Volt.  I have seen people get caught many times where only one other player mentions it and the point gets glossed over and forgotten.  I made the statement I did because I wanted pressure to build from multiple people so that Werewolf had to respond.  I got side tracked by you and don't remember Werewolf responding to why he/she was fishing for such info, which I'd still like an answer to. 

 

@Werewolf, please respond.  Why were you fishing like that?

 

As for the second, I was scumhunting and testing your reaction by pushing you and "firing the brush."  Your response, in it's specifics, would make me think you were scum.  However, you have been so strident about it that it gives me an overall town feel for you. 

 

 

Unreal.

[Mafia-20]

 

Watched, Tracked, and Copped [a feel].

 

It was all or nothing and guess which one I got?

 

I know what I'm guessing, and I just gotta ask, did you shower after?  lol

 

Due to his [surprising] love of goose down, I can honestly say this was the first time I've been tarred and feathered.

[Mafia-1]

 

Mummy targetted Miner, Creeper, and TarMonster.

 

Watched, Tracked, and Copped [a feel].

 

 

It was all or nothing and guess which one I got?

 

 

 

Oh, and vote Elias

 

 

 

 

Polly wanna cracker?

 

Spell it out... like the majority of the players are idiots.

[Mafia-1]

Also, if Ghost ends up being town and Tar Monster ends up being scum... good job, way to tard your way right into being scum MVP.

[Mafia-18]

Oh, and vote Elias

An interesting vote. Are you saying that both MINER and ELIAS are lying about the stealing?

 

Regarding the post you bumped, I thought it was a good catch by 10k Volt. I have seen people get caught many times where only one other player mentions it and the point gets glossed over and forgotten. I made the statement I did because I wanted pressure to build from multiple people so that Werewolf had to respond. I got side tracked by you and don't remember Werewolf responding to why he/she was fishing for such info, which I'd still like an answer to.

 

@Werewolf, please respond. Why were you fishing like that?

Fishing for what exactly?

[Mafia-18]

Polly wants a cracker

Think I should get off her first

I think she wants some water

To put out the blow torch

 

Isn't me

Have a seed

Let me clip

Your dirty wings

Let me take a ride

Hurt yourself

Want some help

Help myself

Got some rope

Have been told

Promise you

Have been true

Let me take a ride

Hurt yourself

Want some help

Help myself