Game Over - Insane Mafia Game. Page 94

[Guest Mesaana-Mafia]

Moridin, can you answer my two questions, in your opinion of me being evil?

 

Why would I go for Balthamel?

What good could it bring me to reveal?

 

I'm really curious how come you believe Balthamel over me.

[Guest Moridin-Mafia]

There was eleven minutes between dawn being declared and Lanfear's post. That is the eleven minutes in which the 'trap' action could be turned in if such it was and if it was turned in after night. People around at the time were Moghedien, Balthamel, Cyndane and myself.

 

Why would you go for Balthamel?

Either he was telling the truth about his role, you knew it by virtue of being evil and sensed that there was enough suspicion around to take him out with a lynch, or

You're both evil and voting each other as insurance.

Or you're innocent. That would be unfortunate.

 

What good would it bring you to reveal? I don't know, you seemed to think it would bring everyone good to reveal. What kind of a defence is that?

And if you and Balth were both evil and smelled the end coming you might well have cooked this up overnight.

 

And do I believe Balthamel over you? Or am I just more willing to risk a role blocker than a healer/cop?

[Guest Mesaana-Mafia]

Well, it doesn't really matter.

 

I was going on a LOA till Friday anyway (quite difficult examination). Though I had hoped to still go through the week-end.

 

Hope the inocents still win, anyway!!

 

Bye

[Barmacral]

Balthamel and Mesaana were arguing, everyone could hear it, and nobody was anywhere near them. Except one of the Rancor's, as they were standing right next to its pit. And it was glad for the silence when it got to eat Mesaana, right after Balthamel pushed her into the pit.

 

Mesaana, an innocent is dead. It is now night, please send your Night actions ASAP. Because of the holiday, I will be giving you until 5pm EST Tuesday to submit them.

[Asmodean-Mafia]

I believe it was a new role, which stops ALL night actions, at least that is the way it seems to be described.

...

...

5. I know that last night no night actions went through. Unequivocally, I had a one night role block that would block every single night action. There was only blunt response to this.

 

 

[glow=orange,2,300]Balthamel, how would you know about that role if you healed?[/glow]

you know that feeling when your scrolling down the page hoping Barm hasn't posted so you can unvote damn it half an hour, although Mesaana... what to say. I suppose maybe there will be an award with your name on for most supicious innocent.

 

Oh yes the quotes, well it was something that was bugging me (grr too late) Baltamel never answered this question (or if you did maybe you could point it out) I can understand you knowing that you were blocked again but all?

 

[Ishamael-Mafia]

 

:-[ The only thing i can say is that it seems strange that out of six players, all have been innocent. It's kind of a longshot statistically unless there are very few mafia or something really screwy is going on.  :P

[Aginor-Mafia]

Yeah, maybe since this is the Nuthouse after all, there's very very few mafia, making it extremely hard to get one?

I'm getting so frustrated with this game!!!!

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

I hate to say it, but I knew we should go after Balth.  Even if Ishy was telling the truth about his role, and all that, that didn't prove that Mesaana was evil.  I was going to post this last night, but, alas, I grew tired and needed rest. 

 

Mesaana, I did believe you as much as I could.  Sorry.

 

If we lose two more innocents tonight...I don't know, but it wont be pretty.  Night all.

 

*curls up under the fridge*

[Guest Moghedien-Mafia]

And at the risk of sounding uninformed, why in the hell did you block all night actions for night 2 when we needed information so badly?

 

I am pretty sure that I said it was to try to circumvent another set of night kills. It was a gamble that worked... until two posts after the switch. It also gave us information about the roles, which is something I was hoping for, albeit in a different manner, since Barm definately won't tell us that.

 

we won't learn anything unless we lynch someone.

 

not much even then.

 

People around at the time were Moghedien, Balthamel, Cyndane and myself.

 

There were more according to my msn. They just weren't posting. That list won't help you. It does make me want to metagame though. :(

[Ishamael-Mafia]

 

I am pretty sure that I said it was to try to circumvent another set of night kills. It was a gamble that worked... until two posts after the switch. It also gave us information about the roles, which is something I was hoping for, albeit in a different manner, since Barm definately won't tell us that.

 

Barm is being a bit tight lipped.

[Guest Moghedien-Mafia]

On the switch to day we all lynch him?

[Aginor-Mafia]

*Grabs torch*

 

[Balthamel-Mafia]

I (somewhat) ironically investigated Messana last night. Thats why I knew all night actions were cancelled, and btw I usually leave my computer logged in so that is why I was 'around' at the time.

 

I would welcome anyone other finders to investigate me tonight! How about this we wait for like 5 hours after the day nobody votes for anyone. If a cop finds a guilty on anyone, we shall vote for them in the first few hours, and then we can bandwagon...If nobody find anyone guilty as will happen if you investigate me, then simply don't post and keep your secret identity. That way we know I am innocent and noone has to reveal.

 

If a cop does come foward, and you lynch me and then find my innocence, then you will of found our first mafia!

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

Interesting plan Balthamel.

 

I ,too, usually keep my account logged in when I leave the computer.  Makes it easier for me to reply when I return instead of continually logging off and logging on.

[Guest Halima-Mafia]

I must compliment Barm on one thing.  This game hasn't gotten so hectic that's is really frustrating.  The many types of roled players makes things really crazy and it's hard to even tell if people are lying now.

 

Anyway I did suspect Mesaana and I'm kinda getting frustrated in the sense that we aren't getting any baddies.  It's really annoying.  I'm thinking the baddies are just enjoying the show while we work ourselves in circles.

 

I think we should try changing tactics somehow.  Any ideas?

 

*huddles inside her blankets as she waits out the night*

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

...maybe...no...uh...draw straws?

[Guest Halima-Mafia]

I didn't notice your idea Balt.  I must admit that it could be a good one assuming that there are other finders that can check you out.  It also hinges on the idea that not only are there other finders but that they also investigate you.  Which I do recommend because right now I really think you are scum.

 

Of course, we won't have any way to confirm their results for certain because if they discover you as innocent then they should not reveal.  We won't know if the silence in the day is because you are innocent or there are no other finders.

 

We can all agree that if no one finds any baddies don't reveal. 

 

I know we are not allowed to edit so in my previous post the 1st paragraph should have been.

 

I must compliment Barm on one thing.  The many types of roled players makes things really crazy and it's hard to even tell if people are lying now.

[ilgross]

I don't know who the mafia are but I think that have done apretty bang-up job, seeing as only innocents have died and I'm the prime suspect...hahah.

[Guest Moridin-Mafia]

Balthamel, I presume?

[Guest Moridin-Mafia]

@ Balth: the reason I said you were around at the time was that you posted at around that time. Less than two minutes after the deaths were announced. Remember?

 

Barm announces death

You are all sitting around in the courtyard when Be'lal walks up to Lanfear and stabs her repeatedly in the gut with a plastic knife. The shock quickly wears off of Lanfear though, and she pulls out a bone knife and promptly cuts Be'lal's throat open from ear to ear. Not a word is said. Both of them fall over and die.

 

Be'lal and Lanfear, both innocent are dead. With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch. It is still Day 3.

 

Moggy accurately summarizes the situation

What?!

 

Then Balth posts

healed myself.

 

We are well and truly back at square one...

 

Then Cyndane, then Moggy again, then me.

 

Now correct me if I'm wrong, but you can only protect or finder at night, not both. So did you heal yourself as you said in the quote above or did you investigate Mesaana?

[Guest Moridin-Mafia]

Oh wait, that's eight minutes. Same diff. When I read Barm's proclaimation there were no replies. By the time I'd finished sitting there staring blankly at the screen and posted something, there were those four other replies, including your's. So the timeframe is still a short one.

 

And the question remains: which story will you be sticking to?

[Balthamel-Mafia]

I told everyone I was healing myself, in order to try and throw the mafia off, so i could investigate someone else.

 

It was all pretty null and void since all night actions were cancelled, but I wanted to try and trick the mafia into not targetting me so I didn't have to waste my abilities protecting myself...I guess that stratergy won't work anymore...

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

Hmmm...I leave my opinions to myself until Day comes.

[Aginor-Mafia]

Oh wait, that's eight minutes. Same diff. When I read Barm's proclaimation there were no replies. By the time I'd finished sitting there staring blankly at the screen and posted something, there were those four other replies, including your's. So the timeframe is still a short one.

 

And the question remains: which story will you be sticking to?

I told everyone I was healing myself, in order to try and throw the mafia off, so i could investigate someone else.

 

 

It was all pretty null and void since all night actions were cancelled, but I wanted to try and trick the mafia into not targetting me so I didn't have to waste my abilities protecting myself...I guess that stratergy won't work anymore...

 

 

Yeah...I'm sure...

I didn't really think Balth was scum until this.

I think this should set it in everyone's minds the correct suspicions.

 

[Guest Moghedien-Mafia]

Balthamel keeps coming off as wishy washy. Did he? Didn't he? Which group is he really trying to shy away from giving the information to?