[Basic] Peg + Cat Mafia -- TOWN WIN

[Eldrick4221]

I knew her claim of seer, I had just finished SCUM reading her though. Oh geez. Lol.

 

Who are you planning to go after once I flip town? Just out of curiosity?

I have no friggin clue. I really hope it's you.

[Eldrick4221]

Your turn to answer.

[Eldrick4221]

If I somehow survive, I'm leaning Tress. Only cuz the points tigs made about her play make complete sense. That what she did this game doesn't make sense from a scum pov.

 

Tress has had a lot of not wanting to play. Which could come from town being wrong about reads or scum annoyed at being the last one and the uphill battle that involves.

[Shanti]

Right now, it has to either be tress or tigs...so depending on their gameplay today and whoever scum nks tonight, I won't know that answer until tomorrow.

 

GTH, I would say Tress because Tigs is on it with reasoning and defense. 

[Shanti]

Sorry, switched to my computer, I was getting frustrated at the game and my phone at the same time. Not a good combo.

[Eldrick4221]

All 3 of you have reason for me to think you're town. But you can't all be.

 

So I'm at Shanti > Tress > Tigs

[Eldrick4221]

Sorry, switched to my computer, I was getting frustrated at the game and my phone at the same time. Not a good combo.

Been there. That's how phone meets wall

[Eldrick4221]

Right now, it has to either be tress or tigs...so depending on their gameplay today and whoever scum nks tonight, I won't know that answer until tomorrow.

 

GTH, I would say Tress because Tigs is on it with reasoning and defense.

At least we agree on that.

[Eldrick4221]

It's a small consolation to have your scum read have the same 2nd pick as you. And for basically the same reason.

[Shanti]

 

I have a tinfoil on Shanti. That she pushed Alex early, but then dropped off when he actually started getting heat. That she never really interacted with Darthe. That all her comments about being confused could be a cover.

 

But it's just tinfoil. I really think she's just a townie getting used to the game.

I wrote a few days ago that there was always the possibility that Shanti could be a wolf who sort of got abandoned by her team and became very overwhelmed. She came in really strong and slowly trickled off. She could have been told to bus on Alex, thinking perhaps it would give her cover later (if true, it did), then maybe Darthe completely dipped out of qt and she was lost on what to do and voted him out of frustration. She mentioned wishing she had taken a mentor which could have symbolized some radio silence on Darthes part. I don't think she understood Hallia as seer, either, which would explain the lack of nk on her.

 

However, I have been town reading her. If she is a wolf I think it has to do more with confusion than manipulation. I haven't had a wolf game yet, I really don't know how I would play as one.

 

I mean, I can pull reasons for all of you being wolves. It's just your attitude this whole game has fluctuated and been so inconsistent.

 

The only reason I can put forward of you not being a wolf is that I am here and I am your biggest threat. But so is Tigs.

So that's where I get very puzzled and wonder what the heck you're doing, if you are a wolf.

 

I desperately want to have faith that Tress isn't wolf, because she's just done so many things that aren't wolfy to me and as a person I don't think she would play wolf like this. However, I was the only one really sticking up for her yesterday, so keeping me alive would have been a very smart move of hers. Keeping me as a shield where LZM wasn't really present and would probably just follow vote based off whoever had the best logic.

 

I can sit here and wrack my brain about all these little reasons. Hell, if I wasn't cleared I'm sure I've done some extremely wolfy things too.

 

At the end of the day, your actions to me can be read as the most wolfy imo. Darthe being wolf threw a lot off, your vote on him threw a lot off. But like I said, and active wolf with a successful bus is a recipe for us to all be chasing our tails around, especially with so many dormant villagers. Your lack of care of being rand lynched next to Alex has remained the biggest red flag of this game to me. 

 

 

 

The bus comment I mentioned in my reread

[Eldrick4221]

I already conceded that point :Pleasant

 

I read what you said wrong.

[Eldrick4221]

Stupid auto fill >.>

[Shanti]

It's a small consolation to have your scum read have the same 2nd pick as you. And for basically the same reason.

 

Too bad you have the wrong #1 read, we would have made a great team if you hadn't tried to off yourself the entire time.

[Eldrick4221]

Well before you guys hammer me, I want discussion from everyone on who you would go after tomorrow at lylo and why.

[Shanti]

I already conceded that point :Pleasant

 

I read what you said wrong.

 

Yes, and I saw, but I said I would show the quote once on a computer so I did. Not backing up what you say is a scum move. I'm not scum. I truly have nothing to hide, because I am vanilla town.

[Eldrick4221]

 

It's a small consolation to have your scum read have the same 2nd pick as you. And for basically the same reason.

Too bad you have the wrong #1 read, we would have made a great team if you hadn't tried to off yourself the entire time.

I wasn't trying to off myself. I was accepting the probable outcome, and still trying to solve despite it.

 

You try being and counter train 3 times and not feel like you're gonna die.

[Shanti]

Well before you guys hammer me, I want discussion from everyone on who you would go after tomorrow at lylo and why.

 

See, it is comments like that, that make it difficult not to be frustrated with you. I'm not hammering anyone until I hear all sides

 

Show of good faith, that you may actually not be scum and just have terrible town self preservation

 

[unvote]

 

P.S if you are scum and you have just been toying with me this entire time....we can't be friends.

[Eldrick4221]

Why did you go after spades for defending Hally, but not anyone else?

[Shanti]

 

 

It's a small consolation to have your scum read have the same 2nd pick as you. And for basically the same reason.

Too bad you have the wrong #1 read, we would have made a great team if you hadn't tried to off yourself the entire time.

I wasn't trying to off myself. I was accepting the probable outcome, and still trying to solve despite it.

 

You try being and counter train 3 times and not feel like you're gonna die.

 

 

Try coming back from missing a day with only needing 3 votes to be lynched and have 2 people ready to hop on your lynch train and one leaning there with the last being the only one saving you due to her being town and wanting to hear from you.

 

If it weren't for Spades, I truly feel you guys would have hammered me, and we would be one step closer to losing and scum having quite possibly the best comeback ever. 

[Shanti]

Why did you go after spades for defending Hally, but not anyone else?

 

In the beginning?

 

Because tbh, I thought it was personal life getting in the way of Spades seeing Halli as scum. 

I truly and wholeheartedly believed that Halli was scum in the beginning, and I just felt like any argument that came

Spades' way, she would say that is fair, but...or just continuously defend her. I later considered the fact that maybe Spades just knew

the entire time that Halli was town and so she defended her, which just read wrong in game because I was getting such a scum read.

[Shanti]

On DM, I have the issue of only being able to focus on one response at a time, and trying to process all the information right in front of me, I tend to forget what I have already read, or that I still have more to read.

I don't particularly like playing on here for that very reason, the only time I felt I could process things, was during my iso reads. 

[Eldrick4221]

Where did that change happen?

[Eldrick4221]

On DM, I have the issue of only being able to focus on one response at a time, and trying to process all the information right in front of me, I tend to forget what I have already read, or that I still have more to read.

I don't particularly like playing on here for that very reason, the only time I felt I could process things, was during my iso reads.

I totally get that...

[Eldrick4221]

 

Why did you go after spades for defending Hally, but not anyone else?

In the beginning?

 

Because tbh, I thought it was personal life getting in the way of Spades seeing Halli as scum.

I truly and wholeheartedly believed that Halli was scum in the beginning, and I just felt like any argument that came

Spades' way, she would say that is fair, but...or just continuously defend her. I later considered the fact that maybe Spades just knew

the entire time that Halli was town and so she defended her, which just read wrong in game because I was getting such a scum read.

This change, btw.

 

When did you start thinking this?

[Eldrick4221]

And do you mean knew cuz you thought spades was scum and Hally was town? Or knew because she realized the peek?